Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Feeling guilty about deciding to have one child

140 replies

Daisiebell · 27/12/2021 07:29

I’ve got a 3 year old DS and me and DP have decided not to have any more.
I had horrific PND and it was a really difficult time for us all. I still struggle now.
But I’m absolutely racked with this feeling of guilt, that I should be giving him a sibling because my body is able.
He saw his cousins yesterday and loved playing with them (unfortunately they don’t live nearby and were just visiting). I felt a sadness that he won’t ever have that.
I don’t want him to be lonely, but at the same time I don’t think I can go through it all again.
I had a brother growing up and my DP had a brother and sister, so neither of us know what it’s like to be an only child.

My friend who is older than me (I’m 33) and who had IVF to have her daughter is really upset that she can’t give her a sibling and seems to wish she was in the position to choose like I am…I feel terribly guilty Sad

AIBU to feel like this?

OP posts:
EmmasMum12 · 28/12/2021 08:04

No need to feel guilty. Make sure your child has plenty of playdates and friends and give DC lots of your time and attention

Sorted

Ragwort · 28/12/2021 08:04

Having children, whether one or more is a totally selfish decision anyway, no one has a child with the view that they are only doing so to produce future tax payers for the economy Hmm.

We have an only child, never felt 'guilty' for one second, he is 21 now with a huge circle of friends, gets on really well with all sorts of different people, is confident and outgoing. Of course, he might have been exactly the same if he had a sibling - we will never know.

My DM (89) is an only DC she has a huge circle of friends as well, although recently widowed she is confident and sociable, never sits alone moaning about her life or health, she gets out and about ... maybe because she never had to 'rely' on siblings she has always known how to meet people and make friends Confused.

ivykaty44 · 28/12/2021 07:55

You don’t ever have a baby to give another relationship to someone else (unless it’s surrogacy, which is a different concept)

Having a baby for your son wouldn’t be the right thing to do

Enjoy your ds and if you want him to have company, then invite his friends round. You decide what type of household he grows up in and if that means open house for mates and them being welcome - then you engineer that situation

Lovelydiscusfish · 28/12/2021 07:55

[quote Elisemum]@Chikapu well I’m hoping they will have great relationship becouse as their mother I’m going to do my best and teach them that. The toddler already loves the baby so much- it’s priceless❤️ I’m trying to be the best mom I can and I know they will be best buddies for life. Yes my childhood was amazing but I said I wish I had a sibling! Even now as an adult would be lovely to have a sibling and a bigger family .[/quote]
How on Earth can you possibly know they will be “best buddies for life”? Have you a crystal ball? Loads of people grow up hating their siblings - my mom for example. I don’t hate mine, but we are certainly not “best buddies for life”.

When you think about the impact on the planet (which we all should) having any children at all is incredibly selfish - having two is double selfish. And so on,

I’m not judging anyone as I have a child myself - I just wouldn’t for a second pretend it was a selfless thing to do.

She is an only child. Which was my decision not, actually, for ethical reasons but for personal preference and to enable myself to give her a better childhood. And it worked - if anybody asks her now she is very clear that she would not have wanted a sibling on any level. And she is probably the happiest person I know!

Icebreaker99 · 28/12/2021 07:53

I know they will be best buddies for life.

You can't know that and to be honest the pressure you seem to be putting on them to be best buddies may massively back fire. Yeah its lovely your toddler loves the baby, wait until they grow and start fighting about every inane thing, maybe they won't and you will be lucky, but sounds like you idealized having a sibling growing up and are now trying to live out the fantasy.

ViceLikeBlip · 28/12/2021 07:48

@Icebreaker99

Some absolutely disgusting comments on here about how people had another child to give their existing child the "experience of sibling" like it's a bloody gap year and not a living breathing person who has to make their own way in this world from birth to death. If the OP came on and said I want to get a dog for my child so they have the experience of growing up with a dog so many posters would be saying how much hard work it was, how expensive, how time consuming but when it comes to a human it's considered selfish and cruel not to have another so your child has a sibiling?!
Good point about the dog!! Fuck it, even a PONY would be cheaper than a sibling 🤷‍♀️
ViceLikeBlip · 28/12/2021 07:46

I saw an interesting news article on the BBC last week (but now I can't find it again!) about the population crash in China. And they interviewed a few couples who were single children themselves (part of the one-child policy) and who had no interest in having more than one child themselves (even though the policy has now been relaxed). They basically said it was too stressful and too expensive to have more than one.

And it made me wonder whether the expectation to provide a sibling is mostly idealised cultural pressure?

GoodnightGrandma · 28/12/2021 07:43

I’m an only child and I’m quite happy.
I see siblings who fight and hate each other, I don’t need that in my life.

Elisemum · 28/12/2021 07:41

@Chikapu well I’m hoping they will have great relationship becouse as their mother I’m going to do my best and teach them that. The toddler already loves the baby so much- it’s priceless❤️ I’m trying to be the best mom I can and I know they will be best buddies for life. Yes my childhood was amazing but I said I wish I had a sibling! Even now as an adult would be lovely to have a sibling and a bigger family .

FakeFruitShoot · 28/12/2021 07:41

I guess your child was about 1 when covid hit? So the lack of social contact with other kids is perhaps a factor that's weighing on you? Do you have close friends with kids who you can go on holiday with occasionally? I just think her first three years have not been representative of reality... in non lockdown times she (and you) can be surrounded by other children if that's what you want.

My only other point would be - do you really feel guilty for your child or is this the beginnings of you yourself changing your mind and wanting another? I imagine with such severe PND (and then in lockdown survival mode) the conversation was off the table completely before... you are allowed to change your mind and can broach the subject with DH if you think this is or could be the case.

Icebreaker99 · 28/12/2021 07:41

It’s not negotiable really and it’s been proven.

