Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mil hit the dog

568 replies

LilyTheMink · 26/12/2021 20:58

We have a 1 year old medium sized dog. He isn't badly behaved and doesn't normally jump up. When MIL arrived for Xmas, he was a little excited - but honestly nothing hyperactive at all.
He jumped around when MIL was hugging my daughter and I told him to get down. I turned my back and he must have done it again as suddenly he was sneezing and shaking his head. This is what he does when he's knocked his nose on something eg. the coffee table.
The kids told me that MIL had hit him.
I wasn't sure what to do and spend the rest of the time keeping him out of her way - although to be honest he did that himself anyway.
She's been horrible to our pets before - once flicking our 3 month off kitten off the table like he was a breadcrumb.
DH has just grown a spine and spoken to her about another ussue - she told our 10 yo DD she was "selfish and didn't think about other people" because she didn't want to wear the Xmas jumper DH had bought her. (This was said in private, but DD luckily told me as she was upset by it).
Wibu to tell her she's not welcome to ever come back if she shows aggression to our pets again, or speaks badly to our kids?

OP posts:
FictionalCharacter · 26/12/2021 22:16

@KeyLimePies I agree.

Gretaburley · 26/12/2021 22:16

My dm hit my dog once.
I went ballistic at her.
I explained that we were using positive reinforcement to train ddog.
Tbf she got the message.

Your mil sounds like a sly, nasty piece of work.

FuckeryIsAfoot · 26/12/2021 22:16

@RoyalFamilyFan

You cant flick a kitten off a table. Do you mean she pushed a kitten off the table? Presumably, because the kitten is not allowed on a table? That is not animal cruelty.
She doesn't get to decide if a kitten is allowed on the table or not in someone else's home.
SoniaFouler · 26/12/2021 22:16

@RoyalFamilyFan

You cant flick a kitten off a table. Do you mean she pushed a kitten off the table? Presumably, because the kitten is not allowed on a table? That is not animal cruelty.
Exactly. Things aren’t making sense in this thread. I think OP is not describing what happened properly, and didn’t see the incident with the dog so is basing it on her children’s words who may have said “hit” instead of “lightly pushed”
FictionalCharacter · 26/12/2021 22:16

What’s with all the people saying that despite the fact the kids saw her hit the dog, she can’t have done because he would have yelped? Dogs don’t necessarily make a noise unless they’re badly hurt.
Knocking a kitten off a table, hitting the dog, being nasty to your child? Nope, she wouldn’t be welcome in my house again. Unless dh had a stern word and she agreed never to do anything like this again.

OhWhyNot · 26/12/2021 22:15

Totally over the too (and absolute nonsense response) on here

Next time shut dog away until it calms down and the comment to your daughter isn’t going to damage her so what a grandparent pulls up a grandchild and you have a different opinion

Stop getting so uptight and looking for reasons to create a drama

KeyLimePies · 26/12/2021 22:14

I find the number of people minimising aggression towards pets really depressing.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 26/12/2021 22:14

5 hour drive or not, anyone who treated my animal like that would be leaving. No, dogs shouldn’t jump up but they have to learn and the MIL had no right to mete out punishment like that.

I am insistent on good manners from my animals but I will - and have - step in to protect them from people who feel entitled to behave like this towards them.

RoyalFamilyFan · 26/12/2021 22:13

You cant flick a kitten off a table. Do you mean she pushed a kitten off the table? Presumably, because the kitten is not allowed on a table?
That is not animal cruelty.

Poppinjay · 26/12/2021 22:13

I don't like dogs jumping up around me. You should not let that happen with guests.

Young dogs need to be taught this. They don't just know automatically that people don't like it. The OP had already addressed it once, i.e. she is teaching him not to do it.

The fact that he did it again while the OP's back was turned does not justify the MIL hitting him.

It's vile thing to do to a dog and a worse thing to do in front of the children.

OP, you or your DH need to speak frankly to your MIL about this. You cannot take a risk on her doing it again.

She also needs to be told that she must not say anything else to your DC that she wouldn't say in front of you.

She sounds like a nasty piece of work.

SnowdropSally · 26/12/2021 22:10

[quote fallfallfall]@Prescottdanni123 dog owner for decades with multiple breeds and fully understand how people will smack a dog on the nose, or put up their knee for a jumping dog.

i don't resort to those techniques but certainly would understand how someone else might.[/quote]
Poor show if you allow anyone to smack your dog. It says all I need to know about you.

FuckeryIsAfoot · 26/12/2021 22:10

You're wondering if you would be unreasonable to not let her come back if she ever shows aggression towards your pets again?
YABU for not manhandling the bitch out the door the moment your kids told you what she did. She is an animal abuser and has no business being around animals or children.

What is wrong with people!?

DownWhichOfLate · 26/12/2021 22:09

It’s young and excitable. You should have had it shut in another room whilst your mil arrived, then slowly and calmly introduced them. Presuming they may have not even met before given age, distance, covid etc.

