Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this isn't a good idea?

84 replies

thesailsaflow · 26/12/2021 14:05

Me and my ex have an 8 year old daughter together. We have had our moments but get along very well now, I'd say we are friends, we confide in each other and I can rely on him and he me.

We have been in talks for the past few months about getting a dog that we will share. He recently lost his dog - a Rottweiler - she was lovely and very well trained and whilst I would look after her on occasion, he bought it with his ex girlfriend so it was not a shared dog with me.

The kind of dog I would like is a cockapoo or Labrador. However, he called me this morning and said he had found an English bull terrier pup for sale and was going to get it next week. He asked if I'd be okay to help out with it - no financial responsibility but watching/training/walking it whilst he is at work (I am a student and work at night, he works during the day). I said I'd have a think.

My concern is number one, having read up on these types of dogs, they aren't for novice owners. So although my ex did own one previous dog I don't think he realised how difficult these types are to train, also I have absolutely no experience of dogs or training them. Secondly, and this may be a stereotype, but I've read these dogs can be quite aggressive. My ex claims this is all in the way they are raised. However, after speaking to a vet (my aunt) she says there is something in their brains that can make them turn without warning no matter how well trained or raised the dog is.

I know I am absolutely within my rights to say I don't feel comfortable helping out with the dog. But then the worry comes with when my daughter is at his house, what if it attacks her? She is with him 50 percent of the time and it has really worried me.

I wish he could just be into the stereotypical 'family dogs' but he's not and he is adamant he is not changing his mind and going ahead with it.

AIBU to have these reservations? Am I buying into the stereotype? Is there just as much risk with a Labrador?

If not, what do I do?

OP posts:
Chickenfarmer4 · 27/12/2021 23:00

When I was your little girl’s age, about 8 or 9, my father brought home the most gorgeous dogue de Bordeaux. He was a true mastiff, and had a terrible temper. If he was lying in front of a cupboard and you went to move him to get to it, he would go for you. From pup-hood he was arrogant. I am actually surprised that he never mauled one of us.

Bless his heart though, he was a terrific guard dog. He guarded our house with his life- we had an intruder once and I have never seen a man look so scared as a dog charged at him- think turner and hooch. Once, a staffie went to kill our terrier and he jumped in the way. He had his cheek torn off and the vet had to put him back together again 😬

He was a nasty piece of work though. From pup hood he seemed to hold contempt for all of us. I would hold my breath while stroking him. He scared the life out of me and my mother. He snapped a few times. My father got along with him alright, because he was the “master” but the dog thought he ranked above all women and children. It was so strange.

We have kept countless dogs, and they were all beautiful and wonderfully trained. My current dog is an absolute sap (BRT- I recommend strongly for a family with young children who want an “impressive” dog) but the mastiff wasn’t right. I’m sure his temperament was down to poor breeding or a developmental delay. Our other large dog knew he wasn’t right or to be trusted- if he came near me and so much as growled he would tackle him to the floor. It was like watching a bear and a lion fight- the other large dog had never so much as growled at a fly!!!!

I will say, that when the mastiff died I bawled. And I miss his quiet company. His pride. I miss sleeping at night knowing that my boy was downstairs guarding the house.

No, I wouldn’t recommend a mastiff type for a family with a young girl. It could work out well, but it could end terribly.

gamerchick · 27/12/2021 22:38

It doesn't matter what the breed OP. You need some input and he doesn't get to expect your help without it.

Tell him no, he's on his own and that's the end of it.

IggysPop · 27/12/2021 22:35

@TheGrinchsDog but Labradors top the bite list in absolute terms due to sheer numbers. It was the most popular dog in the UK that research by breed was undertaken (in 2016 - by an insurance company). Serious bites - including fatalities by breed - look a lot different. This is about bite force - with bull breeds featuring in the top 20. Rottweiler psi is right up there too.

Saracen · 27/12/2021 22:10

As a tactic to try to buy time to think about it, or to hope to discourage him from this breed, you could tell him that you absolutely will not help with the dog.

