Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WWYD heart attack and no ambulance?

365 replies

1wokeuplikethis · 28/12/2021 00:47

This is what happened to our family today. My dad had a heart attack, I phoned 999 and I was put on hold. I’ve heard about this but never thought it actually happens. When I finally got through they said an ambulance would take 2hrs so I can wait or take him myself. Nearest hospital is 30mins away, so I needed my husband to drive so I could be there if dad went unconscious but seriously, WHAT DO YOU DO? I thought, the shop nearby has a defibrillator outside, should I take that? But I don’t know if you can take them. It was busy A roads the whole journey with speed cameras and every light was red- do you go through them? If dad had gone unconscious in the car, do you stop and pull him out on the wet road to do CPR? Carry on to hospital?

I felt so helpless. You always think an ambulance is round the corner but what if it isn’t and you’re just an average joe with no medical knowledge?

Please please tell me, what would you do in that circumstance? I was not prepared.

OP posts:
PussyCatEatingPigsInBlankets · 28/12/2021 08:48

My DH has a heart condition.
We live about 5 mins from an A&E, but he would (and has) be transferred to a specialist Cardiac centre about 20 miles away by ambulance for anything more than monitoring.
We'd love to move to somewhere more rural, but having the security of being able to get him there really quickly it would be faster if I broke the speed limit should (when) he needs it keeps us here.

Chewbecca · 28/12/2021 08:46

I would have put him in the car and headed off to the hospital at (safe as possible) speed.

Glad to hear he is doing ok.

Uniforn · 28/12/2021 08:45

@DontKnowWhatToThink7

I'm so glad your dad is OK, how scary for all of you. I am so shocked that the operator didn't say on the phone tbh, surely they have a duty of care? If I was in your position I don't think I would have waited, I would have driven.
It depends on how many calls are coming in really. I used to take 999 calls, if we had the chance to stay on with people and they wanted us to we would, but when calls are flying in and 999 calls are not being answered within the time window of 3 seconds, you unfortunately have to leave calls sooner than you perhaps usually would.
Screwcorona · 28/12/2021 08:45

I would drive him as fast as safe to do so. No skipping red lights as a crash would only make things worse. Ideally one drive and a passenger to attend to him. No good waiting for ambulance that long

Uniforn · 28/12/2021 08:44

@EllaVaNight

This area is desperate for student paramedics, I might look in to signing up. Could you say roughly what area you are in? My sister has recently qualified as a paramedic. I took her to all her uni open days where everyone was told "don't expect to get in first or second time" as it's so competitive. People want to become paramedics but the government won't provide the jobs so there was no point training people when there would be no job for them at the end.
Yes courses are always oversubscribed, same with midwifery, willing students isn't the problem (although retention is but applies to everyone in healthcare). The issue is largely that there aren't enough mentors in an over stretched service to be able to provide adequate support and training whilst on placement for more, so a bit of a viscous circle I guess.
EllaVaNight · 28/12/2021 08:43

Also there wouldn't be the resources for shadowing/third manning/mentoring etc.

Looubylou · 28/12/2021 08:42

I have (ridiculously) managed attacks of extreme pain at home for years - in my defence, I am a nurse, and I know that the pain caused by my condition will eventually stop after about 10 hours, so long as I don't suffer a perforation. I would 100 % expect others to present in A!E. On the 21st I had an attack like no other - I was crawling the floor, I couldn't speak coherently, I couldn't hold a glass of water as I was shaking so much and my teeth were chattering. My partner was told 4 hours for an ambulance. He was very frightened, having known me for over 30 years, and knowing how I manage pain. We had to get my frightened child out of bed to drive to hospital at 2am. My treatment in A/E was appalling. It was hours before I saw a doctor - I only saw a nurse practitioner in terms of A/E. I eventually saw a surgeon and things got better from there. The lack of compassion from staff in A/E, for someone in such extreme pain was astounding. As a nurse, looking back, I am mortified on their behalf and for the sake of other patients. OP, I am so sorry you and your father have gone through this. I can honestly say I too would have struggled to know which course of action to take. Waiting for treatment reduces chances of survival - however walking someone out to a car who is having a heart attack, is hardly a safe option. You did what you thought was best, in a very traumatic situation. 💐XX

DontKnowWhatToThink7 · 28/12/2021 08:42

I'm so glad your dad is OK, how scary for all of you. I am so shocked that the operator didn't say on the phone tbh, surely they have a duty of care? If I was in your position I don't think I would have waited, I would have driven.

Amijustagrump · 28/12/2021 08:42

@WeWantTheFinestWines and number 10 keep ambulances free for emergencies, use other health care services for minor things like a three week old back ache!

