Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the Guardian is a joke re: JK Rowling?

367 replies

Firesidefox · 28/12/2021 16:19

So, the Guardian was running a 'person of the year' poll, and I voted for JK Rowling for her bravery in standing up to the extremist wing of the trans lobby.

I went to have a look to see when the results were out, and they've deactivated the poll! According to Twitter, it's because JK Rowling was the out and out winner.

If this is the case, this is PATHETIC.

OP posts:
JohnHuffam1812 · 29/12/2021 22:53

@HoliHormonalTigerlilly

There was no poll.

HoliHormonalTigerlilly · 29/12/2021 22:49

JK deffo won.

To think the Guardian is a joke re: JK Rowling?
JohnHuffam1812 · 29/12/2021 22:41

@SantaClawsServiette

I utterly disagree with your post about the LP. The ONLY party offering the working classes things that would support them in the last election was the Labour party.

The narrative you spout is one that comes directly from the internet and ignores actual policies.

Its really funny that you talk about supporters of global capitalism and copratism, because that is what you have with the Tories. The drive for brexit was all about the ability to deregulate enough to maximise profits some more.

Sorry but its just unjustifiable bollocks.

JohnHuffam1812 · 29/12/2021 22:29

@blameless

The stats you quote are questionable for one, in what I can find its workers who were foriegn born not EU. Although EU immigration seems to have been negative for the first time for years, the numbers don't seem to be as large as you suggest.

Housing supply is a national issue, and the ONS and Oxford Migration Observatory provide stats on immigration and its impact on housing.

In reality, the housing issues are due to the UK's privatisation of housing supply since the 1980s since when we have underbuilt by 200,000 dwellings or so per year. Made worse by an ageing population, changing demographics in terms of people living in single occupancy households, split families and more.

SantaClawsServiette · 29/12/2021 22:18

We can do this all day but my point still stands - why can’t the left acknowledge these things fully? What are they concerned about?

The LP really stopped being a leftist party as such and became a party of global liberalism, with their core constituency being the urban university educated middle classes. So their policies reflect that - while they kindly include state supported interventions for the poor at the most basic level they are supporters of global capitalism and corporatism, movement of labour and the movable workforce, and a an individualist approach to social values and social meaning.

That has never been a terribly appealing combination to the working classes, but LP members tend not to be able to see why, because it's what they imagine they would want in the same position.

Most of the various individual areas of disagreement like immigration or whether the nation-state should be the basic lever of power come out of these more basic differences in the way those voting contingencies think about things.

blameless · 29/12/2021 22:07

@JohnHuffam1812

Income tax for the past 5 years is £174m, £186m, £194m, £194m and £192m. I was very surprised when I saw the figures.

While I accept that people may have arrived with children and elderly parents, these published figures suggest that those who came and went did not pay much income tax. You have challenged anecdata, this is objective, audited and published information.

Those who came to make a new life in the UK may well be high earners paying a lot of tax, but it is disingenuous to suggest that there was no impact on the poorest in society (wherever they were born) from those exercising their rights to temporarily visit, work and occupy some of our disgracefully insufficient housing supply.

My own take is that many of those coming for work may have been treated very badly by gangmasters or those trafficking cheap labour. In the South East, I can get my car washed by hand for £5 and people recoil if payment is offered to anyone but the boss - I can see no way that pays the UK minimum wage, never mind other employer costs.

JohnHuffam1812 · 29/12/2021 21:32

@blameless

Was kept more or less the same by furlough. Many EU workers will have still had these payments, there is a 400 m drop in income tax.

Although I think you might implying it doesn't have an impact on tax take.you are forgetting that EU citizens also include students and other groups.

myalbatros1 · 29/12/2021 20:55

I think JK is an incredible woman.

blameless · 29/12/2021 20:43

A question for the experts here. Up to 1.3 million EU citizens left the UK between July 2019 and September 2020.
From the HMRC annual report for April 2020 to March 2021, I can't see any drop in the Income Tax and National Insurance collected.
Any explanation gratefully received.

