Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It’s rude to ask why no present was bought?

133 replies

CescaCesca · 27/12/2021 23:30

My DF has texted me and my sibling asking why his partner didn’t receive a Christmas present. I genuinely don’t know how to reply because we do not have a very close relationship and unfortunately I didn’t even really think about it this year! We have never consistently bought for her (although always him). They have been together for 10+ yrs, and before I had kids I have occasionally bought something little for her, like a gift set.
I have a rocky relationship with my DF, there have been a few big tense conversations in the last couple of years and honestly he’s just a bit of a crap dad in general. He doesn’t make much of an effort to see or ask about my kids and as a family they are always doing things with her side of the family (holidays and meals out etc.) and don’t include us.
If we do ever go round to their house there is no trace of me or my sibling, but plenty of photos on the walls of her grown up children and their kids (so her grandchildren).
They did buy presents for my kids, me and DH so I do feel guilty now for not even thinking about it!

But aside from that even if I was upset I would never in a million yrs message someone and ask them why they didn’t buy a present!

OP posts:
ForagingForMullberries · 28/12/2021 04:23

When you call him, tell him how hurt you feel that there are no photos of you at his home, that you don't feel included.

You have, at least, a right to say that, given he is saying she is hurt.

JohnJacobJingle · 28/12/2021 03:46

I agree with him. If you buy for him you need to buy something for her.

Seems to me like she’s getting the brunt of things that you seem angry about. In terms of photos in the family home, it is your dads home as well, why hasn’t he put photos up? You are being unreasonable to blame her.

shewillhaveherway · 28/12/2021 03:14

If you genuinely feel there is no effort on her part then get them a joint present in the future - wine, a hamper, the nespresso Christmas collection etc - then she is acknowledged at least and it deals with hurt feelings.

But I agree she is likely the one who has been shopping for you and your children and husband and to her, and it is an attempt to show you that she does, at the very least, care that you are her partner’s daughter. (Even if you don’t have a close relationship personally). And I think it would be nice to reciprocate that effort.

How did you exchange presents with your father this year? Apologies if I missed have that detail. If you went around to their house and collected your gifts from them both and handed over the solitary gift to your father whilst she was there, I think that makes it a magnitude worse than if you saw your dad somewhere on his own prior to Christmas and handed it to him.

KimikosNightmare · 28/12/2021 03:08

@tcjotm

The expectations around presents astound me. My family don’t give or expect presents. If we see something we think someone would love we get it with no pressure and for no particular event.

I always thought we we weird and we are but omg does it appear it saves so much grief.

Sorry, not helpful at all but wanted to offer an alternative as stepping away from the obligation to buy and exchange gifts saves money, time, anxiety, guilt and huge amount of resources (where does it end up?). Of course if everyone did this the economy might collapse 😂😂

MN present giving protocols astound me too. I'm entirely with you on this.
AssemblySquare · 28/12/2021 02:58

YANBU OP. There are stepparents of 20+ years in DHs family and we have never acknowledged their birthdays or bought Christmas gifts. I think because they became stepparents when DH and BIL were young adults they have never seen them as part of the family! We never give it a moment’s thought.

LadyPerseverance · 28/12/2021 02:52

It’s definitely rude to ask this. But personally I would have bought them a joint present. It’s what I do for every couple I know except my own parents. That way no one gets offended and it’s easier on my finances.

Saoirse82 · 28/12/2021 02:47

@girlmom21

It's shitty of you not to get her anything and it's clearly upset one of them or he wouldn't ask.

Just be honest if you must but being a shit father isn't a justifiable reason to leave her out, as presumably you bought him a gift?

And them not having photos of you on the wall is a daft reason to be upset if you're a grown adult.

Don't be ridiculous, of course it's hurtful if there's photos on the wall of the wife's family but none of the OPs family and their children. It doesn't matter what age you are, that would be upsetting for most people. Your parent is conveying that you and your children are less than.

OP neither of them sound particularly nice. Don't get either of them next year. Job done Grin

Alondra · 28/12/2021 02:45

You know, your post has reminded me something that happened this morning in the supermarket.

I always go the same place locally and know quite few of the staff. As I was paying I asked the cashier (someone I always have a chat with) how was her Christmas. She delightedly told me she had been a grandma this morning. I asked if it was her first GC, she laughed and said "Heavens, no. It's my seventh". I was a bit surprised because she doesn't look older than late 40s, early 50s and said so. I asked her how many children she had and she said 3. She then told me her eldest just had the 2nd, her middle daugher had 1 and her youngest son had four, two with wife and two stepchildren.

I honestly thought of Mumsnet then. This woman so naturally said she had seven GK that if we hadn't had a chat I would never have known two of them were stepkids.

Most people are kind and inclusive human beings. Your father is simply an arsehole.

Cornflakes44 · 28/12/2021 02:39

Jokingly mention that if you did get engaged you’d want to have nice nails. He books you in for a manicure you know it’s coming.

