Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nephew is dog phobic. Visiting dilemma

634 replies

DaughterOfEvening · 27/12/2021 21:50

I’ve kept this quite vague as my SIL is on here. DB has asked to come and visit us with their children, all three over 6. We don’t live close by, a few hours drive. We have room for them to stay. They have not yet visited our house as we moved during lockdown. Their eldest is 12 and has always been dog phobic (will scream, cry, run away)
Phone call today from DB asking for detailed layout of the house and where the dogs will be as “Billy” won’t be in the same room as a dog. We have two very lazy dogs who sleep for 20+ hours a day. The dogs are not barkers or jumpers.

I have reassured him that neither dog will be wandering around and that they will stay on their respective beds in one room downstairs. The dogs have never been upstairs. Ever.
Brother has said that it’s not enough, that’s it’s nothing personal. He’s just not willing to put Billy under any stress.
I’m not sure if he’s expecting me to shut the dogs outside but if he asked this then my polite response would be oh dear, you have long drive back then.
Should I be more accommodating?

OP posts:
Chasingaftermidnight · 28/12/2021 13:49

I think you were sufficiently accommodating. If the solution on offer wasn’t enough for Billy/his dad (which I think was the only reasonable one available to you) then they can’t visit. Which is obviously what they’ve decided.

YouokHun · 28/12/2021 13:48

@AsYouWishButtercup

I’m not sure if hypnotherapy works on children or is appropriate but it’s really helped me tackle my fear of heights. It’s very expansive though
It’s better to use an evidence-based approach like CBT for phobias. I feel for this boy as a phobia of dogs is truly life limiting given that dogs are everywhere. It must get in the way of staying with friends and even leaving the house and walking down the street. Phobias are some of the easiest (generally speaking) problems to tackle so I hope your DB and SiL are getting him support not just trying to clear away the object of fear for him which will keep the problem going/inflate it. Often I find it’s one of the parents who is frightened and has inadvertently schooled the child in the particular phobia. That’s often the reason why parents don’t seek help for their child’s phobia, because they are equally avoidant but can hide it behind trying to keep their children distress free.
Vivi0 · 28/12/2021 13:41

Put the dogs in a room and shut the door

The OP has offered to do this.

If that did not provide enough reassurance, consider having the dogs elsewhere when the family visit - not always possible I know hence why I am saying consider.

Kennelling dogs can be very distressing for them, so I can understand why the OP hasn’t offered to go down this route if it isn’t absolutely necessary for her to do so.

Leaving the dogs outside in the day if a warm and comfortable enough area can be provided for them.

It’s December, so this isn’t an option.

The OP’s home is clearly not suitable for Billy to visit, so best he not visit. Unless, of course, you have another solution that doesn’t involve shooting them?

ashorterday · 28/12/2021 13:40

Your BIL sounds like a loon. There's no way I'd be making special arrangements/locking my dogs up to have someone stay (I would make adjustments if they were barky/jumpy dogs) They need to address the issue of a 12 year old being terrified of dogs tbh.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 28/12/2021 13:38

@MyrtlethePurpleTurtle not read the ops posts then? No

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 28/12/2021 13:36

@AsYouWishButtercup

This won’t be a popular opinion but he’s you should be more accommodating. People, especially children, with phobias aren’t being awkward or difficult, and phobias can be physically debilitating. Even with sleepy dogs! Can’t you just shut them in your bedroom?
I agree - but this is Mumsnet
PersonaNonGarter · 28/12/2021 13:34

Well done, OP - you were a fair and reasonable in advance and totally sought a compromise.

Offmyfence · 28/12/2021 13:31

@BoredZelda if he can't afford a hotel then he doesn't come. You're just making it look luke the brother is the one being reasonable, he's more and the poll shows most people agree.

What do you expect the OP to do?

Anyway, he's not coming, so problem solved and the dogs can rest easy.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 28/12/2021 13:30

@Vivi0

Yes this would be one solution but if it were my family I would want to move heaven and earth to make it possible for the son to be visit - without shooting the dogs of course....

So, what is your solution?