To think the Guardian is a joke re: JK Rowling?
JohnHuffam1812 · 29/12/2021 19:46

@TeaAndStrumpets

Desperate because it doesn't actually represent the facts. A year previously North Wales was the most murderous place in the Uk, because it measures the number of events to 100,000 people. Its hardly a relative example, also its not known if these murders and threats were due to immigrants or 8f the rate is grater than before 2004.

So it's desperate.

JohnHuffam1812 · 29/12/2021 19:41

It's an interesting point though.

I think its really an appeal to reason. Even in Boston it shows that the schools were doing fine by 2012.so if there were pressure they were dealt with (by the extra funding that you missed out of your article).

In reality most leave voting places saw no extra pressure on services at all and it just became a thing people said.

And yes this was discussed in the run up to the referendum, and again people ignored the points that they didn't like.

Like insaid Sunderland experienced population falling but there are interviews with people during the campaign who cite the "pressure on services" stuff.

TeaAndStrumpets · 29/12/2021 19:37

Mirror article 2016. Obviously faked by some random on the internet.

JohnHuffam1812 · 29/12/2021 19:28

That is desperate.

I note you still quote from 2007 and not the later 2012 document from Boston Council.

So it appears if there were impacts they were in some isolated areas and were redressed quickly.

You left bits out of the article you quoted like the government pledge to increase funding, which the Council doc from later shows they got.

Question. Why are you using the most extreme example in order to prove a point about the whole country?

Most areas that voted leave had very little immigration so would have felt no impact.

Many other areas that voted remain had higher immogration

Clavinova · 29/12/2021 19:22

What actually happened was lots of stories came out in the right wing media which weren't true

The Daily Mirror -

Boston in Lincolnshire is the most murderous place in England and Wales.

www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/murder-capital-britain-revealed-its-7225784

JohnHuffam1812 · 29/12/2021 19:19

Yes and then go read the councils report from 2012.

Just quoting old am data is ridiculous.

Also if you are going to c and p provide the link there is no way of knowing that you haven't left bits out or cut off early.

Clavinova · 29/12/2021 19:13

From your favourite newspaper - also November 2007;

The debate over immigrant children in Britain's schools was reignited this weekend after the country's leading headteachers told The Observer that rising numbers of foreign pupils are putting some schools near breaking point because they do not have the resources to cope. ...

Last year 96 children who did not speak English unexpectedly joined primary schools in Boston, Lincolnshire, alone, more than doubling the number attending the previous year. ...

Jill Rutter, a senior research fellow with the IPPR, said it was time for the government to reassess the provision of English language teaching to migrant pupils. 'The main need of migrant children is to learn English,' Rutter said. 'But funding of English language learning is just not keeping pace with the number of migrant children entering British schools...

www.theguardian.com/uk/2007/nov/25/politics.schools

JohnHuffam1812 · 29/12/2021 19:12

More came than expected but there wasn't an increase in unemployment or lower wages.

Public services? Go look at the Nuffield college Oxford study on the impact on the NHS, LSE, UCL and more.

What actually happened was lots of stories came out in the right wing media which weren't true.

Most in fact the vast majority of EU citizens were here, paying tax and registered.

Most places that voted leave had very little immigration between 2004 and 2016, but spouted the lines anyway cause it was out there in the media.

The fact is that as this debate shows, you can talk about the realities of the impacts or immigration and use facts to do so, and people will still disagree because it doesn't confirm their bias.

Imdreamingofapeacefulxmas · 29/12/2021 19:06

John.

As was hashed over endlessly during the run up to brexit, we simply do not know who was where because no one was counted in. Blair expected a few thousand and millions of people came.
As mentioned and has been documented so many times, many people worked in the shadows to sand money home so they didn't have register anywhere. The only time we got a glimpse was when public services cried out for help eg under funded councils /schools /small charities/ hospitals etc.

JohnHuffam1812 · 29/12/2021 19:00

Also has to be added that Boston saw the largest increase in immigration of anywhere in the UK.

Most places that voted leave had little to no EU immigration so talking about pressure on services and impacts on population is a bit false.

There are even examples of places that saw populations falling, like Sunderland, but voted out where people repeated the mantra about immigration.

