Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WWYD heart attack and no ambulance?

365 replies

1wokeuplikethis · 28/12/2021 00:47

This is what happened to our family today. My dad had a heart attack, I phoned 999 and I was put on hold. I’ve heard about this but never thought it actually happens. When I finally got through they said an ambulance would take 2hrs so I can wait or take him myself. Nearest hospital is 30mins away, so I needed my husband to drive so I could be there if dad went unconscious but seriously, WHAT DO YOU DO? I thought, the shop nearby has a defibrillator outside, should I take that? But I don’t know if you can take them. It was busy A roads the whole journey with speed cameras and every light was red- do you go through them? If dad had gone unconscious in the car, do you stop and pull him out on the wet road to do CPR? Carry on to hospital?

I felt so helpless. You always think an ambulance is round the corner but what if it isn’t and you’re just an average joe with no medical knowledge?

Please please tell me, what would you do in that circumstance? I was not prepared.

OP posts:
kittensinthekitchen · 28/12/2021 10:10

Some talk on the thread of what services should be used for various circumstances. Was recently sent this document, think it went out to all households in Scotland, which is very useful

WWYD heart attack and no ambulance?
SleepyRich · 28/12/2021 10:10

I would make my own way at the moment, if you think you're having a heart attack then you're probably too sick to wait for an ambulance. I was working last night, my first job was for a patient who'd had a seizure, job was 12 hours old! When I arrived they were just returning from hospital having made their own way. Response times are madness at the moment, around 15minutes for a cardiac arrest (for a realistic chance of a good outcome we know this needs to be less than 4minutes), 2-6 hours typical for chest pain/severe difficulty breathing/unresponsive but breathing. Only call 999 for a life threatening emergency for which you are too unwell/unable to make own way.

PostMenPatWithACat · 28/12/2021 10:09

@ParsleySageRosemary because they would be getting their training free. If they want to move to something else, they could convert it to a student loan and repay it. Like every other graduate has to. I think similar should be introduced for doctors and teachers too.

milly74 · 28/12/2021 10:08

@ChardonnaysPetDragon

It's the lack of GP appointments and the inaccessibility of minor out of hours services.

Also, the grey economy, where hundredd of thousands are not even registered with a GP and go to A&E because that's the only place where it's no questions asked.

Agreed about the lack of GP accessiblity - the GPs trying to defend the inexcusable is very telling.
CheshireKitten123 · 28/12/2021 10:07

Postman

"The most effective thing that could be done is to reintroduce the nursing bursary and make it non repayable providing the nurses benefitting provide a minimum of 10 years' service to the NHS and to ensure that nurses are re-equipped with actual nursing skills."

I fully agree.

They also need to re-introduce bursaries for other Allied Health Professionals, such as Physiotherapists, Dieticians, Podiatrists, Occupational Therapists, Orthoptists, Osteopaths, Speech and Language Therapists etc.

These professionals can reduce hospital stay times and/or support patients in the community, thus reducing delayed discharges.

Strictlyfanoftenyears · 28/12/2021 10:05

Just a reminder that Alexa can talk you through CPR if you need it (I assume the others do too)

ParsleySageRosemary · 28/12/2021 10:04

The most effective thing that could be done is to reintroduce the nursing bursary and make it non repayable providing the nurses benefitting provide a minimum of 10 years' service to the NHS and to ensure that nurses are re-equipped with actual nursing skills.

Why should nurses be made the subject of indentured service in what’s supposed to be a free country?

I agree with returning - returning, remember - to free training for jobs that are required by society. Someone upthread mentioned the lack of childcare that blocks women too. The culture of long hours, unreliable shifts and low wages for “heroes” all needs to stop. All the ‘reforms’ of the last two decades have led to this. Surely we can all see that we’re staring straight at a failed state with no healthcare?

Hope your dad is ok, op.

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 28/12/2021 10:04

It's the lack of GP appointments and the inaccessibility of minor out of hours services.

Also, the grey economy, where hundredd of thousands are not even registered with a GP and go to A&E because that's the only place where it's no questions asked.

PussyCatEatingPigsInBlankets · 28/12/2021 10:04

@ifonly4

OP, I really feel for you. My Dad had a heart attack and actually had a GP with him in the house. Things turned from bad to worse and GP told my Mum to get on the phone immediately to basically tell them they had to send the delayed ambulance now. She was told the ambulance assigned to him was currently on an emergency call out to a child. This is going back years ago to a labour government - seems like nothing has changed.
My dad had this. I was told there'd be a delay for an ambulance for my poor old dad with chest pain (82, unstable angina diagnosed but went on to have a CABG the next month) so he was bundled into my car and I drove like a nutter through town to the hospital. Once my dad was being assessed in Majors, I asked one of the paramedics (accompanying a 10ish yr old boy in his school uniform wearing a sling with his mum) if they could cancel the ambulance...he said my dad was his next pick-up Shock he'd been diverted to collect the child.
SleepyRich · 28/12/2021 10:02

@saltinesandcoffeecups

The operator didn’t stay on the line- she said wait or go

That’s damn near criminal. In my area if something like this can be proven, at a minimum that dispatch would have been fired.

