Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask which supermarkets are the worst for substitutions?

39 replies

isaisaisabel · 28/12/2021 10:25

I use a variety of supermarkets for online shopping to get the best deals. Today I've had an extremely disappointing shop delivered from Waitrose with awful substitutions that have ruined my weeks meal plan and a family lunch.

Which supermarkets do you find don't deliver what you ordered which interferes with your weekly plan and is very annoying.

Mine in order of the worst offending are:
Waitrose and Ocado joint first place
Sainsburys
Tesco

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Matilda15 · 30/12/2021 20:57

We use tesco and rarely get subs/items missing. If we do get subs they tend to be good ones e.g Cornetto rather than tesco own brand ice creams.

chocolateisavegetable · 30/12/2021 20:30

Asda are definitely the worst for me. Tesco have got much better in recent years. Ocado are generally quite good, except they don't seem to have a lot of the M&S stuff at the moment (although at least you know that at the time of placing the order).

FindingMeno · 30/12/2021 17:53

I found Sainsburys worse than Ocado.
However my latest Ocado shop has had tons of stuff out of stock so I can't even order it in the first place.

MadisonAvenue · 30/12/2021 17:49

Tesco aren’t too bad when they actually send a substitution.

I always have subs selected but, like today, if something is out of stock most of the time they don’t bother sending a sub, it’s just noted that there’s no suitable substitution available. It’s not even as though it’s obscure items though, it’s basic items like butter.

I wonder if this is because the only subs available are more expensive so that costs them the difference between what is ordered and the more expensive sub, therefore the pickers are instructed not to choose an alternative for everything that’s out of stock.

ancientgran · 28/12/2021 14:22

I use Sainsburys regularly and Iceland occasionally (they are good for last minute orders) and both have had low number of substitutions and only ever declined one of them, nothing wrong with it just not what we like. Short dates have become a thing with Sainsburys lately, I thought they probably have new staff who weren't up to speed but 3 thick sliced loaves delivered at 10pm dated for the following day were a bit much.

lawandgin · 28/12/2021 14:09

@Barwell76 it was for fresh counter / meat and fish where you picked a weight range (which was then merrily ignored). They may have changed it now...

Barwell76 · 28/12/2021 13:45

@lawandgin

We've pretty much always used Ocado, apart from a brief period where Tesco seemed like a better (cheaper) option. They weren't. I'd order a £6 piece of meat or fish and they'd send something costing £10. If you called up and complained they'd refund the difference, but I got so fed up of ringing every week (and I was starting to feel like the call centre might think I was having them on, although surely they could see what I'd ordered?) that I went back to Ocado.

I'm not impressed with Ocado since the switch to M&S. Often there are substitutions and missing items and some items have just disappeared from the shelves (and my basket) with no warning whatsoever. I'm considering moving back to Tesco.

Thats strange if Tesco do sub to a more expensive item then you only pay for the cheaper item you ordered. I thought this was automatically done.
BashfulClam · 28/12/2021 13:40

I always choose no abs for most things. Things where it doesn’t matter like bleach, eggs, loo roll then I’m not as bothered.

Ladylunchalot · 28/12/2021 13:29

I use Morrisons every week and always end up with a few subs but nothing major and I can always refuse them. Shelves in all my local supermarkets have had stock issues for a good few months so I always expect some subs or missing items.
Love getting my shopping delivered, subs far outweigh going out for it myself Grin

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 28/12/2021 13:19

Our saonsburys order had 3 missing items this week... 2 specific cheeses (marked no subs) and a bakery item which apparently nothing else suitable for.

FredaFox · 28/12/2021 13:12

Tesco here and get the odd sun but you always come off better. Occasionally like app I've ended up with a silly amount of fresh stuff eg lettuce so I give it the neighbours

Use sainsburys for work, hate the voucher thing with subs, why not price match like Tesco

sueelleker · 28/12/2021 13:06

I always say no substitutions; I'm lucky in that I can get out, so I'd rather they left something off and go to buy it myself.

Livpool · 28/12/2021 11:58

I disagree with PPs - have had no problems with Asda. The vast majority of substitutions I've had have been better/ more expensive versions of what I ordered

lawandgin · 28/12/2021 11:39

We've pretty much always used Ocado, apart from a brief period where Tesco seemed like a better (cheaper) option. They weren't. I'd order a £6 piece of meat or fish and they'd send something costing £10. If you called up and complained they'd refund the difference, but I got so fed up of ringing every week (and I was starting to feel like the call centre might think I was having them on, although surely they could see what I'd ordered?) that I went back to Ocado.

I'm not impressed with Ocado since the switch to M&S. Often there are substitutions and missing items and some items have just disappeared from the shelves (and my basket) with no warning whatsoever. I'm considering moving back to Tesco.

Cottonheadedninymuggins · 28/12/2021 11:28

To be fair to them all, the last month isn't really a great time to compare as there'll be stock shortages not just because of hgv delivery delays staff illnesses etc but also because of the time of year and people buying like crazy.

They'd probably gotten a delivery and/or restocked the shelves in between your order being picked and delivered, @WalkingOnSonshine.

I dislike Sainsbury's subs and turn them off purely because I don't shop with them often enough to reuse the voucher "sub refunds" as our Sainsbury's is small compared to the asda and tesco stores and there's not a lot of choice. (ie if you order say champagne on offer for 10, they sub it for a 25 pound bottle. You pay the 25 pound out of your bank but they send you a 15 evoucher to use online for your next shop so if your subs are on its can be a vicious circle.

