Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not let my seven year old watch The Goblet of Fire onwards yet?

38 replies

Marianne1234 · 27/12/2021 01:52

My seven year old daughter is a huge fan of Harry Potter, as are her pals. Her Christmas presents were all HP-themed. I’m also a huge fan so I am absolutely loving this. We have read the first three books, and seen the first three films.

Obviously she is desperate to see the fourth one (Goblet of Fire) - basically she wants to see it through. Of course she does. But it seems very dark from there onwards for a seven year old.

I’m thinking things like Cedric Diggory being killed by Voldemort. Harry bringing back his body and his dad’s reaction etc. I’m just not sure she’s ready for that.

I grew up with HP. I was older than she is when the goblet of
Fire came out. So to be honest I hadn’t really thought about it when we started watching it.

I just wondered what others do.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
FeelingdownXmas · 27/12/2021 20:36

When I was 7 I was watching IT and Nightmare on Elm Street Grin. But then my parents did just sort of leave me to raise myself 🙈.

I agree with PP, I would wait. Does get a bit scary after film 3.

lanthanum · 27/12/2021 20:22

We had a "read it before you watch it" policy, which means that any scary bits are less scary because the outcome is already known. We also refused to read the fourth(?) one to her, because we thought she was a bit young for it. She started it a couple of times, but only managed it at the third attempt, by which time she was that bit older.

CryHavoc · 27/12/2021 20:17

'Kill the spare' is the darkest bit of all the books, IMO. I think a child not scared/troubled by it doesn't understand what's going on.

KeyWorker · 27/12/2021 20:15

My DD aged 6 (7 next month, year 2) has got into HP in the last couple of months and watched the first 3 films. I won’t allow her to see Goblet of Fire yet, it’s too dark in my opinion. Not sure when I will to be honest but certainly not anytime soon.

Hadehahaha · 27/12/2021 20:08

Read books 1-3 with mine at 7/8, then watched those films, made him wait until he is almost 9 for book 4 and he’s not allowed to watch the film yet. He has peers who have been allowed to read/watch them all but also plenty of parents have made their children wait, especially for book 4 onwards.

KurtWildesChristmasNamechange · 27/12/2021 19:59

I let mine watch it at 7, in fact they've watched them all. None of them found it scary.

Tigersteakpie · 27/12/2021 19:57

My 7 year old has read (with me, no way can he read them himself yet!!) 1-3. We watch the film after reading the book. This seems like a good way to do it as you can anticipate the scary bits and process them together. I wouldn't let him watch the film without reading it together first.

We are planning on starting it in Feb and it'll take over a month to read so by the time the film comes around he'll be 7.5.

We intersperse the books with other ones so he still keen and enthusiastic but we aren't rushing them. We finished no 3 at the end of Sept so about 4 months between books so he'll be at least 8 before we start book 6. By then I'll probably let him loose on the last ones!

littlepeas · 27/12/2021 19:48

Depends on the kid to some extent. I can’t remember the ages mine were now, but probably 8+ for the later films. My older two weren’t frightened at all, but my youngest was scared of Voldemort and still is at 10!

JMKid · 27/12/2021 19:36

My DC is 6 and he has watched the Goblet of Fire but I fast forward some of the more gory scenes.

foreverandalways · 27/12/2021 19:31

Let her watch them all

foxgoosefinch · 27/12/2021 19:27

I think you're right. My nearly 9 yo has read all of the books, and was happy to watch Goblet of Fire onwards, but a year or so younger she would have found the later ones too much.

In fact, even though she's read all the books, she recently turned off the penultimate film half way through as it was a bit too scary; and hasn't been keen yet to return to it. I should expect she will pick up the last two films again in a year or so, but I don't expect her to before then.

I know of a lot of parents who have imposed a break between the earlier books and films 1-3 or 1-4, and the later ones - you certainly won't be alone in that.

DobbyTheHouseElk · 27/12/2021 19:22

I made mine read the books before the films.

