Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be potentially homeless when I’m old?

431 replies

Dogmummy1980 · 28/12/2021 12:46

I’ve been with DP now for 2.5 years and we moved in together a few months ago - me moving into his house. I was renting a property previously and also moved in with debts that are now almost clear. We have 4 kids, 2 each, none together. I’ve always said if it is that we split I would never claim for his house - I don’t own a property and his is mortgaged but in the instance we split it wouldnt feel right me doing so. He is divorced and it was their marital home. I pay half of the household outgoings each month

However my mind is niggling at me - if we are together until he dies then what then for me? When I’ve brought it up he has simply said to trust that his kids/family wouldn’t see me having to move out immediately. Whaaaattt??? He has also now claimed I am asking this as I am after money - I’m absolutely not as my only question has been if/when we were elderly. I am also aware I would never be in his will - the entire lot would be for his kids. I’m a benefactor in my mums will so eventually I would be ok money wise (as much as I hate to think of this idea)

So essentially for me to ensure I have somewhere to live when I am old I would need to buy a property and rent it out for the next goodness knows how long - something I really don’t want to have to do but I see no other way to protect myself when I’m old. I rented out my now sold (at a loss) property before and it’s been all manners of hassle.

AIBU to think this is ridiculous that I’m having to do this? That you either want to build a life with someone or you don’t??? And certainly if you are planning on spending to next 30+ years with someone you wouldn’t just expect your DP to leave their home at that sort of age in those circumstances?? I just feel lost/bereft - huge mix of emotions really!

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 29/12/2021 16:59

OP you'd actually remain in a relationship where a man is now stonewalling you until it's convenient for you to get the right property?

Either he's being a bit moody about being asked to provide housing for you in the event of his death in which case fair enough as no relationships are sunshine and rainbows in every disagreement, or he really is behaving in a way that is unpleasant in which case surely you'd want to leave and remove yourself and your children from an unhealthy environment. 🤔

CrimbleCrumble1 · 29/12/2021 15:26

Good plan OP, particularly the buying a place for you and your DC.

Dogmummy1980 · 29/12/2021 15:24

@CrimbleCrumble1

OP could you buy on your own in the area you currently live once you’ve paid off your debts and saved for a deposit? I think if you can then that would be my plan.
Yes - the aim is either a) get a BTL in the same or nearby area so I’m close to family, kids friends etc or b) worst case buy a house for me and the kids in the area

Either way 12 months from now I’ll have debts paid off and also a decent amount of money in the bank - and worst worst case if I don’t have enough to buy I can still afford to rent and bank money at the same time

OP posts:
femfemlicious · 29/12/2021 15:24

Good on you @Dogmummy1980. Your future is in your own hands

CrimbleCrumble1 · 29/12/2021 15:14

OP could you buy on your own in the area you currently live once you’ve paid off your debts and saved for a deposit? I think if you can then that would be my plan.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 29/12/2021 15:02

we are now currently on day 2 of him completely stonewalling me

Stonewalling is always wrong, though he's probably coming to realise the whole arrangement isn't as sensible as he thought it would be

Well done, though, for starting to look into better security for yourself. In the end only you can steer this; there's no point in relying on someone you've only lived with a few months, so you're doing the right thing

CrimbleCrumble1 · 29/12/2021 14:52

Well done OP.

Dogmummy1980 · 29/12/2021 14:24

@AlbertBridge

If he's stonewalling you, why haven't you dumped him? I can only presume it's because renting would cost you more than living at his house? And therefore it'd be quicker to save up for a deposit at his house?

If not - if you could afford to rent and save - then definitely dump him and move out!

Right now it would be the upheaval of everything - kids settled etc. For now I’ll focus on repaying my debt and saving for a deposit - either way then I’ll have decent security. Even in the instance that I’m needed to physically leave sooner, I’d have a decent amount of money in the bank and potentially be able to straight up buy a property rather than rent again (10% deposit for the sort of house I would want would take me around 12 months max to save in my current job)
OP posts:
AlbertBridge · 29/12/2021 14:18

If he's stonewalling you, why haven't you dumped him? I can only presume it's because renting would cost you more than living at his house? And therefore it'd be quicker to save up for a deposit at his house?

If not - if you could afford to rent and save - then definitely dump him and move out!

billy1966 · 29/12/2021 14:17

Well done OP for seeing clearly exactly how vulnerable you are.

He absolutely hasn't got your best interests at heart and that should be enough for you.

Stop paying half the morgage and up your debt repayments.

The sooner you are debt free the better.

Keep posting.Flowers

Billandben444 · 29/12/2021 14:13

Well done OP, a good start. As to paying half the mortgage, unless you transfer the money directly to the building society each month then you'd be unable to prove anything - if it goes to him first then he could argue legally it was just living expenses etc.

Dogmummy1980 · 29/12/2021 13:53

@CliffsofMohair thanks! Will take a while to save a 25% deposit to do it properly but that’s it now - goal set. I’m just quite lucky I’m actually in a good job and have the means to be able to hopefully get sorted out relatively quickly - sooner I have that security sorted for myself the better. I’m just waiting for him to next bring up when I will be changing my car….. Grin

OP posts:
pinkpapaya · 29/12/2021 13:50

Stay strong in the face of the stonewalling Dogmummy1980. He is pissed off that his little scheme has been rumbled and your good nature can't so easily be taken advantage of. You have a good job and a real chance for security that nobody can take away from you. Stick with your plan for a BTL. You will be so glad you did! Flowers

CliffsofMohair · 29/12/2021 13:40

@Dogmummy1980

Thanks all!

