Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worried about future generations…

92 replies

Nothingventurednothinggained · 27/12/2021 16:41

Scrolling through Instagram I always come across plenty of ‘influencers’. They don’t seem to do anything worthwhile. It’s just constant selfies, throwaway cheap clothes adverts, flaunting expensive designer clothes/trainers/handbags.
I am starting to get really worried about my childrens futures. So many young people now want to be ‘influencers’ and don’t have any real work ethic.
Obviously, I will be trying my damned hardest to ensure my kids do well at school and know that they will need to work hard to get nice things (if that’s what they want).
It seems a lot of young people think this influencer lifestyle is sustainable (maybe for some, but that will be a minority).
Does anyone else worry about this?

OP posts:
Nothingventurednothinggained · 28/12/2021 14:27

@StFrancisdeCompostela
I guess social media has made it look ‘easier’. Years ago you only read about it girls/socialites in magazines.

OP posts:
Nothingventurednothinggained · 28/12/2021 14:25

And you are deluded for thinking that influencing is a viable career option.

OP posts:
StFrancisdeCompostela · 28/12/2021 14:24

I honestly don’t think it’s anything new. There have always been celebrities, It Girls, groupies, pin ups, socialites etc, and the world has kept on turning with 99.9% of people settling down to sensible jobs. This is the latest iteration of an old phenomenon, not a completely new invention.

WindyState · 28/12/2021 14:22

Nope, won't "come of it".

Tomic especially has been very open about his lack of shits over his lack of effort.

Point is, if you think that there aren't plenty of journeyman sportspeople out there just simply earning a wage, you are deluded.

MaryAndGerryLivingInDerry · 28/12/2021 14:22

You’re not seeing all the other kids who are plugging away at their school work or university and part time jobs or volunteer work because that stuff doesn’t get followers on Instagram. But they exist. Universities are still able to pick and choose from the thousands that apply to get in, employers are still getting lots of applications of single posts.

Nothingventurednothinggained · 28/12/2021 14:17

Come off it. The names you have mentioned do very well in tennis. You can’t get into grand slams if you don’t put in the work.

OP posts:
WindyState · 28/12/2021 14:13

[quote Nothingventurednothinggained]@WindyState
Oh ok, tell that to the Olympic athletes who train 10 hours a day. Who live and breathe their sport.
Are you an influencer? Blush[/quote]
Yeah, because that's the only reason I could possibly have an opinion about it, if I was one myself. Hmm

Obviously I'm not discussing Olympic athletes. If nothing else because a lot of Olympic athletes actually don't make that much money from the sport alone. The sports which allow people to earn the really big bucks typically don't consider the Olympics to be the pinacle of the sport or don't even compete at the olympics at all - tennis/football/motorsport/NFL etc.

Bernard Tomic, Nick Kyrgios, Benoît Paire. 3 examples for you from just 1 sport of people who are more than happy to cruise along (and have openly said as such) earning a huge amount of money and putting in minimal effort. The premier league is full of players who consider it a job and are happy as journeymen, so is rugby, cricket, American football, baseball....

Nothingventurednothinggained · 28/12/2021 13:59

@WindyState
Oh ok, tell that to the Olympic athletes who train 10 hours a day. Who live and breathe their sport.
Are you an influencer? Blush

OP posts:
YouCantTourniquetTheTaint · 28/12/2021 13:53

I don't worry due to influencers, I worry due to the seemingly, if you're not far left and intolerant of other opinions, and also attach a tonne of labels to yourself, you're a horrible bigot. That seems to be the loudest issue for young people IMHO.

Young adults at University not allowing debates due to their beliefs, not liking being challenged. They're only happy in their little echo chambers.

In addition I worry about teens accessing porn, and believing that, it's what sex is like, they have access to some if the most extreme and violent porn and its at their fingertips. Young boys believing that degrading, spitting and strangling their partner is normal. Young women writing on Reddit et al, saying that their bf has done xyz and being told that they're a prude for not liking it. That is a worry. Young Lesbians writing that they're repulsed by penis, and being told they need to get over it.

I worry about social media in general, as it spreads false information like fire and people believe it, and when you challenge someone with facts, they call you a liar. I really do believe it's damaged the fabric of society in the Western world. There was a documentary on Netflix called The Network (I think) and it explains why.

So yes I worry about future generations but for different reasons.

WindyState · 28/12/2021 13:49

@Nothingventurednothinggained

Professional sportspeople have skills that they have perfected for years. They have a strong work ethic to be the best they can in their field. Sorry but pouting in the camera and doing some make up cannot compare.
If you think all professional sportspople have "a strong work ethic to be the best in the field" you don't know much about sports.

Plenty of professional sportspeople are in it for a fast buck and were just lucky to be blessed with natural talent.

WindyState · 28/12/2021 13:44

Looks like my original point a page back was right then. It's just down to jealousy and dislike of people earning a living in a way which doesn't fit with what you think is worthwhile, isn't it?

Footballers get paid millions to run around a bit and kick a ball. Influencers/youtubers get paid millions to advertise products. If you reduce it down like that of course it sounds easy - so why aren't all the people disparaging them off doing it then?

I'n not encouraging my children to become influencers but I wouldn't discourage them if it gave them a good income and - far more imporantly - they enjoyed it because....I'm not a judgemental dick.

purpleboxes · 28/12/2021 13:29

@WindyState

"When you stop influencing people or lose your looks - its over. It has a very short life time."

How is this different to say acting or sport as a career? Most professional sportspeople are retired by 30-35. Do you think we should discourage our children from that too?

