Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the Guardian is a joke re: JK Rowling?

367 replies

Firesidefox · 28/12/2021 16:19

So, the Guardian was running a 'person of the year' poll, and I voted for JK Rowling for her bravery in standing up to the extremist wing of the trans lobby.

I went to have a look to see when the results were out, and they've deactivated the poll! According to Twitter, it's because JK Rowling was the out and out winner.

If this is the case, this is PATHETIC.

OP posts:
ForagingForMullberries · 28/12/2021 19:25

@CorrBlimeyGG

1. There was no poll.
  1. Person of the year can mean whatever you want it to. If Rowling was to 'win', she wouldn't be the first bigot to do so.
  2. Transphobia is not something to be proud of. Rowling deserves zero sympathy.
@CorrBlimeyGG
  1. Rowling is not bigot, she in fact has said trans people deserve protections and safe spaces, but do spew your ignorance and bigotry and refusal to actually get your facts right.
  2. Your ignorance and bigotry is not something to be proud of, nor is your femphobia. Rowling is a hero for trans people as well as women, you and your hatred, ignorance and bigotry deserve no sympathy. Probably just another woman-loathing incel.
AuntyBumBum · 28/12/2021 19:25

@user1471517900

Despite the OP being utterly disproved on page 2 of this thread, the poll shows only 6% voting unreasonable.

Never change Mumsnet.

Which is particularly ironic on a thread which is frothing over a "poll" being ignored Grin
ChardonnaysPetDragon · 28/12/2021 19:25

You are a perfect example of why we are in this Brexit mess, JohnHuffam1812.

Deny and ignore if it doesn't fit your narrative is what got us here.

Beamur · 28/12/2021 19:23

Yes and the point being it is all about perception. There was and is structural inequalities and in many communities, this lack of access to school places, doctors appointments, decent jobs, became the anti immigration narrative. Whether it was true or not is largely immaterial. It suited the Tories as it became a good way to deflect blame (although it then neatly segued into Brexit). My family live in an area that has seen waves of immigration, which has significantly changed the area, it's still pretty prosperous but poorer than comparable areas elsewhere. In one generation they're all pretty much gone from being working class Labour voters to working class Conservative voters.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 28/12/2021 19:17

@JohnHuffam1812

The Tories were in in Boston anyway.

The fact that no one has really been able to link to examples (except for 2) prior to the referendum shows that this is just a created narrative and not actually true.

Where my family are from there is the lowest amount of immigration in England, yet all through the 2000s peope ranted about immigration, even though there were a couple of hundred Poles living in a town of 25,000.

So we actually voted to stay in the EU and we haven't seen a great resurgence of open racism and anti-immigrant sentiments? Gosh. I must just have dreamed it all. Prime Minister Ed Miliband is now in his second term and everything in the UK is just peachy.
JohnHuffam1812 · 28/12/2021 19:13

The Tories were in in Boston anyway.

The fact that no one has really been able to link to examples (except for 2) prior to the referendum shows that this is just a created narrative and not actually true.

Where my family are from there is the lowest amount of immigration in England, yet all through the 2000s peope ranted about immigration, even though there were a couple of hundred Poles living in a town of 25,000.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 28/12/2021 19:11

@IpanemaPeaHen

The Gordon Brown bigoted women moment is widely acknowledged as the tuning point when Britain started pandering to the racists. He was completely correct about her.

Tories got in and the rest is Brexit history. Sadly for UK.

What did she say that was racist and bigoted?
blameless · 28/12/2021 19:10

Just exchanged e-mails with Elon - his took me an hour to interpret as it was full of numbers, hieroglyphs and runes, which turned out to be his kids' names.
Anyway, he was named 'Person of the Year' by Time Magazine, but was a bit embarrassed because he knows that more than a few people (myself included) self-identify as the 'Person of the Year'.
Consequently, being the humble guy that he is, he has asked The Grauniad to pull their (un)planned poll.
So, nothing to see, please move along.

ps If you're reading this Joanne, the one with the grumbling multi-millionaire child actors being picked off, one by one seems favourite!

