Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unanswered MN questions

122 replies

WomanStanleyWoman · 27/12/2021 12:57

There are certain threads that come up on MN again and again, year after year - and for me, they throw up obvious questions. Yet on more than one thread, I’ve asked these questions, but no one ever seems to answer. Am I missing something - or is it that the answer would contradict the OP’s key argument?

A couple of examples that spring to mind:

‘What is it with people who won’t answer the door? What if a lovely relative had sent you a surprise and you missed the delivery? What if one of your neighbours had lost their cat and needed to check your garden? What if someone was desperate for help and you just ignored them?!?’

The question I always ask is ‘What do these people do if you’re out?’ Presumably even people who happily answer the door to anyone at any time of day have to go out to work, to the shops, to visit family etc. What do these people desperate to see you do then? Surely the delivery driver puts a card through the door; the neighbour with the cat leaves you a note; the person in desperate need of help tries the next house. If all of these are perfectly workable solutions for when someone is out, why can’t they work if someone just doesn’t feel like answering the door? But no matter how many people I’ve asked, never a reply.

Another one that I’ve seen come up a few times is whether it’s okay to let children/teens leave the crusts off a sandwich. Whenever I see this topic comes up, a few posters will always claim that said teens will be starving and reaching for chocolate later because they didn’t eat enough calories at lunch, because they were ‘fussy’.

I’ve pointed out on more than one of these threads that a slice of bread averages at around 105 calories; therefore there can’t be more than 10 - 15 calories in the crust. I’ve asked the calorie counters if they really believe that a maximum of 30 calories could really make the difference between being full until dinner and a junk food binge mid-afternoon - but again, not a reply.

What are your unanswered questions? Also, feel free to answer either of mine if you can! Grin

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 29/12/2021 10:47

I'd like to know how MNers acquire ESP as I've been here almost 20 years and mine still hasn't arrived.

I've mentioned that I get Botox, minimum dose once a year or so. I'm always immediately told that I look like a spoon with hair, that EVERYONE can tell, that I'm completely frozen, that I look dreadful and hideous and that I'm a terrible human being.

Most people have to at least see me once to know all that...

Vanuatu · 29/12/2021 10:46

I don't answer the door ever unless I am expecting a delivery, simply because I don't want to 😁

MrsTophamHat · 29/12/2021 10:44

I’m also always amazed by the number of people who expect others to plan for a life they don’t have - i.e. ‘Oh, it’s all very well not being able to drive if you live in London, but what would you do if you lived in a tiny rural village or a little market town? It’s so limiting!’ Why, given I can’t drive, would I move somewhere like that? Didn’t it occur to them that I might have factored it into my choice of location?

You've not convinced me with this answer! The main reason being that I can only assume that many people who live in London really don't realise the lack of public transport even in other cities. You don't have to move to a remote, rural location to find yourself without decent public transport in this country. I live in a city and I can't use public transport to get to my workplace, my daughter's nursery or my in-laws'.

At the age of 17, when most people learn to drive, you don't know what your future holds and where you might end up living. It would seem like a sensible skill to 'bag' when there's no pressure, as learning when you're older is harder.

DrSbaitso · 29/12/2021 10:40

You make it sound like you can't get over how awful it would be for not answering the door, but you don't seem to feel bad that your neighbour had been lying there for 2 days already?!

How was she supposed to know that? Do you speak to your neighbours every day?

MagpiePi · 29/12/2021 10:31

@JurgensCakeBabyJesus

I always think the people who don't answer the door just have difficulty being assertive, I open the door because I'm very nosey and can't stand not knowing who knocked. If it's someone I don't wish to engage with (we have local JWs), I just tell them I'm busy/not interested/have no intention of ever voting for their political party (and why), but some people find that awkward/uncomfortable so it's easier to avoid the situation. I had an unexpected knock last year, it was the fire brigade asking if there was a way to gain access to my neighbour's via our garden as her family were worried she couldn't be contacted and the front door is like fort Knox, turned out she'd had a fall and had been lying there for two days. If I hadn't been there they would've had to find another way, but I was and would've felt awful if I'd ignored the door and she'd been left there even longer.
You make it sound like you can't get over how awful it would be for not answering the door, but you don't seem to feel bad that your neighbour had been lying there for 2 days already?!
MagpiePi · 29/12/2021 10:28

If people have irritating neighbours, there is always a suggestion that the OP should 'just move'. As though packing up and selling your house and finding, buying and moving into another house can be easily accomplished in a few days or something.

