Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nephew is dog phobic. Visiting dilemma

634 replies

DaughterOfEvening · 27/12/2021 21:50

I’ve kept this quite vague as my SIL is on here. DB has asked to come and visit us with their children, all three over 6. We don’t live close by, a few hours drive. We have room for them to stay. They have not yet visited our house as we moved during lockdown. Their eldest is 12 and has always been dog phobic (will scream, cry, run away)
Phone call today from DB asking for detailed layout of the house and where the dogs will be as “Billy” won’t be in the same room as a dog. We have two very lazy dogs who sleep for 20+ hours a day. The dogs are not barkers or jumpers.

I have reassured him that neither dog will be wandering around and that they will stay on their respective beds in one room downstairs. The dogs have never been upstairs. Ever.
Brother has said that it’s not enough, that’s it’s nothing personal. He’s just not willing to put Billy under any stress.
I’m not sure if he’s expecting me to shut the dogs outside but if he asked this then my polite response would be oh dear, you have long drive back then.
Should I be more accommodating?

OP posts:
ForagingForMullberries · 28/12/2021 17:46

@5zeds

If it’s only for a couple of hours a Dog Walker would solve the whole thing, but it seems OP has disengaged anyway so no need for any angst. I personally think having a kennels the dog now sand is comfortable in is part of very basic dog care. I also think accommodating people’s, but especially families and probably more so family children needs is the least I would attempt to do. I’m perfectly happy for others to feel and behave differently but a bit shocked at being told You're absolutely batshit , Then that is selfish and unreasonable , how dare you even suggest that? , How about we lock you in a kennel or lock you away? , What you are saying is absolutely horrible! . OP is asking if she should be more accommodating, I think she should (because that’s what I would do), you don’t do try not to make personal attacks just because someone trains their dogs and treats them and their family differently to you.
A boarding kennel is not something a dog should have to get used to.

What you are asking is batshit and it is very unreasonable. The OP has gone above and beyond, where as the brother has done NOTHING. The onus is on the BROTHER to do something, not the OP, and I'm shocked that you think the OP - in light of the abusive and bullying and gaslighting texts from him - should do even more when she has done far more than most people would do. It is NOT her problem to solve! She has more than done her part, suggesting she send the dogs away or lock them up somewhere is abusive and animal cruelty. What you are suggesting is horrid and not right. The brother at this point anyway, is proving the dogs were never an issue, and the OP was RIGHT in not agreeing to send the dogs away. That you dare say the OP should 'do more' when she has gone way above and beyond shows that you don't think the abusive brother should take any responsibility for his son at all whatsoever. The OP is a saint for doing as much as she did, and suffering the abuse from her brother who refuses to parent his child. The brother sure as shit doesn't care about 'accommodating people' or about families does he?

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 28/12/2021 17:34

[quote 5zeds]@AllThingsServeTheBeam yes I would (and have in a very similar situation not that that matters). We’re different people with different priorities, nobody is “wrong”.[/quote]
I'd have to say no even if you offered as it wouldn't be fair on my dog. And keeping the dogs in one part of the house is more than accomodating anyway

Offmyfence · 28/12/2021 17:33

@5zeds

I think she should put her dog in kennels, lock it away in a way that causes no angst, and talk to her brother. Perhaps it’s all bullshit an db just doesn’t want to come, perhaps there are bigger issues, perhaps db is the anxious one, who knows? I don’t think this is a big ask, though I have very disabled son so perhaps “scared of dogs” doesn’t really seem an insurmountable problem to me. I personally wouldn’t dream of never having my own nephew to my house because of this. He’s part of your family, and a person in his own right not a favour to your brother. Sad
Batshit!
5zeds · 28/12/2021 17:32

@AllThingsServeTheBeam yes I would (and have in a very similar situation not that that matters). We’re different people with different priorities, nobody is “wrong”.

godmum56 · 28/12/2021 17:30

@5zeds

If it’s only for a couple of hours a Dog Walker would solve the whole thing, but it seems OP has disengaged anyway so no need for any angst. I personally think having a kennels the dog now sand is comfortable in is part of very basic dog care. I also think accommodating people’s, but especially families and probably more so family children needs is the least I would attempt to do. I’m perfectly happy for others to feel and behave differently but a bit shocked at being told You're absolutely batshit , Then that is selfish and unreasonable , how dare you even suggest that? , How about we lock you in a kennel or lock you away? , What you are saying is absolutely horrible! . OP is asking if she should be more accommodating, I think she should (because that’s what I would do), you don’t do try not to make personal attacks just because someone trains their dogs and treats them and their family differently to you.
@5zedszed and isn't it a good job we aren't all the same? Because if we were all like you we'd all be wrong.
AllThingsServeTheBeam · 28/12/2021 17:24