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 28/12/2021 19:08

@JohnHuffam1812

Boston in Lincolnshire also didn't have problems with high unemployment, it has lower than average wages because of the type of work available there, not because of immigration, people were paid lower than the regional average back in the 80s and 90s too.
If you read what others are saying on this thread, we know this. What we are saying is that Labour didn't make enough effort to do the long, slow, frustrating work of listening to people and tactfully but thoroughly correcting their misconceptions and making a different case. Grassroots stuff. The Tories, meanwhile, nodded along and said 'Yes, you're right'. Guess who got the votes of the misguided and prejudiced, and a fair number from the undecided in the middle?
JohnHuffam1812 · 28/12/2021 19:07

"Not true. Look at all the schools who are classed as struggling or failing that have a large proportion of English as a second language speakers, not enough school places, long waits for Dr appointments, operations and extra pressure on housing and infrastructure. All governments have failed to make the necessary investments required to deal with the increase in population size"

This is the narrative but its not true.

The schools with the highest number of children who speak English as an additional language are in London and tend to be doing very well.

A huge amount of research has disproved the impact on the NHS point, cuts to social care funding meaning old people end up in hospital longer and the impact of an ageing population have been the causes of longer wait times across the NHS.

Immigrants tend to be young and healthy and not use the doctor much. Nuffield College Oxford did a good study on this.

ScreamingMeMe · 28/12/2021 19:06

@CorrBlimeyGG

1. There was no poll.
  1. Person of the year can mean whatever you want it to. If Rowling was to 'win', she wouldn't be the first bigot to do so.
  2. Transphobia is not something to be proud of. Rowling deserves zero sympathy.
Ooh cpuld this be the day thay somebody finally explains what JK Rowling said that was so transphobic and bigoted - in JK Rowling's own words?
PollyPaintsFlowers · 28/12/2021 19:04

This is the narrative but actually immigration had little to no impact on the NHS or schools or anything else.

Not true. Look at all the schools who are classed as struggling or failing that have a large proportion of English as a second language speakers, not enough school places, long waits for Dr appointments, operations and extra pressure on housing and infrastructure. All governments have failed to make the necessary investments required to deal with the increase in population size

JohnHuffam1812 · 28/12/2021 19:01

Boston in Lincolnshire also didn't have problems with high unemployment, it has lower than average wages because of the type of work available there, not because of immigration, people were paid lower than the regional average back in the 80s and 90s too.

DillonPanthersTexas · 28/12/2021 19:01

Surely one would expect (want) journalists to be clever (ie Oxbridge educated) rather than less clever ? Nothing to be ashamed of ?

Surely for a paper that has presents itself as left leaning and concerned about the plight of the poor and disadvantaged employing a bunch of of people who have had zero experience of said social issues is a bit short sighted. Also, the staggering hypocrisy of trying to shame companies about sharp employment practices, tax evasion and unpaid internships when they have practiced exactly the same does not exactly help their cause.

JohnHuffam1812 · 28/12/2021 18:59

@Clavinova

No comment on the Tories attitudes to the working class then?

KissedintheDark · 28/12/2021 18:53

@AlternativePerspective

Doesn’t Justine’s DH work for the guardian? Editor or some such?
Ian Katz, ex deputy editor?
Clavinova · 28/12/2021 18:49

Gordon Brown and his 'bigoted woman' remark in 2010 would be a fairly obvious example.

And again in 2014 -

A Labour MP [Alex Cunningham] has apologised after launching a renewed attack on the Rochdale pensioner who was derided by Gordon Brown as a “bigoted woman”...

