Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Feeling guilty about deciding to have one child

140 replies

Daisiebell · 27/12/2021 07:29

I’ve got a 3 year old DS and me and DP have decided not to have any more.
I had horrific PND and it was a really difficult time for us all. I still struggle now.
But I’m absolutely racked with this feeling of guilt, that I should be giving him a sibling because my body is able.
He saw his cousins yesterday and loved playing with them (unfortunately they don’t live nearby and were just visiting). I felt a sadness that he won’t ever have that.
I don’t want him to be lonely, but at the same time I don’t think I can go through it all again.
I had a brother growing up and my DP had a brother and sister, so neither of us know what it’s like to be an only child.

My friend who is older than me (I’m 33) and who had IVF to have her daughter is really upset that she can’t give her a sibling and seems to wish she was in the position to choose like I am…I feel terribly guilty Sad

AIBU to feel like this?

OP posts:
CorsicaDreaming · 27/12/2021 20:39

PS he's nine years old next month, and I still think it's fine.

I regret not ever having a daughter sometimes - but for myself really, not as I think they'd be a companion for DS.

CorsicaDreaming · 27/12/2021 20:37

Don't feel guilty.

Having one is fine. We have one. He's great. He has lots of friends. His age, gender, interests. It works. We both have time for him and time for ourselves too.

Listen to "one and done" by Russell Kane. Just very funny but true...

Octopus37 · 27/12/2021 19:11

I think whatever you decide or whatever kids you have, you'll always have the grass is greener moments. I have two boys, two years and nine months apart. Sometimes they are close, sometimes they fight like cat and dog, they are 11 and 14. For me, a big part of wanting another baby was wanting DS1 to have someone to share his childhood with and also to share the burden of old age. That isn't to say, DS2 hasn't been loved and wanted in his own right. My Mum died when I was 27 and we my Sister and I have had and continue to have many turbulent times with my Dad. We didn't always get on when we were younger, but as an adult I am so grateful for this. On the other hand, I see Mum's with one child and they seem so much more organised, focused and better than me, with more money and cleaner houses. I feel very slap dash in comparison, although like most people I do my best. I couldn't have handled any more than two kids though. Its totally up to you, but I agree that Mum's guilt gets you whatever you decide.

Sunset999 · 27/12/2021 17:55

Gosh dont feel guilty, not all siblings get on anyway , even if they do as children not always later in life. Enjoy your child and ignore silly comments

KewMummy87 · 27/12/2021 17:50

@Coroico97 this sums up my experience really well too. I long for someone to be able to remember my childhood with.

KewMummy87 · 27/12/2021 17:47

@Bavarois no assumptions, but if either of my children have children of their own, their child(ren) will have an aunt/uncle.

I’m extremely sad that my children don’t have aunts/uncles/cousins on my side.

HeyMoana · 27/12/2021 17:27

Only child here.
No problems, perfectly happy childhood.
Just a couple of things to consider based on my experience only....
Support your child to keep a couple of life long friendships if possible. I was a fliberty jibbet and now have no one that knew me as a child.

Also, make it clear you don't expect them to take care of you in your old age. They may chose to but it was something I worried about even as a teen.

Finally, don't over- share your problems. I think teens get relief from moaning about their parents together in their bedroom but as an only one it's harder to get perspective....it's easier to take on the adult's problems.
Upside.....more time, more money, more say in things...pretty much brill.

Elisemum · 27/12/2021 17:17

I would feel guilty too :( everyone should give children a sibling if you can, otherwise it’s a bit selfish.
Now before anyone bites me, I said “if you can” as in if you can afford it, have a proper house etc.
I just had a second baby and seeing my toddler with him is the best thing I could ever wish for and makes my heart full every day. It is of course stressful too and very hard sometimes to look after 2, sometimes you can feel like you just want to run away, but it’s all worth it!

Thwackit · 27/12/2021 16:57

I really wish people would stop feeling pressure to have kids they don’t particularly want in order to ‘keep the other child company’ at the expense of their own well-being. Absolute madness and the people that keep raising this nonsense in order to pressure people like you, OP (“won’t they be lonely? When are you going to give us another grandchild?” etc etc’) really do need to mind their own business.

