Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Caused upset!

137 replies

Mellowyellow222 · 28/12/2021 12:52

We had a family gathering on Boxing Day.

We have a cousin who has recently reconnected with the family. He is my mums cousin, and we don’t really know him. This was the first time meeting his wife. They are in their early sixties and have recently married.

He introduced himself to my two nieces as their uncle Fred, and couple used the term aunt and uncle repeatedly to all the children there. They hadn’t met any of the children before so didn’t know their names - or if they were even in the family. One Niece asked me quietly afterwards who he was and if he was really her uncle.

I explained that he was a type of cousin so no not really an uncle but some people use that term for wider family members - we don’t in our family and only parents siblings are called aunt and uncle. But I explained he was just being friendly.

This mans wife overheard and they have now made a big deal about not be made to feel welcome and how we don’t accept them as family? My parents think I should apologise.

This is bonkers right? He isn’t her uncle - how else was I supposed to explain this? I am not sure what I am apologising for so I have refused.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
margotsdevil · 30/12/2021 10:35

I do have a very close relationship with one of my dad's cousins but he was an only child and he grew up with a number of cousins close by. I met all of my parents' cousins and am still in touch with most of them - I didn't realise this wasn't normal but then I only have one actual proper cousin of my own who is a generation apart from me anyway. Interestingly, some of these cousins I called auntie/uncle, some I called cousin whoever, and others were known just by their first name. I also referred to my great aunts and uncles as aunt and uncle. We didn't call any family friends aunt/uncle though.

As an adult I'm honoured to be known as aunt margotsdevil to a few children whose parents are very close friends - but always at the friends instigation - I would never dream of introducing myself as aunt to a child who wasn't actually my niece or nephew without express invitation to do so!

Alpinechalet · 30/12/2021 10:08

I do know my parents cousins and their children and grandchildren. However, this is because pre-Covid we had an annual family get together so we saw each other at least once a year.

Willyoujustbequiet · 30/12/2021 08:53

It's very common here (north east) to call cousins/friends/neighbours Auntie xyz. It just signifies someone known who is older.

I think it may be cultural/regional

BeyondMyWits · 30/12/2021 08:33

I'm in my late 50s and it is great that my kids have the support network round them. My folks are both dead, but the others make up for it. Dd was stuck in her uni town, train strike, dh away with work... uncle"A"'s wife's sister (known as Aunty, but no actual relation) dropped her home. My mum's brother's grandchildren are decorators and helped out with a tricky tall wall. My MIL 's sister's son's wife made our curtains.
With a close extended family, you not only have a great social life, you always have help, someone can do it, or knows someone who can. It's great.

SequinnedShawl · 29/12/2021 21:24

As a child I had an "uncle x and aunty y" they were the parents of my aunt (by marriage - she married my mother's brother) lovely people but it really confused me as aunts and uncles were siblings of your mother or father, no? Confused

ButEmilylovedhim · 29/12/2021 21:19

OP I think it is very telling that distant-cousin-and-wife have “lost touch” (estranged?) with their children and grandchildren. Are they trying to co-opt themselves another lot of family to replace the ones they have misplaced? Inviting themselves to the family holiday house shows how cheeky they are. I would be keeping a beady eye on the whole situation and encouraging any distance I could.

Mellowyellow222 · 29/12/2021 21:14

Thank you! My fiends who are in their forties know their cousins but don’t see them often. They don’t have any relationship with their parents cousin.

It’s lovely so many here are so close, but to be honest I couldn’t even name my parents cousins.

OP posts:
Floralnomad · 29/12/2021 13:26

I’m in my mid 50s , both parents deceased and I don’t have a relationship with my actual aunt / cousins let alone anyone more distant than that .

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 29/12/2021 12:36

@Mellowyellow222

I am interested in how you are all defining extended family.

I am starting to think my family might be weird😂.

For those of you in your thirties, forties and fifties do you all have relationships with your parents cousins?

I have relationships with my cousins and my aunts and uncles. But this is the first time I have met a more distant relative than that.

At one point (before they started to die off) I had thirty-seven first cousins, living in Africa, America, Latin America, Canada, Australia and various countries in Europe.

I had not met them all.

I had not met all their spouses' siblings' families.

