Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband had a vasectomy and never told me 😭

590 replies

Berlyboo · 28/12/2021 11:44

I have children healthy and happy everything was going great perfect until I found out that my hubby had a vasectomy.... Its his body and his choice.... But he never discussed it with me.. I feel so angry and hurt by his choice. He wasn't 100% sure if he wanted more children and I wasn't sure if I wanted more children but he made up his own mind to have a vasectomy without speaking to me. . But since then I'm not sexually attracted to him anymore every time I look at him I feel sick that he took a choice away from me and him to have another baby.... We are both young and he took the choice away from us to have another baby he hurt me so much..... Anyways he is now sleeping on the couch the past three months I want him to leave and he won't I just can't forgive him for what he done it makes me sick everyday. He says it will take time for me to get my head around it but he wants to get it reversed as he doesn't feel good about himself any more? 😡 I want him out and I don't know if I'm just angry or what is happening with me but has anyone else gone through this and if they have does it get better?

OP posts:
Shadowboy · 29/12/2021 09:45

But he doesn’t want more kids… condom, vasectomy the outcome is the same.

It is his body and you cannot control what he does with it. It’s odd that he didn’t tell you but maybe that screams something wrong in the marriage…. This therefore may indicate the vasectomy was for the best

Feelingoktoday · 29/12/2021 09:34

“Men are always told on here that if they don't want children then they should take action themselves and not leave it up to the woman, even if she says she's using reliable contraception. But I always think that if my DH did that in a long term relationship I'd take it as a sign that he didn't trust me not to lie to him about contraception”

So what do I tell my 19 year old son - take responsibility for contraception by using a condom or don’t take responsibility and leave it to the woman for fear of upsetting her because he doesn’t trust her. We can’t have it both ways .

FabulousMrFifty · 29/12/2021 09:25

@NdujaWannaDance

Men are always told on here that if they don't want children then they should take action themselves and not leave it up to the woman, even if she says she's using reliable contraception. But I always think that if my DH did that in a long term relationship I'd take it as a sign that he didn't trust me not to lie to him about contraception

I remember a thread on here years ago where women were saying that if they were using their own BC and in a long term relationship that was monogamous, there was really no need for their partners to use condoms as well, and if they did it would make them suspicious of their motives. They would assume the men either didn't trust them to not get PG on purpose or that they were worried about an STD, meaning either they were being unfaithful or thought their partner might be.

That's problematic when viewed against a culture of women telling men 'no BC is completely reliable. If you can't accept an accidental pregnancy where I make all the choices then you shouldn't be having sex with me.'

This is only ever said to men. Never women.

I do understand why the OP is upset and bewildered, but I imagine when she says 'he wasn't 100% sure he didn't want more children' she's actually in denial about what's been said to her in the past. I'm guessing he tried to tell her he didn't want more kids and she didn't listen and he knew if he broached the subject of a vasectomy it would get shut down very quickly. Or there would be tears, begging and dramatics.

So yes, in theory it would have shown her more respect to tell her. But in reality it might also be understandable why he didn't.

Once it was done though, he should have told her. I'm guessing he was building up the courage to do it. I'm not sure how long it was between the op and her finding out.

But to suggest that she could have wasted all her remaining fertile years with him in the belief that they might one day decide to have more children and that is essentially tricking her out of the right to leave and have more kids with someone else, is a bit of a weird argument.

Most women (and men) don't leave an otherwise happy marriage where children (plural) already exist, just because their partner is adamant they don't want any more.

It reduces the marriage to nothing more than a baby making contract and it reduces the husband to nothing more than a stud animal whose only purpose is his ability to breed.

100% this
rainbowstardrops · 29/12/2021 06:15

@PyongyangKipperbang

It comes down to the fact that he made a decision but by keeping it secret, he denied his wife the same choice.

He wants to stay with her with no more kids. Thats fine. His choice. But he didnt want to risk her leaving him if she wants more, so he lied.

This is not about a vasectomy, its about honesty, trust and what matters more. If his marriage to her matters so much then he would have discussed his thoughts and feelings, but he didnt. He just did it and hoped she would never find out.