@5zeds

If it’s only for a couple of hours a Dog Walker would solve the whole thing, but it seems OP has disengaged anyway so no need for any angst. I personally think having a kennels the dog now sand is comfortable in is part of very basic dog care. I also think accommodating people’s, but especially families and probably more so family children needs is the least I would attempt to do. I’m perfectly happy for others to feel and behave differently but a bit shocked at being told You're absolutely batshit , Then that is selfish and unreasonable , how dare you even suggest that? , How about we lock you in a kennel or lock you away? , What you are saying is absolutely horrible! . OP is asking if she should be more accommodating, I think she should (because that’s what I would do), you don’t do try not to make personal attacks just because someone trains their dogs and treats them and their family differently to you.
I stand by your suggestions being absolutely batshit. I see you haven't said you would pay for the kennels.
RedHelenB · 28/12/2021 17:19

@DaughterOfEvening

Sadly I think there is more going on in their lives than I know. DB has really gone off on one. I’ve been accused of lacking compassion and bullying! I’ve been bombarded with aggressive messages and I’ve now muted him.

Regarding the proxy behaviour, I know SIL is not particularly enamoured with dogs for cultural reasons but DB, like me, grew up with family dogs.

Billy hadn’t visited our (previous) home for a long time even without lockdowns but he was happy to FaceTime and always asked to see the dogs. I wouldn’t ever want to force meeting the dogs upon him or engineer some kind of intervention 🙄
The dogs would be in a different part of the house that he would have no need to enter but this was not reassurance enough for DB. I still don’t know what I could have done to make it safe for him, short of removing the dogs from the house.

In that case you are no longer being unreasonable.
DroopyClematis · 28/12/2021 17:15

You've said that, previously, Billy would stand at the stair gate watching the dogs.
You've also said that , culturally, your SIL doesn't regard dogs the same as you do.

There's clearly more at play here.

5zeds · 28/12/2021 17:15

If it’s only for a couple of hours a Dog Walker would solve the whole thing, but it seems OP has disengaged anyway so no need for any angst. I personally think having a kennels the dog now sand is comfortable in is part of very basic dog care. I also think accommodating people’s, but especially families and probably more so family children needs is the least I would attempt to do.

I’m perfectly happy for others to feel and behave differently but a bit shocked at being told You're absolutely batshit , Then that is selfish and unreasonable , how dare you even suggest that? , How about we lock you in a kennel or lock you away? , What you are saying is absolutely horrible! . OP is asking if she should be more accommodating, I think she should (because that’s what I would do), you don’t do try not to make personal attacks just because someone trains their dogs and treats them and their family differently to you.

RampantIvy · 28/12/2021 17:12

Erm. I'm not sure I wanted so much horrible information @godmum56, but thank you anyway.

I have just found this website that does a good explanation.

I wonder what these cultures make of our dog loving culture. I don't mind dogs, but I find the idea of having dogs on furniture and on the bed rather unsavoury.

godmum56 · 28/12/2021 17:06

@RampantIvy

I know SIL is not particularly enamoured with dogs for cultural reasons

I'm curious to know which culture dislikes dogs.

certain cultures in Spain and Europe regard dogs as tools for hunting and have no interest in treating them well. Google Galgo or Podenco abuse if you have a strong stomach. Some Muslim communities believe that dogs are unclean although recently there has started to be a change of heart over guide dogs for people who are blind. In Japan dogs are still bred and kept for fighting and in China they are eaten. Part of that is killing them slowly or beating them before death as its belived that it makes the meat more tender.
RampantIvy · 28/12/2021 17:04

Thank you @TractorAndHeadphones. Off to google (which I could have done in the first place Smile).

Maybe this is the real reason.

ChiefStockingStuffer · 28/12/2021 17:04

I suspect this is more about the SIL than her son who is perhaps trying to please his mother by not liking dogs either.

Not liking is not the same as fear.

