Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why this attitude towards marriage for men still exists?! [hmm]

158 replies

GreenGreenTreesOfHome · 28/12/2021 14:10

NC for this as I don't want it linking with my other posts.

There was a man on Family Fortunes yesterday, who said he wants to treat his parents to a holiday for their 50th wedding anniversary if he wins some decent money. He said 'my dad has had 2 life sentences, he deserves the break!' He said NOTHING about his mum.

It really REALLY fucking pissed me off. He thought he was funny, Gino just looked a bit Shock and it was pretty much like tumbleweed in the TV studio (with a couple of quiet nervous giggles,) but it made me so furious. Angry

Why is it a 'life sentence' for a man to be married for a long time, but an achievement, and something to be celebrated for a woman? I thought this horrible, wanky attitude had been consigned to the history books.

But no, for men, it's still a tedious chore to be married apparently, and a 'ball and chain' and a 'life sentence!' Yet it's OK for women to be married, and as I say, it's classed as an achievement, and something to be celebrated for HER. Hmm

I have heard many times in the past actually, that men are healthier and happier when they're married, and actually get more out of marriage than women do. So why is this bullshit still a thing?

OP posts:
Hrpuffnstuff1 · 03/01/2022 08:29

I'm struggling to see what 'benefits' men get out of marriage.

Ponoka7 · 03/01/2022 07:35

@TrishM80, I've never heard of that applying to any of the couples I know who are under 40. For my generation possibly, but any of my DD's. But being in the 'doghouse' would have been days, not months. That was back in the day were women were careful about what they said, because it could get you a smack. So rather than communicate, which I see younger couples now doing, they'd withdraw to show that they were upset. I'd say that yours is another dated analogy.

Ponoka7 · 03/01/2022 07:29

@beastlyslumber
"It's not a funny joke, but who cares? If that's all women have to be bothered about these days then I'd say we're doing pretty amazingly well. "

Would you say the same about racist 'jokes'? Are racist jokes acceptable on television gameshows? If not and language is important, why don't we go after sexism the way we have racism? Or if language isn't important why do old fashion racist remakes mean a sacking, as in the case of sports commentators, whereas sexist remarks are just a laugh? If all gay/black/Korean etc people have to be bothered about then they're doing amazingly well.

WeaverofWords · 03/01/2022 06:57

I hate the “it’s only a joke” line, implying it’s excusable to peddle this bullshit in the name of “humour”.

It’s only funny if everyone is laughing, and if they’re not, it’s worth checking “humorous” content for offensive material.

Bat it back, don’t own it!

5YearsLeft · 03/01/2022 06:34

I agree with @GreenGreenTreesOfHome but maybe for a different reason than a few others. And I’m sure those saying it’s a joke aren’t bad people at all. But did the “it’s just a joke” posters know the greatest factor in whether you’ll end up divorced or being left by your spouse if you get cancer or multiple sclerosis is female gender? Women only leave sick men 2.9 percent of the time. But men leave sick women 20.8 percent of the time. People tell me all the time that I’m lucky my DH stayed, and compared to the statistics, I suppose I am. Because if jokes from childhood tell men that marriage is a life sentence, then how much worse is marriage to a sick woman? A marriage where she can no longer do the wife work? Apparently, bad enough that 1/5th of men feel no guilt over leaving women with cancer, or multiple sclerosis.

I think the people who are saying it’s just a joke, are missing something really important here. If society “tells” men, even through jokes, that marriage BY ITSELF is already a “ball and chain” and a “life sentence”… then a marriage to:

  • a sick woman
  • a dying woman
  • a woman who can’t do “wife work” or “house admin” for some reason
  • a woman too sick to have sex
  • a woman who has severe vaginal damage after having children with her husband (and can’t have sex for a long period)
  • a woman in the hospital
  • a woman busy being a carer for someone else

is “too much punishment” on top of that already “life sentence.” When men leave women on this list, other women might be disgusted, but I’ve seen and heard a lot of men who aren’t (obviously, there are men who are disgusted too - it’s not 100% either way).

