Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mil hit the dog

568 replies

LilyTheMink · 26/12/2021 20:58

We have a 1 year old medium sized dog. He isn't badly behaved and doesn't normally jump up. When MIL arrived for Xmas, he was a little excited - but honestly nothing hyperactive at all.
He jumped around when MIL was hugging my daughter and I told him to get down. I turned my back and he must have done it again as suddenly he was sneezing and shaking his head. This is what he does when he's knocked his nose on something eg. the coffee table.
The kids told me that MIL had hit him.
I wasn't sure what to do and spend the rest of the time keeping him out of her way - although to be honest he did that himself anyway.
She's been horrible to our pets before - once flicking our 3 month off kitten off the table like he was a breadcrumb.
DH has just grown a spine and spoken to her about another ussue - she told our 10 yo DD she was "selfish and didn't think about other people" because she didn't want to wear the Xmas jumper DH had bought her. (This was said in private, but DD luckily told me as she was upset by it).
Wibu to tell her she's not welcome to ever come back if she shows aggression to our pets again, or speaks badly to our kids?

OP posts:
LakieLady · 27/12/2021 06:47

@MyOtherCarIsAPorsche

I will shove any animal away which tries to jump up at me. If that's classed as 'hitting' so be it.

Is anyone suggesting that it's enjoyable to have a dog, pissing with excitement (because that's what they do) jumping up at people?

I hope you have a very good awareness of canine body language, then. Doing that to a dog that's been abused and traumatised could well lead to a nasty bite.

And very few dogs piss with excitement much beyond puppyhood.

Beachgirl33 · 27/12/2021 06:47

@LilyTheMink

Yes I did think I'd get a comment along the lines of my dog deserved it. He didn't. He's in training, he is 1, and I didn't 'let him' jump up. We all have to be firm and kind with him and get him to behave properly. She was not scared. She is not a person who ever gets scared to be honest. She is an ex-nurse she is utterly no-nonsense, old school, stiff upper lip and takes no prisoners on any account.
No your dog didn’t deserve it, neither did your kitten or your daughter. She sounds a right horror. I would call her out on it. Advise her that’s the second and last time she will be cruel to your pets and if she has nothing positive to say to your kids she should say nothing at all Flowers
autieok · 27/12/2021 06:39

@LesLavandes

I don't like dogs jumping up around me. You should not let that happen with guests.
She's training him they don't learn instantly and Christmas is always a challenging time for pets.
LakieLady · 27/12/2021 06:28

@TooManyAnimals94

Dogs shouldn't jump up. I wouldn't smack one on the nose but he would get a knee to the chest from me.
My friend's boyfriend did that to my first dog, a 10 month old rescue who'd had no training whatsoever until he came to me.

The BF never set foot inside the door again. And got a massive bollocking from me.

Terfydactyl · 27/12/2021 06:17

@Pixxie7

Hitting the dog is a definite no from me. As far as your daughter is concerned she definitely could have handled it better ie. I know you don’t really want to but could you wear the jumper for a couple of hours or just whilst we have dinner, just to please him.
To please a man she should wear a bloody jumper she doesn't want to? Can you hear yourself? Anything else she should do to please men?

There are some really strange people on this thread, from bee kiiiiind and those that think all animals are trained the moment they are at home. I mean babies and little kids take years to train but a puppy/kitten, well hell they should know from the first time you tell them.

Its pretty simple, dont hit children or animals.

LakieLady · 27/12/2021 06:10

@Mamamia7962

If she had hurt the dog he would have yelped. Not sure how you can flick a kitten off a table, do you mean pushed?

The way she spoke to your daughter was out of order.

Dogs don't necessarily yelp when hit. And hitting a dog on the nose is very wrong, their noses are several thousand times more sensitive than hours.

If she'd hit one of my terriers on the nose, they'd have retaliated with their teeth.

Furries · 27/12/2021 04:51

@SoniaFouler - you’ve really stood out on this thread with your doubts.

