Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this isn't a good idea?

84 replies

thesailsaflow · 26/12/2021 14:05

Me and my ex have an 8 year old daughter together. We have had our moments but get along very well now, I'd say we are friends, we confide in each other and I can rely on him and he me.

We have been in talks for the past few months about getting a dog that we will share. He recently lost his dog - a Rottweiler - she was lovely and very well trained and whilst I would look after her on occasion, he bought it with his ex girlfriend so it was not a shared dog with me.

The kind of dog I would like is a cockapoo or Labrador. However, he called me this morning and said he had found an English bull terrier pup for sale and was going to get it next week. He asked if I'd be okay to help out with it - no financial responsibility but watching/training/walking it whilst he is at work (I am a student and work at night, he works during the day). I said I'd have a think.

My concern is number one, having read up on these types of dogs, they aren't for novice owners. So although my ex did own one previous dog I don't think he realised how difficult these types are to train, also I have absolutely no experience of dogs or training them. Secondly, and this may be a stereotype, but I've read these dogs can be quite aggressive. My ex claims this is all in the way they are raised. However, after speaking to a vet (my aunt) she says there is something in their brains that can make them turn without warning no matter how well trained or raised the dog is.

I know I am absolutely within my rights to say I don't feel comfortable helping out with the dog. But then the worry comes with when my daughter is at his house, what if it attacks her? She is with him 50 percent of the time and it has really worried me.

I wish he could just be into the stereotypical 'family dogs' but he's not and he is adamant he is not changing his mind and going ahead with it.

AIBU to have these reservations? Am I buying into the stereotype? Is there just as much risk with a Labrador?

If not, what do I do?

OP posts:
thesailsaflow · 26/12/2021 21:03

@ScabbyHorse

I don't understand why you would look after the dog in the day, if you work nights, don't you need to sleep in the day?
I work 5 pm to 10 pm
OP posts:
NeverDropYourMooncup · 26/12/2021 18:56

It's also worthwhile bearing in mind that before the 'OMG FIGHTING DOG' stories, there were DEVIL DOG EATS CHILD news items. Usually featuring Rottweilers and the occasional GSD with Rotties.

So you've had an as-seen-in-the-media Devil Dog around your kid. The type that, had MN been around at the time, posters would have been saying must never be around children or off the lead.

The worst thing about bull terriers is that a) they can't hear you unless you're trying to open the fridge door quietly, b) their tails wag really, really fast at shin height, leaving a trail of destruction everywhere they go until you take all ornaments, cups and computer equipment out of reach of their joy at living and c) they have very poor deceleration once they're at warp speed, so if they get the hang of a visual signal for recall, it's rather like a small bulldozer coming straight towards your legs.

PineappleRisotto · 26/12/2021 17:50

we respect each other enough to listen and compromise

But not about this dog, it appears.

ScabbyHorse · 26/12/2021 17:29

I don't understand why you would look after the dog in the day, if you work nights, don't you need to sleep in the day?

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 26/12/2021 15:52

Yes. They are the most aggressive, untrainable breed of dog ever!

Alternatively, they are a large terrier with an odd shaped head and chest. They are not a 'biddable' dog, like labradors and other dogs that have been long bred as working dogs. They are more independently minded and may or may not do as asked.

I've known many and the only one that was aggressive was deliberately trained that way and was put down as it was too dangerous to deal with. Not the breed's fault, the fault of the despicable twat that raised it.

They do take additional patience, a lot of it. They do need a firm and loving hand and they are odd little toads. I say little as they stay puppy like for years, bloody years. They twizzle and turn, zoomie and run circular laps. But they are lazy toads, walking cushions that like nothing better than to sleep on you, be active for just a few hours in a day.

Stubborn cuddles on legs!