I do think that a lot of the posters agreeing with the “just a joke” approach mean no harm, and I love a laugh, laughing keeps me alive, but when we joke about things, they become engrained in our society. We no longer joke about certain terms (racist, sexist, ageist, etc) because it hurts society. So maybe it’s time to consider this one does, as well.

ElftonWednesday · 03/01/2022 06:00

What really fucks me off is a couple of times if I've bought a more expensive item, the (older male) shop assistant has said "Spending your husband's money, eh?"

I just replied "No, I'm spending my own money." And gave them a look which I hope was like Paddington Bear when someone forgets their manners.

I've been the higher earner for most of the time we've been together.

WeaverofWords · 03/01/2022 04:10

Great thread. We need to get rid of implicit sexism like this, at least for our children’s sakes. I don’t want my kids to grow up thinking marriage is any kind of sentence, regardless of what sex they are.

Also, it’s a stupid statement, anyway, that says more about the unintelligent state of the contestant: clearly it wasn’t a “life sentence” if there were two of them.

My father benefitted enormously from his marriage. Apart from my mother sorting his stuff out whilst bringing in a hefty income, she died young, leaving him with various pensions.

Pendolino · 03/01/2022 03:40

It is mostly older men that make these shitty comments and thankfully the attitude should die off when they all pop their clogs.

nalabae · 03/01/2022 03:17

Gross statement and not funny I don’t get it. This world being married for more than 10yrs Is an achievement which should be celebrated not mocked.

RedRobin100 · 03/01/2022 03:11

I hope his mum tells him where to go shove his holiday

TrishM80 · 03/01/2022 03:02

Whether marriage "benefits" men more than women or not, I think it is true to say that women push for marriage more than men though. How many times do we hear a couple is going on holiday somewhere, usually abroad, the woman's girlfriends will be getting her hyped up about "ooh, he's going to pop the question on this trip, I know it!".

Then if the fella doesn't propose, the woman is devastated and he's in the doghouse for the next 6 months until he's almost guilted into proposing!

UndertheCedartree · 03/01/2022 03:01

If I'm honest I've always heard this joke the other way around - how the woman would have got less for murder kind of thing.

ChristmasDay2021 · 03/01/2022 02:44

I understand the points you are making @FutureExH but think your experience is less typical. I would add that many women who have stepped back in some way from work do know what it is like to have a demanding job - I used to work far longer hours than my DH does in leading a team in a high pressure setting, my work phone was never off, I worked incredibly hard to climb the corporate ladder. But I did get some down time, even if not every day, and that made a difference. Incidentally, I'll never be able to return to that industry now in the same way, despite all that.

Like I said - I'm clear and appreciative of the privilege, but making an observation that my DH has free time (I promise that he does not spend two hours a night or a whole day at weekends with school applications or whatever, not least because I do them!) whereas I do not ever, but I'm considered lucky that he does sometimes join the kids and I at weekends or help with the cooking. Now, I am incredibly lucky in most ways, but do notice here an inequality which I suspect is more the theme in many marriages.

BasicDad · 03/01/2022 01:10

I hear you @FutureExH

But it's not quite as straight as you say. Yes, with the right job/role being a FT working parent it can be manageable.

However, babies through 3 years old are no walk in the park. Add multiple kids across a few age ranges, and it's very hard. What I'm trying to say, is SAHP ranges from easy mode to nightmare mode. And it can be nightmare mode for many years.

Still, my experience is similar to yours. I've been RP to a singleton of school age for over 4 years. Yes. It's easy-ish to manage the house and mental load, and my work role enables it. I consider myself (and my child) fortunate that is the case though. It might not be unheard of, but it's certainly not the most common scenario.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 03/01/2022 00:49

Also you’re taking your particular STBXW and assuming others are like her -‘or your interpretation of her.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 03/01/2022 00:47

@FutureExH you’re comparing apples with oranges. A SAHP to school age children may well be easier than a full time demanding job. A SAHP to babies/ toddlers / and preschoolers isn’t. Especially as the poster you’re replying to is also retraining in the evenings!