The achievements that professional athletes gain during their career are not comparable to some declaring on instagram that a certain candle is amazing or a new make up item is just fantastic. Also most professional athletes go on to coaching. A record breaking olympian medalist is not the same as some Love Island contestant selling lip gloss.

Older actors are still needed. I know an actress thats been on a few programs - my dds friend, her parents spent a fortune on acting classes/school/agents/travelling to auditions. This was time invested in a career for her.

If you are encouraging your children to be influencers then I feel sorry for them that you have so little confidence in their abilities and what they are capable off.

Nothingventurednothinggained · 28/12/2021 13:27

Professional sportspeople have skills that they have perfected for years. They have a strong work ethic to be the best they can in their field.
Sorry but pouting in the camera and doing some make up cannot compare.

OP posts:
WindyState · 28/12/2021 12:47

Why not?

Both are earning money in a way many would consider pointless and they both have potentially short career spans, meaning you either have to earn enough during that short career to live off for the rest of your life or transition into another job in your mid 30s.

Nothingventurednothinggained · 28/12/2021 12:40

I don’t think you can compare influencers to professional sportspeople.

OP posts:
WindyState · 28/12/2021 12:26

"When you stop influencing people or lose your looks - its over. It has a very short life time."

How is this different to say acting or sport as a career? Most professional sportspeople are retired by 30-35. Do you think we should discourage our children from that too?

JohnHuffam1812 · 28/12/2021 12:26

I think people always worry about the younger generation. There is a great quote supposedly by Socrates on it.

Most kids work hard at school, harder than most people of my generation did, they take uni seriously and study hard. Mostly.

I think basing a judgement on what you see on social media is naive.

purpleboxes · 28/12/2021 12:24

@Dinkydonky

Why is being an influencer “not a career” but working for a big corporation in the advertising department is? I don’t like influencing in general, but as a career path I don’t think it’s any more or less real than anything else. Any kid who thinks it’s all fun and glam would soon realise it’s not.

And to the pp who asked about encouraging kids to work hard and gain qualifications… personally I think it’s far better to focus on becoming skilled (which may or may not involve any qualifications). If you focus on working hard you will have to grind all your life. Become skilled and hard to replace and it’s much easier to have choices over how hard you work

Being an influencer counts on how many people you can influence and this is mainly around how you look. When you stop influencing people or lose your looks - its over. It has a very short life time.

Its not a career. Its a short term quick fix for cash and adoration.

WindyState · 28/12/2021 12:23

I'm no fan of influencers but the fact is people can and do make a shitload of money out of it. Others don't, but that is the same of just about any other profession.

Can't help but think most of the jugmental attitudes towards influencers/youtubers etc is born of jealously based on an (usually) incorrect assumption that it's easy money.

Dinkydonky · 28/12/2021 12:11

Why is being an influencer “not a career” but working for a big corporation in the advertising department is?
I don’t like influencing in general, but as a career path I don’t think it’s any more or less real than anything else. Any kid who thinks it’s all fun and glam would soon realise it’s not.

And to the pp who asked about encouraging kids to work hard and gain qualifications… personally I think it’s far better to focus on becoming skilled (which may or may not involve any qualifications). If you focus on working hard you will have to grind all your life. Become skilled and hard to replace and it’s much easier to have choices over how hard you work

purpleboxes · 28/12/2021 12:00

I do OP, I think smart phones have caused a lot of damage - especially in sexualised our young kids.

Children with access to hard core porn on their phones making 15 year old boys and girls have a very skewed idea of sex is and what is considered normal

Instagram full of people with heavily filtered photos causing young people to think they should be looking like people that dont actually exist.

Tictok is awful and causes teenagers to become brain dead morons.

I watched a facebook whistle blower in the senate before xmas and she was saying since facebook started Suicidal thoughts in children above 13 have gone up 300%

YungWaffle · 28/12/2021 11:50

Influencer's are no different to the famous people of the past. People have always had those dreams.
I think if you're of a certain age, it's quite easy to miss. I was pretty shocked when I first realised just how famous an influencer that I'd never even heard of could be.
A few weeks ago, I was attending an event at a large exhibition centre. There was a huge line of women in athleisure gear. A bit of googling revealed that a fitness influencer that I'd never heard of had a couple of hundred women paying something in the region of £70 for a group workout and a q&a session.
It's actually a better situation than the past. People can make an exceptional living without the sort of fame that means they can't go out in public. And it is much more "democratic" in that it's open to pretty much any demographic and they keep more of the profit they produce.
I don't think page 3 of The Sun created any millionaires, but OnlyFans certainly has.
It's just not what you're used to.

Magnited · 28/12/2021 11:41

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

YANBU to worry I suppose but YABVU if you are telling them "they will need to work hard to get nice things".

If that was true my postwoman would be driving a fancy car.

A postwoman's job is not really a difficult one though is it?
crazyjinglist · 28/12/2021 11:07

I think the take home point for me is - stay off social media!

Maybe. But I think the problem lies in how human nature makes people use social media, not the social media itself. I use Facebook, Instagram, Whatsapp and MN. Yes, I periodically get into the habit of spending too much time on them. But what I use them for is totally unproblematic. They haven't magically turned me into a shallow, attention-seeking fantasist Grin or inspired me to want to be an influencer!

DickMabutt73962 · 27/12/2021 17:39

@Comedycook

I wanted to be one of the women who held up the prizes on gameshows...sadly it wasn't to be Grin
Same 😂 my cousin and I used to pretended to be Vanna White from the American Wheel of Fortunes
Swipe left for the next trending thread