Who even guarantees they’ll get on? Most people I know bickered constantly with their siblings! What guarantee is there that they’ll want to play together or have similar shared interests? That’s what school and friends are for - keeping children company. You don’t have a child for the main reason of keeping another child company.

BlueJag · 27/12/2021 15:13

Our son never asked or wish for a sibling. He has great friends and does very well socially.

BlueJag · 27/12/2021 15:13

Having one child is wonderful. We have a 16 year old son. We have been able to give him everything. We shower him with love and attention. He managed not to spoil him and he is really well behaved. He loves our company and not a hint of rebellion. Best decision we've ever made to have only one child.

Coroico97 · 27/12/2021 14:13

I am an only child in my 50s. I had a fabulous childhood. Got on brilliantly with my parents. Had lovely holidays, so many laughs and had absolutely no issues. I was very happy, had lots of friends and cousins and all was good. However, when my parents got old and ill I was on my own. My cousins and friends were kind and helpful from a distance but had their own parents and families. They both ended up with dementia and it was incredibly difficult. However many friends you have, and how much family support you have, you are on your own at 3am when the carer calls to say your dad with dementia has gone wandering off. I never wished for a sibling until I was in my 40s. And now they are gone, there no one to share funny everyday family memories with. Not saying this is necessarily a reason to have more than one child of course. Just another viewpoint. In my case, childhood and early adulthood were the easy parts.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 27/12/2021 13:44

YABU to feel like that ,(though I guess you can't actually help the way you feel!). You will have more time, resources and money for your child than if they had a sibling. Only children have some advantages, I thought they generally did better at school, better jobs etc than children with siblings? Getting on with cousins on a playdate is not the same as living with someone day in day out. You might not actually fall pregnant easily the second time. You may have complications that means you are less able to look after your first child. They may hate each other. It's a big gamble even if it is something that you really want to do. I had a second and it triggered a health condition that was fine in my first pregnancy, I was bed bound for 6 months, my second didn't sleep and has issues with food...yes most things gave resolved now but the first 2 years of their life was pretty shit for us as a family and must have had an effect on my eldest

Bavarois · 27/12/2021 13:35

@KewMummy87 . It brings me huge comfort to know that they have a lifelong relationship with one another - can be aunts/uncles to each others children, their children will have cousins etc... I wish, wish, wish I’d had a sibling

Why are you assuming all/any of your children will have their own children? None of the above statements are guarantees.

For an alternative perspective, I won't say I wish I didn't have a sibling as that's awful, but my sister and I very different people who don't get on particularly well. Growing up I was still lonely sometimes. She was 4 years younger so we played separately. At family events I'd get shunted to the kids table despite being a lot older. As adults, she's very immature and selfish. I see her roughly 3 times a year (she lives 40 miles away). In theory I can understand why parents want the sibling relationship for their children but it doesn't always work out that way. My dad still tries to convince me (and himself) that my sister and I get on so well. We don't!

MintyGreenDream · 27/12/2021 13:23

We decided against a second for the same reason as you and I'm very happy.Ds is 7 and has plenty of friends and rarely questions why he's an only.We have the time,energy and money for him that having more could affect.

Fairunibutterfly · 27/12/2021 11:54

I think you’ll feel guilt either way but also either way you can create a nice family life no matter what.

We had 2 because we always wanted 2 but I still felt guilty when youngest was a baby for not spending much time with her. We thought she was ok but when dd1 grew a bit older (5/6) she really felt we loved dd2 more than her. We didn’t and we did lots for her but she didn’t feel that way so we had to invest more time in making sure she felt important in the family and we still do. She does love her sister but they also fight a lot so it goes both ways!

Do what’s right for your family. Whatever you decide, come to peace with it, even if it’s, “we’ll reassess in a year”. I don’t think there’s any right option when it comes to families in terms of how many, what kind of age gap so do what is right for your family.