I would have addressed any of these related-but-strangers by their first name, even when I was a child, and if required to call them "Auntie" at the age of say ten would have investigated their exact relationship to me and then called them by it. I know this because my elder brother did just that: when told "I am your Auntie Eleanor" by an American woman he was meeting for the first time, he went and asked my father about it, and thereafter called her "Second Cousin Once Removed Eleanor" very formally until she gave up and admitted she had been silly to demand a nominal relationship not her own and asked him to make it just "Eleanor".

vodkaginwine · 29/12/2021 12:33

I wouldn’t be apologising either. The lady shouldn’t have been eavesdropping into a private conversation, they are not aunt and uncle, they themselves assumed that title incorrectly, and the children quite rightly have questioned whether someone they had never met and now is calling himself uncle actually is an uncle. Personally I wouldn’t give it a second thought, it’s unlikely you’ll be meeting that often anyway, and if it arises again step in and explain to them that they are not uncle and aunt, but grans cousin and that the children know this. It was once the fashion that all elders would be aunt and uncle, but quite rightly I don’t think that’s that case now. And even if it was their behaviour over it is highly rude.

Mellowyellow222 · 29/12/2021 12:28

@ThanksItHasPockets I can absolutely understand why you address these people as auntie. I assume your children so too?

@BeyondMyWits is clearly also close with her parents cousins and sees them regularly. Which is lovely.

I just struggle to think of distant cousins who I have never met as family. If I found out I had a sibling I had never met, I would be more motivated bated to develop a relationship. But a first cousin once removed doesn’t really mean much to me?

As I said, maybe my family is weird though and other people think differently!

OP posts:
ThanksItHasPockets · 29/12/2021 12:15

@Mellowyellow222

I am interested in how you are all defining extended family.

I am starting to think my family might be weird😂.

For those of you in your thirties, forties and fifties do you all have relationships with your parents cousins?

I have relationships with my cousins and my aunts and uncles. But this is the first time I have met a more distant relative than that.

I do on my Dad's side, but that's because he was an only child of a widowed mother and her sister helped with childcare so that she could work. Consequently his cousins were more like sisters to him and I addressed them all as 'auntie'. I hope this doesn't give pp conniptions Hmm
bedheadedzombie · 29/12/2021 12:13

@ShinyHappyPoster

What did you suggest the DCs call them? Like a PP, in our family it would be considered rude for children to call older adults by their first name.
How about mr. and mrs. Thingy. You know, the default for all of mankind. There is no need to complicate things.

They sound like difficult kind of people that you might want to stay away from anyway.

Ibane · 29/12/2021 12:10

@Mellowyellow222

I am interested in how you are all defining extended family.

I am starting to think my family might be weird😂.

For those of you in your thirties, forties and fifties do you all have relationships with your parents cousins?

I have relationships with my cousins and my aunts and uncles. But this is the first time I have met a more distant relative than that.

Absolutely not. Both my parents have dozens of cousins I've never met, or encountered once or twice at a family funeral -- I couldn't pick them out of a police lineup. I had a first cousin of my mother's who had emigrated about 40 years earlier, changed her name and reinvented herself as a home counties Tory matron, contact me out of the blue when I was in the UK at university, when even my mother hadn't seen or heard from her since childhood. It turned out she'd decided I must be acceptable if I was at Oxford. Hmm
Mellowyellow222 · 29/12/2021 12:06

I am interested in how you are all defining extended family.

I am starting to think my family might be weird😂.

For those of you in your thirties, forties and fifties do you all have relationships with your parents cousins?

I have relationships with my cousins and my aunts and uncles. But this is the first time I have met a more distant relative than that.

OP posts:
ThanksItHasPockets · 29/12/2021 11:59

@BeyondMyWits didn't say that. She said that they were part of each other's extended families before they married, not the first time they were introduced. They might have been together years before marrying.

I don't think it's that unusual though. DH's extended family welcomed me the first time they met me. They knew that he was serious about me and that was good enough for them. That's very different to an unfamiliar blood relation expecting to have immediate status as a member of the family as 'Uncle' Fred seems to expect.

Ibane · 29/12/2021 11:55

@Mellowyellow222

I suppose all families are different.

It’s amazing that in @BeyondMyWits her wider extended family - her parents cousins - thought of her now husband as family the first time they met him.

I define family as people who I love and who I feel close to. My brother in law was of course welcomed into my family. He is my sisters husband - so I have taken time to get to know him, I see him regularly and I love him like a brother.

The new wife of my mother’s cousin (when I don’t even know the man) doesn’t have the same status.

That may sound harsh - my parents have probably about twenty cousins who I have never met. I am close to my aunts, uncles and their children but I don’t think of the relatives beyond that as family. Had they been around more then I am sure I would have developed a bond. But I don’t t think it can be instantly manufactured.

