Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nephew is dog phobic. Visiting dilemma

634 replies

DaughterOfEvening · 27/12/2021 21:50

I’ve kept this quite vague as my SIL is on here. DB has asked to come and visit us with their children, all three over 6. We don’t live close by, a few hours drive. We have room for them to stay. They have not yet visited our house as we moved during lockdown. Their eldest is 12 and has always been dog phobic (will scream, cry, run away)
Phone call today from DB asking for detailed layout of the house and where the dogs will be as “Billy” won’t be in the same room as a dog. We have two very lazy dogs who sleep for 20+ hours a day. The dogs are not barkers or jumpers.

I have reassured him that neither dog will be wandering around and that they will stay on their respective beds in one room downstairs. The dogs have never been upstairs. Ever.
Brother has said that it’s not enough, that’s it’s nothing personal. He’s just not willing to put Billy under any stress.
I’m not sure if he’s expecting me to shut the dogs outside but if he asked this then my polite response would be oh dear, you have long drive back then.
Should I be more accommodating?

OP posts:
BoredZelda · 28/12/2021 11:51

It’s entirely understandable to keep dogs away from your own home if you have a dog phobic child.But to expect dogs to be kept away from your children when you are choosing to be in their space is completely unreasonable.

Thankfully my family don’t see it as unreasonable and work with us.

Dogs are a fact of life. I have a guide dog who is out and about and everywhere with me. In shops, on buses, walking down the street, and while he is of course under complete control at all times, a child who is phobic isn’t going to care about that.A dog is a dog, regardless of whether he’s on a lead or not. And a guide dog owner certainly can’t be expected to alter their life in case they come across a child with a dog phobia on the street or the local bus.

Guide dogs are absolutely fine. She understands they pose absolutely no risk to her at all and are working dogs.

PinkWaferBiscuit · 28/12/2021 11:50

@BoredZelda

So glad to see that the poll is so in favour of OP NBU!

“So glad to see people think dogs are more important than a child’s fear.”

That's a very simplistic way of looking at the situation.

Most of those posting absolutely do not think the dog is more important than the child. They do however comprehend that putting the child in this situation isn't fair on him or the dogs. No one wins or has a nice time apart from the selfish brother who gets to nosey round the house.

In this situation the OP is actually being much more considerate of her nephews phobia than his own father.

BoredZelda · 28/12/2021 11:48

The op isn't a twat. Her brother is the twat.

Yeah, how dare he be concerned about his son.

AlternativePerspective · 28/12/2021 11:47

So it’s logical and sensible that we as a family never visit my parents or my sister? yes. If your children are so dog phobic that they can’t be in the same house as a dog then going into that dog’s territory and expecting to be the one who is fully accommodated is unreasonable.
Parents who enable their children’s phobias are doing them no favours what so ever.

It’s entirely understandable to keep dogs away from your own home if you have a dog phobic child.But to expect dogs to be kept away from your children when you are choosing to be in their space is completely unreasonable.

Dogs are a fact of life. I have a guide dog who is out and about and everywhere with me. In shops, on buses, walking down the street, and while he is of course under complete control at all times, a child who is phobic isn’t going to care about that.A dog is a dog, regardless of whether he’s on a lead or not. And a guide dog owner certainly can’t be expected to alter their life in case they come across a child with a dog phobia on the street or the local bus.

If someone with a dog phobic child wants to visit my house they do so in the knowledge that the dogs (I have a retired GD as well,) will be there. At best I will put them on leads, but the build of my house is such that they can’t be shut away, you walk through the kitchen to get into the lounge, and the stairs are open plan out of the kitchen. And I’m fairly sure the organisation would have something to say if I shut my dogs outside for a couple of days.

I wouldn’t take my dogs to the house of someone who is dog phobic, but if they wanted to visit me then they know the deal.Their child’s phobia is thir responsibility, not mine.

BoredZelda · 28/12/2021 11:47

So glad to see that the poll is so in favour of OP NBU!

“So glad to see people think dogs are more important than a child’s fear.”

MzHz · 28/12/2021 11:46

Not docking… fucking floor plan :)

MzHz · 28/12/2021 11:45

@DaughterOfEvening send him the docking floor plan for when you bought the house and tell him to suck it up or make other plans.

