Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the Guardian is a joke re: JK Rowling?

367 replies

Firesidefox · 28/12/2021 16:19

So, the Guardian was running a 'person of the year' poll, and I voted for JK Rowling for her bravery in standing up to the extremist wing of the trans lobby.

I went to have a look to see when the results were out, and they've deactivated the poll! According to Twitter, it's because JK Rowling was the out and out winner.

If this is the case, this is PATHETIC.

OP posts:
TooBigForMyBoots · 29/12/2021 14:19

I dont think "nonce" means what you think it does @Uabsolutelifelessnonce.Xmas Confused

Beamur · 29/12/2021 14:16

Bringing the discussion back to where it started, this is the same process as JKR has experienced. She says something which is not actually wrong, but jars to the prevailing narrative of some people. Is thus now roundly dismissed as having the wrong kind of opinions and thoughts by people who often haven't read what was said. No amount of truth or rebuttal will sway that.
The Guardian 'story' isn't really about them pulling a poll that wasn't a poll. It's about how they are seen by many people now as having lost their reputation as being an objective news outlet.
It's a common phenomena. Not a great one.

JohnHuffam1812 · 29/12/2021 14:12

@Beamur

You'd have to be not paying attention to the issues, or trying to hide real motives to be using it.

Uabsolutelifelessnonce · 29/12/2021 14:11

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Uabsolutelifelessnonce · 29/12/2021 14:09

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Uabsolutelifelessnonce · 29/12/2021 14:07

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Beamur · 29/12/2021 14:06

It feels as if the north is a long way from the south" yes and which party was it has slashed funding in the north to such an extent? Which party is it that has changed its mind on HS2 and infrastructure upgrades?

But its Labour's fault

Bizarre isn't it. But this is my point too.

JohnHuffam1812 · 29/12/2021 13:58

The narrative is set by the media, and of course by social media, which is easy to manipulate. It also allows people to confirm their bias.

I actually see almost the same messages getting used both here and the states, as part of the "look what you made me do" excuse, its amazing how the narrative has been so well managed that the same message comes across.

"It feels as if the north is a long way from the south" yes and which party was it has slashed funding in the north to such an extent? Which party is it that has changed its mind on HS2 and infrastructure upgrades?

But its Labour's fault

IpanemaPeaHen · 29/12/2021 13:58

Also JKR is fab and judging by her Twitter feed, she doesn’t regret standing up for women and girls for a minute.

IpanemaPeaHen · 29/12/2021 13:56

No ChardonnayPD there is Brexit because the ERG saw an opportunity to avoid the new EU tax rules coming and Boris saw an opportunity to be PM by backing leave.

UK media went hard on blaming EU immigrants and suddenly everyone thought their problems would be solved by Brexiting. I’m sure I remember you being a vocal leave supporter on all the Brexit threads at the time.

Anyway it’s your Brexit mess not mine because I did not vote for it and I won’t be hanging around the UK to find out how bad it’s going to be.

Beamur · 29/12/2021 13:52

You keep banging on about this and you may be right, but you're failing to see the difference between reality and perception. It almost doesn't matter if you're right if the prevailing narrative/perception is elsewhere. Overtons window maybe?
Labour have failed to address that gap too, again, they may have tried to, but the message is not getting through. Perhaps the frustration behind that leads to the sense that they are annoyed with voters getting it 'wrong'.
I grew up in the south but live in the north. It feels as if the 'north' is a long way from the decisions made in London.

JohnHuffam1812 · 29/12/2021 13:35

Point 2 is utter fallacious. There was never thar narrative during the new Labour years. You're being revisionist. Yes labour really despised the working class, minimum wages, better working protections (especially for women and agency workers), EMA for poorer kids, and so on.

  1. What fsm myth? Children on fsm in London (so actually worse off in terms of household income in costs compared to the rest of the country) do better than fsm Children in the rest of the country. London schools out perform schools win any other region.

You're constructing your own narrative here.