If he really needs your help to keep the dog, that might be enough to stop him. If he gets it anyway, you'll always have the option to change your mind later if you decide you want to be involved with the dog and feel confident about doing so.

Kookookachuu · 27/12/2021 18:46

I suggest you join a breed specific group on Facebook and ask if they would recommend this breed around children. Then show your ex their replies.

Beautiful3 · 27/12/2021 18:35

Personally I wouldn't want that breed near my child. I have a different breed who does bite sometimes. We can easily break it up. However yours will have a locked jaw, so you'll never be able to stop an attack. It would have to be killed. You are irresponsible if you let that dog around children.

LoveGrooveDanceParty · 27/12/2021 17:51

I've not really thought about it from this POV. Can I ask why not though? We already have a daughter together, it doesn't get more tying than that. We have been split for 7 years, there is absolutely no physical/romantic attraction on either side. We have both moved on and had other partners since. He is a genuinely good person, and we care about each other. He is a great dad and although there will always be things which we disagree on, we respect each other enough to listen and compromise.

Except on this one issue you’re posting on here about, of course. Zero ‘respect’ for your wishes, or any sort of ‘compromise’ since, as you said, he’s adamant it’s his way.

He is there when I am in a jam, whether that involves our daughter or not. He is there and helps out financially (not just child maintenance).

I couldn't think of a better person to do this with to be honest.

Maybe someone who is willing to listen, and take into consideration your point of view on the breed?

If he expects or wants you to help out with this, you get equal say on the breed.

happychristmasbum · 27/12/2021 17:41

YANBU. It isn't what you agreed, so the answer is no.

FateHasRedesignedMost · 27/12/2021 17:31

I would never get a bull breed.

They were bred for bull fighting, then dog fighting (which sadly still goes on today). So they often have an aggressive streak towards other dogs and smaller animals, a high tolerance to pain and their physical make up makes them a danger if they do turn; oversized powerful jaw, stocky muscular body, a powerful desire to bite and not release.

Add to this many ‘staffies’ in the U.K. are actually crossed with illegal bull breeds like the American pit bull, and may even have false papers.

ICouldHaveCheckedFirst · 27/12/2021 12:09

Will he expect you to look after the dog when he goes on holiday - 24 hours a day for a fortnight? At whose cost? Don't make assumptions.

If you want a dog, wait until you can have one on your own terms - your choice of breed for a start - not one that someone else has imposed on you.

TheGrinchsDog · 27/12/2021 12:00

Also it's a total misconception that these bull breeds were bred for fighting, they absolutely were not!

Read up on the breed histories, they were bred for jobs, herding, guarding flocks from predators, and nanny dogs for children.

As those jobs died out people repurposed the dogs for other work. Sadly this included idiots using them to fight each other but that was not what they were bred for at all in any way!

They now have a terrible rep because of wankers who fight their dogs, drug dealers who use them as status symbols and idiots who don't train correctly.

The myth that they've always been fighting dogs is perpetuated by people who don't know any better and should.

TheGrinchsDog · 27/12/2021 11:55

FWIW Labradors cause more injuries over the year than most any other breed IIRC.

The problem isn't breed of dog, it's upbringing and training of the dog.

So you could get a lab and do nothing with it, and it could possibly be aggressive. Or you get a Bully breed and do nothing with it, could possibly end up aggressive.

IMO Bully breeds are pretty great dogs, high energy in short bursts, then sleep for the rest of the day. Good with children and other animals if correctly introduced and socialised (and children properly trained not to pull/harrass or annoy the dog!), they do have a high prey drive so be careful around smaller animals such as cats or rabbits.

Personally I'd go bull breed over lab but I like a chonky dog. I've got one and he is awesome, he absolutely loves kids, they are the joy in his life, cats and rabbits less so ha ha!

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 27/12/2021 11:20

Not KC classes though. They aren't always right for a Bullie, who will often see the other people and dogs as got to be played with, no matter what.

