Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why this attitude towards marriage for men still exists?! [hmm]

158 replies

GreenGreenTreesOfHome · 28/12/2021 14:10

NC for this as I don't want it linking with my other posts.

There was a man on Family Fortunes yesterday, who said he wants to treat his parents to a holiday for their 50th wedding anniversary if he wins some decent money. He said 'my dad has had 2 life sentences, he deserves the break!' He said NOTHING about his mum.

It really REALLY fucking pissed me off. He thought he was funny, Gino just looked a bit Shock and it was pretty much like tumbleweed in the TV studio (with a couple of quiet nervous giggles,) but it made me so furious. Angry

Why is it a 'life sentence' for a man to be married for a long time, but an achievement, and something to be celebrated for a woman? I thought this horrible, wanky attitude had been consigned to the history books.

But no, for men, it's still a tedious chore to be married apparently, and a 'ball and chain' and a 'life sentence!' Yet it's OK for women to be married, and as I say, it's classed as an achievement, and something to be celebrated for HER. Hmm

I have heard many times in the past actually, that men are healthier and happier when they're married, and actually get more out of marriage than women do. So why is this bullshit still a thing?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WeaverofWords · 03/01/2022 15:07

@Bucanarab

Can only assume a lot of posters on this thread are new to mumsnet but, considering barely a week goes by without a "I'd bury my husband under the patio if he did/said X" joke being made, you're all in for a shock.
You’re clearly new to these parts. Many of us don’t have husbands.
WeaverofWords · 03/01/2022 15:05

@MushMonster

Whatever is said will be taken in an offensive way by some people. It is actions that matter. Action in the example is that this man wants to celebrate his parents long marriage. If he was saying, I want to buy a new car for my father on his wedding anniversary because poor him, he has served two life sentences already! Then, that is not right really. But quite a few of you have serious issues with facts, and you make a huge mountain out of a grain of sand! Try to chill a bit, and focus on equalling tasks between women and men, instead of a joke. Though, I suppose suppressing others sense of humour is easier than actually doing something about it. All this microanalysing each word only pushes people away from any subject. Just chill a bit!
  • some jokes are unfunny
  • some jokes are offensive
  • some jokes are both
  • some jokes are neither

It can’t be that hard to get material to fit the latter category. Not every complaint about comedians is about material being offensive.

Besides which, it wasn’t a comedian who made the statement. It was a contestant on the programme.

IveNameChangedAgain2020 · 03/01/2022 15:05

@Iputthetrampintrampoline I would be hugely proud of your son, I think my son would say the same. If you don't call out acts of sexism/racism etc then I think you are just as culpable.

FutureExH · 03/01/2022 13:10

@BasicDad

I hear you *@FutureExH*

But it's not quite as straight as you say. Yes, with the right job/role being a FT working parent it can be manageable.

However, babies through 3 years old are no walk in the park. Add multiple kids across a few age ranges, and it's very hard. What I'm trying to say, is SAHP ranges from easy mode to nightmare mode. And it can be nightmare mode for many years.

Still, my experience is similar to yours. I've been RP to a singleton of school age for over 4 years. Yes. It's easy-ish to manage the house and mental load, and my work role enables it. I consider myself (and my child) fortunate that is the case though. It might not be unheard of, but it's certainly not the most common scenario.

You're pushing some generalisations again. I'm not here to challenge people's anecdotes, I'm simply saying that generalisations should be avoided.

For example, you say that babies through to 3 years old are no walk in the park. Well, I've got three daughters and honestly they're harder now than they were before they turned 3. I'm not saying this through observation but through experience. I've had my DDs on their own some days and some nights from the day they were born.

Maybe I was lucky but my DDs all slept through 90% of the time from 6 months old and all napped a lot until they were 3. They're no easier to deal with now because nappies, sleepless nights and dressing them have just turned into arguments about washing hands when they go to the loo, very early morning devastation in the kitchen, homework and the sheer frustration of waiting for them to get ready when we're going out! So maybe some parents find it gets easier but in my experience the work just changes so the generalisation doesn't apply to my family.

I'm also not saying my experience is common, only that it exists and when people make sweeping generalisations about SAHPs being saints and breadwinners being lucky they're not just ignoring those of us who make the money but do most of the housework too, they're also jeopardising our futures when we divorce because these horrible generalisations that don't apply to us do permeate the world of mediators, family solicitors and courts. In my case, a myth like that could see my STBXW take 80% of the assets, maintenance for herself and residency only to chuck my DDs on an iPad for 4 hours solid every day whilst they sext on their smartphone.