JurgensCakeBabyJesus · 29/12/2021 10:24

I always think the people who don't answer the door just have difficulty being assertive, I open the door because I'm very nosey and can't stand not knowing who knocked. If it's someone I don't wish to engage with (we have local JWs), I just tell them I'm busy/not interested/have no intention of ever voting for their political party (and why), but some people find that awkward/uncomfortable so it's easier to avoid the situation.
I had an unexpected knock last year, it was the fire brigade asking if there was a way to gain access to my neighbour's via our garden as her family were worried she couldn't be contacted and the front door is like fort Knox, turned out she'd had a fall and had been lying there for two days. If I hadn't been there they would've had to find another way, but I was and would've felt awful if I'd ignored the door and she'd been left there even longer.

PAFMO · 29/12/2021 10:13

The door thing is bonkers.
I didn't think I knew anyone irl who did it until I was in a postal secret Santa with some old friends and I got a "D hasn't received her present, did you send it to the right address?" message.
Transpires D doesn't accept packages ADDRESSED TO HERSELF AT HER ADDRESS yet wants to participate in a fucking postal SS. Hmm

PAFMO · 29/12/2021 10:10

I'd like to know how MNers acquire ESP as I've been here almost 20 years and mine still hasn't arrived.

An OP says something, and the minute someone disagrees, ANother pops up and tells us what the OP meant, what they were doing, where they were going and how the other party was clearly being U. Almost as if they were sockpuppeting present at the scene of the crime.

Nicknames- unless you call your son Pudsey when his given name is Albert and you do it from day 1, nicknames are self-generating. They're like those animals that have sex with themselves to reproduce. No amount of MN threads asking "is Caro a suitable nickname for Rebecca" Xmas Hmm will make it happen.

DrSbaitso · 29/12/2021 10:09

Oh, AND - the "yes I wash them" etc isn't directed at @WomanStanleyWoman, just anyone who's reading it and about to fire a load of silly and very answerable questions about it because it's not something they choose to do.

DrSbaitso · 29/12/2021 10:07

Oh, and yes, I do only offer the slippers. Nobody has to use them.

DrSbaitso · 29/12/2021 10:03

What annoys me is people who choose to do that suggesting that anyone who doesn’t is ‘weird’. It’s the lack of understanding that some people live differently to others.

Well, I was once called "fucking weird" on here - not merely "weird", but actually "fucking" weird - because I've got a box of slippers that I offer to guests in my shoeless house. I know not everyone has a shoeless house, but I have, so in that context, it didn't seem "fucking weird" to me. Actually, it struck me as strange that someone would think it was "fucking weird". So I think I get where you're coming from. (Yes, I wash them between guests, even during a stay if it's a long one and the guest requests it. No, it's not an impossibly arduous task. No, nobody has ever caught any kind of foot infection from using them, just as I haven't from any other household that does the same thing.)

But I do think it's a bit odd to have a policy of not answering the door as standard, especially when it's overwhelmingly more likely to be a delivery you've forgotten about, or a surprise one, than anything nefarious. It doesn't offend or annoy me (though it probably would if I were your postie or local courier); you can do what you like in your house. But I guess I just can't see why you'd deliberately engineer unnecessary inconvenience that might mean you have to go out to the parcel depot or arrange a redelivery that you might well end up ignoring too.

But like I said, I'm not bothered about saying no thank you to cold callers. Are they even very common these days? I can't remember the last time I had one. They seem to put leaflets through the door now.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 29/12/2021 10:00

The traditional names ones comes up lots and the question I think has never been answered is 'why are lovers of traditional names so confident that their choice is better'? They arrogantly assume it just is.

What is the definition of a woman has obviously never been answered.

Who actually sets the rules of cleaning which many posters feel beholden to stick to?

WomanStanleyWoman · 29/12/2021 09:46

It bugs the hell out of me when people on here complain that people who don't drive are always demanding lifts. I vanishingly rarely ask for a lift, and have even found myself in difficult positions occasionally when people were actively trying to make me accept lifts I didn't want or need. My definition of "walking distance" is a lot more than just down to the corner shop!

I know what you mean. Whilst it’s usually borne out of kindness, offers of lifts often come from people who can’t understand how anyone manages without a car - so they think they’re doing you a massive favour by saying ‘If you can wait until 2.30 I can give you a lift part of the way’, when actually you could have got the bus the whole way there and back in the time you spent waiting.