When the number of incoming calls reaches a certain level the call takers are not allowed to stay on the line once the triage tool is finished. It's so busy at the moment when you call 999 for an ambulance you may be kept on hold for a minute or 2 before they answer you. It's quite sensible that once instructions are delivered to hang up the phone
Tiredalwaystired · 28/12/2021 10:02

@saltinesandcoffeecups

2 hours for a heart attack… that is ridiculous. I’m sorry you had to go through that I hope your dad is ok.

I’m not sure why bother spending money on an ambulance service with that kind of response time. You’d be better off paying taxis.

COVID is out there that is decimating workforces. It’s having a massive effect on staffing the ambulance service as well as other services. At the moment the best thing we can do to keep these services running is the old hands face space and vaccines for all.

This is the bigger danger with omicron it seems, rather than direct hospitalisation and deaths. Sick NHS workers can’t treat NHS patients, whatever is wrong with them. This is the fall out of COVID deniers and anti vaxxers in action (alongside Tory austerity legacies)

OliverBabish · 28/12/2021 09:58

Wait time for a heart attack round here is 6 hours. NHS is on its knees. I had to drive to A&E with my relative

Emerald5hamrock · 28/12/2021 09:57

The delays in handing over patients is a huge issue if there is between 3 or 10 ambulances queueing ahead then people will die.
A triage would help hand patients quicker.

PostMenPatWithACat · 28/12/2021 09:57

It is dire but there are common sense practical issues that are structural and need to be dealt with. For example where I live people who need emergency surgery are taken first to the district hospital that has no emergency surgery facilities. After a long trolley wait because they can't help a second ambulance is required to transfer them to the bigger hospital which does have emergency surgery facilities. The two hospitals are five miles apart. But it is the protocol. A protocol which uses two ambulances unnecessarily and the time of two A&E departments unnecessarily. It is a complete joke and those in charge need to be held accountable. However major trauma, and a heart attack falls under that definition is taken directly to the major trauma centre 10 miles away.

I had a ridiculous situation in August. I fell badly severely breaking my wrist and a vertebra. The call handler refused to triage me because I couldn’t categorise which was the worst injury. I'm not sure how I could do that without an XRay machine. I was on the pavement in the rain for two hours. There were three calls in total. On one I wasntold to take paracetamol and I unproven but to get a pharmacist's advice first when I asked how that was possible I was told tongoogle on my smart phone and telephone them. On the third call the call handler said "so it will be 4 hours, is that OK". Thankfully through my pain I twigged and having said yes first, managed to interject that it was not OK, so then a clinician call was arranged. The clinician told me sarcastically that he would send my free ambulance that would be with me in an hour. I could not get up.

The ED was an absolute disorganised shambles, carrying out procedures in contravention of Nice Guidelines. Staff were rude and it was like the third world. When eventually after 6 hours and no pain assessment, I got through to cubicles, there were more staff than patients.

This arises because the NHS is not fit for purpose and because of public worship has been used as a political football for years. The Blair Government wrapped it up in shiny plastic by extending PFI and introducing the PCTs as an additional layer of very expensive bureaucracy, notwithstanding the new GP contract. There are far too many managers, producing almost worthless data but not addressing the structural and practical issues.

The most effective thing that could be done is to reintroduce the nursing bursary and make it non repayable providing the nurses benefitting provide a minimum of 10 years' service to the NHS and to ensure that nurses are re-equipped with actual nursing skills.

The second most effective thing would be for the British public to stop being congenital grateful for a system that is not fit for purpose and which is free only at the point of delivery.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 28/12/2021 09:57

@LakieLady to be fair a sprained ankle can be managed at home with worsening advice given

Janus · 28/12/2021 09:57

@decadance I’m so sorry for what must have been a terrifying experience. I hope your husband is comfortable on the stroke ward and improves steadily.

LakieLady · 28/12/2021 09:55

I'm not sure what the rules are for non urgent ambulance calls but if someone rings up saying they've sprained their ankle and need an ambulance, then surely the ambulance should just not be sent? There has to be a cut off point where people have to ring for a taxi. Just because someone wants something, shouldn't mean they get it

I think that would put a lot of poorer people off seeking treatment.

A taxi to the nearest A&E from my house would be at least £30, considerably more if it was after midnight or on a Sunday. That's a big chunk of money for someone on basic UC, who's probably having to use some of the money they get to live on to top up their rent, as UC doesn't cover the full amount, and pay 20% of their council tax. And it would cost them the same, or more, to get back again.

You see it on money threads on here, where one unexpected expense means a family has to resort to food banks.

AnneElliott · 28/12/2021 09:54

I agree @DrDreReturns - on MN (maybe in RL too) you can't have a sensible conversation about the NHS. Any suggestion of reform is seen as wanting a US system when there are many good systems in Europe that we could look at.