PieMistee · 26/12/2021 22:08

@cocktailclub

Everyone who says kick MIL out, this is the grandmother of their children and mother of the DH. Surely you don't end a relationship like that without trying to repair it first? She hit the dog but doesn't sound like she cruelly beat it : btw I am a dog lover and wouldn't hit a dog but I would be prepared to educate a family member about how to deal with the dogs behaviour instead. Sounds like she was misguided. And the kitten issue again not great but could be fixed with a discussion and directly asking her not to.

I think there's been a huge leap from some unwelcome behaviour which is not animal
Cruelty as such but not the correct way to deal with animals and throwing mil out.

Calling the dd selfish is also out of order but really would she be deliberately horrible or believe she is helping

I know a lot of Mumsnetters hate mils but a lot of you will also be mil one day and perhaps would appreciate a different approach to the things you will do that will annoy your dil

Well said
fallfallfall · 26/12/2021 22:08

@Prescottdanni123 dog owner for decades with multiple breeds and fully understand how people will smack a dog on the nose, or put up their knee for a jumping dog.

i don't resort to those techniques but certainly would understand how someone else might.

Pixxie7 · 26/12/2021 22:08

Hitting the dog is a definite no from me. As far as your daughter is concerned she definitely could have handled it better ie. I know you don’t really want to but could you wear the jumper for a couple of hours or just whilst we have dinner, just to please him.

BringBackThinEyebrows · 26/12/2021 22:06

@SoniaFouler

But you don’t KNOW she hit the dog. Why didn’t the dog yelp or bark or make any noise if it had just been hit? My guess is she pushed him down/away and the children took that as “she just hit him” when she didn’t
I've witnessed an incident where a dog was hit hard by a man- the dog didn't make a sound. Why are people assuming the dog would have made a noise?

If anyone harmed my pets they would never see me again.

Prescottdanni123 · 26/12/2021 22:04

@fallfallfall

excuse me but what is the big deal with hitting a dog that is jumping up or being a nuisance? it's even suggested when dogs jump up you knee them in their belly or push them backwards, which to me seems much worse than a smack on the nose? sounds to me like you're making excuses for a poorly trained dog who rushes to the door. some people don't like that behavior.
@fallfallfall

Have you ever had a dog before? Where did you find the suggestion to knee a dog in their belly and push them backwards? That sounds like something from a 1940s dog training manual. A one year old dog is still a puppy. Young and daft and very excitable. And young, daft, excitable puppies do things that they are not supposed to do, like jump up. It takes a while for a dog to become fully trained and you need to have patience with them. There are far better ways of dealing with a dog that is jumping up than smacking them.

DrSbaitso · 26/12/2021 21:57

You flick my kitten off a surface, I fucking flick you out of my home. I don't need any more of your company to know you're also the kind of person who makes children cry and hits dogs. And I don't care how long you drove or that you're my husband's mother. You're cruel to animals and kids, you can stay somewhere else.

Prescottdanni123 · 26/12/2021 21:57

@SoniaFouler

Why were you letting your dog jump up on people? I find that so rude and she could have found it frightening. Not to say she should hit him but surely a dog would help or cry out if had been hit? I think she probably just pushed him away, which I would have done if a dog jumped on me.
@SoniaFouler

He is 1 year old. Still a puppy and very excitable. Excitable puppies get carried away and do things they shouldn't.

Dogs don't always yelp when they hurt themselves, in a similar way to how humans don't always yell 'Owww' when they hurt themselves.

SheldonesqueTheBstard · 26/12/2021 21:56

Sorry. Posted too soon.

There would not be a second chance.

SheldonesqueTheBstard · 26/12/2021 21:55

My old rescue never made a sound when we got her. She was broken on body and spirit.

She learned quickly (I believe) that to do so would get a bigger hiding.

It took her over 5 years to bark and she’d been so quiet that I didn’t even think it was her until she repeated it.

If anyone had done that to my girl they would not be welcome again.

If I’d witnessed it? I would not have been responsible for what came out of my mouth.

There

NMC2022 · 26/12/2021 21:54

And I f a dog rushes to the door, I tend to do what my friends would want which is totally ignore the dog, turn my back if I need to, say hi to friend etc. Then when the dog settles/sits you go over and fuss them

GayParis · 26/12/2021 21:53

@fallfallfall

excuse me but what is the big deal with hitting a dog that is jumping up or being a nuisance? it's even suggested when dogs jump up you knee them in their belly or push them backwards, which to me seems much worse than a smack on the nose? sounds to me like you're making excuses for a poorly trained dog who rushes to the door. some people don't like that behavior.
You don't hit defenceless animals? Would you hit your kid for running up to you when you came in the door and trying to get your attention?

The issue is that you just don't hit things. You don't hit animals, you don't hit kids. If you do, you're quite frankly a cunt.

stillvicarinatutu · 26/12/2021 21:53
  1. If mol is scared of the dog she has the choice NOT to visit a house with a dog . The dog lives there - she doesn't . For me she either accepts that on a visit to someone else's home their rules
Apply if she doesn't visit . End of !
  1. She doesn't have a right to come I to someone else's
Home and abide their pets or children.
  1. I'd have shown her out . Politely. Not .