Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be potentially homeless when I’m old?

431 replies

Dogmummy1980 · 28/12/2021 12:46

I’ve been with DP now for 2.5 years and we moved in together a few months ago - me moving into his house. I was renting a property previously and also moved in with debts that are now almost clear. We have 4 kids, 2 each, none together. I’ve always said if it is that we split I would never claim for his house - I don’t own a property and his is mortgaged but in the instance we split it wouldnt feel right me doing so. He is divorced and it was their marital home. I pay half of the household outgoings each month

However my mind is niggling at me - if we are together until he dies then what then for me? When I’ve brought it up he has simply said to trust that his kids/family wouldn’t see me having to move out immediately. Whaaaattt??? He has also now claimed I am asking this as I am after money - I’m absolutely not as my only question has been if/when we were elderly. I am also aware I would never be in his will - the entire lot would be for his kids. I’m a benefactor in my mums will so eventually I would be ok money wise (as much as I hate to think of this idea)

So essentially for me to ensure I have somewhere to live when I am old I would need to buy a property and rent it out for the next goodness knows how long - something I really don’t want to have to do but I see no other way to protect myself when I’m old. I rented out my now sold (at a loss) property before and it’s been all manners of hassle.

AIBU to think this is ridiculous that I’m having to do this? That you either want to build a life with someone or you don’t??? And certainly if you are planning on spending to next 30+ years with someone you wouldn’t just expect your DP to leave their home at that sort of age in those circumstances?? I just feel lost/bereft - huge mix of emotions really!

OP posts:
C8H10N4O2 · 28/12/2021 16:40

I pay half of the bills/mortgage - full amount worked out and literally halved

Do you earn about the same? ie do you both put the same percentage of your own income into household bills?

Either way, why are you paying toward his investment via mortgage and home improvements when he won't even assure you 12 months security in the property in the event of his death? You are augmenting his DCs' estate and incentivising them to cash in on it if they are that way inclined.

I've seen too many women left homeless due to not being married and having no registered interest in the property they helped to fund. Either your house contribution needs to be reflected as an interest in the property or you use that to buy your own place or save to rent in the future.

CheshireKitten123 · 28/12/2021 16:40

OP,
Please consult a solicitor and obtain information about a 'Cohabitation Agreement'.
This is for couples who are living together but not married.

Itsokay2020 · 28/12/2021 16:38

Never spend more than you’re willing to lose! Stops contributing towards the mortgage and any improvements. Get yourself a financial advisor and book in for a financial review. Pay off debts and, if possible, buy a property but don’t act on impulse, think strategically!! Make sure your financial ties are limited, protect yourself! It has to work both ways, within reason, and there needs to be financial equality

Iwonder08 · 28/12/2021 16:38

You are unreasonable. It has been only 2 years and you are not married. Also you shouldn't be paying 50%of mortgage. Manage all the finances separately and work on your own provisions for old age

HopelesslydevotedtoGu · 28/12/2021 16:32

What is wrong

  1. You are paying half the mortgage. For his half, he gets somewhere to live now, and also an investment. For your half, you just get somewhere to live. That isn't fair.
He was presumably paying the whole mortgage before you moved in. I would want to pay less than half of the mortgage, and save or invest the difference. It's hard to be completely "fair" when you get together in later life and are financially unbalanced. Currently his mortgage bill is halved, he is really benefiting financially from cohabiting as you are paying off half his mortgage. It would be fairer if you were both financially advantaged by cohabiting.
  1. You are paying for improvements to his house - definitely not on. Unless it was something solely for your benefit e.g. if you wanted to create a space for your hobby (although being aware you could break up and need to move out suddenly, don't spend more than you are willing to lose).
  1. You are paying over half the energy bill, in anticipation of the energy bill possibly increasing in future, although it hasn't yet. Wtf?! So what does he do with your extra contribution, save it for himself? Get a smart meter so the bills are correct, and pay half. If the bill goes up in future you can both pay more. Put extra money aside in your OWN savings account for any future increases.