You don’t get to invite yourself AND dictate everything

He’s a shit dad, and a piss poor brother

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 28/12/2021 11:42

@BoredZelda

Of course it's logical and sensible to not take someone with a phobia of dogs somewhere where there are dogs.

You realise that means never going anywhere at all? We already avoid parks, public transport and all those”dog friendly” hotels, restaurants, garden centres, attractions etc. People have been whining for 2 years about not being able to see family. We’re expected to do that forever?

No one's saying it's the child's fault, but the father seems more fixated on having a nosey round his sisters house than arranging a meet up where his son would be more comfortable.

Oh plenty of people think my daughter should just snap out of it. Or as parents we should just cure her fear as if it is that easy. My sister and parents live 200 miles away, we can’t just travel up there for an afternoon to have a dog less meet up somewhere for an hour. As I said, thankfully they aren’t twats and we work together to find a solution that suits all of us without having a moan about it on the internet.

The op isn't a twat. Her brother is the twat.
Howshouldibehave · 28/12/2021 11:42

He’s being unreasonable. He can’t decide to come to nose round your house but then control every part of the visit! I would reply to anything he says, ‘well what about this then?’with, ‘well, don’t come then if you don’t like it?!’

He could come to do a house survey on his own if he’s that bothered!

Offmyfence · 28/12/2021 11:40

@BoredZelda

Yes services are stretched but parents could help by gradual introduction to very safe dogs rather than go down the shut everything away route.

I don’t see why people are always convinced this needs to happen, but tried that. Doesn’t work. The only thing that happens is my child becomes ok with that particular dog.

So it does work to a certain extent? Can you not build on that? Maybe is worth the DB trying that with his own child. Then it's easy to visit.
Elphame · 28/12/2021 11:40

If your nephew is that bad then he needs a course of desensitising treatment. There are programs available and my older dog has often taken part as a registered therapy dog.

Dogs are everywhere. Such a severe phobia will impact his life badly and your brother is doing him no service.

TrashyPanda · 28/12/2021 11:40

But without closing the door. How is that safe? Also what type of dogs are they?

OP did not say the door would be open. You made that up.

She said Billy would be able to see the dogs if he deliberately went down the corridor.

That does not necessarily mean the door would be open. It could be the door is glass/has glass panes in it.

Offmyfence · 28/12/2021 11:39

Oh plenty of people think my daughter should just snap out of it. Or as parents we should just cure her fear as if it is that easy. My sister and parents live 200 miles away, we can’t just travel up there for an afternoon to have a dog less meet up somewhere for an hour. As I said, thankfully they aren’t twats and we work together to find a solution that suits all of us without having a moan about it on the internet.

Well done, shame DB is not as accommodating.

BoredZelda · 28/12/2021 11:39

Yes services are stretched but parents could help by gradual introduction to very safe dogs rather than go down the shut everything away route.

I don’t see why people are always convinced this needs to happen, but tried that. Doesn’t work. The only thing that happens is my child becomes ok with that particular dog.

BoredZelda · 28/12/2021 11:37

Of course it's logical and sensible to not take someone with a phobia of dogs somewhere where there are dogs.

You realise that means never going anywhere at all? We already avoid parks, public transport and all those”dog friendly” hotels, restaurants, garden centres, attractions etc. People have been whining for 2 years about not being able to see family. We’re expected to do that forever?

No one's saying it's the child's fault, but the father seems more fixated on having a nosey round his sisters house than arranging a meet up where his son would be more comfortable.

Oh plenty of people think my daughter should just snap out of it. Or as parents we should just cure her fear as if it is that easy. My sister and parents live 200 miles away, we can’t just travel up there for an afternoon to have a dog less meet up somewhere for an hour. As I said, thankfully they aren’t twats and we work together to find a solution that suits all of us without having a moan about it on the internet.

nanbread · 28/12/2021 11:36

Yes services are stretched but parents could help by gradual introduction to very safe dogs rather than go down the shut everything away route.

They do need to help him but going to stay somewhere where there are dogs would never be the first step, it's hardly gradual exposure is it.

Offmyfence · 28/12/2021 11:34

So glad to see that the poll is so in favour of OP NBU!