EllaVaNight · 28/12/2021 08:41

This area is desperate for student paramedics, I might look in to signing up. Could you say roughly what area you are in? My sister has recently qualified as a paramedic. I took her to all her uni open days where everyone was told "don't expect to get in first or second time" as it's so competitive. People want to become paramedics but the government won't provide the jobs so there was no point training people when there would be no job for them at the end.

CovidCorvid · 28/12/2021 08:41

@KloppsTeeth

I’m so sorry this has happened, it must’ve been very scary.

This area is desperate for student paramedics, I might look in to signing up. Mid forties, and I’d need someone to look after my disabled son whilst I was at work, but they need more people, and it is something I could very well do. 🤔

I think the issue is lack of student training places not lack of applications. It’s very competitive to get on the course as hundreds of people chasing a small number of places. They can’t expand places as they need enough placement places (ie ambulances and qualified staff) for training.
Amijustagrump · 28/12/2021 08:40

This is so sad and I'm so glad your dad is okay- but isn't uncommon anymore! DH spent his shift the other week waiting outside an out of area hospital for 6 hours while he hear about 25 "broadcasts" for urgently needed ambulances. And then someone phoned with a bad chest, cough and temperature (so covid..), its a combination of the system failing and people wasting ambulance time! Amazingly this isn't the worst he's seen it in 7 years on the job

WeWantTheFinestWines · 28/12/2021 08:38

@chaosrabbitland

im glad your dad is ok , i dont know what i would have done in that situation either , its just crap ,the old days of phoning an ambulance and it actually getting there in a few minutes are long gone , its just so unacceptable , but nothing we can do about it , in 2018 my mum had a bad fall on my garden path shes 84 , broke her collor bone , lying there in agony and it took a good hour before they got there , she was face down on the path , freezing cold , had to put 3 mink fleeces over her , and every time i rang back to see how much longer it was the same old stuff , ambulance was on the way , got divirted , i felt like screaming down the phone at the dispatcher even tho its nothing to do with them how long it takes ,

id rather have a reformed nhs along the french / german model even if it meant we payed into it more ,for a service thats fit for purpose

As pp have said, there is not 'nothing we can do about it'.

  1. Stop voting Tory.
  2. Educate everybody you know about the link between taxes and healthcare/social care funding so they will understand that higher taxes = better public services.
  3. Stop everybody you know voting Tory - barricade them in their homes on election day if you must.
  4. Explain to everybody you know who voted for Brexit that they share responsibility for current NHS staff shortages.
  5. Vote for a party that will increase NHS pay to at least the level of inflation and reinstate the bursary for student nurses. Clue: that won't be the Tories.
  6. Do not compare favourably to the US. The reason they can get an ambulance quicker is that fewer people call one, because of the cost. Many people cannot afford medical insurance, insurance doesn't cover everything anyway and inability to pay healthcare bills is the single biggest reason for personal bankruptcy in the US.
  7. Get angry. Not with call handlers or A&E staff. With the government. Sick people were waiting on trolleys in hospital corridors during the Tory government of the 90s. That stopped during the Labour years (and I am no fan of New Labour but it's a fact) and further years of Tory disdain for anything publicly funded have now put us back there, but many times worse.
  8. Be sure to tell anyone who won't get Covid vaxxed that they're ignorant and dangerous and should not be allowed out of the house.
  9. Start again at 1.
Twatforaneighbour · 28/12/2021 08:38

@CheshireKitten123

"I don't want a lockdown but we do need something to help this situation"

So what do you expect the government to do about it ?

Exactly. As PP said, there are queues of ambulances at a&e and wards full so nowhere to put more patients. Even if there could be more funding for more staff, the answer would seem to be to build more hospitals to increase capacity which is not going to happen overnight.

But right now, covid is adding to the numbers going into hospital so ambulance waits are longer but people dont want to lockdown to reduce this.

LizzieSiddal · 28/12/2021 08:35

I’m blaming the Govt because this isn’t due to Covid, it’s been going on for years. Ambulances are regularly stacked up outside A&E departments

Hear hear! STOP voting for the Tory’s and the NHS WILL be better. I’m old enough to remember when Tony Blair got in the NHS was in a dreadful state after a decade of the Tory’s. Labour ploughed money into the NHS and it vastly improved. As soon as Cameron came in budgets were slashed again. They don’t care because they can afford to go privately.

SheWoreYellow · 28/12/2021 08:31

@saltinesandcoffeecups

Is this what it's like everywhere atm?

I know the favorite pastime here is to mock US healthcare. But our wait times average 4-9 minutes regardless of the type of call (stubbed toe, strokes, heart attacks, to picking up gran after a fall) for an ambulance.

I honestly can’t imagine counting ambulance wait times in hours.

OP, I’m pleased your dad is doing ok.

To give some reassurance, the December ambulance response times report for england gives nine minutes for the mean response time for cat 1, so I don’t think this is usual.