Of course not, and to be honest, their behaviour at this first meeting is unlikely to grow any closeness that might have developed had they chosen to behave in a less entitled and whiny way. You don't get to show up in a family you've never met and tell them how to alter their behaviour to suit you, and complain if they do things differently.
Mellowyellow222 · 29/12/2021 11:52

I suppose all families are different.

It’s amazing that in @BeyondMyWits her wider extended family - her parents cousins - thought of her now husband as family the first time they met him.

I define family as people who I love and who I feel close to. My brother in law was of course welcomed into my family. He is my sisters husband - so I have taken time to get to know him, I see him regularly and I love him like a brother.

The new wife of my mother’s cousin (when I don’t even know the man) doesn’t have the same status.

That may sound harsh - my parents have probably about twenty cousins who I have never met. I am close to my aunts, uncles and their children but I don’t think of the relatives beyond that as family. Had they been around more then I am sure I would have developed a bond. But I don’t t think it can be instantly manufactured.

OP posts:
AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 29/12/2021 11:30

@BeyondMyWits

Thing is even now saying "our" family do it differently is stating that they are not part of your family. They are cousins. They are part of your family and you are saying they aren't. They find that hurtful.

My husband was part of my extended family even before we married. And I part of his.

It was not said to this unrelated female; she eavesdropped and overheard a conversation in which a child was having something explained.

It is hurtful to a child to be told lies, think on. Possibly even damaging. This female stranger expects her lie to a child ("I am your aunt") to be accepted as truth. Not good enough.

Was your now-husband part of your family on the first occasion you met him? Was he perhaps your mother's son? That is what this man is claiming: to be the child's uncle he would have to be the brother of either her mother or her father.

Devilmakes3 · 29/12/2021 10:52

*A few red flags here op.

First that they were over-familiar and insisting on being called Aunt & Uncle when they are not. Second that they are making you feel guilty for not playing along. Third that they complained to your parents about it. I'd be wary. There may be a very good reason he was a "distant" cousin in the first place.*

This 100% I’d be giving them a wide berth personally.

AngelonTopoftheTree · 29/12/2021 10:47

It's normal to call those kind of relations aunt and uncle
Not in OP's family, and also not in mine. They'd never be aunt and uncle in my family, just plain old Fred and Joan (or whatever).
OP, I don't think you've anything to apologise for, so don't.

Mellowyellow222 · 29/12/2021 10:31

Maddy I have decided I am not going to apologise. What i said was correct - they aren’t aunt and uncle and calling them that just isn’t normal in our family. The children feel weird about it.

The children have much closer relatives who they don’t call aunt and uncle so this would seem odd to the rest of the family.

I don’t think you can arrive into a family and expect them to change to suit you.

I also don’t think there was a tone in what I said because I was talking factually to a child who I love very much.

These are grown adults with children and grandchild of their own - who they have lost touch with over the years.

I won’t see them till next Christmas - the children won’t call them aunt and uncle next year - but it’s unlikely they would call them anything, or have any reason to speak to them apart from saying hello or happy Christmas.

OP posts:
maddy68 · 29/12/2021 10:02

It's normal to call those kind of relations aunt and uncle. Im guessing you made it sound offensive with the tone of your explanation rather than the actual content

Just apologize for causing offense and explain that you want your children to understand family trees etc so it's important that they understand the complexities of families.

BluebellsareBlue · 29/12/2021 09:52

Honestly OP what a lot of pish. You were absolutely right to explain the way you did, if the flavour of the month to a second cousin you hadn't met before, who doesn't know the names of the people he is 'uncle..ing' is pissed off let them be. Tell your parents that even though they would like to keep up appearances, lying to children and confusing them re family members is not your thing. Hopefully your uncle will set your parents right and let them know how he feels too and you don't have to see these odd people again

Ibane · 29/12/2021 09:26

@Mellowyellow222

I had wondered if it was a cultural issue. She is from Wales - we are in Ireland.

But manners are universal and it seems odd to create such a fuss over such a little thing the first time you meet people.

I think a certain kind of lower-middle class British person is far bigger on the use of ‘auntie’ and uncle’ for distant or non-relatives than Irish people.

I remember English friends of my grandfather’s long-lost sister being quite insistent about being ‘aunties’ to DS and me when they first visited, despite not being relatives and never having met us before.

That they were also rather prissy and had poor manners is suggested by their shocked response to seeing a milk carton on the kitchen table — they’d shown up unannounced at breakfast time and four children were eating their cereal — and one of them picking it up and calling in panicked tones for a jug and saying ‘We never do that!’

My poor, meek mother was humiliated.