We don't have a waitrose or ocado so can't comment on them.

Morrisons here pick very early for later on in the day shops. For example if your order is due between 1 and 2 you get the email at around 8am with what's missing.... Generally that's the fresh stuff that wasn't ready at that time but would be later in the day 🤦🏻‍♀️ plus their delivery crates are filthy to the point when they were delivering in bags, a bag bottom picked up so much dirt from the bottom of the trays that it transfered it into my house in the living room floor whilst tubs were emptied and also then into the kitchen where it was noticed. Since found out they store their crates outside overnight and haven't gone back (store on the very edge of town surrounded by countryside and all sorts of creatures about... Even if its just been raining overnight you can bet the literal filth from the bottom of the trays is all over your food.... Quite a few local shoppers reported it to customer services a few times and nothing was done so environmental health were notified at the council.... Fingers crossed things have improved.

Asda here aren't too bad. There's the odd silly 'not available' like a mixed flavour Multipack of crisps.... Really there were no crisps at all in the store? Mostly they're pretty decent.

I asked tesco not to sub certain things on the Christmas shop because we wanted those brands or those particular items only.... They subbed quite a few we'd asked them not to...thst was the first time they'd done that for us.

Iceland have been pretty decent. Barely any subs and when it is its been related stuff.

I'm most amused when they sub something for exactly the same thing. For example a TV mag at Xmas was subbed for the same TV mag/same edition... Just under a different computer generated name 🤣🤣

Forbthe shopper who did their first asda shop and expected to know the day before (sorry forgot username), unfortunately that's not the case with asda. They can only shop what's on the shelves at the time they pick it (usually about 3ish hours before delivery).

Thesearmsofmine · 28/12/2021 11:18

@FawnFrenchieMum is correct they do pick from the shop floor so can’t predict the exact stock levels as someone could come in 10 minutes beforehand and buy all of the bananas and there will be none left for your order.
The cut off for changing orders did used to be midnight but changed to 10pm during covid.

swampytiggaa · 28/12/2021 11:18

[quote llm24]@swampytiggaa

It was 10pm I could amend my order not too midnight

Do you work for Asda would be ideal to know why

Ordered plain and salt and vinegar crisps - alternative sent Cheese and Onion

Ordered full size Sausages - sent me chipotala sausages

I’m the grand scale of things not a major problem but frustrating 😂 when have a fussy household[/quote]
I work for Morrisons. @FawnFrenchieMum not all Morrisons pick from a warehouse we pick from store.

Regarding the subs we get alternatives given on the handset. We aren’t allowed to use our initiative which is frustrating when we can see a better sub on the shelf.

Ours seems to like to keep to the same brand which is probably why you got salt and vinegar crisps 😊

The shop is filled overnight for us to start at 5am so there is no way of seeing what isn’t there until then iyswim. We are working whilst they are still filling.

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 28/12/2021 11:10

@Starcaller

Never had any issues with Tesco. Never many subs and when there are, they are sensible. I think a lot of it just depends on your local shop or warehouse where your food is picked though.
Same for me.
FawnFrenchieMum · 28/12/2021 11:08

[quote llm24]@swampytiggaa

It was 10pm I could amend my order not too midnight

Do you work for Asda would be ideal to know why

Ordered plain and salt and vinegar crisps - alternative sent Cheese and Onion

Ordered full size Sausages - sent me chipotala sausages

I’m the grand scale of things not a major problem but frustrating 😂 when have a fussy household[/quote]
I don’t work for them but my understanding is, Asda pick from the shop floor so don’t really know what they will have in at any times.
Morrison’s pick from a warehouse so are more able to keep track of stock.

FawnFrenchieMum · 28/12/2021 11:07

Should say Sainsbury’s weren’t awful!

WalkingOnSonshine · 28/12/2021 11:06

Asda for me is awful. I am supposed to have a £80 order arriving today - it’s going to be £45 as they have nothing in stock.

Weirdly my neighbour has gone in this morning and bought two of the items that are apparently out of stock.

I find Sainsburys to be brilliant, mostly in stock and sensible subs.

llm24 · 28/12/2021 11:06

@swampytiggaa

It was 10pm I could amend my order not too midnight

Do you work for Asda would be ideal to know why

Ordered plain and salt and vinegar crisps - alternative sent Cheese and Onion

Ordered full size Sausages - sent me chipotala sausages

I’m the grand scale of things not a major problem but frustrating 😂 when have a fussy household

FawnFrenchieMum · 28/12/2021 11:06

Asda is the worst, hate using Asda. I used Sainsbury’s a couple of times during the first lockdown, they weren’t amazing but given the shortages and the pandemic they were awful and I was just grateful for any form of delivery. I barely get substitutes from Morrison’s so use them most regularly.

Thesearmsofmine · 28/12/2021 11:02

I think it varies. Asda here used to be terrible but these days are very good, I rarely have subs and if I do they are usually ok and you only get charged the price of the item you ordered. Sainsburys annoy me with their subs because you have to pay full price for the subbed item and they do that voucher thing instead.

orderanda · 28/12/2021 10:56

Asda. I'm vegetarian and I had 8 veggie meals subbed with meat. It's just common sense...