Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not want sister and family to come along tomorrow?

39 replies

JessePinkmanYo · 26/12/2021 23:21

Belated xmas family gathering tomorrow. We haven't been together since the summer. Parents and grown up siblings and their children. Parents have organised something special (I don't know what this is - it's a surprise) One of my sisters has recently had covid in her household. Her ds was first but is now negative after 8 days isolation. Sister and my niece have been negative throughout. But her husband is positive on lateral flow.

We have been asked if we would be okay with my sister and the 2 kids coming along seeing as their lateral flows are negative. (She isn't actually decided she would come - just gaging thoughts and opinions)

Less of an AIBU really and more of WWYD? I'm inclined to say no. I'm uncomfortable. I've concerns about myself getting it and dealing with work and isolation etc.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DivorcedAndDelighted · 27/12/2021 16:32

@Tricked2003

This would make me very uneasy. A friend was visiting family recently and the daughters' boyfriend had been working with someone who had just tested positive, he was neg on LFT. The boyfriend said he would stay away if people felt uneasy, friend felt uncomfortable and said she would rather he stayed away. A few days later boyfriend tested positive. He may not have been contagious at that point but we will never know
Almost certainly he would not have been contagious at that point, if it took several more days until he was testing positive on LFT. That's what's great about LFTs - they are really good at identifying when you're actually infectious, and if you're doing them regularly after an exposure they can allow you to pick it up at the point you need to know. Attached is a nice diagram comparing infected period, infectious period, and LFT and PCR positivity periods.
Aibu to not want sister and family to come along tomorrow?
Drunkpanda · 27/12/2021 13:08

Ah. There is where I live, just brought back in due to omicron.

JohnSmithDrive · 27/12/2021 12:48

@Drunkpanda

Why does the household not need to isolate if two members of it have Covid?
Because they don't. There's no such thing as household isolation anymore.
Drunkpanda · 27/12/2021 12:46

Why does the household not need to isolate if two members of it have Covid?

thing47 · 27/12/2021 12:40

You can't really catch Covid outside without prolonged face-to-face contact, so you're very safe if you're not hugging, kissing etc. I think I'd want to know exactly what the activity is before deciding so I'd insist on being told so I could gauge the level of risk.

Offmyfence · 27/12/2021 11:28

I also have to say that if it's you not comfortable and SIL is following the rules, then it's you that should pull out, you shouldn't expect your SIL to not go.

JohnSmithDrive · 27/12/2021 11:08

I've had this situation twice over the holidays and whilst not entirely comfortable with it, did agree .

In both my cases, a household member was positive and the fully vaccinated (and boosted) adults they shared a home with never caught it.

GloriaSicTransitMundi · 27/12/2021 11:05

I don't see an issue with you meeting up outside, perhaps they could also wear masks just in case (the ones who have not yet had it) even though outside as they do for the most part prevent those with it spreading it

Wearing a mask protects other people from you, it doesn't protect you from other people if it's a cloth mask. It needs to be a proper KN95 face mask and definitely the ones who have covid in the household should be wearing it.

Tricked2003 · 27/12/2021 10:49

This would make me very uneasy.
A friend was visiting family recently and the daughters' boyfriend had been working with someone who had just tested positive, he was neg on LFT. The boyfriend said he would stay away if people felt uneasy, friend felt uncomfortable and said she would rather he stayed away. A few days later boyfriend tested positive. He may not have been contagious at that point but we will never know

saraclara · 27/12/2021 10:48

Indoors no, but outdoors after a very recent LFT, yes, I'd let them come. I'd be distancing from them though, which presumably will be possible.

I suppose the nature of the surprise would be relevant though. I think I'd want to check that there's no indoor element.

Offmyfence · 27/12/2021 10:42

I'd be fine with it!