There are multiple reasons why a dog might not yelp/scream/bark/make any noise if bopped on the muzzle/slapped etc etc.

Anyway, for everyone else who has, or encounters, jumpy dogs. First rule is - don’t hit them!

Most effective rule, as an owner, is remove dog from situation - ideally before the event could happen. If you have a “jumpy” dog, then set up a space/room for said dog before your guests arrive.

For those trying to stop dogs from jumping up, don’t turn your back on them as “punishment”. Dogs turn their back to another dog as a sign of “submission/I’m not a threat”.

As an owner, you need to teach your dog that jumping up has no benefit at all. Reward/praise them for all paws on the floor!

If a dog jumps up at you, do t hit it or push it away with your hands. And don’t turn your back on it. Just walk towards it, gently, they will eventually climb down.

Best thing, in puppy stage, is to encourage and reward for all four paws on the floor. Doesn’t matter if it’s a chihuahua or a Great Dane. No one should have to tolerate a bad mannered dog.

OP - I’m with others on this thread. The kitten thing would have made me seriously think about how to handle future visits. That kind of flippant dismissal re animals would render that person unwelcome in my house.

FuckeryIsAfoot · 27/12/2021 04:49

@Jaguar77

You let your unrurly dog jump up on an old woman . Your ungrateful daughter refused to put on a jumper an action that would have taken seconds and pleased her grandmother who probably just wanted a photo. All of this after a 5 hour car journey.

On a side note keep your cats off the dining table it's not sanitary

OPs daughter isn't a performing seal. She is a human being and is entitled to not put a piece of clothing on in order to please someone else. Do you not get that?

On a side note, your cats are on the table when you leave the house anyway. Stop kidding yourself, sweetie.

Ginmaker · 27/12/2021 04:30

To be fair whenever we or our friends have had an overexcitable pup we have arrived with clear instructions that the dog will jump up but as part of training we were told to gently push him away or ignore the behaviour until they were calm then reward profusely. 'Four paws on the floor for visitors'. Works well but needs time

echt · 27/12/2021 04:23

@Jaguar77

You let your unrurly dog jump up on an old woman . Your ungrateful daughter refused to put on a jumper an action that would have taken seconds and pleased her grandmother who probably just wanted a photo. All of this after a 5 hour car journey.

On a side note keep your cats off the dining table it's not sanitary

She didn't let her dog jump. The age of the the OP's MIL is not mentioned. Why should GD perform for anyone? It's not cats, a kitten actually , that was the issue, it was the MIL's behaviour.

She. was. not. in.her. own. house.

garlictwist · 27/12/2021 04:17

I would never hit a dog but honestly if it jumped up I would be scared and feel like doing it in self defence. Perhaps you need to control your dog better.

Ginmaker · 27/12/2021 04:16

@RoyalFamilyFan

So people are supposed to just put up with dogs jumping all over them?
You ever had kids who behave unreasonably? Do you hit them when they do? I guess you don't. No, no one has to put up with it but there are obviously better ways of education that don't require physical violence and a puppy is still like a toddler. I don't have kids but I'm damn well aware of the many options beyond physical harm to deter them from kicking, biting, shouting, pulling etc.
Ginmaker · 27/12/2021 04:11

@TooManyAnimals94

Dogs shouldn't jump up. I wouldn't smack one on the nose but he would get a knee to the chest from me.
In which case you are on your way to creating a defensive and possibly violent animal.
Jaguar77 · 27/12/2021 03:51

You let your unrurly dog jump up on an old woman .
Your ungrateful daughter refused to put on a jumper an action that would have taken seconds and pleased her grandmother who probably just wanted a photo.
All of this after a 5 hour car journey.

On a side note keep your cats off the dining table it's not sanitary

SantaClawsServiette · 27/12/2021 02:24

Thanks for popping by Ceasar Millan.

Oh come on. There is a huge difference between an idiot like CM and saying that any kind of physical discipline with a dog is inappropriate.