To think this isn't a good idea?
Hippychicken1 · 26/12/2021 15:44

Honestly I wouldn’t worry
If he is getting it from a puppy then he can train it properly
He’s already proved that he can train and look after a Rottie which is a much bigger dog so I would be confident he can do the same with a EBT
I have a french bulldog and despite everyone saying how cute and sweet he is i truly wouldn’t trust him with a stuffed toy let alone a small child 😂
He’s absolutely vicious when he gets in a strop and I’m an experienced dog owner of large breeds for many years and my Frenchie is by far far the nastiest dog I’ve ever had
Many people would sell him or have him PTS
I won’t do either as I know what triggers him and can pretty much avoid anything happening with him

MolkosTeenageAngst · 26/12/2021 15:27
  • I've not really thought about it from this POV. Can I ask why not though? We already have a daughter together, it doesn't get more tying than that. We have been split for 7 years, there is absolutely no physical/romantic attraction on either side. We have both moved on and had other partners since. He is a genuinely good person, and we care about each other. He is a great dad and although there will always be things which we disagree on, we respect each other enough to listen and compromise. He is there when I am in a jam, whether that involves our daughter or not. He is there and helps out financially (not just child maintenance).

I couldn't think of a better person to do this with to be honest.*

Having a child is entirely different. You both have legal and financial obligations and protections when it comes to your DD which will not exist when it comes to the dog.

You say things are good now which is great, but a dog will likely live for 12+ years and things can change. You may have the time and commitment for a puppy/ dog now and he may have the finances for it but what happens if that changes in the future? What happens if one or both of you have a new partner who isn’t happy with the set-up? What happens if you decide in the future to get a job and no longer have the time for the dog? What happens if his financial situation changes and he no longer wants to pay for the dog? What happens if one or both of you have another child with new partners? What happens if one of you wants to move away? Who is responsible if there is a large vet bill? What happens if the dog is injured in your care and your ex feels it is your fault and expects you to foot the bill? What happens if he decides he doesn’t want the dog anymore and wants to rehome it?

Getting a dog is a huge commitment and it seems absurd to go into it with somebody who you are not committed to considering there will be no legal protections. A dog isn’t like a child, if he is the legal owner and in the future has a partner who decides she doesn’t want him sharing a dog with his ex he can remove all contact and there will be nothing you can do. If he decides to sell it or use it as a pawn in any parenting disputes there will be nothing you can do. If he dumps the dog on you one day and refuses to be involved with it anymore there is no dog-maintenance you can legally seek out. Just because he is able to compromise and listen with regards to your child doesn’t mean he will with a dog.

There are just too many things that can change over the next 12+ years that I really think you are foolish to risk investing into sharing a dog with an ex, regardless of the breed.

Candlyflosss · 26/12/2021 15:18

It’s actually quite a sweet natured dog breed but like any dog you just need to train it properly.

PAW326 · 26/12/2021 15:17

I have just rescued an English Bull Terrier. She is my third one although I have owned other breeds too. They are fabulous dogs, hilarious and love to make you laugh. They are like the clowns of the dog world. I have never had any issues with aggression at all but they are terriers so will do as they please these and do not give a fig about you want. I would not let mine off a lead as she will disappear and has no recall, it's not because she is aggressive. They were bred as family pets, look up James Hinks and read about their history. I love them and wouldn't want any other breed now BUT they are really, really willful, stubborn and more akin to a toddler than a dog. They are very hard work to train as they are clever but use this to get their own way.
They need a lot of attention and directing onto what they can do as they will find their own fun if you aren't watching them. A really good book to look at is called "when pigs fly" by Jane Killion. .
Good luck whatever you decide.

custardbear66 · 26/12/2021 15:07

In my experience with these dogs (I owned one a years ago) they are lovely natured. Mine grew up with my dc and was loving and patient. But they are strong, boisterous and notoriously stubborn to train. You will also get lots of people buying into the bull breed stereotypes.

I wouldn't be worried about this breed as part of a family but I would worry about training it and managing its strength and energy. Hence why I never got another. Loved mine to bits though, he was a nutter but absolutely gorgeous.

ballstoit · 26/12/2021 15:07

Any kind of dog can turn on a person and be aggressive. However,lock jaw breeds, such as bull terriers, do more damage, more quickly and it's much harder to intervene once they are attacking. I would be really worried about my child spending time with one with an inexperienced owner.

Nocutenamesleft · 26/12/2021 15:03

I’m on the fence with regards to English bull terriers.

My step sister just paid upwards of £10,000 for an American bull terrier and I would never allow them to stay on their own with it. Frightening animal In the wrong hands.

