Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WWYD heart attack and no ambulance?

365 replies

1wokeuplikethis · 28/12/2021 00:47

This is what happened to our family today. My dad had a heart attack, I phoned 999 and I was put on hold. I’ve heard about this but never thought it actually happens. When I finally got through they said an ambulance would take 2hrs so I can wait or take him myself. Nearest hospital is 30mins away, so I needed my husband to drive so I could be there if dad went unconscious but seriously, WHAT DO YOU DO? I thought, the shop nearby has a defibrillator outside, should I take that? But I don’t know if you can take them. It was busy A roads the whole journey with speed cameras and every light was red- do you go through them? If dad had gone unconscious in the car, do you stop and pull him out on the wet road to do CPR? Carry on to hospital?

I felt so helpless. You always think an ambulance is round the corner but what if it isn’t and you’re just an average joe with no medical knowledge?

Please please tell me, what would you do in that circumstance? I was not prepared.

OP posts:
AlternativePerspective · 28/12/2021 08:17

id rather have a reformed nhs along the french / german model even if it meant we payed into it more ,for a service thats fit for purpose the thing is that people don’t actually want a reformed nhs. They want the exact nhs that they already have. Where everything should be treated and paid for despite the fact the number of treatments available for various conditions is going up, thus meaning the amount of resource and money is going down.

Stop offering treatments like bloody IVF on the NHS, and free up some of that money to improve the emergency responses and treatments. Just to use one example. But everyone thinks their situation is unique and should be treated. Well perhaps sometimes the less life-threatening things shouldn’t be.

AlternativePerspective · 28/12/2021 08:13

I think some people are getting confused between a heart attack and cardiac arrest. A heart attack does not require CPR, CPR is only required if the person is in cardiac arrest and their heart has stopped. agree with this. Actually most heart attacks don’t result in cardiac arrest, although that doesn’t mean a heart attack isn’t an emergency obviously.

The truth is that even if an ambulance can arrive promptly, the chances of surviving a cardiac arrest outside of hospital are tiny, around 5%.

As for saying that it’s all the government’s fault, there is also some public culpability here on the part of the millions of time wasters who ring the emergency services every year for things which simply aren’t even worthy of going to hospital for at worst, or which the patient could drive themselves to a&e for at best. This is one of the reasons why 111 was established, in order to hopefully reduce some of the burden on the emergency services.

chaosrabbitland · 28/12/2021 08:10

@Pinkypenguin

11 years of underfunding, staff shortages caused by poor training policy, and Brexit have all been the government's deliberate choices.

Yes. But it's also the public's choices because they voted for Brexit and keep voting in this shitty Government because they don't seem to understand that cheaper taxes means less money for Government services.

Just start a thread about inheritance tax (my dad's worked hard all his life, blah, blah) or increasing the tax rate and the vast majority will say how unfair it is. I don't know how they think taxes can be raised. And the tax burden already (quite rightly) falls on the higher earners, but you can only squeeze them so far.

And as for Brexit, anyone who spent any time in hospital pre-Brexit would have come across the Greek newly qualified doctor or the Polish nurse etc. at least in London. How they thought Brexit wouldn't change things, I just don't know.

People just don't seem to see that their choices have consequences. Unfortunately those who keep voting for better public services also have to suffer the consequences of no ambulances.

agreed , id rather cut my thoat than vote conservative ,
PainterMummy · 28/12/2021 08:10

Oh OP what a traumatic experience for you.

My dad had a heart attack while helping a friend move things, which as over 80 he shouldn’t have been doing anyway but my DM used to volunteer him for all sorts of things. This was February 2019 so pre pandemic. He started with the pain in chest and arm, so went to sit down in his car. Thankfully the friend knew the signs and immediately drove him to the hospital. I don’t know why they didn’t call an ambulance or even if they did but the hospital was 15 minutes away and dad arrived there mid heart attack. Dad was not well for a long time. But he’s doing ok now.

We were told he was only alive for getting treatment quickly.

So I think I’d have gone to the hospital asap rather than wait up to two hours. I used to do a St Johns Ambulance first aid course regularly as I was first sided for work first over 25 years but your post has made me think I need to go again for refresher. These things have been on hold.

chaosrabbitland · 28/12/2021 08:08

im glad your dad is ok , i dont know what i would have done in that situation either , its just crap ,the old days of phoning an ambulance and it actually getting there in a few minutes are long gone , its just so unacceptable , but nothing we can do about it , in 2018 my mum had a bad fall on my garden path shes 84 , broke her collor bone , lying there in agony and it took a good hour before they got there , she was face down on the path , freezing cold , had to put 3 mink fleeces over her , and every time i rang back to see how much longer it was the same old stuff , ambulance was on the way , got divirted , i felt like screaming down the phone at the dispatcher even tho its nothing to do with them how long it takes ,

id rather have a reformed nhs along the french / german model even if it meant we payed into it more ,for a service thats fit for purpose

Pinkypenguin · 28/12/2021 08:06

*falls more heavily

Pinkypenguin · 28/12/2021 08:05

11 years of underfunding, staff shortages caused by poor training policy, and Brexit have all been the government's deliberate choices.