MmeSosostris · 29/12/2021 13:30

Yea, absolutely - but

  1. that London uplift left a lot behind (and there is so much more to it)

  2. the left simply took a position of despising w/c for being gullible and falling for right wing rhetoric instead of recognising the hidden poverty that kept them in the line of fire of Daily Mail/online sources of information

  3. the FSM myth needs to be challenged. Many families exist just above the benefit level but do not have a secure finances particularly in cities as wealthy as London. I was much more comfortable in the north on less than in London on a ‘good’ salary.

We can do this all day but my point still stands - why can’t the left acknowledge these things fully? What are they concerned about? The only way for Labour to regain members and voters is to be open about this. Starmer has addresses the Jewish issue and tried to create a way back for those who felt they had to leave (to the best of my knowledge). Young people who supported Corbyn need to be heard (and are simply saying the very things that old Labour supporters said but were vilified for). To talk about able, healthy and dynamic communities doing better whilst some poorer communities got significantly worse is a real kick in the teeth to those of us politically lost, ambitious, renting, concerned about the practicalities of the future.

JohnHuffam1812 · 29/12/2021 13:15

Children on FSM in London out perform all other FSM children in the country and London school recieved massive investment due to the London challenge.
I have read chavs by Owen Jones and agree that the langauge used to describe the working class is terrible.

But its the Tories and the Tory press that do it.

MmeSosostris · 29/12/2021 13:02

@JohnHuffam1812.
John, you can talk about successes (Newcastle /sure start) but to not recognise that no system is perfect and that London is a completely different dynamic to the North is just disingenuous.

We know that surestart in certain areas was dominated by cliches of m/c women who had moved into those areas as part of gentrification. I’m not critical of that but I am critical of services that knew that many W/c /immigrants would be intimidated in that setting and avoided it. There is little that can be done about that at a policy level but there are schools now doing interventions for parents as the problems became apparent in the children once they started schools.

This isn’t beyond the imagination of people to recognise - esp at community level. As I say, I am from a London borough and moved back as a graduate and I can’t get into those circles in my own area as it became quite them and us. It’s bizarre to me but in most communities there are a mix of all sorts of people and there has always been a narrative in those communities that bound people together over common behaviour/practice. To denigrate that and to attack those who challenged the denigration , particularly in areas that were very multicultural was an extraordinary mistake. It showed that much of what was going on was the theatre of change in some places but not real change.

My example of the schools is meant to illustrate that at a real, functioning level within all of that time, nothing of substance had been built when it was desperately needed. Areas that were already at breaking point, broke.

Why can’t people realise this? We had to leave. The area became too violent , my father was badly attacked and to this day we are still dealing with the consequences. It was an exchange, not an uplift and imv, the people who paid the highest price were the already vulnerable - immigrants (Windrush), second gen migrants, elderly and those traditionally marginalised in the community.

JohnHuffam1812 · 29/12/2021 12:46

"And you mentioned immigration but as others have pointed out it was about resources in communities where the narrative has always been ‘there’s no money’"

Immigration was originally mentioned as a reason for voting for leave and then the tories.

JohnHuffam1812 · 29/12/2021 12:46

"In late 90s London?"

Then you weren't specific and the debate regarding immigration and not being listened to has been focused around EU migrants and the referendum.

Also how are you blaming late 90s London on Labour when at best they would have been in power 2 years.

Funding for schools increased dramatically throughout the 00s. I was in a school in Newcastle in the late 00s that had students from many deprived backgrounds and we did exceptionally well as we were able to provide the services they needed.

I don't see your link between new Labour, who launched sure start, increased school funding, increased funding in deprived areas, and in London launched the London Challenge for schools.

MmeSosostris · 29/12/2021 12:21

And you mentioned immigration but as others have pointed out it was about resources in communities where the narrative has always been ‘there’s no money’

MmeSosostris · 29/12/2021 12:18

@JohnHuffam1812

In late 90s London? John you are entrenched in dogma. Didn’t you read Owen Smiths Chavs? He was appalled at the language used to describe W/c people. All of the state mechanisms that failed (education/housing, etc) for some people were being posited as not a failure of organisation but of the individuals fault whilst at the same time failing to recognise that once you enter into the services you are very much bound by the often limited options available.

