Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Caused upset!

137 replies

Mellowyellow222 · 28/12/2021 12:52

We had a family gathering on Boxing Day.

We have a cousin who has recently reconnected with the family. He is my mums cousin, and we don’t really know him. This was the first time meeting his wife. They are in their early sixties and have recently married.

He introduced himself to my two nieces as their uncle Fred, and couple used the term aunt and uncle repeatedly to all the children there. They hadn’t met any of the children before so didn’t know their names - or if they were even in the family. One Niece asked me quietly afterwards who he was and if he was really her uncle.

I explained that he was a type of cousin so no not really an uncle but some people use that term for wider family members - we don’t in our family and only parents siblings are called aunt and uncle. But I explained he was just being friendly.

This mans wife overheard and they have now made a big deal about not be made to feel welcome and how we don’t accept them as family? My parents think I should apologise.

This is bonkers right? He isn’t her uncle - how else was I supposed to explain this? I am not sure what I am apologising for so I have refused.

OP posts:
LunaMay · 28/12/2021 16:27

Were you the only one to have this reaction to them OP? Did any one else mention the uncle/aunty thing before your conversation with your niece?

Klinkerbell · 28/12/2021 16:22

They sound like people who like to cause dissension in a group, so they can worm themselves closer by playing victim.

bananabuddy3 · 28/12/2021 16:13

They sound like the kind of people who likely get offended over everything.

I have lots of “aunts and uncles” who are exactly the term we are using here, not actually aunts and uncles but extended relatives and family friends considered as family.

You’re explanation was correct but clearly was misinterpreted or taken to heart. I wouldn’t apologise as such, but maybe just clarify what you were saying and if they still take offence and get upset then step back and leave them to have a whinge because sadly some people are just like that.

“ Fred and wife, I realise you are upset about something said to niece. I apologise if you’ve interpreted what I said to mean we don’t think you are family. I was explaining to niece that in the literal sense, you are not an uncle, but that it’s a term many use for extended family because it’s much easier than saying “second cousin Fred 8 times removed” or whatever. Also by saying we don’t tend to use it in the family, again this wasn’t implying anything to you, it was simply a factual term - until now, we havn’t. If we do from now on that’s fine. Of course you are family, you are just newly reunited and niece was curious. No offence or implications were meant at all. You are back in our lives, let’s move on.”

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 28/12/2021 15:51

@ThanksItHasPockets

This topic has come up before and an awful lot of MNers are very literal about the use of ‘aunt’ and ‘uncle’ being reserved specifically for the siblings of parents and their spouses only.

I grew up in north-west England with family across the region and in north Wales. It was considered very normal to address any older family member, regardless of specific relationships, as ‘auntie’ and ‘uncle’, as well as close family friends. I went to a preschool where the children addressed the staff as ‘Auntie X’ and it was so long-established that the preschool was universally known as ‘Auntie June’s.’ It implies a degree of respect and trust. It would have been considered overfamiliar to address those adults by their name only. It would always be initiated by our parents and it was a tacit signal that this was a trustworthy adult.

All of which is secondary to your OP! You’ve done nothing wrong and like you I would be very wary of a virtual stranger trying to crowbar himself and his wife into the family like this.

All of this. There are big regional and (though we are never supposed to mention this on MN) class differences in what families consider normal. But there isn't a right or wrong, there is just the norm for your family - which is what the OP told her DD.

What was wrong - and weird - was the reaction.

CPL593H · 28/12/2021 15:49

We called our more distant cousins (some of whom were 70 years older than us, lot of generational shifts) "Cousin (firstname)". Some friends of parents had the honorific "aunty/uncle" and it can be a nice thing, but the difference being it was never self awarded and certainly not on first contact.

I don't think you've done anything to apologise for and would be avoiding further contact with Uncle and Aunty Drama Llama.

ThanksItHasPockets · 28/12/2021 15:43

This topic has come up before and an awful lot of MNers are very literal about the use of ‘aunt’ and ‘uncle’ being reserved specifically for the siblings of parents and their spouses only.

I grew up in north-west England with family across the region and in north Wales. It was considered very normal to address any older family member, regardless of specific relationships, as ‘auntie’ and ‘uncle’, as well as close family friends. I went to a preschool where the children addressed the staff as ‘Auntie X’ and it was so long-established that the preschool was universally known as ‘Auntie June’s.’ It implies a degree of respect and trust. It would have been considered overfamiliar to address those adults by their name only. It would always be initiated by our parents and it was a tacit signal that this was a trustworthy adult.

All of which is secondary to your OP! You’ve done nothing wrong and like you I would be very wary of a virtual stranger trying to crowbar himself and his wife into the family like this.

Hadjab · 28/12/2021 15:42

@Mellowyellow222

I had wondered if it was a cultural issue. She is from Wales - we are in Ireland.

But manners are universal and it seems odd to create such a fuss over such a little thing the first time you meet people.

I’m of African heritage, it’s normal to call anyone who is your parents age uncle/aunty, your grandparents age grandma/grandpa, anyone your age is your cousin, and younger would be your niece/nephew. We just find it easier that way. My daughter has just had a baby, and has asked me what he is in relation to her cousins, and I had to look it up! Maybe that’s how your extended family member and his wife were brought up?
billy1966 · 28/12/2021 15:42

@itsgettingweird

I'd ask the person asking you to apologise to clarify that

"You want me to apologise for saying he's a cousin (truth), not an uncle in the sense niece understands (truth), and some families use aunt and uncle for elder relatives - but we generally don't (truth)"

This.