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 03/01/2022 00:43

Apparently the happiest people are married men and single women. So I think it’s factually incorrect as much as misogynistic.

LondonQueen · 03/01/2022 00:37

Jeez, who rattled your cage?

FutureExH · 03/01/2022 00:25

[quote ChristmasDay2021]@FutureExH it's anecdotal I admit but in my experience it isn't a lazy stereotype but more often than not the reality. Perhaps not in your situation but many others.

I have very young (not school age) kids and am temporarily at home while retraining (having given up a career where I was - just - the higher earner to facilitate his career move around the kids) but to it would probably take a few years of sitting on my bum with school age kids to catch up with my DH's free time, although ultimately I am very grateful that he supports us financially and overall our marriage is ok. He gets at least two hours to himself every night, his hours aren't that long either, practically unlimited hobby time at the weekends, and a full night's sleep every night. I have done virtually every night wake for two children for nearly four years, neither child sleeps through, and have almost never left the house without one or both kids. I haven't done my hobby since my eldest was born, haven't had any nights out, and never have any downtime in the evening as that's my time to study and it is considered entirely my responsibility to find time for, even though it means I can't go to bed early despite often being woken five or more times a night on my own.

Yet I'm always being told how lucky I am because he sometimes cooks, and often comes for a walk with us at the weekends! I'm glad to be with my children while they are so little, and to have the opportunity to retrain now, but if he leaves me tomorrow I'll be ruined financially whereas his career has sailed without any childcare concerns and ample time to sleep and relax to support this career. I'm sure I'll recover mine eventually but there will be nobody to make sure the children are thought about while I'm free to commit to whatever is needed[/quote]
I think it's common enough to be "a thing" and I can easily think of men I know who didn't pull their weight around the house (mostly men who are older than me). I also know plenty of stay at home parents - mostly women - who do a fantastic job and work just as hard or harder than their "breadwinner" spouses. However, that does not mean these stereotypes should have any place in our laws that should treat every case as unique but I fear that unfortunately they do. Breadwinners who pull their weight lose out the most; stay-at-home-parents who do the bare minimum gain the most.

All this used to be water off a duck's back when my STBXW used to make comments about how I had "so much free time." It was true I spent time commuting and I guess that was "free time" although I'm not sure how I'd have gotten to work otherwise! However, I regularly had to log on and work in the evenings too whilst she watched telly all night. I assumed she had been busy all day and was tired until lockdown. That's when I learned that the school runs, a load of laundry, a cleaning job like vacuuming the whole house and making the DDs dinner was about 3 hours work maximum a day.

Don't get me wrong. I know being a SAHP can be monotonous. I often spent the entire weekend (when they weren't at school) looking after the DDs on my own before we separated because she felt like going out. Obviously I do a lot more than that on my own now! It's still nothing like the stress and demand of keeping a well paid job though. SAHPs who envy their spouses' lives need to grow up and learn empathy. It's a privilege to be able to quit work and bring your own children up that less and less people can do because their partners don't earn enough. SAHPs also need to fact check their opinions on the free time of their earning spouses. I know I spent most of the time I was accused of "doing nothing" with "fun" jobs like renewing insurance, paying bills, checking bank accounts, replying to school letters, helping with homework and all the other crap that comes with being an adult that my STBXW was oblivious to.

ChristmasDay2021 · 02/01/2022 22:21

@FutureExH it's anecdotal I admit but in my experience it isn't a lazy stereotype but more often than not the reality. Perhaps not in your situation but many others.

I have very young (not school age) kids and am temporarily at home while retraining (having given up a career where I was - just - the higher earner to facilitate his career move around the kids) but to it would probably take a few years of sitting on my bum with school age kids to catch up with my DH's free time, although ultimately I am very grateful that he supports us financially and overall our marriage is ok. He gets at least two hours to himself every night, his hours aren't that long either, practically unlimited hobby time at the weekends, and a full night's sleep every night. I have done virtually every night wake for two children for nearly four years, neither child sleeps through, and have almost never left the house without one or both kids. I haven't done my hobby since my eldest was born, haven't had any nights out, and never have any downtime in the evening as that's my time to study and it is considered entirely my responsibility to find time for, even though it means I can't go to bed early despite often being woken five or more times a night on my own.