Nocutenamesleft · 26/12/2021 14:59

Cockapoos are nutters

Poodles which are highly strung. And a cocker spaniel. Bound to be a nightmare breed!

BoredAndUnfulfilled · 26/12/2021 14:59

EBTs can be amazing dogs, but they require a LOT of training and patience (just like any other large breed). They are better with more experienced owners. I personally adore them, but definitely wouldn’t recommend them to most people, you need to be able to commit to them like a full time job.

WorraLiberty · 26/12/2021 14:56

@thesailsaflow

Regardless of opinions on whether I share with my ex....what about the breed? Am I being ridiculous?
If you're still happy to go ahead despite him controlling everything, you'll have to do your research just as you would with any breed.

Start with looking at sites specifically for that breed and look at the FAQs etc - some might have forums attached where owners/breeders chat.

Don't expect him to take much notice of your verdict though if it doesn't match his.

thesailsaflow · 26/12/2021 14:51

Regardless of opinions on whether I share with my ex....what about the breed? Am I being ridiculous?

OP posts:
WorraLiberty · 26/12/2021 14:34

he called me this morning and said he had found an English bull terrier pup for sale and was going to get it next week.

he is adamant he is not changing his mind and going ahead with it

And yet you say I couldn't think of a better person to do this with to be honest Confused

How about someone mature enough to make a mutual decision?

If he's not interested in your opinion at this stage, what makes you think he will be in the future?

Don't invite this stress into your life.

Watchingpeppa12 · 26/12/2021 14:32

Bull terriers are much more likely to be dog aggressive than human aggressive also.

Watchingpeppa12 · 26/12/2021 14:32

I think it’s fine, especially if he’s already owned a rottie. especially if he is getting this dog from a young puppy, it can grow with your daughter too. I bet you’ll love him

thesailsaflow · 26/12/2021 14:29

@Pinkdelight3

he is adamant he is not changing his mind and going ahead with it.

I would say no on this basis. He wants you to help out with it, but won't take your views into account. He needs to have a proper conversation and be more considerate about compromising. Probably he can't which is why he's an ex, but no way do you need to suck it up just because "he is adamant". You can be adamant too, can't you?

Absolutely. However, I would love a dog and can't do it on my own at the moment. I would be up for helping out with any breed but I'm worried about the aggressiveness of this particular breed.
OP posts:
simonisnotme · 26/12/2021 14:29

he wants a dog = he looks after, trains, picks up shit of said dog
not your circus not your (monkey) dog
dont get involved

WorraLiberty · 26/12/2021 14:29

he called me this morning and said he had found an English bull terrier pup for sale and was going to get it next week.

That's the point at which the conversation would've ended for me.

He made that decision alone so he can deal with his dog alone.

thesailsaflow · 26/12/2021 14:28

@MolkosTeenageAngst

YANBU to say no to helping out with and looking after the dog and honestly I think it is absurd to consider getting any dog (including a Labrador/ poodle cross etc) to share with an ex.

Obviously in terms of him wanting to get a dog you have no say in what kind of dog he gets but I would be making it clear you aren’t in a position to help out. And truly I think that should apply regardless of what kind of dog he wants, don’t tie yourself to your ex in this unnecessary way.

I've not really thought about it from this POV. Can I ask why not though? We already have a daughter together, it doesn't get more tying than that. We have been split for 7 years, there is absolutely no physical/romantic attraction on either side. We have both moved on and had other partners since. He is a genuinely good person, and we care about each other. He is a great dad and although there will always be things which we disagree on, we respect each other enough to listen and compromise. He is there when I am in a jam, whether that involves our daughter or not. He is there and helps out financially (not just child maintenance).

I couldn't think of a better person to do this with to be honest.

OP posts:
Aprilx · 26/12/2021 14:28

Why on earth would you get a dog with an ex? A dog needs one home, one owner, one family, not being split in two. The breed is almost secondary here.

Pinkdelight3 · 26/12/2021 14:25

he is adamant he is not changing his mind and going ahead with it.

I would say no on this basis. He wants you to help out with it, but won't take your views into account. He needs to have a proper conversation and be more considerate about compromising. Probably he can't which is why he's an ex, but no way do you need to suck it up just because "he is adamant". You can be adamant too, can't you?

Swipe left for the next trending thread