Update - discretely tried to discuss it again and explain it is just a concern over an IF - and we are now currently on day 2 of him completely stonewalling me

I’m on right move as we speak coming up with plans and ideas - or indeed locations of where I could buy a BTL - if anything all this and his behaviour has made me completely understand that I’ve only myself to look out for me

As for what had been my long term plan - as mentioned previously I had discussed potentially buying a BTL when I was moving in with him but we looked into it and mutually decided it wasn’t worth the hassle as we had a home - however had it been that I was in rented now I would still be paying off the debts the same figure I am doing now with the intention of saving for a deposit thereafter for a home for me and the kids

And yes he really did expect me to fund half his mortgage, pay for a nice new car, holidays etc etc - with all the risk of being thrown out at a moments notice

Well done for tackling it now
CliffsofMohair · 29/12/2021 13:39

OP needs to think about her future rather than buying a lodge for the family to holiday in that will be worthless in 20 years time, or paying towards major improvements to the house she can be thrown out of at a moments notice

In a nutshell

Dogmummy1980 · 29/12/2021 13:37

Thanks all!

Update - discretely tried to discuss it again and explain it is just a concern over an IF - and we are now currently on day 2 of him completely stonewalling me

I’m on right move as we speak coming up with plans and ideas - or indeed locations of where I could buy a BTL - if anything all this and his behaviour has made me completely understand that I’ve only myself to look out for me

As for what had been my long term plan - as mentioned previously I had discussed potentially buying a BTL when I was moving in with him but we looked into it and mutually decided it wasn’t worth the hassle as we had a home - however had it been that I was in rented now I would still be paying off the debts the same figure I am doing now with the intention of saving for a deposit thereafter for a home for me and the kids

And yes he really did expect me to fund half his mortgage, pay for a nice new car, holidays etc etc - with all the risk of being thrown out at a moments notice

OP posts:
RoyalFamilyFan · 29/12/2021 12:54

@Puzzledandpissedoff

Surely, you understand that the OP is unlikely to be able to pay rent upon retirement?

I find what's often meant by folk who say they "won't be able to afford it" is that what they can stretch to won't be as nice as what they have now, and while this may be so, it doesn't mean you get to expect a share of someone else's house that you've lived in for merely weeks

As PPs have said, if this was a woman whose partner came with debts and was now expecting a share, she'd be instantly told to protect herself. In fact that's the way the thread was going, so along come the details of other things he's expecting which were interestingly left out of the original post Hmm

If OP has only a state pension, they will get housing benefit. But this could mean renting a bedsit or a very cheap one bedroom flat. She won't be able to afford a house. OP needs to think about her future rather than buying a lodge for the family to holiday in that will be worthless in 20 years time, or paying towards major improvements to the house she can be thrown out of at a moments notice.
RoyalFamilyFan · 29/12/2021 12:50

@femfemlicious If I was her I would sort out my own finances, by moving out.

femfemlicious · 29/12/2021 12:37

@Dogmummy1980 put your big girl pants on and sort out your finances. Dont expect this man to pay for you in old age. Im sure you are paying a lot less now than when you were renting your own house. Invest that money for your old age.

WaterBottle123 · 29/12/2021 12:31

@Dogmummy1980

Tagging you OP in the hope you see this post.

My mum did what you've done aged 45, grown up kids left home.

Age 52 she was homeless overnight when her partner decided the relationship was over. 52 and scrabbling around for a home. It was absolutely brutal, she got nothing despite paying half bills, caring for his dependant kids, contributing to refurb. And all those posters who think you legal recourse in this situation are WRONG. The legal fees to try and prove it would eat any potential gains, people need to stop posting this RUBBISH.

OP, you must absolutely cut what you're paying this man who is profiting from you and prioritise a property of your own.

Mum has just got back on property ladder age 59, as thankfully she met someone new who had deposit and was willing to go halves on mortgage. Both their shares are protected and us kids can't kick the surviving partner out.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 29/12/2021 12:07

Surely, you understand that the OP is unlikely to be able to pay rent upon retirement?

I find what's often meant by folk who say they "won't be able to afford it" is that what they can stretch to won't be as nice as what they have now, and while this may be so, it doesn't mean you get to expect a share of someone else's house that you've lived in for merely weeks

As PPs have said, if this was a woman whose partner came with debts and was now expecting a share, she'd be instantly told to protect herself. In fact that's the way the thread was going, so along come the details of other things he's expecting which were interestingly left out of the original post Hmm

femfemlicious · 29/12/2021 12:04

Before you met him and moved into his house where were you going to live at 80.

Thid is a relationship not a pension. Why do women expect men to pay for thrm?

LostForIdeas · 29/12/2021 11:57

I will also be reconsidering his plans for us to fully recarpet the house, do the bathroom, bedroom etc….. him wanting these things paid for between us - after all he has made it clear that it’s his house

That sounds really reasonable.
He can’t have it all his own way and expect you to pay for HIS lifestyle really.

billy1966 · 29/12/2021 10:07

He wants the OP to spend her money on life's comforts whilst he has a nice asset at the end of it.

I think it is not unreasonable that he wants his house to go to his children, however he doesn't get you to pay 50% of it's morgage and improvements.

You to pay for a nice car or fancy holidays.

He is a user who thinks the OP is really DIM.

Beautiful3 · 29/12/2021 09:38

You should not be paying half the mortgage, nor home improvements, only bills. How are you supposed to save up for your own place? Honestly, after reading your updates, I'd buy a place and move out.