Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WWYD heart attack and no ambulance?

365 replies

1wokeuplikethis · 28/12/2021 00:47

This is what happened to our family today. My dad had a heart attack, I phoned 999 and I was put on hold. I’ve heard about this but never thought it actually happens. When I finally got through they said an ambulance would take 2hrs so I can wait or take him myself. Nearest hospital is 30mins away, so I needed my husband to drive so I could be there if dad went unconscious but seriously, WHAT DO YOU DO? I thought, the shop nearby has a defibrillator outside, should I take that? But I don’t know if you can take them. It was busy A roads the whole journey with speed cameras and every light was red- do you go through them? If dad had gone unconscious in the car, do you stop and pull him out on the wet road to do CPR? Carry on to hospital?

I felt so helpless. You always think an ambulance is round the corner but what if it isn’t and you’re just an average joe with no medical knowledge?

Please please tell me, what would you do in that circumstance? I was not prepared.

OP posts:
SetFreeTheKites · 28/12/2021 12:57

LuluBlakey1 - Not necessarily, no. Chest pain is chest pain. A cat 2 is a cat 2. How could a call assessor prioritise between somebody calling with chest pain who has recently had a heart attack, and somebody else who has chest pain who hasn't recently had a heart attack but is still experiencing all of the classic symptoms of one? They can't.

Also, just to add, somebody above (sorry I'm awful remembering user names) has said that a heart attack is a category 1. It absolutely isn't. Category 1 calls are cardiac arrests, unconscious with noisy/ineffective breathing, seizures, anaphylaxis, life threatening asthma, or labour when the birth is imminent. Not chest pain.

Bunnybunny1 · 28/12/2021 12:44

God OP what a shocking thing to happen, I’m so glad your dad is okay.
The NHS is being strangled by the Conservative party covertly.
People have really got to just stop voting for these cruel and heartless Etonians.

Sofawithoutstuffing · 28/12/2021 12:44

@WirKindervomBahnhofZoo

I waited 8 hours for an ambulance for my 81 year old Dad on Christmas Day. When it eventually arrived the lovely paramedics told me they had been in someone's house for the last 2 hours as that person had been suffering from backache for the last 3 months, so not an emergency. Words failed me and I still don't know how the call handler could prioritise that over my Dad's situation.
The call handler will not have made a decision to prioritise and send an ambulance to the person with back ache over your Dad. Call handlers take the call and follow the triage system, they don't make decisions on the priority of calls - the system does that automatically and it is very regimented. Call handlers are not supposed to deviate from the script and Quality Assurance check up on whether they are exactly following each "card set". The person who assigns ambulances is normally a different person, not making calls, called an emergency medical dispatcher. Sometimes these roles are combined but usually they are separate.

This means the call handler will normally pick up the full force of someone who angrily calls back and is asking/screaming where the ambulance is but will most likely have no ability to actually assign a response vehicle, even if they wanted to. If something has changed in the patient's condition they can update the call to see if it gives a higher level category or, if their condition has worsened may stay on the line to give instructions on positioning/monitoring a patient who is unconscious and breathing. Or CPR instructions if the patient stops breathing.

Back ache is rarely a high priority call but we have no idea what the person who called 999 actually reported. People can be known to lie and/or exaggerate! Quite often crews will turn up to a completely different scenario to the one reported. For example, that person with backache may well have reported with chest pains and feeling breathless which would have resulted in a higher category of call.

TowandaForever · 28/12/2021 12:37

@SheWoreYellow

How accurate are those figures if people are being told to get themselves to hospital who are cat 1 though?

bigred22 · 28/12/2021 12:31

I'm not surprised at all- I work for another emergency service and the wait times for ambulances is seriously shocking- woman unconscious and laboured breathing at 5am? Cat 2 unallocated 🤷🏻‍♀️

Puzzledandpissedoff · 28/12/2021 12:28

I used to work for a (diabolical) IT company that sold to the nhs and local gov, every feb/ March sales people would rub their hands with how much unspent budget would come flooding in

I believe you completely, Namechangetimes100, though I'm relieved the money actually got as far as being spent even if it was (as so often) on somethong inappropriate

BoredZelda I'm genuinely very pleased that you've managed to get treatment, but can't quite accept mine was a "ridiculous comment" when so very many haven't
Agree with you about the need to take the whiole thing out of the political arena though, but unfortunately that's not going to happen ... not when there are so many opportunities involved

Brindle88 · 28/12/2021 12:25

Who is going to take it out of the public arena?

Politicians, that’s who.

And Boris and chums can’t be trusted. They are totally corrupt. They would sell it off to their mates, and some would pay through the nose for the shit they deliver and others would go without.

WirKindervomBahnhofZoo · 28/12/2021 12:19

I waited 8 hours for an ambulance for my 81 year old Dad on Christmas Day. When it eventually arrived the lovely paramedics told me they had been in someone's house for the last 2 hours as that person had been suffering from backache for the last 3 months, so not an emergency. Words failed me and I still don't know how the call handler could prioritise that over my Dad's situation.