The amount of anthropomorphize that is going on in this thread is unbelievable. It may be that the MIL was inappropriately rough with the dog. But it's hard to tell because people are so set on the idea that dogs are children who will be traumatized in an ongoing way due to even a small tap.

So we end up with all of these dogs who continue to jump up at people and are potentially dangers to themselves when they hurt someone.

MerryChristmas21 · 27/12/2021 02:00

@Sunflowers095

You knew she hit the dog and let her stay? You're an awful pet owner if so.

If you're going to let people abuse your dog and the abuser to be in your home, give the dog to someone who will care for it properly.

FFS, she smacked it in the nose (which used to be a common way of disciplining a dog) she didn't kick it!

I wouldn't do it, & I would definitely give out at anyone else doing it these days, but it's not 'animal abuse/cruelty'.

Children also often do see/understand nuances in behaviour.

My friend was standing talking to me, she had her arms folded, he DD (8) came running over & ran into her. She kind of bounced off & landed on her bum. She then got indignant that her mum had pushed her over

I believe the MIL smacked the dogs nose - which is outdated & she'd be left very clear it was not to happen again, but the over reactions in this thread are ridiculous.

As for the grandmother tells child she's being selfish, it's not ideal, but it's not the end of the world as we know it either.

jellybutton1 · 27/12/2021 01:17

[quote MyOtherCarIsAPorsche]@jellybutton1

Thank you - you sound like a great, responsible and respectful dog owner. Animals deserve no less.

I always ask for permission to approach a dog - I have no qualms about appreciating well behaved and well looked after pets.

The saying that dogs resemble their owners goes for behaviour too.

[/quote]
Thank you. And I really appreciate folks who respect dogs personal space as well. I actually have far more issues with this, than I do with my dogs giving people their personal space.

Dogs are easy to train. People, not so much. And I'm afraid to say there's an awful lot of pandering these days where people treat dogs like humans. You don't need to hit a human or animal to get it to behave, but you do need to be consistent and absolutely firm each time for complete 'no-go' behaviours. People saying their visitors can do one if they don't like their dogs jumping up? Just ridiculous.

I'm wary of strange dogs for good reason. I don't want them jumping up at me - it frightens me. I say that as a dog owner. Difference is, I know my dogs. My dogs are large and will likely minorly hurt someone if they were to jump up. One of ours was particularly bad for it when she came to us - she busted my lip with her nail pretty badly 'just being friendly'. That was two days in. A week in the behaviour was gone. No hitting here. And lets just say she is a stubborn breed type.

Branleuse · 27/12/2021 01:16

this is so bloody weird. Honestly if my dog jumped at ANYONE id forgive them a smacking it away - within reason. Its not how you train a dog, but if the dog is pissing someone off then what happens is my fault. I would just tell your husbands mother, please, if the dog jumps, dont hit him, it makes it worse, we make him sit till he gets any attention, or whatever. No need to react to his mother as if shes just come in and beat the kids. She is not thinking of your pet as your family like you do, she thinks its just an animal thats freaking her out

Buildingthefuture · 27/12/2021 01:15

@EbonanzaScrooge I’m not sure which small breeds you might be referring to? I have Chihuahuas (literally the smallest dogs you can get) and they are in no way considered adult at 9/10 months?
And no @oakleaffy, they wouldn’t necessarily. Mine wouldn't’ (and I have big dogs as well) they would be frightened and confused and would have come to find me. At which point, MIL or not, she’d have been down the road!!!

NumberTheory · 27/12/2021 01:12

I think there’s been a huge shift in understanding of how to treat dogs in the last 30 years or so. This may just be a matter of educating her better. When I was growing up in the 80s and tapping a dog on the nose to stop it doing unwanted stuff was often positioned as the kind way to discipline and train a pet. So if you let the dog jump up (and it’s really hard to see how MIL could have hit it’s nose if she was hugging a grandchild and it wasn’t jumping up) then this may just be the way she has always expected to tell a dog to stop.

