Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the Guardian is a joke re: JK Rowling?

367 replies

Firesidefox · 28/12/2021 16:19

So, the Guardian was running a 'person of the year' poll, and I voted for JK Rowling for her bravery in standing up to the extremist wing of the trans lobby.

I went to have a look to see when the results were out, and they've deactivated the poll! According to Twitter, it's because JK Rowling was the out and out winner.

If this is the case, this is PATHETIC.

OP posts:
oakleaffy · 28/12/2021 18:00

@Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g

I can't remember the ins and outs of what the woman said, but I do remember very clearly that Labour under Blair and Brown, with their enormous majorities, ignored the concerns of ordinary voters about immigration from the EU. They could and should have had a frank discussion with their voters about why they agreed to put no limits at all on immigration from the EU and what they thought the benefits would be. They could have reassured them that they would make sure school places, housing, NHS etc would have capacity to deal with all these new UK residents. Instead of which they shut all discussion down and labelled all the concerned people as bigots. People's concerns, founded or unfounded, didn't go away and we see the end result in the Brexit referendum.
Exactly this. Brexit was mainly won over migration worries and nothing else. Brexit has been a disaster- and still the U.K. has no control at all over its borders as the out voters wanted.

People were lied to.
Never should have been put to the people.

MedusasBadHairDay · 28/12/2021 17:58

@CharlieFarnsbarns123

The Guardian did not run a "Person of the Year" poll. What they did do, was ask people to send in their comments on Time magazine naming Elon Musk as "Person of the year" and asked readers to tell them "Who would be your 2021 person of the year, and why?"

Now, it may be that a lot of people did suggest JK Rowling, but this was not a poll, and there was no suggestion that the results of the non-poll would be published. The Guardian do these "Tell us" pieces all the time. Recent examples are "Tell us: what are your thoughts on the Sex and the City spin off?, and "Tell us: has having a loud voice ever caused you issues at work?"

I write this as a strong supporter of the positions taken by JK Rowling. But this is not "chilling", and no vote has been rigged.

This. It's not a conspiracy. And acting like it is just looks batshit. They asked for quotes for a piece in response to Elon Musk being named person of the year, they have now stopped asking for quotes (assume they are now writing their piece). Chances are they will use only a tiny number of the quotes, and yeah they'll probably downplay the numbers of us who said JKR, but it wasn't ever about a vote so we knew that was likely.
VladmirsPoutine · 28/12/2021 17:58

@TheHamburgler So what's the truth?

LuluBlakey1 · 28/12/2021 17:58

I subscribe to The Guardian but am finding it increasingly thin in depth and can't believe the ridiculous stance it takes on issues surrounding women/trans. Am ready to close my subscription but don't know what I would read.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 28/12/2021 17:58

[quote Itsalmostanaccessory]@Waitwhat23

That woman was a racist bigot. He only said the truth. What she said was bigoted and Gordon Brown had to stand there and listen and reply as carefully as he could. Then, when he thought it was private, he said the truth about her. She was a bigot.[/quote]
Can you explain what it was that woman said that you think was bigoted and racist please?

TheHamburgler · 28/12/2021 17:55

@VladmirsPoutine

The story isn’t true.

Nancydrawn · 28/12/2021 17:53

(I suppose I should say that's true if it was like all of the other Guardian 'Tell Us' pieces, which aren't polls and aren't serious.)

Lockheart · 28/12/2021 17:52

@StillWeRise

why did they ask then???
Because they ask for views on lots of things!
VladmirsPoutine · 28/12/2021 17:52

I refuse to think someone over there with more than a handful of braincells would have totally seen this coming. It seems they've been left with their pants down and the curtain open.

Nancydrawn · 28/12/2021 17:52

This is such silly baiting.

It wasn't a poll, it wasn't deleted, and you're looking for offense where none has been given.

StillWeRise · 28/12/2021 17:51

why did they ask then???

Lockheart · 28/12/2021 17:51

@CharlieFarnsbarns123

The Guardian did not run a "Person of the Year" poll. What they did do, was ask people to send in their comments on Time magazine naming Elon Musk as "Person of the year" and asked readers to tell them "Who would be your 2021 person of the year, and why?"