Put the dogs in a room and shut the door. If that did not provide enough reassurance, consider having the dogs elsewhere when the family visit - not always possible I know hence why I am saying consider. Leaving the dogs outside in the day if a warm and comfortable enough area can be provided for them.

I don't mind dogs but I am allergic. My sister keeps hers in a different part of the house when I visit and we all wear multiple layers as I also need the windows open. It's not ideal but we make it work.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 28/12/2021 13:28

@Gardeningtipsneeded

I think it’s odd that you haven’t just offered to pop a baby gate across the entrance to the corridor to their part of the house if the baby gate worked well last time? I say this as a dog lover and owner, but that would seem to me to be a fair compromise for a child you love.
Yes I agree. Though perhaps the onus is on the brother to provide the stair gate rather than the OP.
godmum56 · 28/12/2021 13:27

@Gardeningtipsneeded

I think it’s odd that you haven’t just offered to pop a baby gate across the entrance to the corridor to their part of the house if the baby gate worked well last time? I say this as a dog lover and owner, but that would seem to me to be a fair compromise for a child you love.
I think its odd to have expended so much angst on someobody who just wants to come and nosey around the OP's new house, brother or not.
godmum56 · 28/12/2021 13:26

@FruitMelange

My kid hates dogs so we never go to anyone's houses with dogs. Simple

Same here. People get really offended though, if you don't like their dog. My cousin gets all sniffy and starts banging stuff around when I tell her no thanks, you come to us instead.

SOME people get really offended and they are probabaly asshats anyway and not just about their dogs. Please don't tar us all with the same brush.
Gardeningtipsneeded · 28/12/2021 13:20

I think it’s odd that you haven’t just offered to pop a baby gate across the entrance to the corridor to their part of the house if the baby gate worked well last time?
I say this as a dog lover and owner, but that would seem to me to be a fair compromise for a child you love.

Vivi0 · 28/12/2021 13:20

Yes this would be one solution but if it were my family I would want to move heaven and earth to make it possible for the son to be visit - without shooting the dogs of course....

So, what is your solution?

Coffeepot72 · 28/12/2021 13:18

I am not madly keen on dogs but would never expect a relative to shut them outside if I was visiting

WasScaredOfDogs · 28/12/2021 13:18

At our previous home the dogs were shut behind a babygate in a utility area when they visited. Many times I had found Billy standing next to the babygate watching the dogs asleep on their beds and found this strange. Make if this what you will.

That's a good thing - it shows that he's curious enough and wants to learn and understand how another creature behaves, but with the safety of the babygate stopping said creature from getting to him.

The same as watching the lions at the zoo from behind the safety glass - But you wouldn't feel comfortable standing in the enclosure with them.

Now, as per my previous posts, it's about gradually building on that interaction.

He's happy watching the dogs behind a screen... But terrified of being in the same room as an off-lead dog.

So the next middle-ground - Put the dog on a lead for a bit and encourage your DN to be in the same room. The dog is still moving around, but can't get at him because of the lead.

Gradually your DN will understand that he won't get eaten the moment he sets foot in the same room :)

Everydaydayisaschoolday · 28/12/2021 13:17

My daughter was terrified of dogs. We twice tried to visit family members with dogs. On each occasion they invited us and offered to ensure that she would never be in the same room as the dogs. On each occasion they stuck to that for a few hours and then tried to acclimatise her to them. On each occasion we left early and after that we declined future invitations to homes with dogs. I think your brother should not be visiting with this child.

Eventually DD had hypnotherapy which was very effective. She can now stay calm around them but she still isn't keen on them so she avoids houses with dogs.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 28/12/2021 13:15

The OP has said nothing about not closing doors.

Exactly and as this is such a relevant point, one wonders why the OP is not saying she will shut the door. Your point does not prove that the door will be shut so you can't really call everyone wrong for not agreeing with you.

*In that case, the only thing that will work will be shooting the dogs.

If keeping them away from the kid isn’t enough, what will be?*

Nope, shutting the door would work. No need to get dramatic about things.

*Your post doesn't even make any logical sense. If it was about 'graded exposure', then why is he so desperate to make sure Billy can't ever see the dogs?