Yes. But it's also the public's choices because they voted for Brexit and keep voting in this shitty Government because they don't seem to understand that cheaper taxes means less money for Government services.

Just start a thread about inheritance tax (my dad's worked hard all his life, blah, blah) or increasing the tax rate and the vast majority will say how unfair it is. I don't know how they think taxes can be raised. And the tax burden already (quite rightly) falls on the higher earners, but you can only squeeze them so far.

And as for Brexit, anyone who spent any time in hospital pre-Brexit would have come across the Greek newly qualified doctor or the Polish nurse etc. at least in London. How they thought Brexit wouldn't change things, I just don't know.

People just don't seem to see that their choices have consequences. Unfortunately those who keep voting for better public services also have to suffer the consequences of no ambulances.

ivykaty44 · 28/12/2021 08:05

I hope your Dad is okay, OP - how traumatic and scary. I'm so sorry. flowers

I do wish that the posters on MN who think Covid is a conspiracy, and vaccines don't work, and we shouldn't ever have a lockdown to protect the NHS, could read this thread, though. Because it's always been about not allowing the NHS to become overwhelmed so that everyone can get the urgent care they need. Staffing and care in the NHS at the moment is on its knees with Covid, Brexit, and Tory cuts and austerity for the last ten years.

I hope the people who thought Brexit would be great for the NHS, and who voted Tory, could also read this and see what the real life repercussions of their political decisions are for real people.
This^^

rrhuth · 28/12/2021 08:03

@IDontKnow00

2 hour ambulance wait for a heart attack? That's unbelievable and terrifying. I'm so sorry this happened to you. Is this what it's like everywhere atm? Sad
It is like that in many places and in two weeks will be worse everywhere - but at least NYE parties can go ahead Hmm

OP - I really hope your dad will be OK, take very good care of yourself as you have had a scary experience and try to focus on how lucky it was that you had a car, weren't inebriated, the journey went well... Flowers

MrPickles73 · 28/12/2021 08:02

Where we are average wait time is currently 4 hrs. Hmm so I wouldn't hesitate to drive.

CheshireKitten123 · 28/12/2021 08:02

"I don't want a lockdown but we do need something to help this situation"

So what do you expect the government to do about it ?

Stormwhale · 28/12/2021 08:02

@Porcupineintherough

It was Christmas day. The roads were completely empty. He made the choice he needed to to save a life. There was no accident, so clearly I was talking about being prosecuted for speeding/running lights.

cupofdecaf · 28/12/2021 08:01

To use the public defibrillators you'll need the keypad code. 999 can give you that but I doubt they'd want you carrying it around just in case.
You can buy defibrillators to keep at home. If it's ongoing risk maybe something to think about.

whenwillthemadnessend · 28/12/2021 08:00

Awful Just awful hope your dad is getting better.

This govt is a joke. People can't get an ambulance for a heart track and we still
Have no social distancing in place

I don't want a lockdown but we do need something to help this situation

Not acceptable 😡😡😡

CheshireKitten123 · 28/12/2021 07:59

@SetFreeTheKites

Defibrillators in public places are in boxes locked with security codes. When somebody calls 999 and tells the call assessor that somebody is in cardiac arrest/they're unconscious with ineffective breathing, the call assessor will be able to see on their screen where the nearest public access defibrillator is and if there is one nearby and there is somebody able to go and collect it while somebody else is performing CPR, then the call assessor can provide the code to access the defib. They can't just be taken out by anybody.
This is why everyone needs to do a course in First Aid including use of a defibrillator.
SpiderinaWingMirror · 28/12/2021 07:59

Jesus. I despair.
What if you don't drive or have a car? What if you have a stroke and need an injection to save you from life long issues?

Porcupineintherough · 28/12/2021 07:58

@Stormwhale of course he would have been prosecuted if he had caused an accident. Do you really think that killing or injuring other people would be ok because you grandad was in trouble? Hell, it wouldnt even have helped your grandad if he'd hit another car on one of those junctions.

itsutterlyshit · 28/12/2021 07:57

It's horrendous. I know wait times vary but they seem to be ridiculously long and only getting longer all the time.

I know of a someone who called for an ambulance with chest pain and it took 12 hours for an ambulance to arrive. Sadly he had passed away prior to ambulance attending. He was on his own with no way of getting to hospital.

In your circumstances I'd have done the same as you and just risk assessed every red light on the way.

Glad to hear your dad is doing ok. Look after yourself, it's a shock to have to make these decisions while also being extremely worried about a loved one.

Recycledblonde · 28/12/2021 07:56

Covid really isn't the problem at the moment, call numbers have been going up year on year and together with wait times outside hospital escalating due to social care being in a complete state, there just aren't enough ambulances available and you can't magic one up.
Years of underfunding both the NHS and social care together with seriously bad management have led to this plus Tony Blair saying that anyone who wanted (not needed) and ambulance would get one.