So I'll say it again. There's a difference between a SAHP and a parent who just doesn't work and we need to recognise that.

FutureExH · 03/01/2022 12:56

[quote GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing]@FutureExH you’re comparing apples with oranges. A SAHP to school age children may well be easier than a full time demanding job. A SAHP to babies/ toddlers / and preschoolers isn’t. Especially as the poster you’re replying to is also retraining in the evenings![/quote]
I'm not making a case against individuals, I'm making a case against sweeping generalisations that cause actual harm to real people.

For example, you make a sweeping generalisation that being a SAHP to babies, toddlers and preschoolers is harder than being a SAHP to school age children. Having spent many a weekend on my own with my children from the day they were born I know that is absolute rubbish and just another generalisation. My children were a lot easier when they were toddlers! Granted it can be boring, monotonous and repetitive with children that age but it's the confinement rather than the work that was hard, at least that was my experience.

My case doesn't fit the myth peddled by people like you though so it's not allowed to exist. Anyone who dares to contradict the generalisation is a "misogynist" (I see you're also ignoring that SAHPs can be men too, even though there are plenty of posts on this site about "lazy" male SAHPs who are criticised for performing exactly the same role).

MushMonster · 03/01/2022 12:34

Lol I set my standards on actions and it has given me a good lifeGrin

Pendolino · 03/01/2022 12:28

@MushMonster

Whatever is said will be taken in an offensive way by some people. It is actions that matter. Action in the example is that this man wants to celebrate his parents long marriage. If he was saying, I want to buy a new car for my father on his wedding anniversary because poor him, he has served two life sentences already! Then, that is not right really. But quite a few of you have serious issues with facts, and you make a huge mountain out of a grain of sand! Try to chill a bit, and focus on equalling tasks between women and men, instead of a joke. Though, I suppose suppressing others sense of humour is easier than actually doing something about it. All this microanalysing each word only pushes people away from any subject. Just chill a bit!
It’s not funny though, it’s lame. Sorry that you have such low standards
Bucanarab · 03/01/2022 12:23

Can only assume a lot of posters on this thread are new to mumsnet but, considering barely a week goes by without a "I'd bury my husband under the patio if he did/said X" joke being made, you're all in for a shock.

MushMonster · 03/01/2022 12:12

Whatever is said will be taken in an offensive way by some people.
It is actions that matter.
Action in the example is that this man wants to celebrate his parents long marriage.
If he was saying, I want to buy a new car for my father on his wedding anniversary because poor him, he has served two life sentences already! Then, that is not right really.
But quite a few of you have serious issues with facts, and you make a huge mountain out of a grain of sand! Try to chill a bit, and focus on equalling tasks between women and men, instead of a joke.
Though, I suppose suppressing others sense of humour is easier than actually doing something about it. All this microanalysing each word only pushes people away from any subject. Just chill a bit!

Pendolino · 03/01/2022 11:47

Comedy writers need to be coming up with original material, not recycling the same old crap.

WeaverofWords · 03/01/2022 11:33

@MushMonster

It is just a lighthearted joke. The truth, as you say, is that men do much better if they are married. So, you could say "you lucky", or you could have a bit of sarcastic sense of humour and say " oh this "life-sentence" of yours". I do not find it offensive, he is not really meaning the literal words, he is playing the game to celebrate their marriage! "One life sentence" gets you through the hard work of raising your children, "two" through getting them married and helping them settle and start having their babies!, and all the joy that comes with it. The sad thing is that many women actualy end up working more if they are married. Between the stress in the body of pregnancy and birth, and that many work out of the household, and then do a large share of the household. Big cheers for married women!
“This is a lighthearted joke” “It’s not literal” “He’s not meaning it”

All these things are enabling this sexist bullshit to be peddled. How about we have jokes that are properly funny, well-meant, and clear in their non-sexism?

WeaverofWords · 03/01/2022 11:30

@WhatAWasteOfOranges

This is why there was that report on the news recently that comedy is in trouble. People are so quick to get offended & cancel culture. I think it’s a bit narrow minded to think that everyone is going to have the same humour and opinions. Yeh it’s a crappy joke but I can’t get worked up about it. Who knows what was edited out that the son may have said about his Mother.
Perhaps the same editor should have edited out this bullshit “joke” too, then, cos as you say, it’s a crappy joke.