PullingAtTeeth · 27/12/2021 11:51

Don’t feel guilty.
Embrace his friendships, offer plenty of play dates and he will be absolutely fine.
I have two boys, two years apart and they can’t stand each other. I often think both would be so much happier and less stressed as an only child.
They both get on brilliantly with their friends from
School etc.

2reefsin30knots · 27/12/2021 11:49

My DH is one of 5. One of his siblings chose to have no children and three (including us) have only one by choice. One has chosen to have two children but I think that was because his wife felt very strongly about it. I'm extrapolating that being part of a big family was not so great for them.

I don't think the idea that having siblings is unconditionally life enhancing is particularly well founded. I know at least as many adults who don't get on with their siblings as those who do.

Forgothowmuchlhatehomeschoolin · 27/12/2021 11:36

I used to feel terrible l couldn't give dd a sibling - she is 10 now and loving life as an only!
Even if you had another, there is no guarantee they would get on and during lockdown as hard as it was, l was very pleased l didn't have to be referee as some of my friends with more than one had to be!
I used to really overturns it but the truth is, they don't know any different and in my dd's class, about a third of the kids are onlies so def more common.

FateHasRedesignedMost · 27/12/2021 11:32

Neither you nor your friend are wrong. People decide to stop at one for all kinds of reasons, from a hard first pregnancy/labour/PND to financial reasons, space, amount of time, energy and attention they can give to the child, work commitments, choice. I have lots of friends with one child by choice and all the kids seem happy.

But I’d hold back mentioning you have the choice to your friend. The desire to provide your child with a sibling can be very intense, especially if you’ve grown up with siblings and have good adult friendships with them. Your friend may feel she’s failed at giving her child a play mate, or feel like everyone else has big families.

I had secondary infertility (now pregnant) and there was a time I was very jealous of people with 2 or more children, especially when they talked about loving sibling moments or their kids being companions. In reality the kids seemed to fight and squabble a lot, but I still desperately wanted to be pregnant again and have another baby, and give my son the experience of a sibling. If your friend’s set on that or going through more IVF she may be unable to see the positives of an only child just now.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 27/12/2021 11:28

@AllThatFancyPaintsAsFair

Absolutely right, I don't know if a sibling would have made her happier but somehow you know that the OP"s child will be fine. Can you explain how you are able to know that? What special power do you have that I don't?

I have the special power of being able to think critically and not be a dick by making a mum who doesn't actually want a second child due to previously having crippling PND second guess her decision and feel even shitter.

Dixiechickonhols · 27/12/2021 11:21

My only is 15 and very happy as an only. She’s an only due to my health. No regrets. It suits us well. Easier for many reasons. She’s not weird has lots of friends. Lots of children are not in 2 parent 2 kids set up eg her best friend is effectively an only as her siblings are a lot older and left home. We got a dog 5 years ago so he’s her brother!

KewMummy87 · 27/12/2021 11:12

I had a happy childhood as an only child but it’s teens and into adulthood that I feel I’ve missed so much. Im so grateful to have more than one child. They will always have each other (yes siblings sometimes don’t get on Etc but lots do). It brings me huge comfort to know that they have a lifelong relationship with one another - can be aunts/uncles to each others children, their children will have cousins etc. I didn’t have PND but a few of my friends did and it either didn’t happen second time around or they knew what to expect having faced it once before.

I have lots of friends who have only children not by choice. The friends I have who decided to stick at one - I never question them but I do feel sad for their children. They all have siblings they have happy relationship with and I wonder why they don’t want to give that to their child.

So this is just my pov. But I wish, wish, wish I’d had a sibling. You’re young op, so no rush. As I say, this is just my perspective as a child who was happy as an only child (but lonely sometimes) but feels the force of being alone now as an adult.

Rollmopsrule · 27/12/2021 11:07

Well look at it this way. You could have another just to provide a sibling and they don't get on - you'd feel guilty about that. There's always something to beat yourself up about as a parent. Enjoy your family - you know the reasons you don't want another and you've nothing to feel guilty about. Families come in all shapes and sizes.

runningfromtheoutlaws · 27/12/2021 11:04

Bit of a hobson’s choice though!