Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Don’t buy clothes for people for Christmas!

65 replies

GaiusHelenMohiam · 27/12/2021 20:56

A relative of mine always does.

It’s mad. I wear two styles, smart office type wear, inoffensive tops and dark trousers; and basically pjs. If I’m going out I have plenty of dresses/jeans and nice top combos.

This year they have gifted us:

Me: a high necked puff sleeved smock. A care bear jumper. A Per Una top with random bottoms and frills.

17yo DD (ids as non binary, dresses like a 90s goth) a floral blouse, flared stone wash jeans, both too big.

DH (6 ft and 10stone) a pair of extra large pyjamas. She is married to his ID twin…

AIBU to think this is insane behaviour? She does have shopping issues. My presents were two bags full, the rest was dust gathering ornaments that she would love but I very much do not.

She’s known me for nearly two decades.

I’ve played this game for too long and this time I’m actually going to tell her it’s rubbish. It’s all going to the chazza.

In comparison we got them the things they asked for from their list. I used to hate lists but I’m starting to see their value. This year for eg my brother and I agreed to give each other ten million pounds and leave it at that 🤣. (The rest of my siblings and I literally swap money, it’s bonkers). I’d really rather not bother apart from kids.

OP posts:
Nightmanagerfan · 27/12/2021 23:01

YANBU. My MiL does this and takes the labels off everything so we are stuck with it (well, it goes to the chazza (love that word!)).

This year we got:
Jumper each for me and DH. Neither fit and are awful quality.
Christmas outfit for the baby that’s six months too big - won’t fit him this year or next.
Slippers for toddler that are so heavy (wtf?) that he won’t wear them.
Four pairs of Christmas pjs for toddler that are too small, and she knows he still wears zip up Wondersuits anyway.
Booties for the baby that are so tiny they don’t go on his feet.

Don’t get me started on the rest of the crap. I now have to bag it all up and take it to the charity shop, I wish DH could just tell her. In my family we would be honest!

pinkstripeycat · 27/12/2021 22:58

My sil spends £100s on her friends kids but nothing for mine so I don’t buy for hers either

FernieB · 27/12/2021 22:50

My DM has finally got the message about clothes but this year bought me an apron,oven gloves and pan scourers.

SheSaidHummingbird · 27/12/2021 22:48

Organise a get together and persuade all of your family to dress in the clothes that she gifted. All of you stand together as if posing for a twee famiyl photo, big scary smiles. The sight of you all - with DH in his XXXL PJs - may send a message that she doesnt quite get it right...

Getyourjinglebellsinarow · 27/12/2021 22:44

MIL bought DH 12 pairs of socks. For his birthday a month ago she bought him 6 pairs of socks. She always buys him at least 2 packs of socks every gifting occasion. He has 2 draws and 3 storage boxes of fucking socks. I specifically told her not to. I'm donating all but a handful when I've finished tidying Christmas presents up!

Aubriella · 27/12/2021 22:43

DH (6 ft and 10stone) a pair of extra large pyjamas. She is married to his ID twin…

Your relative is married to your DH’s twin? Is she your sister? Shock

SouthParkCovid · 27/12/2021 22:41

She also removes the tags so i can't exchange 🙄

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 27/12/2021 22:41

I think a blouse with random bottoms sounds like a lot of fun!

SouthParkCovid · 27/12/2021 22:40

Sounds familiar op 😂
My mum bought DD Christmas pjs, however it will be summertime by the time they fit her. Also bought xmas joggers and a random pj top with no bottoms. And yep, wrong sizes again 😂

Limeavocado · 27/12/2021 22:35

I’ve tried time and again to persuade my ILs to not do adults presents and just do kids presents or even none at all (it’s not like our kids or any of the others don’t have enough). They feel that would take the fun out of Xmas but the amount of c**p we’ve acquired this Xmas alone makes me feel a) guilty that people have spent their money on stuff none of us wants and b) depressed at the waste.

On the rare year where I’m asked what I’d like, I always suggest something like scented shower gel or consumables such as nice ground coffee, chocolates or spices. But it’s very seldom this ever happens!