I think you need a talk with her first, not a blanket ban or resentful surveillance.

oakleaffy · 27/12/2021 01:12

@jellybutton1

The fact the dog was shaking it's head and sneezing suggests not only did she hit the dog, she hit it hard enough to cause discomfort and pain. My dogs have bumped their noses off things and have never done this. She's wrong to hit the dog. She's even more wrong to hit the dog hard.

This being said, whilst 1 year is technically a puppy, it's not puppy enough to be getting overexcited at visitors like this, lockdown pup or not. Unless I was well briefed on what training the owner wanted me to take part in for their dog when I arrived, then I'd be asking for the dogs lead, and leading it to another room until it had calmed down. Overexcited dogs jumping around can and frequently do, cause unintended injuries, usually to people. Ever had a broken nose from an exciting dog jumping around but not up?

Your dog is still jumping around not simply because it's a 'puppy', but because you've not managed the behaviour effectively. I love dogs, but I still expect peace from being bombarded by overexcited dogs at friends houses, as they know to expect from me when they visit me. The dogs aren't allowed to greet visitors at all until they're calm. They quickly switch on when they want something (ie - greeting a guest) that the best way to get what they want, is to be calm about, with really very minimal training.

Discipline doesn't equal abuse.

That being said, he likely won't bother her a second time. If you'd disciplined him, she wouldn't have to. And I agree with another poster - an unknown dog jumping up or around me gets a knee put up against it's chest, so it can't scratch me or hurt me. I'm absolutely allowed personal space, and if the owners don't like it, they should train their dogs better. I'm not entering into a wrestling match pushing dogs off me. A) I shouldn't have to, B) It easily encourages it further by 'making it a game'. Turning your back and ignoring a dog doing this is all well and good, until the dog physically hurts you.

Guests absolutely have the right to expect personal space away from animals over-excitedly jumping up or around them when they walk into someones homes. It's basic manners. The dog doesn't know this - but will if you teach it. It doesn't take even the most stubborn dogs that long to learn.

Absolutely! People say ''Only one year old'' but a dog at one should be able to greet people calmly without leaping up.

It doesn't take long.

So many untrained dogs about though , at moment.
A farmer had scatty ''He's only a pup-pee'' {Adult sized} dog run amok and try to attack his cattle and then his working dog~ He was entitled to shoot it.

Dogs need training to keep them and other people and animals safe.

MyOtherCarIsAPorsche · 27/12/2021 01:09

@jellybutton1

Thank you - you sound like a great, responsible and respectful dog owner. Animals deserve no less.

I always ask for permission to approach a dog - I have no qualms about appreciating well behaved and well looked after pets.

The saying that dogs resemble their owners goes for behaviour too.

jellybutton1 · 27/12/2021 01:09

'Regardless of how long you keep your dog away from a new visitor, when the dog first sees them it'll be excitement. So you can lock it in another room but as soon as you open the door you have the problem you would have had at the front door.'

As soon as the dog shows too much excitement when it's greeting guests, you return it back to the room and wait until it's calmed down. Again, and again, and again. Rinse and repeat.

It's annoying, and hard work for maybe the first 2-3 occasions until it clicks. 3 rescue dogs here. It's really not difficult to have calm dogs that learn over-excited behaviour isn't acceptable except at actual play time.

CallMeRachel · 27/12/2021 01:06

Yanbu. She’s a horrible uncaring person. Hurting animals is never a good look no matter how folk try and justify it Hmm
I wouldn’t allow her back in your home again.

A terrible example to set young children also who should be taught patience, care and compassion imo.

oakleaffy · 27/12/2021 01:03

Jumping up really is a behaviour that needs never to be allowed to develop, a calm greeting is much better for everyone~ Especially the dog!
I had our first dog kicked by someone whom she jumped up at~ so have been very careful since then to do only a calm greeting.
One year old is plenty old enough to know not to jump up, or put dog in another room until everything is calm.
Not everyone likes dogs, and some can be really painful if they jump up raking one with their nails~Especially poodle crosses who often have talons in my experience.

If the dog had been really hurt, he or she would have made a noise.

Swipe left for the next trending thread