Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I not have done this?

138 replies

ThymeTravel · 27/12/2021 14:37

Partner and I were having an argument whilst I was cleaning out the bedroom.

Things started to get very heated and I could tell nothing was going to get resolved when we were both pissed off. So, I told DP to leave the room several times and said that we'll talk when we're both calmer. DP refused every time I told him to go downstairs. I eventually told DP that I was very close to losing my temper, and that he needed to leave before I screamed. Again, he refused and stood in the doorway. I then just slammed the door over.

He punched the door and yelled at me that I almost broke his fingers. I said I was sorry and that I genuinely didn't know his fingers were in the door.

I know that people will say that I should have walked away to another room, but I know he would have followed me and things would have escalated. He has form for doing this when we argue, I'll ask him to leave the situation and he'll refuse, or I'll try to leave, and he'll follow me.

OP posts:
Helpstopthepain · 27/12/2021 17:00

You are basically saying, ‘Obey me or I can’t be held responsible for my reaction’.

You are threatening him.

GatoradeMeBitch · 27/12/2021 16:59

I feel that if someone is heated and needs time alone to cool down, the onus is on them to leave. You can not and should not try to make someone leave a room in their own house. Mind you, if he's deliberately following you and antagonizing you he's a knobhead.

Next time just get your keys and go for a walk or drive. And think about whether your relationship is worth continuing with.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 27/12/2021 16:57

@mamaweebeastie

My ex did this. He would refuse to leave me or the room and if I did he'd follow to ensure the argument continued & got worse to the point of getting physical. After 8 years, one argument got physical within 10min of starting- the police removed him 30min later & he's never been back in my house again.

He WILL get worse, get out NOW!

Sounds like OP is the one who escalated to physical behavior
Beautiful3 · 27/12/2021 16:55

You both sound awful. You don't slam a door over and over again. You remove yourself from the situation.

Itsmybaby · 27/12/2021 16:51

Both sound as awful as each other

Herewegoagain84 · 27/12/2021 16:50

You definitely can’t expect him to obey your wishes, especially if you’re in the middle of an argument when he is very unlikely to do so. If you wanted space to calm down, you leave the situation. Leave the house, go for a walk, shut yourself in the loo, whatever works. Though If you’re worried he’ll follow you / not respect your space, you’re in a bad relationship.

KurtWildesChristmasNamechange · 27/12/2021 16:44

@mamaweebeastie

My ex did this. He would refuse to leave me or the room and if I did he'd follow to ensure the argument continued & got worse to the point of getting physical. After 8 years, one argument got physical within 10min of starting- the police removed him 30min later & he's never been back in my house again.

He WILL get worse, get out NOW!

Are we reading the same post? It was OP who got physical when she slammed a door on his hand.
Bagamoyo1 · 27/12/2021 16:44

@mamaweebeastie

My ex did this. He would refuse to leave me or the room and if I did he'd follow to ensure the argument continued & got worse to the point of getting physical. After 8 years, one argument got physical within 10min of starting- the police removed him 30min later & he's never been back in my house again.

He WILL get worse, get out NOW!

It was OP who got physical, not her partner.
Ofnoteandnightmares · 27/12/2021 16:44

I think people are being a little (a lot) unfair here.

It's not a healthy situation for either of you regardless, but you asked him to leave several times as it became more and more tense, warned him that your temper was rising and that you'd prefer to speak when you both were calmer - you did the right thing here. By physically pushing past him you may have only made the situation worse. He did not take the opportunity to de-escalate, and it sounds like you struggled to do so too, probably because of the lack of space to let the adrenalin pass through you. Catching his fingers sounds like an accident, slamming the door an expression of frustration.

However, an argument that gets to that stage is not healthy or a positive way to resolve conflict for either of you - so maybe focus more on what caused such heat in the argument rather than just the outcome.

Bagamoyo1 · 27/12/2021 16:43

You were in the wrong OP.
Imagine a man telling a woman that if she didn’t leave the (equally owned) room, he was going to lose his temper, and then slamming a door in her face when she didn’t leave?
Every single reply would include “LTB” and “call women’s aid”.
You need to apologise.

mamaweebeastie · 27/12/2021 16:43

My ex did this. He would refuse to leave me or the room and if I did he'd follow to ensure the argument continued & got worse to the point of getting physical. After 8 years, one argument got physical within 10min of starting- the police removed him 30min later & he's never been back in my house again.