Indeed, we might say that the reason why comedy is in trouble, is because the jokes are unfunny, and sexist, if this is anything to go by.

5YearsLeft · 03/01/2022 11:15

@Hrpuffnstuff1

I'm struggling to see what 'benefits' men get out of marriage.
How about staying alive?

I suppose I could wax on about partnership, love, romance, having someone to support you, but let’s talk science.

Never-married men are three times more likely to die of heart disease than married men. On the other hand, married men are 46% less likely to die over a 10-year period than unmarried men, even taking age, body fat, smoking, blood pressure, diabetes, and cholesterol into account. And the studies show it’s not because healthier men are the ones who get married.

The studies prove: men living with partners have better health but those living with their wives “have the best health of all.”

www.health.harvard.edu/mens-health/marriage-and-mens-health (page includes results of several studies)

Iputthetrampintrampoline · 03/01/2022 11:05

Not rude at all,Mainly demonstrating that life and marriage is a partnership requiring teamwork and dedication and respect plus input equally from both sides, No one is more deserving or more important than the other and the attitude of men are king whilst the poor little woman be kept down in her place of servitude often as well as holding down employment herself and still running the home etc is, as it should be. as out dated as the dinosaurs, Serve the men first,,oh no! no place for that in any society these days, Rude no sorry ,outspoken yes totally ..was .he was wrong , to challenge and question such antiquated ideas? If so the lot of women will never change. I rather admired his respect for the females of the world! still we can all beg to differ!

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 03/01/2022 11:00

I know the conversation has moved on a bit - but yes these ‘jokes’ irk me too.

See also: bride throwing a bouquet and the woman that catches it, her boyfriend runs away. Hilarious. Equally hilarious, the one woman who doesn’t make an attempt to catch it and the boyfriend stands proudly looking on at his Cool Girlfriend.

Ho ho ho.

MushMonster · 03/01/2022 10:40

@Iputthetrampintrampoline

OP you would have been so proud of my son yesterday! we were at my mums for Xmas dinner as everyone had had covid so it was the first time we could all get together and it was time for lunch to be served,this was the conversation that followed.. My mum...right tramp you get the plates and do the meat ,,serve the men first My darling son 30 yrs what did you just say Granny? Mum I am telling your mother to plate up and serve the men first My son..Siorry Gran but sod that..its 2022 you and mum sit down we will serve you first,You have done everything sit down right now and let us mere men sort it out ,,go on sit yourself down My mum was mortified and very angry with him ..I just beamed,literally beamed, My heart sang at his attempt to right everything that was wrong with that situation and he did,It ended up with a bit of a debate which ended with my mum saying she didnt like these new fangled ways and she wasnt having it about women and men being equal , She believed men were there to be served by mere women it was our job to look after our men and keep them happy,fed ,watered and looked after cos it was our place and how things have always been and how it should be and how it is proper. My wonderful son was not having any of it and was very vocal.It was an interesting day! I began to wash up and ended up instead of being on my own ,which I was quite happy to be pottering about in peace and quiet whilst a noisy game was taking place in the living room was joined by 3 of the 4 men there,one who tidied,one who dried the washing up and one who put the furniture back and swept the floor.Sit down mum I will put the kettle on...my son my bloody wonderful,caring,thoughtful,modern thinking son...Sorry Gran you couldnt win your argument!!! I only hope the rest of the younger generation lead with putting to bed the outdated steryotyping that my mums generation think is normal,After yesterday I feel we may soon see the back of this rubbish and well not before time!!
Well done to him for helping and asking his grandmother and mother to sit after they had been cooking! This sounds fair to me. About how you speak to family, each family is as bold or as formal as they choose to be with each other. I cannot imagine calling my grandmother host for a family meal, for example.
Pendolino · 03/01/2022 10:38

@WhatAWasteOfOranges

This is why there was that report on the news recently that comedy is in trouble. People are so quick to get offended & cancel culture. I think it’s a bit narrow minded to think that everyone is going to have the same humour and opinions. Yeh it’s a crappy joke but I can’t get worked up about it. Who knows what was edited out that the son may have said about his Mother.
Comedy is in trouble because most comedians are lame and unfunny.
MushMonster · 03/01/2022 10:34