Now, it may be that a lot of people did suggest JK Rowling, but this was not a poll, and there was no suggestion that the results of the non-poll would be published. The Guardian do these "Tell us" pieces all the time. Recent examples are "Tell us: what are your thoughts on the Sex and the City spin off?, and "Tell us: has having a loud voice ever caused you issues at work?"

I write this as a strong supporter of the positions taken by JK Rowling. But this is not "chilling", and no vote has been rigged.

Away with your rational comment, don't you know there are pitchforks to sharpen Grin

As much as I'd have liked to see the guardian hold up JKR as person of 2021, I really don't think this is the conspiracy theory everyone is making out to be.

TooBigForMyBoots · 28/12/2021 17:50

@DillonPanthersTexas

Are you actually surprised?

Bit like that infamous list that was posted on various Comment is Free articles that listed the educational background of all the guardian journalists (90% of whom were public school and Oxbridge) that kept on getting deleted as it did not quite tally with the editorial line that lamented the lack of diversity in the Westminster village or other industries.

They sacked Dawn Foster (working class, disabled woman) on Tom Watson's say so after she wrote a scathing article about him.Xmas Angry

It abandoned its principles and actual reporting of "News" a long time ago.Xmas Hmm

TheHamburgler · 28/12/2021 17:50

@Firesidefox
They won’t be announcing results - the Guardian does not do a Person or the Year award.

Porfre · 28/12/2021 17:48

They could still announce the results??

Havent they just closed the nominations?

I'd probably wait a couple of weeks to see whether they announce anything.

JohnHuffam1812 · 28/12/2021 17:48

@Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g

This is the narrative but actually immigration had little to no impact on the NHS or schools or anything else.

There has been one example given of someone being called a bigot, not lots of labour.

Its yet another trope on the Internet to pretend that Labour don't care about working people

coffeerevelsrock · 28/12/2021 17:48

I entirely disagree with what she said. It still stands as an example to illustrate what a pp said about calling their voters 'racist bigots' without engaging with them about their concerns.

He tried really hard to engage with her concerns but she wasn't interested and also kept changing the subject. The problem is, unless the response to concerns such as hers is ‘Yes, you’re completely right, all your problems are caused by immigration,’ the respondent is dismissed as not listening/ignoring the concerns/treating people as if they are thick.

I am so depressed about the whole JKR debate and the way she is being treated by so many people who should know better. She would be a worthy winner for sure.

DadDadDad · 28/12/2021 17:47

@CharlieFarnsbarns123 - at last, a voice of reason. It would be great to see the Guardian announce JKR as winner of a Person of the Year award, but as you say, they are not running any such award, never asked for nomination, and didn't open any kind of voting.

"Tell us your views" is something they do all the time ( www.theguardian.com/profile/guardian-community-team ), and on this occasion it was views on the Time Magazine's PotY.

JohnHuffam1812 · 28/12/2021 17:47

So the guardian don't do a person of the year award ?

So it's fake news then.

crosstalk · 28/12/2021 17:46

Mole is to be congratulated. But I suspect some will take this literally. Can anyone link to the Grauniad's actual decision and explanation?

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 28/12/2021 17:46

I can't remember the ins and outs of what the woman said, but I do remember very clearly that Labour under Blair and Brown, with their enormous majorities, ignored the concerns of ordinary voters about immigration from the EU. They could and should have had a frank discussion with their voters about why they agreed to put no limits at all on immigration from the EU and what they thought the benefits would be. They could have reassured them that they would make sure school places, housing, NHS etc would have capacity to deal with all these new UK residents. Instead of which they shut all discussion down and labelled all the concerned people as bigots. People's concerns, founded or unfounded, didn't go away and we see the end result in the Brexit referendum.

TheHamburgler · 28/12/2021 17:46

Or a Person of the Year award, for that matter.

JohnHuffam1812 · 28/12/2021 17:46

God the Gordon brown bigot remark was not "'ignoring people's concerns about housing and jobs".

Fucks sake.

TheHamburgler · 28/12/2021 17:46

The Guardian don’t do a Person or the Year award.