He WILL get worse, get out NOW!

oftenbaffled · 27/12/2021 16:42

Any children in this horrible environment?

RedskyThisNight · 27/12/2021 16:40

Flip this round. A man tells his wife several times she has to go out of the room and then that it will be her fault if he loses his temper. He then does something that results in her being hurt and claims that he didn't have an alternative.

Wonder how many LTBs there would be by now?

PineappleTart · 27/12/2021 16:39

OP can you really not see how you would be in the wrong here? Reverse the situation for a minute and try again.

There are many ways you would have removed yourself from the argument to cool down even just to go into the bathroom to cool down. This level of rage is very unhealthy

Ponoka7 · 27/12/2021 16:36

I think that it also depends on who started the argument and what it was about. I know someone who will pick away at people and when it blows up demands space. It looks like she's being reasonable, when she just wants to be in total control and get away with her behaviour.

KurtWildesChristmasNamechange · 27/12/2021 16:35

@R0tational

I imagined a scenario where the OP was asking the DP to leave and he refused to back down and she was at the end of her tether. Sorry used word gaslight.
But that's not gaslighting. Perhaps don't use a word when you don't know what it means.
beastlyslumber · 27/12/2021 16:35

I don't get how you can slam the door on his hand and not break his fingers. That would be unbelievably painful.

You shouldn't have done that. He shouldn't have punched the door. You shouldn't be screaming at each other. He shouldn't be following you about the house. You shouldn't be ordering him out of rooms. (The bathroom would be an exception - a good place to go if you need to calm down.)

What's your relationship like generally?

Heronwatcher · 27/12/2021 16:34

TBH I just pray that you don’t have kids, it sounds awful. If this is anything other than a one off you seriously need to think about separating. If it was a one off then yes I agree with the others up thread that you need outside help to make sure it doesn’t happen again, it sounds like you were lucky not to break his fingers.

KurtWildesChristmasNamechange · 27/12/2021 16:33

@BoredZelda

Could you not have gone out for a walk or something until you calmed down?

Wait, she asked him several times to leave and because he wouldn’t, it’s her fault?

How does that work?

Because you don't get to order someone out of their own home or tell them you're going to 'lose your temper' like they're some naughty child. If you want space to calm down you remove yourself from the situation.
Misty84 · 27/12/2021 16:31

Doesn’t sound like a good relationship OP if you often argue like that😕
I’d try and address how you can both communicate better.

Vallmo47 · 27/12/2021 16:31

You are both in the wrong and I think you know it, based on your thread title alone. Sounds like you’re in a really dark place and you are bringing out the worst in each other. I really hope there are no children involved in this.

icedcoffees · 27/12/2021 16:27

@BoredZelda

Could you not have gone out for a walk or something until you calmed down?

Wait, she asked him several times to leave and because he wouldn’t, it’s her fault?

How does that work?

Because you don't get to order a grown adult out of their own home.

If you want space, you should be the one to leave the room, or the house if necessary.

CustardySergeant · 27/12/2021 16:24

@BoredZelda

Could you not have gone out for a walk or something until you calmed down?

Wait, she asked him several times to leave and because he wouldn’t, it’s her fault?

How does that work?

She didn't ask him, she told him. No adult is likely to meekly obey an order. It just inflamed the situation that she kept telling him what to do, instead of asking. It makes a lot of difference how something is expressed.
girlmom21 · 27/12/2021 16:23

@BoredZelda

Could you not have gone out for a walk or something until you calmed down?

Wait, she asked him several times to leave and because he wouldn’t, it’s her fault?

How does that work?

Her reaction to him not leaving was to tell him she was going to lose her temper and slam the door in his face.

He wouldn't leave so she could have attempted to remove herself from the situation (although, granted, based on previous arguments this might not have been possible).

She's equally responsible here.

Wombat69 · 27/12/2021 16:21

I lost a digit doing that, not recommended.