I'd be very wary of someone that I hadn't seen in 30 years kicking up a fuss like that.

Very strange.

Great excuse to avoid them.

They reek of drama.

WingingItSince1973 · 28/12/2021 15:36

@BusterGonad

I get a bit creeped out when adults are referred to as 'uncles/aunties' when they quite clearly are not. Its too familiar for my liking and gives them too much authority over young children.

Absolutely agree with this x

pigsDOfly · 28/12/2021 15:34

When my children were young in the 80s my next door neighbour would refer to herself as 'auntie Joan' when talking to them, used to annoy the hell out of me.

I always just used her name when talking to them about her, she wasn't their aunt.

Likewise this man isn't your nieces uncle and his wife is most definitely not your nieces aunt.

I think your answer was absolutely fine.

Absolutely do not apologise.

IrishMama2015 · 28/12/2021 15:33

@Cocomarine really, in Ireland? Maybe a regional thing then. I'm way way rural South, (falling off the end!) and would not be the done thing here

TheOrigRights · 28/12/2021 15:31

It sounds like he is a first cousin once removed (from you) and twice removed from your niece.

I do think we don't have good names for these relations in the English language. Cousin Sally doesn't sound as warm as Aunt Sally.

Anyway, they sound bonkers.

Cocomarine · 28/12/2021 15:30

@IrishMama2015 interesting! In my Irish family (both sides: mum Catholic and south, dad Protestant and north) it’s widespread to call any older male and female - relative or not! - auntie or uncle.

RampantIvy · 28/12/2021 15:27

He isn’t her uncle - how else was I supposed to explain this?

In my family we called my mum's cousins uncle, and their wives auntie. They were the next generation up from us, and it was an accepted thing. Strictly speaking they were my first cousins once removed, but a 6 year old calling a 40 something year old by their christian name alone just wasn't the done thing in the 1960s.

These were all German "aunties" and "uncles" in case it was a cultural thing.

Wreath21 · 28/12/2021 15:26

I grew up calling several unrelated adults Auntie or Uncle - they were very close friends of my parents (who were both only children). There isn't anything inherently wrong with it even though Jilly Cooper says it's vulgar.
However, this couple do sound creepy and a bit strange. As PP said, it might be worth finding out why he was estranged from the family for so long...

ANameChangeAgain · 28/12/2021 15:23

We have a thing in our family when we call older or elderly close friends of the family Auntie and Uncle. My own DC still call a good older family friend Uncle. I do think its something you have to be careful with, as when strangers introduce themselves as aunt and uncle it implies a trust / connection that isn't really there. I think your response was fine. A pp mentioned that you should have warned your dc that these people would be there, which made me chuckle. We have such large families that before every family party my teenagers as if there are any new cousins they are going to meet tonight, there usually are Grin

IrishMama2015 · 28/12/2021 15:23

@Mellowyellow222

I had wondered if it was a cultural issue. She is from Wales - we are in Ireland.

But manners are universal and it seems odd to create such a fuss over such a little thing the first time you meet people.

I was just reading thinking there would be uproar in our Irish family over anyone not an actual uncle or aunt tried to be called auntie or uncle!! Defo not the thing to do
Mrstamborineman · 28/12/2021 15:22

She’s a little screwy and offended that you have not shared joy at their self bestowed title of affection.

BarkminsterBlue · 28/12/2021 15:19

@Mellowyellow222

They were being very over familiar with everyone - I think my niece was confused. It was almost like he was my long lost brother rather than my mums cousin.

I suppose if I am honest I was trying to out a distance between us - I found it all quite uncomfortable. Maybe the wife picked up on that.

I suspect you are right here.

It’s normal in some regions for children to use ‘aunt’ and ‘uncle’ as a term of respect for any older adult or family friend in the wider family and I think that would have been a simpler explanation.

Woeismethischristmas · 28/12/2021 15:18

Meh I’m sure I remember a Christmas conversation where I was told that “uncle” Jimmy was really my first cousin once removed and then everyone round the table worked out how exactly they are related. Kids are curious. I’m not overly keen on extended family or friends being given honorary uncle / aunt title either.

I really don’t understand why this is an issue for them.

Waftypants · 28/12/2021 15:14

Bonkers, be grateful she revealed this to you so early in the process before you invested any more emotional energy.

rc22 · 28/12/2021 15:12

I called one of my mum's cousins 'auntie' growing up but my mum and her were extremely close - more like sisters than cousins. Apart from that, 'auntie' and 'uncle' were reserved for my parent's and grandparent's siblings. That said, my best friend's kids call me auntie.

It's unreasonable of these relatives to expect children who don't know them to use these terms and highly unreasonable of them to be offended by your entirely polite and kind explanation to your nieces.

LegoPandemic · 28/12/2021 15:09

Courtesy title?
I was brought up to call my Godparents Auntie/Uncle and DS does this too.
I have a close friend who is Hindu/ Indian heritage and our children call us Auntie too, it’s a respectful title in their culture and we both like it.

ancientgran · 28/12/2021 15:07

You've all managed without them for 30 years so it won't be much of an issue if they don't want to be family unless they can be aunt and uncle.

Clarice99 · 28/12/2021 15:01

Your parents are the bigger problem here. You don't owe anyone an apology and your parents pushing you to do that is outrageous.

You didn't say anything wrong, you were honest and tactful.

Uncle Fred, his wife and your parents can bugger off Grin

Swipe left for the next trending thread