BoredZelda · 28/12/2021 12:15

Total restructure needed from top to bottom, not a Tory restructure aka selling off for scraps though

All parties have tried this countless times. It never works. What needs to happen is, it should be taken out of the political arena.

rc22 · 28/12/2021 12:15

The way budgets work in the Public sector is pretty inefficient. I work in a primary school. In an attempt to make the nation healthier, we are flooded with money to spend on PE and have cupboards full of more sports equipment than we can ever possibly use. However, the budget for other things we desperately need is tight/non-existent!!

BoredZelda · 28/12/2021 12:13

(though admittedly not as bad as since it's been turned into a Covid-only service)

What a ridiculous comment. I’ve had quite a few non covid related health issues dealt with over the past year. Going for a non urgent non covid related procedure tomorrow.

Backtomyoldname · 28/12/2021 11:56

@Bonbon21

One reason for ambulance delays is that they are backed up in queues waiting to admit current patients to a + e. There are NO empty beds in a + e because there are no beds available in wards. There are no empty beds in wards because there is no place for people to go to recuperate, rehabilitate or go into care. It is a chain reaction. Successive governments have failed to make provision for decades. Staff in NHS, including ambulance service, physiotherapy, mental health etc are on their knees, working flat out. And this was before Covid. So how much worse it is now. Basic first aid training for everyone would be amazing and help declog (!) a + e. But people have become used to getting helped in every circumstance, rarely taking personal responsibility for the outcome.. think falling off high heels in the street when pissed put of their skulls... we have all seen those on a Saurday night... Calling 999 for the least reason... cut fingers, the lightbulb needing changed... yes REALLY!! Walking into a + e with a problem they have had for 3 weeks. The list goes on.

Sorry... had to vent!!

This and….

The idea that a system should have no slack in it.

That hospitals, ambulances should normally *have vv few spare beds, that ambulances should be out on the road 99% of the time.

*normally ie in the summer, no covid, no big emergencies.

Along comes covid, ambulance crews off sick, no spare beds etc etc

Any emergency service needs slack built into it so that it can provide in times when the shit is hitting the fan.

The lack of sensible investment and understanding is now biting us on the bum.

user14943608381 · 28/12/2021 11:54

@Puzzledandpissedoff

What I meant was that (privatising IVF) won’t solve anything. The money won’t find its way back to the nhs and be used to fund care in the community or buy more ambulances

Quite right, but then even giving the entirety of the UK's GDp to the NHS probably wouldn't solve anything either

Because of the way it's structured, instead of finding its way to the front line extra money invariably goes on more managers to decide how it'll be spent, more reports on issues already known, more "consultations" and so on
It might be nice to think they'd say "Okay, we've known for years that you need more nurses/beds/equipment/whatever so here's the cash", but it simply doesn't work like that

Completely agree again! I used to work for a (diabolical) IT company that sold to the nhs and local gov, every feb/ March sales people would rub their hands with how much unspent budget would come flooding in. One of the midlands hospitals that’s made the news for maternity service and a and e wait times had storage cupboards FULL of Ipads because they needed to spend their remaining budget to ensure they got it next year. The hospital didn’t use apple and none of their systems were designed to use it but it’s the most expensive tech devices so tens of thousands were dropped on that.

Total restructure needed from top to bottom, not a Tory restructure aka selling off for scraps though

thetinsoldier · 28/12/2021 11:52

Op, what an absolute nightmare for you. I'm so so sorry. You think the NHS will be there for you but it can't can't cope.

It sounds like you did brilliantly. Well done.

I'm so sorry for the lots of your mum. Massive hugs.

Summersdreaming · 28/12/2021 11:45

What a horrible shock for you all, I hope your dad is recovering, and I'm so sorry about your mum Flowers

Go easy on yourself too, you did extremely well in the circumstances, and you will be in shock.

HunterGatherer · 28/12/2021 11:44

My DM (87) had a fall recently and we were told 13 hours wait for an ambulance, luckily we have medics in the family who came, got her up from the floor and checked her over. We have bought all necessary equipment (including walking aids, a stairlift and bathlift) and rehabbed her back to some level of being able to cope.
Social services offerred her 6 weeks of free care to prevent admission which she accepted, so it was a shock to be sent a bill for several thousand pounds for the first 4 weeks.
Her social worker initially denied the offer of free care but after telling her that her phone call had been witnessed by a family member who is also a SW in another area she backed down and suddenly remembered that she had indeed offerred us free care.
Awful experience.
How people, who have no knowledge of how these things work, cope, is beyond me.
I can't see the health/social care budget being increased any yikes soon, so I predict that sadly cases like these will just rise.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 28/12/2021 11:42

What I meant was that (privatising IVF) won’t solve anything. The money won’t find its way back to the nhs and be used to fund care in the community or buy more ambulances

Quite right, but then even giving the entirety of the UK's GDp to the NHS probably wouldn't solve anything either