I can give you a very example of what I am talking about. In 1995 I taught in a school where 2 Somalian brothers escaping the civil war were placed. I was a nqt, little real experience and had to teach them Shakespeare when they had no English. They were known to be much older than they said. As staff we all tried to do our best but there were no resources/external agencies/support. The boys had experienced horrific family trauma and only just escaped and just kept their heads down.

In that same class was a traveller girl (English). Lots of behavioural issues but very, very able. Again no support. The class was a disaster for the year with little achieved as it was (alongside a fairly naughty cohort) too much for a nqt with no ta/support.

Fast fwd to 2017. A syrian refugee came to my class mid year. No English, behavioural issues. Again, school not particularly helpful but individual staff and many parents very supportive. I had no support with him and the person who lost out was a little Pakistani- British girl who needed lots of language input. She tried really hard but there was little English spoken at home and she lost out because (imv) her needs weren’t as immediate as the boys.

It shouldn’t be either/or yet ideologically, that is where some schools are at.

There is more I could say but I think you can piece together the bits in between and work out that, at that time what really went on was a massive exchange of resources - from one group to the next. Not extra - a new disadvantaged/poor were created.

There may well have been funding from central government- but my experience is that older teachers were pushed out, new staff appeared and wages were very generous if your face fitted. That’s now mainstream but in pockets of old W/c areas that all crept in between those years of 97-2010 whilst so many people just got pushed out of the inclusiveness of that time. I would say particularly those of other descent and POC - it was a hard, white nationalist vibe that I couldn’t fit in to or make sense of.

JohnHuffam1812 · 29/12/2021 12:16

Do love how this thread is still going when its initial point has been proved to be bullshit.

1dayatatime · 29/12/2021 12:11

@PolytheneRam

Given its brevity I thought I would help and expand you post with some actual JK Rowling jokes:

Q: What do you call a gardener that has a beard?
A: Hairy Potter.
Q: How does Voldemort keep his breath fresh?
A: He eats de-mentos
Q: How does Harry Potter get rid of a skin rash?
A: With quit-itch

TheLovelinessOfBaublyDemons · 29/12/2021 12:11

@PolytheneRam

JK Rowling is the joke as far as I'm concerned.
Prepare to get flamed.
sst1234 · 29/12/2021 12:02

@PolytheneRam

JK Rowling is the joke as far as I'm concerned.
I’m sure your accomplishments dwarf hers. And you also sound so much more articulate than her too. I mean your succinct use of words is just superb. Tell me, is you username designed to indicate the amount of storage in your head.
Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 29/12/2021 12:01

Oh good, @PolytheneRam is here to explain to us, clearly and in detail, with reference to J K Rowling's writings, what she has said and done that's transphobic. We've been waiting a long time for this.

Here's a link to the article in case you need reminding about specific turns of phrase: www.jkrowling.com/opinions/j-k-rowling-writes-about-her-reasons-for-speaking-out-on-sex-and-gender-issues/

JohnHuffam1812 · 29/12/2021 12:01

EU Immigration impacted different communities in different ways, and it is not surprising that communities under pressure had concerns. Even my polish neighbour who got a job as a TA in a school in a deprived area said she was appalled at the number of Polish children in the class who could not speak English and which impeded the ability of the teacher to teach the class. People had real concerns which were not about being racist but about being communities under pressure. If people had felt listened to and engaged with then maybe we would not have go to the Brexit situation."

Anecdote fail.

The whole "pressure on public services" point was dealt with in the referendum. Austerity caused the increased pressure on services, not EU migrants.

@MmeSosostris

I read your post and I see no links to immigration. What I see is communities that were destroyed by deindustrialisation ( because of Tory policy).