Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU at the word bollocks being used in Clifford the Big Red Dog?

138 replies

ThisMustBeMyDream · 27/12/2021 00:06

As per the title. I watched this in the cinema with my 6 and 9 year olds. I knew it was a PG and checked to see if it was suitable on common sense media as well as googling reviews, after previously making a mistake thinking Ghostbusters was okay (I didn't realise it had loads of swearing!). Nothing was mentioned at all on there. No other googling brought up this either. I know bollocks is hardly hugely offensive, but as I have an SEN 9 year old, who has great difficulties with impulse control, I am careful over what he sees. Swearing and violence is something we actively avoid.
Anyway, AIBU to think that I should have been able to find that information beforehand?
Also, is it even necessary?! It is used in a scene where Jack Whitehall says (in an American accent) "You see, if I hadn’t moved here when I was two, I would’ve grown up with a British accent. Bollocks. Rubbish. Collywobbles". I don't even know why it was necessary, but there you go!

OP posts:
Imayhaveerred · 27/12/2021 10:54

@Tal45

It's just so annoying when film makers do this as it's just unnecessary and doesn't add anything to the film. Mind you it comes from a country where people take their kids to Hooters for their birthday parties so they just don't seem to really understand what's appropriate for kids generally IMO. Mind you OP YABVU to mention the swearing in Ghostbusters and completely overlook the ghost oral sex scene.
I used to love Ghostbusters but my god it’s rapey…Bill Murray’s character is basically a stalker.
User12398712 · 27/12/2021 10:54

I swear (a lot) but would find bollocks being used in a kids film completely unnecessary and I'm surprised it has been used in Clifford the big red dog!? When Clifford the cartoon was on when I was a kid I'm sure it was aimed at kids that were about 3-5 years old!

Same, I was surprised it was a PG as I thought the original show was aimed at pre-school/reception sort of age so would have thought they would have made it at U level.

Imayhaveerred · 27/12/2021 10:53

Isn’t it one of those swear words that people in the US find quite funny as they don’t use it? You can make a bollox of something in the USA but that’s not the same. Much like Gwyneth Paltrow having great fun saying “wanker” a lot in Sliding Doors.

spongedog · 27/12/2021 10:53

@Marynotsocontrary

I once, on a phone call in the States to a utility company, who had utterly been messing me about, said that I was irritated by x, y, &z. The CS rep was very angry with me and told me off for swearing.

I'm not sure I understand @spongedog. Was'irritated' the word the rep didn't like or was it something else?

Yes - irritated. Which is very mild in the UK. Mild annoyance.

Apparently it was a lot more over there!

Tal45 · 27/12/2021 10:44

It's just so annoying when film makers do this as it's just unnecessary and doesn't add anything to the film. Mind you it comes from a country where people take their kids to Hooters for their birthday parties so they just don't seem to really understand what's appropriate for kids generally IMO.
Mind you OP YABVU to mention the swearing in Ghostbusters and completely overlook the ghost oral sex scene.

LyraVega · 27/12/2021 10:41

This thread is interesting, I'm surprised so many people see bollocks as being milder than crap and bloody.

To me bloody and crap are the mildest terms around, with bollocks being a step up from that and then shit being above that.

I swear (a lot) but would find bollocks being used in a kids film completely unnecessary and I'm surprised it has been used in Clifford the big red dog!? When Clifford the cartoon was on when I was a kid I'm sure it was aimed at kids that were about 3-5 years old!

SlowBoiledFrog · 27/12/2021 10:37

MorningStarling

"Mild" bad language would be words like "shit" or "twat

WTF?

MorningStarling · 27/12/2021 10:35

"Mild" bad language would be words like "shit" or "twat".
Bad language with no qualifier would be words like "fuck".
"Strong" bad language would be "cunt".

Something like "bollocks" or "crap" wouldn't fall into any category. They wouldn't necessarily be used in a "U" but are fair game for a "PG".

The safest thing to do if you are unsure whether a film is suitable for your children is to actually watch it first.

User12398712 · 27/12/2021 10:35

I suspect it's a "divided by a common language" thing. I think bollocks is a rather adult word that I wouldn't expect in a kid's movie - I'd put it in the same category as words like cock and knob, rather than the milder willy or bum. If bollocks isn't a term used in America, the writers probably assume it is the latter category and not inappropriate.

Legoisthebest · 27/12/2021 10:34

OMG this is the most hilarious thing I have read on here lately.
Bollocks is barely a swear word. I seriously doubt most children would even notice it if it is said ONE time in a film that presumably had loads more dialogue.
Whatever you do don't let your kids watch the PG rated film 'The Pirates in an Adventure With The Scientists' (which is an absolutely hysterical film). The part where the C word* is said was so unexpected I snorted so loud I made my (then aged about 5) daughter jump more than the word did.

*'Crap' incase you are interested.

ufucoffee · 27/12/2021 10:34

I agree OP. Absolutely no need for it. Bad language is creeping more and more into pre watershed programmes on the TV too.

ZZGirl · 27/12/2021 10:32

[quote SoniaFouler]@ZZGirl
While I agree it's unnecessary in the movie, Jack Whitehall didn't write the script.