89%

BreakfastClub80 · 28/12/2021 11:32

Just a thought but could you use a stair gate to provide a barrier that is more comfortable than a closed door?

Personally I think I would try to facilitate the visit, and would limit my dogs to do so. We have cats and dogs and when other dogs visit, the cats will disappear for a while. It’s not something I want for them but occasionally it’s important for us to see other people who need to bring their dog so we live with it.

AliceA2021 · 28/12/2021 11:27

Some adults enable phobia's rather than try to help treat them. Let's face it Billy will not get better and when out in society will struggle everywhere until someone helps him deal with his phobia. Phobia's being unreasonable levels of fear of a thing.

Yes services are stretched but parents could help by gradual introduction to very safe dogs rather than go down the shut everything away route.

Offmyfence · 28/12/2021 11:26

[quote nanbread]@Offmyfence
*So you're choosing not to believe anything in the OPs posts?

And she's already covered the door situation, it will be open.

Do remember that the OP had not invited these guests, they've invited themselves.

So if they don't like the arrangement, the very simple answer is... don't come.

But OP is trying to accommodate them, which is very good of her.

You're not a dog lover , are you?*

On the contrary, I love (most) dogs, but there are a lot of dickhead dog owners.

The brother does seem to be acting in a very entitled way and should not have invited himself but having experienced the whole "my dog never jumps up at people and is never at fault" type of owner, many times, I wonder if the reason he is questioning her is because of this kind of past experience.

We all have our sets of beliefs about ourselves which may or may not be true in the eyes of others.

For the sake of her nephew, would it be so hard to shut a door or put a gate up. If that's not enough for the brother then he shouldn't come.[/quote]
Op has made clear her intentions, the onus is on her DB.

Maybe the OP has two mad red setters that jump everywhere, but her OP makes it clear they are dogs that are lazy and don't jump. Their is little point it trying to offer options to rectify the situation, if you don't believe the situation is true.

It doesn't sound to me like the dogs need to be shut in a room. It could also lead to the dogs barking, because the doors shut. Which I'm sure will further worry the nephew. DB seems to want the dogs put outside, in the wet, cold etc, this would certainly mean my dog would bark.

TheGoogleMum · 28/12/2021 11:25

Couldn't you just promise you'll keep the dogs out of the room your nephew is in? I think your brother is overreacting if that isn't enough

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 28/12/2021 11:22

@Flaxmeadow

Read the Opening Post - being safely out of the way in another room is exactly what OP was arranging.

But without closing the door. How is that safe? Also what type of dogs are they?

Are people saying they would feel comfortable staying over night in a house with your family with pit bull types, or other powerful dogs, in a room with an open door. Seriously?

Yes. Perfectly comfortable. I've owned my own bull breeds. I'd trust a bull breed not to bite me over a small dog 100 times over.
PinkWaferBiscuit · 28/12/2021 11:22

So it’s logical and sensible that we as a family never visit my parents or my sister?

Of course it's logical and sensible to not take someone with a phobia of dogs somewhere where there are dogs.

Thankfully they aren’t so up their own arses with their dogs and realise a little girl can’t help being afraid of dogs.

No one's saying it's the child's fault, but the father seems more fixated on having a nosey round his sisters house than arranging a meet up where his son would be more comfortable.

nanbread · 28/12/2021 11:21

@Offmyfence
*So you're choosing not to believe anything in the OPs posts?

And she's already covered the door situation, it will be open.

Do remember that the OP had not invited these guests, they've invited themselves.

So if they don't like the arrangement, the very simple answer is... don't come.

But OP is trying to accommodate them, which is very good of her.

You're not a dog lover , are you?*

On the contrary, I love (most) dogs, but there are a lot of dickhead dog owners.

The brother does seem to be acting in a very entitled way and should not have invited himself but having experienced the whole "my dog never jumps up at people and is never at fault" type of owner, many times, I wonder if the reason he is questioning her is because of this kind of past experience.

We all have our sets of beliefs about ourselves which may or may not be true in the eyes of others.

For the sake of her nephew, would it be so hard to shut a door or put a gate up. If that's not enough for the brother then he shouldn't come.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 28/12/2021 11:17

@Blackberrybunnet

How hard is it to shut your dogs in a room?
Not very which is what the op was planning to do.