I wouldnt want to share a bed with someone so duplicitous either.

100%

ClaryFairchild · 29/12/2021 06:09

This isn't about a vasectomy - this is about trust. He took your trust in him and destroyed it. That can't just be fixed. A vasectomy reversal doesn't fix that. Once the trust is gone it's incredibly difficult, if not impossible, to get it back again.

Isthatthebestyoucando · 29/12/2021 05:54

I would be angry about the initial hiding it and being willing to tell friends would hurt me and be humiliating, because he obviously would have told them not to mention it around you.
I couldn’t respect a sneaky coward, I can’t be attracted to someone I don’t respect.
If you’ve Asked him to leave and he’s refusing, hoping he grows on you then he is disrespecting you as someone allowed to have a say again, you don’t need both people’s permission to end a relationship, could you push this harder and raise the subject of putting the house on the market if he won’t leave it?

Doesntfeellikexmas · 29/12/2021 05:34

Of course he was sure. No man let's someone cut into his balls, if they aren't sure they want to.

Either there's a history of him lying, just because he is a liar, which doesn't seem the case by the ops description of the marriage.

Or on the subject of more jobs he has tried telling op and she just isn't listening. He is saying he wasnt sure and will look at a reversal to try and salvage the relationship.

Or maybe he doesn't trust her ro take care of contraception.

Op, and several people here, seem to think they have a right to dictate that someone can not sleep in their own bed and should leave their home, because the other person says so.

If she wants him to leave she needs to divorce and sort it that way. Yet she hasn't started divorce proceedings. It appears she just wants to punish. Not actually move forward.

NdujaWannaDance · 29/12/2021 03:48

Men are always told on here that if they don't want children then they should take action themselves and not leave it up to the woman, even if she says she's using reliable contraception. But I always think that if my DH did that in a long term relationship I'd take it as a sign that he didn't trust me not to lie to him about contraception

I remember a thread on here years ago where women were saying that if they were using their own BC and in a long term relationship that was monogamous, there was really no need for their partners to use condoms as well, and if they did it would make them suspicious of their motives. They would assume the men either didn't trust them to not get PG on purpose or that they were worried about an STD, meaning either they were being unfaithful or thought their partner might be.

That's problematic when viewed against a culture of women telling men 'no BC is completely reliable. If you can't accept an accidental pregnancy where I make all the choices then you shouldn't be having sex with me.'

This is only ever said to men. Never women.

I do understand why the OP is upset and bewildered, but I imagine when she says 'he wasn't 100% sure he didn't want more children' she's actually in denial about what's been said to her in the past. I'm guessing he tried to tell her he didn't want more kids and she didn't listen and he knew if he broached the subject of a vasectomy it would get shut down very quickly. Or there would be tears, begging and dramatics.

So yes, in theory it would have shown her more respect to tell her. But in reality it might also be understandable why he didn't.

Once it was done though, he should have told her. I'm guessing he was building up the courage to do it. I'm not sure how long it was between the op and her finding out.

But to suggest that she could have wasted all her remaining fertile years with him in the belief that they might one day decide to have more children and that is essentially tricking her out of the right to leave and have more kids with someone else, is a bit of a weird argument.

Most women (and men) don't leave an otherwise happy marriage where children (plural) already exist, just because their partner is adamant they don't want any more.

It reduces the marriage to nothing more than a baby making contract and it reduces the husband to nothing more than a stud animal whose only purpose is his ability to breed.

PyongyangKipperbang · 29/12/2021 03:31

It comes down to the fact that he made a decision but by keeping it secret, he denied his wife the same choice.

He wants to stay with her with no more kids. Thats fine. His choice. But he didnt want to risk her leaving him if she wants more, so he lied.

This is not about a vasectomy, its about honesty, trust and what matters more. If his marriage to her matters so much then he would have discussed his thoughts and feelings, but he didnt. He just did it and hoped she would never find out.

I wouldnt want to share a bed with someone so duplicitous either.