I would renegotiate on these points, so you get a fairer split of the bills. Then plan to create your own financially security.

He's been clear that he wants to leave his house solely to his kids, please believe this and act accordingly rather than hope he changes his mind.

Also I wouldn't be keen on the lifetime interest idea. Not ideal for his kids who may want to access the inheritance to improve their lives and their own children's lives rather than have to wait for you to die, and not nice for you to know they are waiting for you to die! With no option to downsize or relocate without losing your lifetime interest. I would only think this a good idea if there was somebody incapable of earning their own money who needed secure housing, e.g. I know somebody who is doing this for their adult child with a learning disability who will never be able to work.

billy1966 · 28/12/2021 16:32

As for saying you could trust his kids, I have never heard anything so ridiculous.

He really can't care deeply about you to say something so utterly unbelievable.

His children will want, and be fully entitled to their inheritance.

billy1966 · 28/12/2021 16:29

Paying half his morgage, bills and house improvements?

You are out of your mind.
He is being a LOT cleverer than you in this transaction.

Be glad he was honest and now you know.

I would think paying half the bills and a nominal rent would be fair and absolutely no contribution to maintenance or improvements.

You need to buy a small property so start saving as soon as you can and start looking now.

A bungalow might be a good idea or an apartment.

supermoonrising · 28/12/2021 16:24

Paying his mortgage with no formal contract regarding …anything … is crazy. You’d be better off just spending that money on a rental property yourself. At least a normal landlord has to give you legal notice.

SunshineCake1 · 28/12/2021 16:21

You're a fool to be half the mortgage.

I wouldn't stay with him. No way. It's not that you want the house. You want breathing space ffs.

Redburnett · 28/12/2021 16:17

Marry him, problem solved.

IrishMama2015 · 28/12/2021 16:14

Op did he ask you you to move in or did circumstances make it the best option? You should not be paying half the mortgage. He was presumably covering it totally before you moved in. Make a new agreement. You both pay half the bills. He pays the mortgage and all home repairs and improvements. You then pay an agreed 'rent' to him to reflect way and tear and use of house and items in house. It should be less than half the mortgage.

You didn't get a fair deal from the start but now want rights that aren't there for you.

Seedandyarn · 28/12/2021 16:11

I wouldn't be happy paying 50% towards his mortgage year after year to see others profit out of it.
I would be renegotiating with him to pay a lower % if not I would make sense to live apart otherwise you are going to be paying two mortgages.

CleansUpPenguinPoo · 28/12/2021 16:05

DH owns our home outright and I pay about 2/5 of the running costs - his pension is bigger and I do all the organising / management of the house, car, garden, pets and taxes. And family gift buying ;-) His two sons will inherit the house if he dies before me, but it's written into the will that I have right of abode until I either die or remarry, whichever comes first. I don't have children and rented before. Both DSS (they're in their thirties) have been made aware of this and are quite happy with DH's decision. The house we live in was never their family home, he bought it when we decided to get married, he had a smaller house before that where his children would visit, they lived with their mum and inherited the big family house when she died.

There are legal options in OP's situation without disadvantaging her DP's children, but it depends on her DP's willingness - or not - to make provision for her.

TatianaBis · 28/12/2021 16:04

@CavernousScream

You should both have taken legal advice before moving in. If he wants you to have no legal claim on the house, you should have a cohabitation agreement in place and you shouldn’t be contributing towards the mortgage. You will legally have a claim on the house as you’ve been paying half the mortgage. That’s whether you split up and move out or if he dies. He’s been very stupid thinking he could have everything his own way.
This.
TractorAndHeadphones · 28/12/2021 16:02

[quote RoyalFamilyFan]@GatoradeMeBitch they won't let the house fall down. But people can still end up living in a house that they cant afford to heat and without the adaptations needed as someone gets older, and looking very shabby. I doubt the adult kids will want to pay for decoration, new carpets, heating bills, or stairlifts and wet rooms.
I say this not to be negative, but because I have seen this happen.[/quote]
That’s another thing - this house is big enough for 6 people (assuming everyone lives in it together now)
How likely is it that the OP/DP are going to continue to live it in until they’re old?