And I also agree with a pp that Tony Blair's GP reforms were a mistake. I worked for a GP practice at the time and they could not believe their luck at having negotiated at getting rid of out of hours. This has directly contributed to the difficulties we now see with everyone turning up at A&E.

PinkTonic · 28/12/2021 09:53

@Kinneddar

It's totally different here. Fire fighters are first aid trained so they can help at their calls until Paramedics arrive but they won't go as first responders to medical calls. The 2 services are totally separate here

It was suggested a few years ago that firefighters undertook more medical training but the Firefighters union.wouldnt back it - nor would most Firefighters apparantly.

I had the fire service turn up as first responders to my dad in November this year.
DrDreReturns · 28/12/2021 09:50

few people are prepared to have a real conversation and make difficult decisions about funding and running the NHS in the future.
This is the danger with turning the NHS in to a national religion - it makes it impossible to reform or criticise it.

ittakes2 · 28/12/2021 09:49

I am sorry to hear about your mum and dad. What a scary experience.
It would be interesting to hear from someone from an A&E department or an ambulance officer as to what they would do.
From personal experience of family member and I also once tried to resusitate an elderly man who had sadly had a heart attack in the car - interestingly I would consider a) asking the operator if I could give them disprin to thin their blood and b) getting the defribillator and waiting for an ambulance depending on a person's pain level.
When you call an ambulance for a suspected heart attack you are calling them for someone with chest pain. Heart attacks can only be determined after an ECG or a blood test. Some chest pain is stress or angina. Angina can be relieved with blood thinners. I know its scary when someone who has had a heart attack has chest pain.
I am not medically trained so I might not be thinking the right way but there are two reasons I would have got a defibrillator and waited for an ambulance is a) you can't do CPR in a car so you would need to stop and do it by the side of the road if necessary and that might not be a safe place to stop. You can't do it in the car because you need a flat surface or the chest compressions won't work. b) sometimes unfortunately some hearts can only be started with defibb and I would worry I needed defibb on the way to the hospital. I have been on community defribillator training and you really don't need to know how to use one - a voice talks to you and tells you exactly what to do when.
I hope your dad is OK. If he doesn't have this already, I would ask the doctor for a nitrate spray which thins the blood instantly when someone has chest pain and buy a blood pressure kit and an oximeter pulse finger tester which tests for oxygen levels.

ChristmasyFairy · 28/12/2021 09:49

Sadly this is very common.

A couple I know- young- thought the woman was having a possible heart attack. This was in London a few weeks ago.

The ambulance was promised in 30 mins and took 2 hrs to arrive.

There was a major hospital 2 mins away but they don't own a car , could have got a taxi, but she wasn't well enough to move and they were promised the ambulance 'any minute'.

Thankfully her partner is a trained first aider and knows how to do CPR etc but it's just another example of how appalling things are.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 28/12/2021 09:49

Everything is a mess not just the NHS but social care too which has a major effect on the NHS especially in my rural area of Scotland where there are more old people than there are young. 3 community hospitals closed at the start of covid meaning there isn’t enough step down facilities, these should have been reopened as a first step and the redeployed staff put back. Our main hospital is full of people fit for home but no care packages, they don’t tell you this though so people assume it’s over run with covid

SpanielsAreMyLife · 28/12/2021 09:49

My Uncle has had several heart attacks, and unfortunately had another one in late November. His wife rang for an ambulance, which arrived within 20 minutes, and he was loaded straight into it and blue lit to hospital.

He then sat in the back of that ambulance for 9 hours because A & E (main county hospital) was so stacked up. Didn't see a Dr during that time, and it's luck more than judgement that he didn't deteriorate. He then had to wait nearly 7 days for treatment (clot removal in catheter lab) because he picked an infection up and needed high dose antibiotics. My aunt wasn't allowed into see him once during his stay, and he was discharged in a hell of a state - he hadn't had a single wash or shave during his time in there, could barely walk and was in grubby soiled clothing.

I'm so sorry you had this awful scare. And the hysterics will blame Covid but there are 72 patients in the county in hospital and none requiring ventilation. The system is fucked. I'm terrified because DH needs cardiac surgery in the coming months Sad

decadance · 28/12/2021 09:49

I had to call an ambulance on christmas eve morning after finding my husband completely unresponsive on his bed, i knew he'd had a stroke as his mouth was drooped to one side, when i called 999 they told me they couldnt tell me how long the ambulance would take, we waited the longest 15 minutes of my life, my son rang them back but ambulance still took 40 minutes to get to us, i don't drive and husband has parkinsons, he couldnt go in a car, they took him straight to Resus and i was sat on my own for nearly 8 hours in the relative's room to try to get an update on his condition, i wandered through to A&E to ask about him and it was horrendous there, full of drunks, i had to ask 4 or 5 different staff, no one seemed interested, eventually a doctor came to speak to me to tell me he',d had a massive stroke but it was too late to operate, he's now in the stroke unit there, i keep having flashbacks to what happened, its just day by day they said but i keep thinking he could have been helped sooner and had a better outcome