PyongyangKipperbang · 29/12/2021 03:25

Yeah, the way you post makes me think you would have worked to persuade him not to do it. I can't blame him for not wanting to justify himself about this. He took responsibility, it's his body and nothing to do with taking choice away from you. If having more children is more important than staying with him, you're free to make that choice.

She is now free to make that choice as she knows that more kids are definitely off the table with him. But as far as she knew, they agreed to her going on long term contraception and they would discuss it further in the coming years as neither of them were sure.

But then he decided he didnt want more (except from what the OP says he said, he wasnt even sure on the day he had the op!) and didnt tell her. He has admitted that he doesnt know when he would have told her, if ever. She has said that she would have asked him to stick to their original agreement of 5 years, to give them both time to think about it and come to an understanding.

Would you be this understanding if she had just decided to come off contraception and not tell him because that was her taking control of her fertility? No. Because it is deceitful and wrong. What he did is no different in terms of the effect on their marriage.

grapewine · 29/12/2021 03:10

@Chickenkatsu

If a woman decides to get her tubes tied, it's her choice and her choice only. I imagine he did it without telling you because he knew how you would react.
Yeah, the way you post makes me think you would have worked to persuade him not to do it. I can't blame him for not wanting to justify himself about this. He took responsibility, it's his body and nothing to do with taking choice away from you. If having more children is more important than staying with him, you're free to make that choice.
gingerbreadhotel · 29/12/2021 02:58

What I don't understand that PP can't seem to realise is his deceit involved OP wasting her fertile years with him rather than leaving him and moving on to have the opportunity to have more dc. This is why it's important, her dh told her that is the choice he took away from her not his choice to have a vasectomy.

She couldn't have physically taken that choice away from him anyway (as he has now proven) but he has totally led her on to believe there's hope for another dc all the while allowing her to be on unnecessary bc and with a whole different line of thinking to what the reality was. Extremely cruel and a massive lie that I would never be able to recover from myself. It's the huge and awful lie and I think OP has rightly expressed that hurt around it. I hope you find happiness OP.

backtolifebacktoreality · 28/12/2021 23:46

For me it wouldn't necessarily be about the fact that you could not have more children as you mentioned you weren't sure if you wanted any more.

I feel it's about the secretiveness around it all and the fact that he felt he couldn't tell you. What else does he keep from you?

JurgensCakeBabyJesus · 28/12/2021 23:45

Also if we're talking about coercion and control, he isn't covering himself in glory, they have another property but he refuses to leave, he refuses to listen to the OP when she says it's over because he lied to her and is dead set on 'persuading her' to carry on the relationship, seemingly by moping around and making it more difficult for her to move on.

JurgensCakeBabyJesus · 28/12/2021 23:42

For me this is not about bodily autonomy that's an automatic right, it's about secrets. If he wanted a vasectomy absolutely his choice, but who on earth has an elective surgery and deliberately hides it from their spouse? It's weird. I couldn't be with someone who would choose to lie to me repeatedly and it's not about more DC or not, I don't want any more DC , but if DH snuck around to get a vasectomy or any surgery then continued to lie about it and I only knew by accident, I'd wonder what else he could lie about, relationships are about trust and communication and this one seems to have neither, so why carry it on.

Mayorquimby2 · 28/12/2021 23:37

Tbf I'm with op

I couldn't forgive my wife if she had an abortion without even telling me, let alone discussing it.

I'm not saying that I think I should have a right to veto or cajole her decision either way, but I think I'd find it hard to feel anything other than disposable and inconsequential in those circumstances.

But that's based on relationship which I view as equal and open, and which I believe to be based on a willingness to discuss all issues openly even where it's difficult.
I can completely accept it's different for people who feel abused or controlled

thedancingbear · 28/12/2021 23:22

[quote Greensmoothie1]**@Berlyboo* Honestly if he told me that he was getting it done I would have asked him to wait as the decision that he was making is permanent.*

This is why he didn’t tell you. He knew you’d take his body autonomy away and demand that he wait a few years. You wanted to take ownership of his body and his life choice (I.e not wanting more dc). Your dh didn’t want to risk an unwanted “accidental” pregnancy.