Seneca · 27/12/2021 10:34

@DivorcedAndDelighted

If they've been doing daily lateral flows and they're all negative then I'd be happy to have them. I've worked on research on this area and feel LFTs are often under - appreciated, as they're extremely good at detecting when people are actually infectious. Although one LFT in isolation is not foolproof, it is very unlikely that they would be infectious and yet getting negatives 2 days in a row. LFTs are generally thought to pick up an active (symptomatic) infection about 80% of the time, so to get two false negatives in a row from someone who's actually shedding would only happen 4 times in a hundred. Get them to do another test on arrival (so 3 negative LFTs) and you take that down to 0.2 times in a hundred, ie 1 in 500.
Excellent advice . Thank you 😊
LethargicActress · 27/12/2021 10:33

If they test negative and you still don't want to see them, then it's you that should bow out. They would be following the rules, you would be making up extra rules. It would be really horrible if you to make your sisters children miss out because of your anxiety, so just don't go.

DivorcedAndDelighted · 27/12/2021 10:25

@Kisskiss

Those lateral flow tests don’t seem to be so accurate in this wave, I know people who had symptoms for 3-5days, testing negative on lateral flows for those days, then finally testing positive on pcr and lateral flow maybe 2 days afterwards..
In this situation it's possible they had a regular cold first, then caught Covid. Lateral flow tests are actually most accurate when you have symptoms and research has validated them at around 80% sensitivity in this situation, so the probability of getting several negative LFTs in a row while symptomatic with Covid is really low (I'm a researcher & keep abreast of the literature) . But there are some horrible colds going round at the moment. My kids all had colds, all negative on PCR. I've had a grotty 10-day cold, negative every day on LFT. Meanwhile my boyfriend has had Covid, which was a lot milder than the cold. If I had caught it from him while I had the cold, it would have looked like I was just taking a few days to test positive for Covid.
CagneyNYPD1 · 27/12/2021 10:07

As long as they still test negative on LFTs this morning, I would think it OK. But only for outside and I wouldn't be hugging etc.

Marianne1234 · 27/12/2021 10:03

Yeah why don’t you miss out if you’re so worried

5128gap · 27/12/2021 10:00

I wouldn't say no, and would be fine with her being there, as presumably the rest of the family are. If you're still anxious despite it being perfectly legal and them not having covid you should stay away yourself. I don't think its reasonable for people to be refused things due to someone else's anxiety, and a bit selfish to expect it.

Kbyodjs · 27/12/2021 09:43

When your kids go to school they’ll be constantly around other kids who have it at home and the same at work so unless you’re vulnerable my approach is to just go with it at this point

Kisskiss · 27/12/2021 09:35

Those lateral flow tests don’t seem to be so accurate in this wave, I know people who had symptoms for 3-5days, testing negative on lateral flows for those days, then finally testing positive on pcr and lateral flow maybe 2 days afterwards..

Dishwashersaurous · 27/12/2021 09:33

Outside. Low risk

Negative lft within hours of seeing you. Low risk.

MrzClaus · 27/12/2021 08:39

They've got negative LF tests and it's outdoors - sounds fine. LF can pick up when you're most infectious (even with symptoms) as it can detect the higher viral load.

Tbh they don't need to isolate under current guidance, and you could be in close contact in everyday life with any number of people in the same situation. Personally, I'd attend with them!

SnarkyBag · 27/12/2021 01:29

If it’s outside I’d be fine with it

DivorcedAndDelighted · 27/12/2021 00:40

If they've been doing daily lateral flows and they're all negative then I'd be happy to have them. I've worked on research on this area and feel LFTs are often under - appreciated, as they're extremely good at detecting when people are actually infectious. Although one LFT in isolation is not foolproof, it is very unlikely that they would be infectious and yet getting negatives 2 days in a row. LFTs are generally thought to pick up an active (symptomatic) infection about 80% of the time, so to get two false negatives in a row from someone who's actually shedding would only happen 4 times in a hundred. Get them to do another test on arrival (so 3 negative LFTs) and you take that down to 0.2 times in a hundred, ie 1 in 500.

Normski67 · 27/12/2021 00:28

I wouldn’t want to see them. We had a meet up planned last Sunday. A friend’s son tested positive on PCR that day and friend was testing negative on LTF. Friend insisted they were ok to come and meet up. I disagreed and dropped out. Guess what? They tested positive on Weds and now 3/5 people who attended are now positive.

DukkaTheHallsWithBoughsOfHolly · 27/12/2021 00:24

DH and I didn’t catch it from our DC.

If they test negative before they come I would go.