However, when it comes to opening the door, I normally like to open it if I can, so I'd just like to check: do you actively disagree with other people always answering the door, so long as they don't disagree with you for not opening it?

I don’t disagree with other people answering their door to whoever they want to whenever they want to; it’s their door! What annoys me is people who choose to do that suggesting that anyone who doesn’t is ‘weird’. It’s the lack of understanding that some people live differently to others. I know what the likelihood of a friend or neighbour ‘popping in’ would be (i.e. zero).

OP posts:
JanisMoplin · 29/12/2021 09:34

Why is everyone always terrified of the "clique-y" school gate mums? And if everyone is terrified, who is in the clique?

Obv I am not being entirely serious.

GuesswhatIamnotarobot · 29/12/2021 09:33

I think the answer to the question about door answering is that a lot of people on MN probably don't work cos they all have very wealthy husbands who are far too important to lift a finger around the house.

Or maybe it's about boundaries. Because so many people on MN have absolutely none, they don't realise that they don't actually need to allow randoms their time or into their home.

Who knows.

DrSbaitso · 29/12/2021 09:32

[quote UnsuitableHat]**@DrSbaitso* @TheWayTheLightFalls* I know. I was mocking the question.[/quote]
Oh, sorry.

DrSbaitso · 29/12/2021 09:31

@RedBonnet

Love this thread 😝 I never answer the landlines mainly because nobody I know has the number. Even I don't know the number 🤣 So if it rings it must be spam.

I remember my ds aged 10 or so being absolutely gobsmacked when I threw an unopened letter in the bin. Like it was a world disaster 🤣 He still didn't get it even after I explained what junk mail is; he's still sticking rigidly to 'the rules' 20 years later!

If nobody you know has the number, why do you have the landline at all?
Justme10 · 29/12/2021 09:31

What is cheap white bread?

Always see it people mention it on food threads 'a fish finger sandwich with cheap white bread!'
As some kind of indulgent treat.

Is is smart price bread? Or is it the warburtons I eat on a daily basis? Is there a fancier everyday bread I should be using?

UnsuitableHat · 29/12/2021 09:31

@DrSbaitso @TheWayTheLightFalls I know. I was mocking the question.

RedBonnet · 29/12/2021 09:30

Love this thread 😝 I never answer the landlines mainly because nobody I know has the number. Even I don't know the number 🤣 So if it rings it must be spam.

I remember my ds aged 10 or so being absolutely gobsmacked when I threw an unopened letter in the bin. Like it was a world disaster 🤣 He still didn't get it even after I explained what junk mail is; he's still sticking rigidly to 'the rules' 20 years later!

TheWayTheLightFalls · 29/12/2021 09:25

Why do people without children read Mumsnet? Ok not all the threads are about having children. But it’s called MUMSnet. How did childless people even find the site??

Via Google I expect - if you search for Farrow and Ball paint or life in St Albans or whether chihuahuas make good pets you may find a Mumsnet link to a discussion comes up.

DrSbaitso · 29/12/2021 09:23

@UnsuitableHat

Why do people without children read Mumsnet? Ok not all the threads are about having children. But it’s called MUMSnet. How did childless people even find the site??
It's pretty well known and appears in the news frequently...very often for stories that don't involve being a parent. Misogynistic stories about bridezillas and weight-based arguments are more common, actually.
marcopront · 29/12/2021 09:21

My question is.

Why do people who don't like damp towels lying around think washing them and therefore making them wetter is the answer?

If you can dry the wet towels, why can't you dry the damp ones?

DrSbaitso · 29/12/2021 09:21

@WomanStanleyWoman

I can’t imagine why I would pretend to be out if I was in. Confused

You can’t imagine a scenario where you don’t want to see anyone or be disturbed?

I can imagine that. I can't really imagine not answering the door as standard practice, but then I'm not bothered about telling salespeople etc that I'm not interested and closing the door again. I order a lot of stuff online, I'd hate to miss the delivery for no good reason.

I suppose if it's a legitimate call and you're out, there's just a bit of inconvenience that you could have avoided (unless you pretend to be out again on redelivery or whatever). And it's not unheard of for potential burglars to knock on the door to see if anyone's home before they break in. Your home is safer if they think someone's in it. But the odds of it being a criminal casing the joint are quite low.

It's your door, you can choose not to answer it as standard if you want. I just wouldn't want to be your local Hermes courier.

Swipe left for the next trending thread