It is just a lighthearted joke. The truth, as you say, is that men do much better if they are married. So, you could say "you lucky", or you could have a bit of sarcastic sense of humour and say " oh this "life-sentence" of yours".
I do not find it offensive, he is not really meaning the literal words, he is playing the game to celebrate their marriage!
"One life sentence" gets you through the hard work of raising your children, "two" through getting them married and helping them settle and start having their babies!, and all the joy that comes with it.
The sad thing is that many women actualy end up working more if they are married. Between the stress in the body of pregnancy and birth, and that many work out of the household, and then do a large share of the household. Big cheers for married women!

Thesearmsofmine · 03/01/2022 10:33

@Iputthetrampintrampoline

OP you would have been so proud of my son yesterday! we were at my mums for Xmas dinner as everyone had had covid so it was the first time we could all get together and it was time for lunch to be served,this was the conversation that followed.. My mum...right tramp you get the plates and do the meat ,,serve the men first My darling son 30 yrs what did you just say Granny? Mum I am telling your mother to plate up and serve the men first My son..Siorry Gran but sod that..its 2022 you and mum sit down we will serve you first,You have done everything sit down right now and let us mere men sort it out ,,go on sit yourself down My mum was mortified and very angry with him ..I just beamed,literally beamed, My heart sang at his attempt to right everything that was wrong with that situation and he did,It ended up with a bit of a debate which ended with my mum saying she didnt like these new fangled ways and she wasnt having it about women and men being equal , She believed men were there to be served by mere women it was our job to look after our men and keep them happy,fed ,watered and looked after cos it was our place and how things have always been and how it should be and how it is proper. My wonderful son was not having any of it and was very vocal.It was an interesting day! I began to wash up and ended up instead of being on my own ,which I was quite happy to be pottering about in peace and quiet whilst a noisy game was taking place in the living room was joined by 3 of the 4 men there,one who tidied,one who dried the washing up and one who put the furniture back and swept the floor.Sit down mum I will put the kettle on...my son my bloody wonderful,caring,thoughtful,modern thinking son...Sorry Gran you couldnt win your argument!!! I only hope the rest of the younger generation lead with putting to bed the outdated steryotyping that my mums generation think is normal,After yesterday I feel we may soon see the back of this rubbish and well not before time!!
He just sounds rude and patronising. He could have offered to help nicely without upsetting his grandmother and all the self important talk. I’d have been embarrassed, not proud. Your poor mum.
ufucoffee · 03/01/2022 10:23

@Iputthetrampintrampoline

OP you would have been so proud of my son yesterday! we were at my mums for Xmas dinner as everyone had had covid so it was the first time we could all get together and it was time for lunch to be served,this was the conversation that followed.. My mum...right tramp you get the plates and do the meat ,,serve the men first My darling son 30 yrs what did you just say Granny? Mum I am telling your mother to plate up and serve the men first My son..Siorry Gran but sod that..its 2022 you and mum sit down we will serve you first,You have done everything sit down right now and let us mere men sort it out ,,go on sit yourself down My mum was mortified and very angry with him ..I just beamed,literally beamed, My heart sang at his attempt to right everything that was wrong with that situation and he did,It ended up with a bit of a debate which ended with my mum saying she didnt like these new fangled ways and she wasnt having it about women and men being equal , She believed men were there to be served by mere women it was our job to look after our men and keep them happy,fed ,watered and looked after cos it was our place and how things have always been and how it should be and how it is proper. My wonderful son was not having any of it and was very vocal.It was an interesting day! I began to wash up and ended up instead of being on my own ,which I was quite happy to be pottering about in peace and quiet whilst a noisy game was taking place in the living room was joined by 3 of the 4 men there,one who tidied,one who dried the washing up and one who put the furniture back and swept the floor.Sit down mum I will put the kettle on...my son my bloody wonderful,caring,thoughtful,modern thinking son...Sorry Gran you couldnt win your argument!!! I only hope the rest of the younger generation lead with putting to bed the outdated steryotyping that my mums generation think is normal,After yesterday I feel we may soon see the back of this rubbish and well not before time!!
Really? You were proud of him for talking to his grandmother like that? Her house, her rules even if he doesn't agree with them. He'd have got a massive telling off from me.
curlii103 · 03/01/2022 09:13