1forAll74 · 28/12/2021 17:04

I would tell him not to visit, or to even ask about the layout of your home. It might have been a good chance, as you are a dog person, to carefully try and give the frightened 12 year old, a bit of therapy, and gently get him used to two calm dogs.. as this would be the way a so called dog expert,or therapist would deal with things.

TractorAndHeadphones · 28/12/2021 16:59

@RampantIvy

I know SIL is not particularly enamoured with dogs for cultural reasons

I'm curious to know which culture dislikes dogs.

Dogs are impure animals for Muslims
DogsandCatsB4u · 28/12/2021 16:54

And op your dogs live there if they don’t like it they don’t need to come to your home

RoseAndRose · 28/12/2021 16:53

Perhaps it’s all bullshit an db just doesn’t want to come,

Then why did he invite himself? Surely if he didn't want to come he wouid never have created the circumstances in the first place Xmas Confused

DogsandCatsB4u · 28/12/2021 16:53

My nephew is the same and my sister tries to discourage this. It’s really toxic to allow and entertain children to be scared of dogs, dogs are a part of this country.
They need to stop entertaining this screaming, jumping over dogs and tell him to stop being silly he’s 12 ffs

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 28/12/2021 16:51

@5zeds

I think she should put her dog in kennels, lock it away in a way that causes no angst, and talk to her brother. Perhaps it’s all bullshit an db just doesn’t want to come, perhaps there are bigger issues, perhaps db is the anxious one, who knows? I don’t think this is a big ask, though I have very disabled son so perhaps “scared of dogs” doesn’t really seem an insurmountable problem to me. I personally wouldn’t dream of never having my own nephew to my house because of this. He’s part of your family, and a person in his own right not a favour to your brother. Sad
So you'd choose to have a dog distressed? I'm also assuming you'd pay and organise the kennels?

You're absolutely batshit

Santahatesbraisedcabbage · 28/12/2021 16:50

At 2 yo my dd didn't like ddogs after a spaniel knocked her over in a play area of our local park. Got the usual he is just playing story. After dd managed to pull free of my hand one day to avoid a ddog I took drastic action.. We got a dpuppy. A Rottweiler dpuppy. Took a few weeks but dd loved her.. Your db has had 12 years to address his ds's phobia.... His problem. Not yours and actually not dn's either... Db is the parent. So parent. Mh needs helping too not just chicken pox and coughs..
Glad he isn't coming op.

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 28/12/2021 16:46

Phobias can be disabling - yes, absolutely if not treated, they can feel completely overwhelming and disabling and restrict life to great part.

or part of a disability Anxiety disorders are not a disability in the same way physical things are. Anxiety is a normal part of life, and anxiety disorders can be treated. There is no need for it to become restricting. But there are people who feel that they should never feel distressed, challenged or uncomfortable and these people can go on to feel permanently disabled by their anxiety. A parent would not be doing their child any favours if they enabled this.

DaughterOfEvening · 28/12/2021 16:37

@erinaceus

Your most recent post suggests that something other than Billy is behind your brother’s behaviour.

It is possible to that your relationship with Billy can unfold of its own accord in the future. I don’t think you should stage any sort of intervention!

You have misunderstood what I have said. I said that I would NOT want to stage an intervention.
OP posts:
PinkSparklyPussyCat · 28/12/2021 16:36

People with phobias don’t ask to see what they are phobic of!

I have a needle phobia and I have forced myself to look at the pictures in the press of people having their vaccines. It didn't help at all when I actually had mine and I've gone back to avoiding the pictures but I tried.

ForagingForMullberries · 28/12/2021 16:35

Tell him he's got a cheek since he 'invited himself' and you've bent over backwards to help, OP. Ask him flat out what more does he suggest you could possibly do, before you block him permanently. (muting is no good it just encourages him). I'd also tell him unless he apologises you refuse to have anything to do with him again.

Also, @DaughterOfEvening How far away does he live? Is it possible he could come for a few hours and not overnight? Although with the abusive (I was right all along, to that poster who rolled their eyes at me saying he was abusive), manipulative and gaslighting texts from him, I would be of the mind to block him permanently. I'd shoot him a text to 'step up and be a father and get your son some help' jibe before I blocked him.

erinaceus · 28/12/2021 16:34

Your most recent post suggests that something other than Billy is behind your brother’s behaviour.

It is possible to that your relationship with Billy can unfold of its own accord in the future. I don’t think you should stage any sort of intervention!