It ever so clearly is NOT 'part of a graded exposure'. Graded exposure entails an hour or 2 maximum, not 24-48 hours. It entails actually seeing the dogs, not being unable to ever see the dogs.*

Graded exposure is done in various different ways. It should be set up in an indivdualised way so these rigid rules you suggest do not actually exist. Being in a house with something you are working towards being able to fully tolerate could easily be a step in this. #

*Well, the OP’s house is clearly unsuitable for Billy to visit.

Probably best for Billy that they don’t visit. Simple.*

Yes this would be one solution but if it were my family I would want to move heaven and earth to make it possible for the son to be visit - without shooting the dogs of course....

Caka2 · 28/12/2021 13:11

If it was my child I wouldn't even be considering the idea of staying over and would keep the visit short and preferably away from where the dogs are.
A phobia is something that would set the child on edge even being aware that the dogs are somewhere in the house.
Your brother should be aware of this and should make moves to help his child with his fear in a controlled and progressive way rather then avoiding dealing with it appropriately.
Turn the visit down based on his expectations- you will be doing the child a favour and tell him to rethink how it can be done. Booking a travelodge sounds good

ForagingForMullberries · 28/12/2021 13:10

@Whatiswrongwithmyknee

Such judgement on the brother here! He's damned if he does and damned if he doesn't. No-one knows whether he's tried to get help for his son and yet he's being called horrific names for not doing to. No-one knows if the visiting is actually part of a graded exposure which could have a positive effect if the dogs were reliably (and in Billy's head reliably) always in a different part of the house.
Your post doesn't even make any logical sense. If it was about 'graded exposure', then why is he so desperate to make sure Billy can't ever see the dogs?

It ever so clearly is NOT 'part of a graded exposure'. Graded exposure entails an hour or 2 maximum, not 24-48 hours. It entails actually seeing the dogs, not being unable to ever see the dogs.

The 'D'B is abusive, controlling and manipulative and neglecting his son. That's that.

applesandpears33 · 28/12/2021 13:09

It's interesting the nephew would go to watch the sleeping dogs. I wonder if he is ready to try and address his fear.

Buttercup54321 · 28/12/2021 13:08

Its the dogs home. They should book a travel lodge. 12 year old needs professional help with his issues. Family should not have allowed it to get this bad.

TrashyPanda · 28/12/2021 13:08

@Whatiswrongwithmyknee

Such judgement on the brother here! He's damned if he does and damned if he doesn't. No-one knows whether he's tried to get help for his son and yet he's being called horrific names for not doing to. No-one knows if the visiting is actually part of a graded exposure which could have a positive effect if the dogs were reliably (and in Billy's head reliably) always in a different part of the house.
He’s damned because isn’t doing a single, solitary thing.

And he is damned because he wants to bring his dog-phobic kid to a house with dogs, and putting them well away from the kid wasn’t enough.

And he’s damned because he likes bossing his sister.

Great that OP stood her ground.

Vivi0 · 28/12/2021 13:07

@Whatiswrongwithmyknee

The child doesn't even need to go near the room they are in.

But that's completely irrelevant. The point is that knowing the dog can leave the room is going to be frightening for Billy. As others have tried to point out, think of something you are terrified of and then imagine that it was in a room with free access to you if it wanted it. Would the host telling you that it won't leave the room feel like enough protection?

Well, the OP’s house is clearly unsuitable for Billy to visit.

Probably best for Billy that they don’t visit. Simple.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 28/12/2021 13:06

@Snugglepumpkin

I'm dog phobic. I cannot stand them & think dogs, dog people & their homes absolutely reek.

I don't visit or stay over at dog owners houses.
That's my choice.

It's not the dogs fault, or the dog owners fault that I won't be in the same building as one & much as I dislike them, it seems really unfair the dog should be turfed out of it's own home for someone else (unless it was a baby visiting because I think dogs are unsafe around very young children even if you never leave them alone in a room together).

The people? So you know someone owns a dog just by smelling them? Wow!
Swipe left for the next trending thread