Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Father constantly asking me where my money comes from…?

118 replies

Aloha7373 · 26/12/2021 13:11

Basically: AIBU to think my father constantly asks me about my finances for toxic/jealous reasons? Or is it just insensitive curiosity?…

He used to do it when I was much younger (16/17), always saying things like “You’re going out???” “With what money????” “How are you affording a big night out on the other side of London?” “I think you’re really irresponsible spending the money you earn” etc etc.

Cut to today (I’m now 30). Every single piece of news about my life is responded to with the same questions. For example - I got engaged last year, and instead of congratulating me he just said, “But how will you afford a wedding?” “Didn’t you just get a car???” “I just think you should be looking after your money and not blowing it on getting married”.

I’ve just told him my husband and I are buying a house, and I got the same exact inquisition. No “congrats,” no “how wonderful!” Nothing except “But HOW?????? WHERE ARE YOU GETTING YOUR MONEY FROM?” “Didn’t you just get married?” “I just don’t understand where you seem to be sourcing infinite money.”

I’ve literally earned every penny I’ve ever spent. And my parents have never given me money towards my wedding, car, university nothing (except for bringing me up in their house of course). I’ve always just worked my absolute arse off for the things I want!

AIBU to think this is coming from a place of bitter jealousy in order to bring me down? Or is this normal/innocent behaviour?

OP posts:
ChargingBuck · 26/12/2021 17:31

Yes, I have explained to him where my money comes from (perhaps too much to be honest, his relentless questions make me squirm to the point I feel like I’m apologetically talking through my bank accounts/outgoings). But he always replies with “hmmmmmm, okaayyy”, with a raised eyebrow, as if to suggest I’m lying about it or something I’ve said isn’t good enough.

His cross-questioning is a conscious technique to get you to exactly this state of 'babbling' responses & giving him too much information. Bonus for him is that you will be on the back foot, struggling to assert yourself, while he gets to sneer & feel superior.

Nip it in the bud now.
Next time he inevitably kicks off, have a go-to phrase ready, & keep firing it at him on a 'Broken Record technique' until he shuts the fuck up.
"Where am I getting my money from? Dunno dad, it just turns up in my account every month, fucking mystery innit. Do you think it's got anything to do with all those hours I put in at work?"

"Will you ever stop droning on about money like you're surprised I have a job?"

"Where the fuck do you think the money comes from, given that I'm a grown up with a job?"

Aloha7373 · 26/12/2021 17:23

Thanks everyone, really useful suggestions all round! Particularly love the idea of saying it’s money from onlyfans 🤣

Sorry to those who’ve gone through the same experience. It’s so horrible having someone constantly question whether you’re capable of managing your own life - at 30!!! Especially when I’ve funded literally everything in my life up until this point.

You guys are right who said I’m probably over explaining, in future I’m just going to shut it down - or indeed, ask why he even cares so much. And no, I haven’t really spent anything on credit other than our car which we’ve almost paid off now (although I don’t think he’s even aware that was on credit). So I definitely don’t think he’s worried that I’m in serious debt.

I like to think it’s coming from a good place of concern, as others have suggested - it’s just that he never actually congratulates me on any of this stuff, or says he’s proud. I imagine if one of my (future) kids told me they were buying their first house, I’d say a MILLION other things first, like “well done what an accomplishment” or “congratulations I’m so happy for you, can I help?” before ever mentioning finances (and even then…)

OP posts:
JohnSmithDrive · 26/12/2021 17:18

I can hear myself doing this to my DC. They're younger, only just adult, but Amazon packages arrive daily. I know it's their money to spend as they wish, but I do hate to see them "wasting" it and worry that they should take the opportunity to save for more important things.

I'm sure it comes across as criticism and I'm trying to stop, but it does come only from a caring place.

StEval · 26/12/2021 17:18

@MrsHookey

I don't think it's jealousy. It's probably just his background and caring but it comes out in a strange way!
Its not caring! Its a boundary issue -doubting that you can actually afford it, a put down and a patriarchal attitude. A caring person would say how exciting, lovely and be pleased for you.
MrsHookey · 26/12/2021 17:09

I don't think it's jealousy. It's probably just his background and caring but it comes out in a strange way!

DeliriaSkibbly · 26/12/2021 17:04

My father used to try this with me when I was much younger (I'd left home, had my own place and so on). His tack was to try to tell me that I should do X or I should do Y or not do A.

In the end I just told him: It's my life. If you finance it, you can dictate it - but you finance it fully to every last penny, otherwise it's nothing to do with you and if you carry on you'll find you lose contact with your only child. Next time he tried it when I was over for Sunday lunch I literally got up and walked out. He never tried it again.

LittleRoundRobin · 26/12/2021 17:04

Wanted to add also, if someone of 25 to 30 is rude, and their age is mentioned, it seems to be OK... Eg, 'a rude woman in her mid 20s cut me up on the road today,' is classed as OK, and nobody says AGEIST. Why is it only ageist when the person is over 60? Confused

LittleRoundRobin · 26/12/2021 17:01

@Swonderful

I think it might be partly a generation thing. I find some older people in my family constantly talk about how poor they were when they were young and are obsessed with being frugal - it's morally virtuous not to spend money. They don't understand replacing kitchens, cars etc. when they're not falling apart. They also hate the idea of expensive holidays even though they could easily afford it now.

