Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to wonder why he is saying he does not remember me?

109 replies

Marble2021 · 27/12/2021 22:00

Last year, I was in a couple of classes with a guy from uni. Him and I worked together on a project for a couple of months in a team. I also chatted with him over whatsapp and in person quite often. I bumped into him a few weeks ago and I asked him how he was. He looked at me blankly. He really did not seem to even know who I was. I tried reminding him about when we worked together on that project, but he said I must have confused him with someone else. I have definitely not confused him with someone else. Anyone got a clue as to why he said he does not remember me?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Toomanypeople · 28/12/2021 11:06

Dh had this recently, a man came up in the shop said hello by name, asked about me and DC how was work etc. Dh chatted for about 10 minutes later told me he has no idea who the man was or how he might know him

RedElephants · 28/12/2021 10:30

Live in ....

RedElephants · 28/12/2021 10:29

Several years ago I was driving along our village high street , when I had to stop due to traffic coming the other way, when a man came over and tapped on the window, and started talking to me, it must have clicked after a moment or too that I had no idea who he was, as I was obviously looking rather blankly at him.
He turned round and actually said "you don't know me do you?"
I said "no, sorry"
"Well you look like her" he said, and walked off.

I work in a village not far from the village I work in.
A couple of weeks ago, a colleague came in to the room and started laughing, the conversation was pretty much this...
"I've just seen you walking your dog, I was waving at you, and you look at me as if I was quite mad"
"I don't have a dog now though, she died last year"
"I know" she replied "it just didn't click, she looked like you, same hair, dressed similar to you, and had a GSD just like yours, I couldn't believe it when you didn't acknowledge me, I thought it was a bit rude, It was only when I started thinking about t, Why would RedElephant be walking her dog in this village..? she doesn't live here.? Then it clicked" 🙄Grin
Cue me starting to laugh at/with herGrin

RandomLondoner · 28/12/2021 09:48

I don't think it's reasonable to speculate that he's pretending not to recognise her. Anyone doing something so odd would have had to have much more of a relationship than is involved in sharing a project. He definitely didn't recognise her, the only reasonable question is if that's because he's someone else, or his memory is bad.

OP has now clarified that he did not confirm he was on the same course/project has her, so despite her certainty, I think on balance of probability she was wrong about it being him.

Yuledo · 28/12/2021 09:47

@ScaredOfOverDiagnosis

00:14steff13 Where are you based? Never heard of Hulu but I'll try and source the film. I can't believe this was done as a social experiment! The example of the twins I gave, the separation was due to a divorce.
I’ve watched it in the uk. It is very sad.
hungrypanda2008 · 28/12/2021 09:43

Twins sometimes don’t say ‘oh it’s my twin’ as they don’t often get a good response and assume people who knew them well, would know. My elder brothers are identical. Many years ago one twin was out with his fiancée and was approached by an angry woman. She wanted to know why he had stood her up. He eventually worked out it must be his brother and told her he was an identical twin. This angered her more. Fiancée thought it was hilarious so didn’t do much to help the situation. It was pre mobile phones so he took the irate woman to the public phone and rang home so she could speak to the offending twin. He apologised for standing her up etc but the woman still didn’t believe it and said it was his mate lying for him. After saying in no uncertain terms what she thought of him, she walked off, even more irate he couldn’t admit it

dayswithaY · 28/12/2021 09:37

Is this still going? He's clearly not the man you think he is OP, you've made a mistake.

LostForIdeas · 28/12/2021 09:31

He didn’t want to speak to you. Whatever the reason.

Youdoyoutoday · 28/12/2021 09:28

Why does it bother you so much?
He doesn't remember or does and doesn't want to engage with you. Some people are just like that.

SpookyScarySkeletons · 28/12/2021 09:24

I like the twin theory.

One of my DCs best friends mum is a twin. I was so confused when I had to go pick DD up from school as she was unwell and there's her best friends mum working on reception!L I didn't realise she had got a new job! Started chatting to her like she was BFM... she was the twin.

watchingrnfire · 28/12/2021 09:17

I had a guy come up to me in the supermarket once and chatting to me like he knew me, I stared at him blankly, and said sorry am not sure who you are. To which he responded 'oh you don't want to talk to me out of the work place' I said u have the wrong person and walked off. He did not look like he believed me

Franklyfrost · 28/12/2021 09:14

I have face blindness and tend to either bluff it (always a bad idea but I panic) or explain. Maybe he panicked, denied knowing you and then couldn’t back out? It’s pretty embarrassing because the implication is you don’t care or are stupid. I can only recognise people I’m very familiar with, everyone else is just kinda the same, in the same way apples are all kinda the same and I wouldn’t notice if I was eating the exact same apple again and again.