My Sil in particular always gets my OH the most horrendous items of clothing which he just can’t wear out. She’s so lovely and always asks if he likes it or if he’d like her to send it back but he just doesn’t have the heart to say on the spot ‘oh sorry it’s not really my thing’ as he (and I) think she would be crushed. She has clearly bought the stuff online and she doesn’t have much money - she’s the one we always say to pre-Xmas ‘we have loads of stuff so please don’t spend money on us or if you do, make it a small token present like some chocolates’. Never works though and after over 20 years of this I despair about finding a better way forward…

WreathSupreme · 27/12/2021 21:47

I’ve never heard the word “chazza” before.

misses point of thread

mcmooberry · 27/12/2021 21:44

No YANBU its annoying when they don't fit/suit. My FIL bought PJs far too small for my DS and then a book for one of my DDs that we already had - it's an old David Walliams one so not hot off the press or anything. A waste of his money on both counts.

HopeYourHighHorseBucks · 27/12/2021 21:41

My close relative buys me clothes that are 3/4 sizes too big, they know my size but think I need to put on weight so their solution is to waste their money, every year.

esloquehay · 27/12/2021 21:40

I agree with a PP who said YABU for calling charity 'chazza'.

Eileen101 · 27/12/2021 21:35

Ysnbu. My mil buys me clothes but she's generally very good at it.

Reminds me of the time my boss called me over to his computer to ask me if his DD would like these pjs. No idea! I'd never even met her...

DeepaBeesKit · 27/12/2021 21:28

I can't even say what MiL got me, DH and the kids because it's too outing but yanbu.

With you in sympathy OP.

GaiusHelenMohiam · 27/12/2021 21:28

I do wish lists!

I just used to resent them because it became like a shopping list. Literally with Argos catalogue numbers.

This year (and for about the last ten) I’ve said please just get us experiences or promises. So my parents gave us vouchers for a local restaurant, my sisters and I went for an expensive meal and paid for each other 🤣 that kind of thing. I’ve stuck religiously to the lists as required. This particular relative has gone so off list it’s ridiculous. As every year.

OP posts:
KCee30 · 27/12/2021 21:26

Buying someone clothes is too risky imo. She's probably found it all in the sale and thought that will do.

Kite22 · 27/12/2021 21:24

I voted YABU, as I (and dh and my dc) have had some lovely clothes as present over the year.

However
The issue isn’t buying clothes for Christmas it’s giving gifts are shit because there’s no thought into them at all and what the person receiving them would like

I agree with this.
If you had asked about people buying presents that do no suit the person they are giving them to, then Y wouldn't B being U

On the other hand, the fact you have said you have resisted offering up a 'wish list' for people to get something from then loses my sympathy. If you've known them 20 years and always have presents you'll never use / don't like, then why on earth wouldn't you guide them towards something you'd like ? Confused

VaccineSticker · 27/12/2021 21:22

OP get an Amazon wishlist next year.
You won’t get unwanted gifts anymore.

GaiusHelenMohiam · 27/12/2021 21:22

@BitterTits

I have an aunt who used to do this. It was basically random unsuitable stuff she'd picked up in the sales. At 17 and a size 10-12 I was given a XL top. It would fit me now but at the time it was just offensive that because she and her side of the family were very thin, they saw me as extra large. Entirely preferable to receive nothing.
This is exactly it, I think she trawls the sales for anything in a size 10/12 and decides it’s my size so it will do. And I have no idea the logic behind the kids and dh wrong sizes. DH tends to be based around films he likes. DD stuff was just so off base though
OP posts:
Suzanne999 · 27/12/2021 21:17

I’m sorry but I had to laugh at the Care Bear jumper. Who knew such a thing existed?
Have also had the weird clothes presents—- a too small sweatshirt with all over print of various dogs…….. because I have a dog. From a lovely friend but I wish she wouldn’t.

BitterTits · 27/12/2021 21:16

I have an aunt who used to do this. It was basically random unsuitable stuff she'd picked up in the sales. At 17 and a size 10-12 I was given a XL top. It would fit me now but at the time it was just offensive that because she and her side of the family were very thin, they saw me as extra large. Entirely preferable to receive nothing.

HalloHello · 27/12/2021 21:12

My husband's Grannie does this for the kids. Random things she's seen on sales and outlets for my 2 kids in random sizes and normally don't match the seasons, and I have to store them for an unspecified amount of time. This year, she gave my 3 month old a winter coat in size 2-3. Fits my 3 year old daughter... So pointless and I'll put it in a safe place and forget all about it!

Bearnecessity · 27/12/2021 21:09

Buy clothes provide the gift receipt to exchange if required, I got a gorgeous jumper and shirt from my mum....couldn't be happier...

Swipe left for the next trending thread