I know we’ve established that the point is really the DP’s cavalier attitude but it’s highly unlikely they’d be in the same house 😂😂😂

CavernousScream · 28/12/2021 16:01

You should both have taken legal advice before moving in. If he wants you to have no legal claim on the house, you should have a cohabitation agreement in place and you shouldn’t be contributing towards the mortgage. You will legally have a claim on the house as you’ve been paying half the mortgage. That’s whether you split up and move out or if he dies. He’s been very stupid thinking he could have everything his own way.

bonetiredwithtwins · 28/12/2021 16:01

@Notmoresugar

You need to protect your future and buy a property, just as your DP is protecting his future and that of his DCs. I would do exactly the same as your DP.

Exactly this

You've been together 5 mins you have no moral or ethical claim to his assets presumably you splitting bills on this house you live in together is enabling you to pay off your debt which you wouldn't otherwise be able to if you had all the bills on a home to cover yourself?? You're already benefitting from this arrangement

daytriptovulcan · 28/12/2021 16:00

Another idea, get a mutual life assurance, so if one of you dies before the age of 65, the other gets, for example 300,000. It wouldn't cost too much.

Ponoka7 · 28/12/2021 15:59

Where I live There's good over 55 provision and more are being built. Once you become pensionable age you are considered vulnerable for housing purposes. I'd more be concerned what would happen if he died around 50, while going through the menopause etc. It's a tough time.
As said, stop paying towards the mortgage and major building costs. It's worrying that he won't write that you can stay in the house for a year. I'd just build up savings and see how this pans out. I don't think that he's in it for the long haul.

TractorAndHeadphones · 28/12/2021 15:58

@GatoradeMeBitch

Lifetime tenancies only work if there is enough money to maintain the house

In this case he'll have (at some point) two adult children. it will be in their best interests to maintain the house as it will be their investment. She will also have two adult children to help out. I think it's unlikely that between five adults they'll allow the house to fall down.

On the contrary. None of the children might have the means to contribute. Her kids especially might not want to pay for a house they won’t benefit from. They might rather for example their mother bought her own.

Again it depends on luck… how long the OP lives.. whether something expensive to replace goes.

Notmoresugar · 28/12/2021 15:56

You need to protect your future and buy a property, just as your DP is protecting his future and that of his DCs. I would do exactly the same as your DP.

daytriptovulcan · 28/12/2021 15:55

Could you not get married then? Are you sure he sees your relationship as very long term, ie the rest of your lives. It sounds like you have better living conditions than if you were renting privately. Get over the hassle of renting a house out, and save like mad so you can get on the ladder yourself if you can and if he won't marry. And don't be subsidising his child care obligations.

RoyalFamilyFan · 28/12/2021 15:54

And if OP was paying proper rent, she would have legal rights that come with the tenancy. Currently she has none.

ShrinkingViolet9 · 28/12/2021 15:54

Yes, I know what I meant was that if assets are joint the half belonging to the deceased might pass on to the other joint owner, who could then do what they liked what it. For example money in a joint account usually passes to the surviving owner, unless an agreement is signed to the contrary. For a house there are several ways (joint tenants, or tenants in common).

I am aware of the above. But in this instance, the OP's name is not on the mortgage, either as joint tenant or tenant in common (although she is paying towards the mortgage) - so she does not have that security and it is not relevant to her current situation.

OP has not said whether she and her partner have joint bank or joint savings accounts.

RoyalFamilyFan · 28/12/2021 15:53

@GatoradeMeBitch they won't let the house fall down. But people can still end up living in a house that they cant afford to heat and without the adaptations needed as someone gets older, and looking very shabby. I doubt the adult kids will want to pay for decoration, new carpets, heating bills, or stairlifts and wet rooms.
I say this not to be negative, but because I have seen this happen.