Deeandwizzy · 28/12/2021 09:09

WhatsApp him and see what he says?

Volterra · 28/12/2021 09:08

I have a doppelgänger. A woman at the bus stop said ‘hi Susie’. I said hello but that I wasn’t Susie. She said I was and I said I wasn’t . Then she said ‘Susie it’s me, Pamela, I had Christmas dinner with you the other year’. I said no i’m sorry you didn’t, must be someone else.

She said ‘you live just up the hill on Bramble Drive ‘ which I do so I agreed I did but was not Susiie. Next she said ‘and you have a golden retriever ‘ which I agreed I did but was still not Susie. She kept going , next it was ‘your DD goes to Woodgreen School’ which indeed my DD did but I still wasn’t Susie. Eventually she gave up, I saw her at the bus stop a fair few times more and it became a joke that I wasn’t Susie.

My DH nearly went to someone at an event we were at before realising it wasn’t me, friends have complained I ignore them a couple of times. On a dog walk recently I got chatting to a woman who also has a retriever, she was saying she had spoken to me as I live close to her , her DD goes to same school as mine. Suddenly the penny dropped and I said I know this might sound weird but are you called Susie?!

Susie and I have a scary amount in common with our lives we discovered over a coffee!

Marble2021 · 28/12/2021 09:06

I said 'Hi (his name)!' . He turned around and looked at me. I started asking him how he was and how his summer was and he looked very confused. I said it's me Marble, and said we worked together on the project for the course last year. He replied that we didn't. I said that we did and tried to remind him about the project and he said I had confused him with someone else. Then he walked off.

OP posts:
Chocoqueen · 28/12/2021 08:55

Was he on his own or with friends/a woman? Perhaps (for some reason) acknowledging you would cause grief with them? For example if his girlfriend gets jealous she might not be happy with him having spent so much time with you or he'd told his friends he slept with you when you were working on the project and was worried you'd give him away.

ArblemarzipanTFruitcake · 28/12/2021 08:51

Unless the OP confirmed this man's name with him, I'm going with mistaken identity here.

DaisyNGO · 28/12/2021 08:44

Windy that is scary!

DaisyNGO · 28/12/2021 08:43

@Thatldo

Maybe you look totally different from what you looked liked at uni(weightgain/loss/hair.I have bumped into people from years ago and I havent recognosed them because of complete change in haircolour/style and weigjt gain.
OP said it was last year.

One thing that occurs to me, I'm sorry to mention it

But I have pretty much memory holed the lockdown period, I only really woke up about a month ago. Might be related to that, he just dragged himself through the days?

Bluntness100 · 28/12/2021 08:40

Actually if he doesn’t even remember the project op or the other guy it is more likely you got the wrong guy.

Postitmug · 28/12/2021 08:37

@Marble2021 did you use his name in the conversation? Do you remember his name? Does he have the same name as the man you remember? If not, you really could be the one who is mistaken

BigYellowHat · 28/12/2021 08:30

God that’s so unbelievably cringey when that happens. It’s only happened to me once and I wanted to shrivel up and die even though I 100% knew who the person was. I’ve had it done to me before and would never embarrass the person like that. One woman seemed to know me really well so I just made some bland chit chat for a few minutes and then apologised as I ‘had the dentist’

OmgIThinkILikeYou · 28/12/2021 07:56

I used to get mistaken for a lady I have never met when visiting dps home town all the time. I have never met her but have met a lot of people who do know her who insist I am her.

I had one encounter with a man I'm a pub which was quite intimidating. He kept looking at me, then started waving. I ignored him as I had never met this man in my life. He then looked pissed off and eventually came over and asked why I was ignoring him. It settled as soon as I started talking in my non-local accent and he realised his mistake.

Haus1234 · 28/12/2021 07:30

Sorry but maybe he just doesn’t like you, if you’re really sure he’s the guy you’re thinking of.

WindyRose · 28/12/2021 07:24

Oh, as a PP said, I do look very different from when I was at school, but then 50-60 years does that!!