Emerald5hamrock · 28/12/2021 02:38

It was thoughtless not have give her a small gift.

ChrimboGateauxCatto · 28/12/2021 02:35

Alternative point of view. I don't buy for my dad at all and he didn't get me anything for my 50th which I was a little upset about. I did used to send him a small chocolate gift for birthday and father's day prior to him being diagnosed diabetic.

Onthedunes · 28/12/2021 02:34

I think the circumstances of how her father and her stepmother got together may have some bearing on this situation.

Maybe op is trying to hurt her feelings.

I wonder why.

DickMabutt73962 · 28/12/2021 02:32

Joint gift to the both of them from now on.

Alondra · 28/12/2021 02:32

Look, if she has been nice to you, you need to separate issues when answering your father:

  1. Apologise for your oversight and give her a call directly to say so.
  1. Tell your father he's a crappy father and grandfather and unfortunately she's been collateral damage by his rejection of you.

Your feelings are valid, don't allow your father's lack of love to make you feel guilty. Be frank.

Cissyandflora · 28/12/2021 02:29

@Dillidalli

It’s really quite awful of you and she must be feeling very hurt. Crap excuse you’ve given too. What you did is far worse than him asking why there wasn’t a gift.
Agree with this exactly. You’ve hurt her feelings and you’ve been happy to take gifts that she has bought for your family. It’s shitty behaviour and you’ve been called out on it. Rightly so.
sweetbellyhigh · 28/12/2021 02:24

I suppose you could just tell him? Doesn't sound as though he is after an answer though. It's more like a reprimand.

Onthedunes · 28/12/2021 02:22

"With all my worldly goods, I thee endow""

This is what it's about and how things pan out in later years, especially if property is involved, although it seems almost crude to bring it up.

Being a wee bit older, I can't tell you the ammount of divorced families, where fathers leave behind children, it hurts them, I've seen the dance of trying to keep their fathers connected to them, when really most of the time they want to give it to them with both barrels.

The fathers hide behind the new family and really don't try themselves, expecting estranged children to do the running.

Years later with frayed relationships the dad dies, leaves everthing to the second wife and then her kids inherit the lot.

It's horrible for children of absent fathers, the constant tightroping of, do I bother with him or not, because all his effort seems to be going to his new family.

You have my sympathy op.

There is so much more to this post than 'just' a present but the new wife is too stupid to accept or understand and your dad is not facing up to the reality of the situation.

Communication is the key but too many men wish to sweep their responsibilities under the carpet.

It all becomes a bit fake.

caringcarer · 28/12/2021 01:58

You could just buy her a bottle of wine but you chose to snub her. Yet she gives gifts to your children.

NobodyChoosesToBeBorn · 28/12/2021 01:57

Sibling didn’t buy a gift either so maybe that just added to the wondering? Although personally I wouldn’t have asked.
Could you buy a nice picture frame putting a photo of the grandchildren and gift that? I am a “step” mum btw. The photos on the wall may well have been gifted. As for your Dad although he should be the one to think of your kids, well they don’t always “think”.

ShippingNews · 28/12/2021 01:52

I included the photo point to demonstrate how they exclude us a lot in general So why doesn't your Dad put up photos of you and your siblings ? Why is it her fault ? Sounds like you want to blame her because you didn't bother to get her anything .

BinChicken3 · 28/12/2021 01:51

Don’t put the no photo of you thing on her, just because she’s the woman. Your dad is perfectly capable of organising photos, don’t blame her for that.

You were being rude to exclude her. And I bet she did the organising of your gifts, not him.

SpilltheTea · 28/12/2021 01:48

He doesn't really bother with you or his grandchildren, but he's upset his partner didn't get a Christmas present? Pathetic.

Mummyoflittledragon · 28/12/2021 01:43

Why are you calling him to apologise? You should call her. Better still, send a small gift.

Mummyoflittledragon · 28/12/2021 01:41

@FortunesFave

My weird SIL never buys my kids a present. I always get her son one. I honestly can't think why she thinks it's acceptable.

I buy her son something for every birthday and every Christmas. What's going on in her mind?

You will never know. I think you should realise she isn’t in to present giving and consider stopping giving your nephew presents. Do they even get acknowledged? And why are you not asking yourself why your brother doesn’t buy anything for your child? Perhaps your sil doesn’t want to do wife work. If neither one of them puts anything into your child, they shouldn’t expect presents from you.
tcjotm · 28/12/2021 01:32

The expectations around presents astound me. My family don’t give or expect presents. If we see something we think someone would love we get it with no pressure and for no particular event.

I always thought we we weird and we are but omg does it appear it saves so much grief.

Sorry, not helpful at all but wanted to offer an alternative as stepping away from the obligation to buy and exchange gifts saves money, time, anxiety, guilt and huge amount of resources (where does it end up?). Of course if everyone did this the economy might collapse 😂😂

Swipe left for the next trending thread