We are going to start to get really tough and say to people who have non-lifethreatening illnesses or injuries and are mobile that they have to get themselves to hospital, it is the only way we can achieve the 18 minute response time for heart attacks etc and get out to the elderly folk stuck on the floor. Currently their wait time is up to 6 hours and can be even longer which is neither fair nor safe.

Kitkatchunkyplease · 28/12/2021 07:55

My friend did for on her husband as he lay lifeless on the floor and she was just on hold with 999. When she got through they just said, sorry, no ambulances. This was pre pandemic. It is not new.

My mum waited three hours for a an ambulance in August after collapsing at home. We were also put on hold. It was like a nightmare.

Stormwhale · 28/12/2021 07:48

We had the same situation but with a stroke. My brother ran every red light and sped the whole way. If he hadn't my grandad would be dead. He had fallen unconscious and was in a very bad way.

At the end of the day he was willing to risk the consequences to save his life. I dont think you would be prosecuted in those circumstances anyway.

daretodenim · 28/12/2021 07:48

OP I'm sorry, being unable to help someone close to us in a life or death situation is exactly the stuff of nightmares. Take it easy on yourself for the next few weeks. Don't bottle up what you're feeling - you will have a better chance at emotionally getting over this if you "let it out". Fresh air every day and early nights. Your nervous system has taken a beating and needs a chance to calm back down and our brains process this sort of thing when at rest and when asleep. Alcohol is ultimately not your friend right now - better to get a big hug from DH instead. Your DF had a heart attack but you (and DH to lesser extent) went through a traumatic experience. It doesn't mean you'll get PTSD (that's a month+ of symptoms), but does mean you need time to recover and to give yourself the best conditions for that. Of course you feel bad - what just happened was enormous.

My close friend's DM fell on the pavement and broke her hip when out shopping. She had to lie on a wet pavement for 6-7 hours before the ambulance could come. This was about 18 months ago. The government needs to stop having cheese and wine in their meetings and serve the country, first of all by fixing the state of the nation's health, which can never be optimum if people who have heart attacks can't get to hospital. I don't drive so my relatives are screwed.

Sofawithoutstuffing · 28/12/2021 07:47

@Littleoakhorn

I’ve seen a few comments on this thread saying how much faster/ better it would be in the US, but also how expensive to the patient.

This is just a gentle reminder: there’s more than two countries in the world with health systems. Your choices aren’t limited a chronically (criminally) underfunded NHS or wildly profiteering US system.

Agreed. I don't understand why any calls for change to the health system in either the USA or the UK seem to inevitably end up with, "well, we don't want to end up like them do we?" Followed by scary music.

There are alternatives to the current set up with the NHS, reform isn't necessarily a bad thing and in no way means we should trying to copy the US profit driven system. We never seem to have in-depth discussions about the French/Australian/Norwegian systems or any other alternative. Reform doesn't mean dismantaling the NHS, it does need improvements and there other methods which might work better in the 21st century which doesn't automatically equal using the US set up.

Countries With The Best Health Care Systems, 2021
Health Care in the U.S. Compared to Other High-Income Countries

There are more than 2 options for healthcare, it would perhaps be sensible to have a proper debate on it. I don't hold up much hope though. Far easier to point at the US and tell terrifying stories of people being left unable to even look at a hospital without handing over a massive golden ingot. Then people in the US can point back and go look, in the UK they're just left on hospital trollies for weeks before even getting sight of a doctor.

TheFairyCaravan · 28/12/2021 07:45

@Twatforaneighbour

OP Im sorry for what happened, that sounds like an awful situation to be in.

Why tho are people blaming the government? Surely hospitals cannot have unlimited resources to deal with emergencies and with covid adding so many extra numbers to the amount of ambulances called and staff getting sick, it means there will be even less resources available, yet the answer to reducing the amount of covid is a lockdown but people do not want to do this.
Yes a lockdown is a massive hit to the economy and is not something we want to do but if we want the NHS to be available for emergency situations, then this is an example of why we have be to do it?

I’m blaming the Govt because this isn’t due to Covid, it’s been going on for years. Ambulances are regularly stacked up outside A&E departments, for hours on end, waiting to offload patients because there’s nowhere in A&E to put them. All the cubicles are full, resus is full and corridors are full of patients on trolleys. It won’t change until people stop voting Conservative
takenforgrantednana · 28/12/2021 07:41

i can sort of relate to this, last sept i woke having a major asthma attack, tried all my normal things but nothing was working, i was going blue! shaking heart racing, husband checked my blood pressure and i was 200! phoned for an ambulance to b told it would be anything upto 4 hrs wait even though they agreed i needed to be in asap. i was one stage away from heart attack. hubby had to drive with me absolutely struggling for air and he even had to carry my into the hospital. he was terrified driving, but basically said sod the speed limit if he had got stopped that would have been better than the situation he was dealing with as they could have blue lighted me to the hospital which is what i really needed. ok clearly they sorted me out that time, but its only a matter of time before we go thr all that again

Swipe left for the next trending thread