I suggest you read further into the thread[/quote]
Found it, though you could have just reiterated the fact.
I apologise

SoniaFouler · 27/12/2021 10:29

@ZZGirl
While I agree it's unnecessary in the movie, Jack Whitehall didn't write the script.

I suggest you read further into the thread

SlowBoiledFrog · 27/12/2021 10:28

@autieok

We saw the film and I didn't pick up on it. But I agree it didn't need to be there. Anything off level one i would say is possibly ok.

Swearing scale -
Level one
Crap shit bloody bugger damm sod
Level two
Bollocks bitch wanker asshole balls
Level three
Fuck twat dick bastard prick
Level four
Cunt
😂😂😂

Bugger, as in to put a dick in a arsehole is not level one, and certainly not lower than balls.

Op I agree, I'm sick of unneeded language (or nudity, sexual innuendo, obviously not in Clifford) in films aimed at children.

ZZGirl · 27/12/2021 10:22

@SoniaFouler

Jack Whitehall has form for this. YANBU.
While I agree it's unnecessary in the movie, Jack Whitehall didn't write the script.
Scrabblecrabapple · 27/12/2021 10:22

It has a rating system, you can choose to ignore it but Yabu for assuming something and being annoyed. It’s not hard to check

Google bbfc (film title) then scroll to ratings info. It has one for every film.

First lines on the bbfc report for clifford…..”Mild bad language includes of uses of 'bloody', 'bollocks', 'ass' and wordplay on the term 'shit' when a woman exclaims 'Holy sheep';”

Marynotsocontrary · 27/12/2021 10:21

I once, on a phone call in the States to a utility company, who had utterly been messing me about, said that I was irritated by x, y, &z. The CS rep was very angry with me and told me off for swearing.

I'm not sure I understand @spongedog. Was'irritated' the word the rep didn't like or was it something else?

AlwaysColdHands · 27/12/2021 10:15

I wasn’t happy about it. It’s not the sort of word I want my 7 year old using in the playground- I don’t think “it was in the film” would be a very good defence when she’s hauled up for bad language at school
Misjudged by someone somewhere in my opinion

Keepitonthedownlow · 27/12/2021 10:13

Bollocks is another word for testicles. Don't think it's that appropriate for a kids film.

spongedog · 27/12/2021 10:10

@Pleaseletitbenaptime

I'm pretty sure I heard Jack Whitehall talk about this on Jessie Wares Table Manners podcast. If my memory serves me correctly he was improvising and the Americans he was working with didn't understand what the word meant until later on. I'm pretty sure in the podcast he was under the impression that that part got removed.
I was coming on to discuss similar. British and American interpretations are sometimes very different.

I once, on a phone call in the States to a utility company, who had utterly been messing me about, said that I was irritated by x, y, &z. The CS rep was very angry with me and told me off for swearing. We ended the call on good terms having had a good discussion regarding the same word in English and American English.

But like you OP - not suitable for a younger child's film at all.

CornishGem1975 · 27/12/2021 10:00

I mean, I wouldn't get my knickers in a twist over it, my kids hear worse at home Blush but it does seem a bit gratuitous and totally unnecessary when there are a multitude of other words that could be used to express the same.

ArblemarzipanTFruitcake · 27/12/2021 09:58

Surely this is just a cultural difference between the US and the UK?

The film is PG - not U. The 'parental guidance' was available as posted above on the BBFC website [as a total aside, the BBFC website is a fascinating read] so you could decide whether the level of swearing was acceptable.

I bet your children hear worse at school!

Damnloginpopup · 27/12/2021 09:57

Back in 1977 there was a court case raised over this very word in relation to the sex pistols debut album and the display of the word in a shop window... Professor James Kinsley, head of English at the University of Nottingham. His evidence showed that "bollocks" was in fact an Old English term for "priest" and in the context of the album meant "nonsense". All charges were thrown out

So never mind the bollocks, just enjoy the film.

AmyDudley · 27/12/2021 09:56

A discussion of how 'bad' bollocks is a bit irrelevant IMO.
It's more a question of is it necessary - why does a film that presumably will appeal to fairly young children, need to be a PG ? Leave out the swearing and make it a 'U' (or whatever the category is now). Parents shouldn't really have to research the level of swearing when taking their kids to see a film about a big red dog, it should be a given that all parts of it are suitable for children. Does use of the word bollocks enhance the film such that it would cause irreparable artistic damage if another word like ' gibberish' or 'balderdash' was used instead? I doubt it.

SoniaFouler · 27/12/2021 09:53

I'm pretty sure I heard Jack Whitehall talk about this on Jessie Wares Table Manners podcast. If my memory serves me correctly he was improvising and the Americans he was working with didn't understand what the word meant until later on. I'm pretty sure in the podcast he was under the impression that that part got removed

Haven't seen it, but I assume maybe it's an American film? If so, (as an American) it's not even remotely a swear word over here so I wouldn't be surprised it's in a children's film. Maybe a bit surprised a British film watch program missed if if it is considered one in the UK.

I wasn’t aware of the first part but it proves the earlier point I made that whenever JW sees a tone he just has to lower it. He knew it was a word that is not suitable for a children’s film and decided to use it anyway. This always seems to happen a lot whenever he’s involved with something.