Because of the way it's structured, instead of finding its way to the front line extra money invariably goes on more managers to decide how it'll be spent, more reports on issues already known, more "consultations" and so on
It might be nice to think they'd say "Okay, we've known for years that you need more nurses/beds/equipment/whatever so here's the cash", but it simply doesn't work like that

52andblue · 28/12/2021 11:41

OP I hope you are ok ?
I think the 1st time you realise that the Services you believed were out there for support actually aren't its a real shock. My story isn't about the ambulance but about immediate care. My (now ex)H had what I believe was a heart attack. Paramedics came quickly, assessed as that too & took him to A&E by ambulance. (I stayed at home with 2 small kids as 3am & no one to take them). I was shocked when 90 mins later he arrived home in a taxi. He'd been put on a bed in a corridor, no further assessment, no bloods done, told 'he looked ok now' & sent home. (6 yrs ago, rural Scottish hospital with very poor record). The NHS has been in a declining state for a long time, and it's now in its terminal phase. I hope your Dad recovers well.

kittensinthekitchen · 28/12/2021 11:39

@blameless

1) Just because someone on Holby City or Casualty brings someone back from dead, doesn't mean that it's always possible. I have had two strangers die in front of me from cardiac arrest where nothing could be done. In both cases I felt guilty for weeks, despite there being no chance for them.

Yes, there needs to be better education on this, as many get their 'medical knowledge' from the media. I watch Grey's Anatomy, and don't think there's a single leading character who hasn't had resuscitation, with no after effects. It's not at all realistic. Community CPR is very rarely successful.

Nothingventurednothinggained · 28/12/2021 11:36

That’s awful!
We are 20 minutes from nearest A&E. I would have took him via car. Grabbed defib from nearest shop and pull over if he arrested.
Diabolical service. 2 hrs for a genuine life or death emergency?

Benjispruce5 · 28/12/2021 11:35

That is horrific. It sound like you did all the right things. I’m glad your dad is doing ok.
Yet we are still all able to go out partying on NYE! Write to your MP!!!

AshLane · 28/12/2021 11:35

Sadly, this is the state our country is in. A combination of issues.

Lack of public sector funding - from central government to all services.
Lack of staff, especially in social care (so bed blocking and ambulances waiting) caused by Brexit
Covid - staff are ill, staff are not at work

Reflect on your own voting, reflect on your wish for us all to ignore Covid and carry on. This is what happens.

playmelikeasymphony · 28/12/2021 11:33

@saltinesandcoffeecups

Is this what it's like everywhere atm?

I know the favorite pastime here is to mock US healthcare. But our wait times average 4-9 minutes regardless of the type of call (stubbed toe, strokes, heart attacks, to picking up gran after a fall) for an ambulance.

I honestly can’t imagine counting ambulance wait times in hours.

In my case, I had a fall a while ago and needed the paramedics to get me up (I was unhurt but am disabled) I was advised I was looking at waiting up to three hours. In reality I waited about 30 mins as there was a crew just starting there shift in the next town. But they couldn’t tell me that, they had to tell me that I was a low priority and the worst case scenario.
LuluBlakey1 · 28/12/2021 11:32

@SetFreeTheKites

The problem is that even if you call and say someone is having a heart attack, they can't categorise it as 'heart attack' because they can't diagnose that over the phone. It's categorised as chest pain, which is a category 2 - along with a whole host of other symptoms and complaints, and a load more people calling who also have chest pain. There aren't enough ambulances to cover the number of calls coming in. It's shit, of course, and people who are genuinely having heart attacks shouldn't have to wait 2 hours for an ambulance, but this is unfortunately the way things are at the moment. I can't see it getting better any time soon.

I would have done the same thing in your situation, got Dad in the car and drove as quickly as I could - while still abiding by the laws of the road - to hospital. If he lost consciousness on the way then I'd have called back on 999 as the situation then is obviously more serious.

I'm fairly certain you can't access a defibrillator unless you're calling because somebody is in cardiac arrest, I don't think they'd give you the code to access the defib because you're driving somebody with chest pain to hospital.

Surely if the person had a heart attack just a week previously, they would be a priority for an ambulance now with further symptoms?
user14943608381 · 28/12/2021 11:31

@Puzzledandpissedoff

Stopping offering IVF on the NHS is not the answer

Maybe not, but sooner or later it's almost certainly going to happen

With optical services, dentistry, chiropody and so on already effectively privatised, do people really think NHS IVF will go on for ever, especially when infertility isn't an acute illness (though the causes of it may be)?

You are quite right, it’s already a postcode lottery thus basically rendering private the only viable option for many, so it will happen but what I meant was it won’t solve anything. The money won’t find its way back to the nhs and be used to fund care in the community or buy more ambulances.

I agree Chardonnay the whole thing needs actual reform and not Tori reform which will be selling off and privatising whilst simultaneously offering doorstep claps for ‘heros’ and scapegoating.