Goblet of fire was a 8+ book.
I wanted to keep the DH for 10+ but they found it in lockdown and had secretly read quite a chunk.

I wouldn’t show goblet of fire to a 6 year old. My DM was terrified when I took her to see it at the cinema.

UnaOfStormhold · 27/12/2021 19:18

DS(7) has read the first 4 books but I have been holding off letting him read book 5 for about a year. His 8yo cousin has just lent him her copy and he's so keen I don't want to discourage him or let him feel left out. He gets very easily scared by films (Up and Toy Story are both on the list of films he won't watch) so we've not watched any of the HP films, but he seems much more able to cope with scary scenes in writing so fingers crossed!

Mylittlecoconuts · 27/12/2021 19:16

I watched them all with my then 7 year old. We hadn't seen any or read the books so didn't know what to expect. She was fine and she's normally scared of everything!

I'd let your dc watch and if it seems like it's getting a bit much, leave it for when she's a bit older.

purpleme12 · 27/12/2021 19:12

I go by the film certificates so no you're not unreasonable
And yes I also like to look at that Common Sense Media although it's shit how they've started making you pay for it to see the details of the reviews now
It used to be free
Just cos other people let their kids watch things don't feel bad for not letting yours

BerthaBlythe · 27/12/2021 19:11

It would be a firm no from me.

TinyTroubleMaker · 27/12/2021 19:08

My daughter has been watching the whole lot on repeat play since she was about 5 and can't see any harm done. She is '8 going on 18' in character so might be a bit different depending on the child.

DigitalGhost · 27/12/2021 19:05

My DD loves the first 2 & she's 4. Definitely wouldn't let her watch beyond that until she's about 6/7. I'd probably let her watch them all by then though. Suppose it depends on your kid. My DD doesn't really get scared by films but yet is terrified of loud noises in real life so odd lol Confused

Whinge · 27/12/2021 18:59

@DockOTheBay

Even if they're not frightened by it, it is a waste to show it to them. They won't understand it all properly and then they've seen it. Save it and they will enjoy it so much more in a few years.
I agree. It's so much nicer to introduce them slowly alongside the books, rather than rushing through the films.
Shmithecat2 · 27/12/2021 18:56

We haven't read the books together, but DS has seen all the films. He's 6yo. Didn't seem too bothered by any of them.

minipie · 27/12/2021 18:53

I think it depends on personality tbh. My 6 yr old and 9 yr old have watched Goblet of Fire today (as it happens!)

Of the two it is the 9 yr old who is far more likely to be scared and have nightmares from it. She has a very over active imagination whereas 6 yr old is much more blasé about such things.

GreenPumpkins · 27/12/2021 18:51

I'm reading the 6th book to my 7 year old at the moment. We read the books and then watch the film so at the moment he's seen films 1-5 and can watch them again whenever he wants. I actually think 7 is too young for the later ones but as his classmates are busily spoiling the books for him we're reading them now! He already knows (from school) what happens at the end of the 6th one. Its would appear a lot of his classmates have seen all the films already. I never actually realised how much is missed out in the films until we started watching them straight after reading. I wish they'd film them all again but as a series.

DockOTheBay · 27/12/2021 18:48

Even if they're not frightened by it, it is a waste to show it to them. They won't understand it all properly and then they've seen it. Save it and they will enjoy it so much more in a few years.

DockOTheBay · 27/12/2021 18:46

I wouldn't read or watch goblet of fire onwards to a 7 year old. Even POA is pushing it to be honest...

TappThatJazz · 27/12/2021 18:42

My 7 year old has seen all of the films and we're currently working our way through the books (on no.3 at the mo). She watched them all when she was 6. She didn't love the graveyard scene but didn't have nightmares/worries about it. I was like you and didn't want her watching from the 4th film onwards but honestly she found the 4th scarier than 5-8.

Swipe left for the next trending thread