1dayatatime · 29/12/2021 18:58

@Itsalmostanaccessory

So her discussion with Gordon Brown focused on benefits , the deficit and immigration. Here is the full transcript of her comments:

"We had it drummed in when I was a child … it was education, health service and looking after the people who are vulnerable. But there's too many people now who are vulnerable but they can claim and people who are vulnerable can't get claim, can't get it."

Brown replied: "But they shouldn't be doing that, there is no life on the dole for people any more. If you are unemployed you've got to go back to work. It's six months…"

Duffy continued : "You can't say anything about the immigrants because you're saying that you're … but all these eastern European what are coming in, where are they flocking from?"

So there are a number of separate points she is making namely a feeling that there are too many vulnerable people, that how benefits are allocated amongst the vulnerable is unfair and that immigration is a concern.

If Gillian Duffy had included a concern on climate change in her discussion would you have also linked that to her concern on immigration, perhaps she's blaming Polish builders for climate change as well?

The key issue here is that Gillian Duffy raised separate points that you have chosen to link simply because she included the topic of immigration and due to your obstinate attachment to an opinion (please see my definition of a bigot on previous post).

JohnHuffam1812 · 29/12/2021 18:54

"Whcih schools in Boston have no EU Children at all" did you miss the bit where I said this would have increased since 2012 because of the no of children born here ?

Most EAL children don't need too much additional support if any btw.

JohnHuffam1812 · 29/12/2021 18:52

10 percent growth in the total population of Boston was not an underestimate. It was actually a bit more but not far off.

Desperate yes.
.the point about sone afhiols having no EAL kids at all came from the councils document of 2012 which talks about how it isn't a problem, no that the schools got extra funding.

Imdreamingofapeacefulxmas · 29/12/2021 18:44
  • feels like ghosts of Christmas past are rising again on this thread?

The volume of immigration and the way it wasn't controlled means whilst a huge number of people came here, hard working, keen to assimilate, speak English etc, unfortunately also a large number of people came who were also hard working but who moved in shadows under the radar, sending money home, living in unregulated hmos, small numbers again not a problem but it seemed many didn't register at doctors, so went to a and e, obviously no taxes paid and sadly some unsociable behaviour. But... Then came the gangs and criminals and sadly their human slaves.

With no way of tracking anyone's back ground or anything, we did get an influx of undesirables who should never have been allowed to set foot on UK soil.

Car washes used to wash money , fruit pickers... Exploited and women trafficked.

Councils up and down the country bore the brunt of official numbers going down but.. Real numbers not going up, but exploding up and no money to help.

Many councils found themselves in dire straights and the BBC did a panorama report into schools in Slough v care in older adults facilities. Slough Council in particular did a now infamous memorandum to Parliament.
It carefully laid out how each support team had been inundated with huge numbers of new cases eg say children's center dealt with ten families a month, suddenly they had 70+ on their books.

As above schools couldn't cope with so many children in one class who couldn't speak English.
A few children in each class is always manageable but the numbers were too high.
Then minors unaccompanied also went up, vulnerable children dumped into councils, which we know have always been poorly supported and funded before this huge influx brought to bear.

The Blair government just hid it's head in the sand. Hospitals creaked as the birth rate shot up with no extra beds or midwifes to help.

Very few people benefitted unfortunately except those who enjoyed the cheap labour and criminal over Lords.

Clavinova · 29/12/2021 18:40

JohnHuffam1812
That data doesn't go against the stat I used.

I filled in the missing stats for you.

Some schools have a percentage of EU children, some have none at all.

Which primary schools in Boston have no EU children at all?

Boston though is one of a few examples of leave voting places where there has been significant immigration (about 10 percent growth).

10% growth is clearly an underestimate.

Your copy and paste from 2007 is desperate, but you know councils did get extra money right?

Not desperate at all - clearly relevant to your posts above (you posted "between 2004 and 2008"). When did the councils receive the extra funding?

JohnHuffam1812 · 29/12/2021 18:38

It also is expected as immigrants tend to be young that they have children.

After all its the reason Boston kept its maternity hospital. Most of those EAL students in primary schools were born here.

Swipe left for the next trending thread