Yet I'm always being told how lucky I am because he sometimes cooks, and often comes for a walk with us at the weekends! I'm glad to be with my children while they are so little, and to have the opportunity to retrain now, but if he leaves me tomorrow I'll be ruined financially whereas his career has sailed without any childcare concerns and ample time to sleep and relax to support this career. I'm sure I'll recover mine eventually but there will be nobody to make sure the children are thought about while I'm free to commit to whatever is needed

FutureExH · 02/01/2022 21:55

[quote FredWinnie]@swimlyn

And finally: it’s easy to spot the hidden men on this thread, isn’t it? Smile
God yes!

It's children that tip the balance, IMO
Once a couple has children, then the fathers seem to enjoy the best of both worlds: they have a partner who (often) works and who does a lot, if not all, of the wifework
Women with children seem to end up taking on so much that it really does become a lengthy sentence

It used to be the norm for married women to suffer in silence at being treated like servants, but thanks to the internet and forums like this, the myth that women adore being married and have few other aspirations other than to 'bag a man' is slowly being challenged.
Too slowly, IMO[/quote]
Whilst I think statistically it is more common for women to end up doing most of the housework in dual income households (and should be the norm where they are the SAHP and the hours of labour are divided equally between a couple), from my own experience and that of many of my male colleagues suggests that it is not absolute.

First of all, we need to slay a myth. Being a SAHP to school age children is not equivalent to a full time job. If it was, SAHPs in divorce cases wouldn't be expected to go out and work and maximise their earning capacity when their children reach school age and single parents similarly would not be expected to work on pain of losing their benefits. Also, before people pile on me for saying something "controversial" read the rest.

My STBXW was a SAHP and up until lockdown would do most of the housework and childcare. Since lockdown began two things happened.

  1. I learned just how much time she sat on her backside doing nothing each day. I guess SAHPs can fill a day cleaning, cooking, making up activities for their kids etc but they certainly don't have to;

  2. I gradually picked up most of the chores including washing up, laundry, vacuuming, cleaning, cooking, sitting with kids to do homework etc etc. I could fit it around my full time job but it meant my SAHP STBXW did even less than before.

Nevertheless, lazy stereotypes about men and women will no doubt continue to be peddled especially by SAHPs who want to avoid the world of work after a divorce.

FredWinnie · 31/12/2021 20:16

@swimlyn

And finally: it’s easy to spot the hidden men on this thread, isn’t it? Smile
God yes!

It's children that tip the balance, IMO
Once a couple has children, then the fathers seem to enjoy the best of both worlds: they have a partner who (often) works and who does a lot, if not all, of the wifework
Women with children seem to end up taking on so much that it really does become a lengthy sentence

It used to be the norm for married women to suffer in silence at being treated like servants, but thanks to the internet and forums like this, the myth that women adore being married and have few other aspirations other than to 'bag a man' is slowly being challenged.
Too slowly, IMO

Echobelly · 31/12/2021 18:14

I hate that kind of attitude as well OP - like women 'trap' men in miserable marriages because obviously men should be free to go around shagging everyone really. Whereas, as others have said, there's so much evidence as to the way it massively benefits men and has the opposite effect for women, which us the really galling bit when people still insist in this attitude.

It harks back to a time when a woman was reliant on a man so it meant him giving up 'his' money.

JustLyra · 31/12/2021 18:10

The protection of marriage really only kicks in when the shit hits the fan.

My DH benefitted from the protections when his first wife died very young. Widowed parents allowance (although it’s now much less generous) really helped with suddenly having to change career (she worked days and he worked nights), as did inheritance rules.

PinkPiranha11 · 31/12/2021 17:14

Marriage has huge benefits for men….it seems to be a free housekeeper, free Nanny situation for lots of men I know. If I had daughters (I don’t) I’d tell them to think very carefully before getting married. I can’t see many benefits to marriage for young women in heterosexual relationships - other than the law seems to protects married women more than unmarried ones in the event of separation!!