I made that mistake and it took 2 dog behaviourists to set me straight again. Most Bullies need to be persuaded that doing as asked is their idea. Coaxing them with treats is not the best way - which is why the Pigs Might Fly book is essential reading.

They are hard work OP. Maybe get him the book to give him some idea of what he is considering.

Hankunamatata · 27/12/2021 11:13

I would encourage ex to take dd to specific puppy training sessions so she can learn.

Hankunamatata · 27/12/2021 11:12

The breeds fine, they can be super cute! I would change the arrangement that you are happy to have a dog sitter role rather than shared ownership.

RandomMess · 27/12/2021 11:04

My concern would be your DD being old enough to seemingly help with the training but a actually getting it wrong and causing issues.

I have a small terrier and I always she was rather dim a rescue that has only learned 3 words ever. I am know wondering if she just doesn't give a shit and stubbornly does what the hell she wants unless food is involved Hmm

The walking cushion sums her up.

Daenerys77 · 27/12/2021 10:55

Trust your instincts. And the dog sharing scheme sounds like a very bad idea unless you have a written agreement covering all possible eventualities.

MsAgnesDiPesto · 27/12/2021 10:39

I don’t think you are looking at this in the long enough term.

  1. This dog will still be alive after your daughter reaches adulthood. That’s a long time to be voluntarily linked to your ex.
  1. Presumably you are not intending to be at university and working part time at night for the next 15 years. Given that, there will come a time where you are also out at work full time (probably within 3 years) during the day. What is the plan for looking after the dog then? Will you split the cost of doggy daycare or a frequent walker? Will the dog be at your house or his?
  1. Have you thought about what will happen when either of you gets a new partner? Will you want a dog with them, to be part of your new family and live with you full time? Where does that leave the shared dog?

This idea might be attractive right now, but your circumstances are going to change a lot in fairly near future, and you must put the welfare of the dog first. Your plan doesn’t do that.

Dozer · 27/12/2021 10:34

I think it’s inadviseable for you to provide free dog care services for your ex, for any dog.

Agree with your concerns about the breed.

Also agree with PPs that ex acting unilaterally seems disrespectful of your views and time, so you’d not be at all U to refuse to provide free services for this dog.

RealBecca · 27/12/2021 10:31

I also think youd be mad to tie yourself further to an ex.

RealBecca · 27/12/2021 10:29

The main problem here is as nice as you think your new friendship is with him, it isn't.

HE has decided, and HE is getting a dog that HE wants and expecting you to fall in line. He is walking over your conversation about something you both wanted and doing what suits him.

I'd be saying it's not what we discussed and I'll be having nothing to do with it. It's about boundaries and respect.

fairydust11 · 27/12/2021 10:26

Yanbu - tell him you don’t feel comfortable with him getting one as you don’t want it around your child and you won’t look after it either. Explain that your feelings won’t change and you’d prefer him to get the dog of your choice which you’ll be happy to help out with.

Tal45 · 27/12/2021 10:20

What's going to happen to the dog all day if you don't have it? He says he's going to get it whether you help or not but I'd be very concerned about a puppy that's left alone most of the day. That is not good at all IMO and unlikely to end in a well trained dog from other dogs I know that were left alone a lot as puppies.

JabNotInArm · 27/12/2021 10:00

she says there is something in their brains that can make them turn without warning no matter how well trained or raised the dog is

This is not reserved for certain breeds. Any dog will switch (seemingly without warning, tho they often give warning signals). The main difference is where breeds tend to attack (ie the more dangerous breeds tend to go for the face or neck, whereas "friendly" breeds like labs will go for an arm etc meaning attacks are less likely to be fatal or make headlines.

My point is if you're worried about your child around certain breeds but you should be thinking about educating yourself and your child for any dog coming into their home

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 27/12/2021 09:54

And don't forget the head like a brick. Forever banging into walls and apologising to them.

Yes, they do apologise. They are quite good at it, they get lots of practice 😃

Swipe left for the next trending thread