Evidence please? You obviously had something missing in your childhood apart from a sibiling as so many onlies are perfectly happy.

Chikapu · 28/12/2021 07:34

[quote Elisemum]@WithANameLikeDaniCalifornia yes it is selfish. Children grow better with a sibling, they have better, more fun childhood, they have each other as friends, they play with each other and have someone else to relay on in life when parents are gone:(. Its obvious and the truth. It’s not negotiable really and it’s been proven.
Whether you want to have one or more- up to each individual but having only one child (when you could have 2) is selfish as parents obviously chose their own well being first ahead of their child… I’m the only child and I had amazing childhood but always wished I had a sibling. I cannot wait to see my 2 boys being best friends and doing everything together, standing up for each other and go together through life! That’s what’s life is about[/quote]
What a load of idealised crap. You have no idea what kind of relationship your sons will have later in life.
Being an only child didn't harm you, by your own admission your childhood was amazing so what are you even talking about?

Elisemum · 28/12/2021 07:27

@WithANameLikeDaniCalifornia yes it is selfish. Children grow better with a sibling, they have better, more fun childhood, they have each other as friends, they play with each other and have someone else to relay on in life when parents are gone:(. Its obvious and the truth. It’s not negotiable really and it’s been proven.
Whether you want to have one or more- up to each individual but having only one child (when you could have 2) is selfish as parents obviously chose their own well being first ahead of their child… I’m the only child and I had amazing childhood but always wished I had a sibling. I cannot wait to see my 2 boys being best friends and doing everything together, standing up for each other and go together through life! That’s what’s life is about

Icebreaker99 · 28/12/2021 06:23

Some absolutely disgusting comments on here about how people had another child to give their existing child the "experience of sibling" like it's a bloody gap year and not a living breathing person who has to make their own way in this world from birth to death. If the OP came on and said I want to get a dog for my child so they have the experience of growing up with a dog so many posters would be saying how much hard work it was, how expensive, how time consuming but when it comes to a human it's considered selfish and cruel not to have another so your child has a sibiling?!

Chikapu · 28/12/2021 06:12

I would feel guilty too sad everyone should give children a sibling if you can, otherwise it’s a bit selfish

Exactly how is it selfish?

Cici22 · 27/12/2021 23:17

Me and my partner had the worst time during teens with our siblings. Me and my brother used to fight loads. Honestly don't want that life for me and my kid. You don't have to have more than one. This is my first pregnancy and I'm sure as hell not going to be jumping to do this again. It isn't fun at all

BowledOverly · 27/12/2021 23:03

@Elisemum

I would feel guilty too :( everyone should give children a sibling if you can, otherwise it’s a bit selfish. Now before anyone bites me, I said “if you can” as in if you can afford it, have a proper house etc. I just had a second baby and seeing my toddler with him is the best thing I could ever wish for and makes my heart full every day. It is of course stressful too and very hard sometimes to look after 2, sometimes you can feel like you just want to run away, but it’s all worth it!
Disgusting comment. You’re utterly wrong of course as you’re only thinking of your want for a second child. May your smugness last as with that sort of outlook and judgemental attitude, it’ll be interesting to see how your two turn out.
WithANameLikeDaniCalifornia · 27/12/2021 23:00

^^ Actually I take my question back. I don’t want to know how you justify your bigotry. Just go away and stop trying to make the Op feel even worse.

WithANameLikeDaniCalifornia · 27/12/2021 22:58

@Elisemum

I would feel guilty too :( everyone should give children a sibling if you can, otherwise it’s a bit selfish. Now before anyone bites me, I said “if you can” as in if you can afford it, have a proper house etc. I just had a second baby and seeing my toddler with him is the best thing I could ever wish for and makes my heart full every day. It is of course stressful too and very hard sometimes to look after 2, sometimes you can feel like you just want to run away, but it’s all worth it!
How is it selfish?
lollipoprainbow · 27/12/2021 22:57

My dd is an only and not super confident like a lot of people on here saying their only children are. She's autistic and struggles socially, I would have loved a sibling for her.

ToastofLandon · 27/12/2021 22:49

Please don’t feel guilty. I do feel where you are coming from though as it is something I’ve grappled with but I’ve made peace with my decision and my DD is nearly 5 now. Hang in there.

There is a Facebook group called My first, my last, my everything that I highly recommend for parents of onlies. Made me feel like I wasn’t alone and could share my feelings in a safe space.

BowledOverly · 27/12/2021 22:47

Teen DD spent today with her cousins. When she came home she was utterly drained and thanked me for only having her Grin

Not all only children are lonely. I’m an only too and never felt lonely growing up as I had lots of friends.

Seedandyarn · 27/12/2021 22:44

I don't find it any more selfish having not provided my child with a (living) sibling than providing one that she might grow up to hate.
People love to go on about how selfish it is to have an only child ignoring their own selfish desires for another can be detrimental to the first born.

Reading the threads on her plenty of people have cute moments with their sibling as kids only to later for the relationship to sour.

Seedandyarn · 27/12/2021 22:40

I find parents care way more about a child being an only than the child.
We knew after my DD was born we wouldn't have another after loosing her sister.
We always framed being a single child family in a positive light at 7 she isn't the slightest bit bothered about having a sibling or lonely at all.

Two of her best friends are only children too (I have come to realise it's much more common now a days) and they both seem just as happy as DD to be one.

My DD is confident and out going always happy to approach other children in the playground far more so than other children I know especially those with siblings close in age.

mermaidgiraffe · 27/12/2021 22:29

It's absolutely fine. He may wish he had siblings as he gets older, he may not. His sibling could be his ready made best friend or they could have absolutely nothing in common. It's impossible to predict the future so it's really not worth beating yourself up over.