It’s always a good idea to have first aid training and so on though.

WWYD heart attack and no ambulance?
MuchTooTired · 28/12/2021 08:30

I’d have done exactly what you did - bundle him into the car and belt it to the hospital ourselves. As PP said, if you get stopped at least they can blue light him in themselves!

My dad had a heart attack recently, luckily they sent an ambulance quickly, similarly a few weeks later when we feared another was happening. When my DS was ill a week later (he’s 3) the 111 operator said she was arranging an ambulance for him but the wait time was going to be long. Once she heard his most recent temperature reading she told us to get him to hospital ASAP ourselves if we can because we’d be fastest and he was at risk of seizures.

It’s bloody terrifying, and I don’t blame you for feeling traumatised. I’m sorry it happened to you both, and I wish your Dad a speedy recovery. 💐

Brindle88 · 28/12/2021 08:29

How dreadful. I hope your dad is getting better now.

How the government can claim the NHS is not overwhelmed is beyond me.

Pinkypenguin · 28/12/2021 08:28

@AlternativePerspective

id rather have a reformed nhs along the french / german model even if it meant we payed into it more ,for a service thats fit for purpose the thing is that people don’t actually want a reformed nhs. They want the exact nhs that they already have. Where everything should be treated and paid for despite the fact the number of treatments available for various conditions is going up, thus meaning the amount of resource and money is going down.

Stop offering treatments like bloody IVF on the NHS, and free up some of that money to improve the emergency responses and treatments. Just to use one example. But everyone thinks their situation is unique and should be treated. Well perhaps sometimes the less life-threatening things shouldn’t be.

I agree there should be less access to the NHS for absolutely everything (but look what happens on here when someone wants the NHS to supply gluten free bread or aspirins on prescription). Or if people suggest you go to the pharmacist first for non urgent assessments.

People, should be seriously discouraged from going to the GP for every little thing that they could deal with themselves. People should be encouraged to look after their own health, so they're less of a burden on the NHS.

But maybe we do need to look at another model for healthcare, so that people do have to pay a bit for accessing routine checks, as they do in other countries.

Unfortunately, I don't trust this Government not to go full on US-style private healthcare/insurance route, which will enrich the pockets of their own supporters one way or another.

Gretaburley · 28/12/2021 08:28

In France the Pompiers (Fire Service) are also first responders for medical emergencies. They truly are amazing and are all trained paramedics.
We still have ambulances too.

CornishTiger · 28/12/2021 08:27

And often they aren’t staying on the phone. They say call back if situation worsens.

CornishTiger · 28/12/2021 08:26

This is sadly not uncommon. 2 hrs for a neighbour with similar. When I rang back to get a code for the defib was a 10 min wait to get through to 999.

Lessofallthisunpleasantness · 28/12/2021 08:22

How scary. Not sure how I would react. I think I would have got them in the car and driven to the hospital.

Although might depend on the age of the person. I remember my Granny had a heart attack at a party before Christmas years and years ago when she was late 70s. She was blue lighted to hospital and she did survive. Afterwards many times she said she was grateful for the care she had received but really she wished that nature had been able to take it's course as it would have been a lovely way to go and a good time, she did not have a good quality of life for the next 6 years that she lived and often commented that she was on borrowed time and not sure that was a good thing.

Pinkypenguin · 28/12/2021 08:19

@AlternativePerspective

I think some people are getting confused between a heart attack and cardiac arrest. A heart attack does not require CPR, CPR is only required if the person is in cardiac arrest and their heart has stopped. agree with this. Actually most heart attacks don’t result in cardiac arrest, although that doesn’t mean a heart attack isn’t an emergency obviously.

The truth is that even if an ambulance can arrive promptly, the chances of surviving a cardiac arrest outside of hospital are tiny, around 5%.

As for saying that it’s all the government’s fault, there is also some public culpability here on the part of the millions of time wasters who ring the emergency services every year for things which simply aren’t even worthy of going to hospital for at worst, or which the patient could drive themselves to a&e for at best. This is one of the reasons why 111 was established, in order to hopefully reduce some of the burden on the emergency services.

I'm not sure what the rules are for non urgent ambulance calls but if someone rings up saying they've sprained their ankle and need an ambulance, then surely the ambulance should just not be sent? There has to be a cut off point where people have to ring for a taxi. Just because someone wants something, shouldn't mean they get it.
Punxsutawney · 28/12/2021 08:17

Op, hope your Dad makes a good recovery.

I think it might have been mentioned previously on this thread. But having the fire service trained in attending emergency medical calls, could be useful.
When we were in America on holiday, Ds who was a baby at the time, had some kind of febrile seizure and was unconscious. When we dialled 911 for medical help, it was the fire service that initially turned up.