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/brown-was-right-about-bigoted-woman-says-mp-cdtt6tml38p

Astonishing tweets from Labour MP Neil Coyle last year -

Labour MP calls Brexiteers ‘shtbag racist w**ers’ over Proms row
Neil Coyle says song Rule! Britannia is only liked by 'sh*tlickers" ...
The Southwark MP went on to claim that “fat old racists” would blame the EU if Brexit went wrong...

The Independent understands that Mr Coyle has been spoken to by Keir Starmer's office, which told him to take down the tweets.

www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/labour-mp-brexit-neil-coyle-proms-farage-jacob-rees-mogg-a9689776.html

Waitwhat23 · 28/12/2021 18:46

@ChardonnaysPetDragon this is the thing. An example of an area which has had issues with high unemployment and low wages etc is Boston in Lincolnshire who voted to Leave at one of highest percentages of the country - 75%. A fairly large influence of this seems to have been the idea that foreigners were 'taking all our jobs'. Obviously incorrect but refusing to listen to these concerns, even to correct them, lead to a situation where people there felt disenfranchised and so voted to leave.

A political party can call their voters bigots and tell them not to vote for them if they like - there's been quite a lot of that directed towards women who are trying to keep sex based rights. It's then slightly bizarre to be surprised when those people do exactly that and you lose votes/seats.

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 28/12/2021 18:43

Immigration wasn't a big issue in 2010. It became one as austerity kicked in.

It was.

www.theguardian.com/news/2015/mar/24/how-immigration-came-to-haunt-labour-inside-story

It wasn't addressed, it wasn't addressed later and now we are all suffering the Brexit consequences.

madisonbridges · 28/12/2021 18:42

[quote JohnHuffam1812]@whachatalkinaboutwillis

This old tripe again? Got examples?[/quote]
Didn't Emily Thornberry have to resign over this very thing?

AvieMaria · 28/12/2021 18:41

Newspapers are all part of the same business group and operate through "carpetbagging" - promoting whatever it takes to get sales and clicks and keep a position of power.

It's naive to think they have the Guardian has some idealistic attachment to justice or supporting or believe in any point of view, they just what they can do to get sales and promote their own importance.

They make money through the same stories, "playing both sides of the equation".

It's not like the noble leftie journalists are speaking against the nasty tabloids or vice versa - they all are profiting from the set-up. It's the people who trust them or the people who they report on who are normally the victims or caught in the crossfire.

Journalists will move between different papers, they don't believe a word of what they write unless it makes sales or conforms to a particular agenda or targets a particular person the paper's Editor wants targeted!

The editor of the Mail was known to be close friends with the editor of the Guardian .The Guardian wrote a massive sycophantic "flattery piece" about Paul Dacre's son when he took on a new job.

With the trans movement, there's been a clear attempt by organisations like the BBC and the Guardian early on to "set up" vulnerable young people and "promote their surgery"

And then they know a few months later, afterwards the Mail gets to run articles humiliating the same young people with "sadface" articles. The culture is of drama and clickbait and "making stories".

JK Rowling has never been well supported by any sections of the Press. Even the BBC runs vicious articles on her!

She was a woman who got so commercially successful early on and was an "early adopter of Twitter and her own blog" so she didn't need to use the media for tacky promotion, and received extreme harassment from a lot of the Press (including the broadsheets and of course the Mail etc) and testified against them in the Leveson Inquiry.

Plus, beautiful, successful, philanthropist, married a doctor - the jealous media knives were out for her early on!

heathspeedwell · 28/12/2021 18:41

I think the overwhelming public opinion is that a once-good newspaper has become a joke.

Sadly the Guardian has forgotten that half of their readership are women, and we care about our rights and the rights of future generations.

JohnHuffam1812 · 28/12/2021 18:39

@user1471517900

Its funny to watch all the fury.

user1471517900 · 28/12/2021 18:38

Despite the OP being utterly disproved on page 2 of this thread, the poll shows only 6% voting unreasonable.

Never change Mumsnet.

CorrBlimeyGG · 28/12/2021 18:37

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.