Your dh is happy with the dc you already have together, but you are not content. You want to leave your dh because of some hypothetical dc that do not exist. If you want to break up with him then that’s your decision. However, you need to realise why he hid this from you.[/quote]
This in spades

This thread has proven without doubt that, on MN, men only have bodily autonomy with their wives’ consent.

Fucking disgusting

whittingtonmum · 28/12/2021 23:11

As it's been three months now I would try and find a counselor to help you work through your emotions and help you to find out what you really want. If you think you really want a seperation you need to make it very clear to DH and you need to actually start seperating. But maybe after talking it through with a counselor you might think it would be worth giving marriage counseling a go. In any case I would have my own counseling first to work through some of the emotions.

JustLyra · 28/12/2021 23:00

Only on Mumsnet could it be “feminist” to have a vasectomy behind your wife’s back and “over the top” to consider it a betrayal.

It’s a whole other world on here.

Keeping it secret from your spouse that you’d taken steps to end your ability to have children is a massive betrayal, especially when he’s stated he has no idea when he’d have told her.

Taking away her right to decide what she wanted to do is massively deceitful. The OP couldn’t stop him doing it, that’s his right, yet it’s baffling how many people are shouting at her about his rights whilst failing to recognise that his secrecy was removing hers.

Guavaf1sh · 28/12/2021 22:50

Perhaps the over the top reaction of the OP is why it was done in secret. The relationship is over and they are both better off without each other

HippoRaine · 28/12/2021 22:49

Fucking hell, this thread is mental and the vote is insane. All these women telling you you're being unreasonable and parroting "hiz body hiz choice" like that makes it ok to keep this from you, let you stay on hormone contraception and make you think that further children are a joint decision to be made in the future. For fucks sake guys this is a huge, relationship-breaking decision he took unilaterally and the OP found out accidentally via email. All you chirruping fools solemnly nodding along with "hiz body hiz choice" are seriously saying you would be absolutely fucking fine and dandy with your husband/partner/father of your children doing this AND NOT TELLING YOU? Like fucking fuck you would be. What a load of shit. Of course it's his choice but it's also OPs choice if she wants to stay in the relationship or not, if she wants more children or not. That's why it's 100% obviously absolutely unreasonable that he kept this from her.

StormzyinaTCup · 28/12/2021 22:48

Your dh is happy with the dc you already have together, but you are not content.

That’s not correct though. The OP and her DH both said they were undecided on whether their family was complete and would revisit in a few years. He took that option away from her when he went behind her back and decided for himself that they would call it a day on having anymore, not only that, he then thinks it’s OK to sit on this fait accompli until a time of his choosing/when he feels it’s most appropriate? He is at best a coward and at worst a deceitful piece of work.

FrippEnos · 28/12/2021 22:35

PyongyangKipperbang
And now she should leave her kids behind?

Its a choice that she has

Fucking hell is it St Poor Menz night tonight?!

And you were doing so well.

PyongyangKipperbang · 28/12/2021 22:32

And now she should leave her kids behind?

Fucking hell is it St Poor Menz night tonight?!

JustLyra · 28/12/2021 22:27

[quote Greensmoothie1]**@Berlyboo* Honestly if he told me that he was getting it done I would have asked him to wait as the decision that he was making is permanent.*

This is why he didn’t tell you. He knew you’d take his body autonomy away and demand that he wait a few years. You wanted to take ownership of his body and his life choice (I.e not wanting more dc). Your dh didn’t want to risk an unwanted “accidental” pregnancy.

Your dh is happy with the dc you already have together, but you are not content. You want to leave your dh because of some hypothetical dc that do not exist. If you want to break up with him then that’s your decision. However, you need to realise why he hid this from you.[/quote]
Asking him to wait is not removing his bodily autonomy. It’s asking.

He could still have done it and dealt with the fact that OP may have decided to end their marriage over it.

She couldn’t have physically stopped him. He stopped her from deciding her reaction to his decision.

He wanted his right to choose, which he’s completely entitled to, whilst deciding that his wife should be kept in the dark and prevented from making a further decision that he wouldn’t like, which he’s absolutely not entitled to do.