He wants to buy them a holiday to celebrate 50yrs together. Assume they all get on well and are happy!

notanothertakeaway · 03/01/2022 09:06

@Iputthetrampintrampoline

OP you would have been so proud of my son yesterday! we were at my mums for Xmas dinner as everyone had had covid so it was the first time we could all get together and it was time for lunch to be served,this was the conversation that followed.. My mum...right tramp you get the plates and do the meat ,,serve the men first My darling son 30 yrs what did you just say Granny? Mum I am telling your mother to plate up and serve the men first My son..Siorry Gran but sod that..its 2022 you and mum sit down we will serve you first,You have done everything sit down right now and let us mere men sort it out ,,go on sit yourself down My mum was mortified and very angry with him ..I just beamed,literally beamed, My heart sang at his attempt to right everything that was wrong with that situation and he did,It ended up with a bit of a debate which ended with my mum saying she didnt like these new fangled ways and she wasnt having it about women and men being equal , She believed men were there to be served by mere women it was our job to look after our men and keep them happy,fed ,watered and looked after cos it was our place and how things have always been and how it should be and how it is proper. My wonderful son was not having any of it and was very vocal.It was an interesting day! I began to wash up and ended up instead of being on my own ,which I was quite happy to be pottering about in peace and quiet whilst a noisy game was taking place in the living room was joined by 3 of the 4 men there,one who tidied,one who dried the washing up and one who put the furniture back and swept the floor.Sit down mum I will put the kettle on...my son my bloody wonderful,caring,thoughtful,modern thinking son...Sorry Gran you couldnt win your argument!!! I only hope the rest of the younger generation lead with putting to bed the outdated steryotyping that my mums generation think is normal,After yesterday I feel we may soon see the back of this rubbish and well not before time!!
@Iputthetrampintrampoline I think your son was rude, TBH. All he had to say was "Sit down Mum, I'm happy to help, I've got this", instead of lecturing his hosts
notanothertakeaway · 03/01/2022 08:48

@RampantIvy

but the salesman constantly kept referring to it previously being owned by "one lady driver".

Actually, statistically, it could mean that the car is in better nick. Car insurance is usually cheaper for women as well.

@RampantIvy

In the past, car insurance was often cheaper for women, as, statistically they have fewer accidents. But this changed a few years ago, as it was considered discriminatory

WhatAWasteOfOranges · 03/01/2022 08:39

This is why there was that report on the news recently that comedy is in trouble. People are so quick to get offended & cancel culture.
I think it’s a bit narrow minded to think that everyone is going to have the same humour and opinions. Yeh it’s a crappy joke but I can’t get worked up about it. Who knows what was edited out that the son may have said about his Mother.

Iputthetrampintrampoline · 03/01/2022 08:37

OP you would have been so proud of my son yesterday! we were at my mums for Xmas dinner as everyone had had covid so it was the first time we could all get together and it was time for lunch to be served,this was the conversation that followed..
My mum...right tramp you get the plates and do the meat ,,serve the men first
My darling son 30 yrs what did you just say Granny?
Mum I am telling your mother to plate up and serve the men first
My son..Siorry Gran but sod that..its 2022 you and mum sit down we will serve you first,You have done everything sit down right now and let us mere men sort it out ,,go on sit yourself down
My mum was mortified and very angry with him ..I just beamed,literally beamed, My heart sang at his attempt to right everything that was wrong with that situation and he did,It ended up with a bit of a debate which ended with my mum saying she didnt like these new fangled ways and she wasnt having it about women and men being equal , She believed men were there to be served by mere women it was our job to look after our men and keep them happy,fed ,watered and looked after cos it was our place and how things have always been and how it should be and how it is proper. My wonderful son was not having any of it and was very vocal.It was an interesting day! I began to wash up and ended up instead of being on my own ,which I was quite happy to be pottering about in peace and quiet whilst a noisy game was taking place in the living room was joined by 3 of the 4 men there,one who tidied,one who dried the washing up and one who put the furniture back and swept the floor.Sit down mum I will put the kettle on...my son my bloody wonderful,caring,thoughtful,modern thinking son...Sorry Gran you couldnt win your argument!!! I only hope the rest of the younger generation lead with putting to bed the outdated steryotyping that my mums generation think is normal,After yesterday I feel we may soon see the back of this rubbish and well not before time!!

Swipe left for the next trending thread