Try to ignore and change the subject as it's more about his attitude to money/worries and not worth using up mental energy on this.

Yes, it is pretty generational. People, under 55 I would say - rarely come out with shit like this. It's not 'ageist' to say it's the older generations who behave like this - or any other certain way. If people have had this experience, with someone a generation or two older, they should be entitled to say so, and mention they're 'older' without having their head bitten off.

I get so bored with this 'ageist' accusation. If in someone's experience they find people over 55/60 to be more rude and insulting than younger people, why the F can they not say this, without being accused of being 'ageist?' Confused People are entitled to say this if this is their experience. Daft!

Puts me in mind of when I posted a while back to say that - in my experience - mothers of sons are more rude to the daughter-in-law, than mothers of daughters are to their son-in-law. Not ALL of them, but moreso mothers of sons, than mothers of daughters....

Someone threw a right strop and called me all sorts, and said it was a sweeping generalisation blah blah blah..... But it wasn't a sweeping generalisation, and I wasn't 'wrong.' I said it was 'in my experience...'

And it was (and still is.)

I was not 'wrong.'

Swonderful · 26/12/2021 16:36

I think it might be partly a generation thing. I find some older people in my family constantly talk about how poor they were when they were young and are obsessed with being frugal - it's morally virtuous not to spend money. They don't understand replacing kitchens, cars etc. when they're not falling apart. They also hate the idea of expensive holidays even though they could easily afford it now.

Try to ignore and change the subject as it's more about his attitude to money/worries and not worth using up mental energy on this.

beenthereboughtthetshirt · 26/12/2021 16:30

You reply 'It's absolutely none of your business'

Mrstamborineman · 26/12/2021 16:29

How about. I’m so glad you asked, we are short this month can you lend me some money please,
That ought to shhhhh him up for bit.

AnnaMagnani · 26/12/2021 16:26

I remember being really excited about a major trip - and booked round the work flights. He asked me how much they were - I stupidly told him - and he immediately told me I got ripped off. I hadn’t- I researched for months and he had no idea what they should cost

This is absolute FIL. He laid into the unfortunate BIL for spending too much on a house because back in the dark ages he could buy a 5-bed in Surrey for £40K and BIL was now struggling to buy a starter home in one of the most popular housing markets for £350K. Utterly bonkers.

Topseyt · 26/12/2021 16:21

How irritating. Just tell him that you robbed a bank recently, so no need to worry unless the police come knocking at the door.

Seriously though, I suspect you are oversharing. Stop telling him anything. When he asks and maybe starts up again about money then tell him to mind his own business. Tell him too that it is getting boring now.

IncompleteSenten · 26/12/2021 16:04

Ask him.
Dad, you seem obsessed with my finances. Why is that?
And keep asking.

Dad, we've been through this. Why do you keep asking me the same questions?

Either that or say we are part of an international illegal organ harvesting ring.

We found a diamond mine under the house.

I stole the crown jewels

And give equally ridiculous answers every time he asks.

Mellowyellow222 · 26/12/2021 16:03

My parents are like this - especially my dad.

If I say I am buying anything - they always say what I have is fine, or try to talk me into a cheaper version. My dad in particular is very negative.

I remember being really excited about a major trip - and booked round the work flights. He asked me how much they were - I stupidly told him - and he immediately told me I got ripped off. I hadn’t- I researched for months and he had no idea what they should cost.

I am now much older and doing a house renovation. Anytime he comes round and there is something new he tells me I have bought the wrong thing, or the wrong size or overpaid. The negativity is really draining.

But now I am older I have learnt to just say okay and ignore it. It’s like a compulsion - he needs to tell me what I have done is wrong and only he is clever enough to get good deals.

Youdoyoutoday · 26/12/2021 15:52

@Winniemarysarah

I’ve got a mother who does something pretty similar, but only when I’m spending money on my dc. For some reason it gives her the absolute rage when she sees me treating my dc. She doesn’t believe money should be spent on children outside birthdays and Xmas (not that me and my siblings got much even then). I grew up believing we were extremely poor even though both my parents had decent, full time jobs and practically no outgoings. Every time we went out shopping or on a day out I ended up getting anxiety knowing my dc might ask for an ice cream or a toy from the gift shop, because my mother and step father would start tutting and huffing and glaring at me. I ended up going nc after we all spent a week in butlins together (whole holiday completely funded by me btw) and my mother had a complete meltdown in a shop because I spent £16 on a teddy for dd1. I later caught her nastily whispering to my dd (she was only 4) ‘don’t you dare ask your mother for anything else for the rest of the week, you’ve had a treat now and that’s all you’re getting’ 😡😡
OMG your poor little DD!!
JennieLee · 26/12/2021 15:29

I think that there's been a lot of generational change to do with the availability of credit. For people who can remember an era where getting stuff on HP (hire purchase) was seen as a bit dodgy, they may feel apprehensive when they see young people taking out mortgages. They may also know that even if work is well-paid that the era when people had a 'job for life' is gone.

I think I'd be inclined to be quite bland, 'Thanks for your concern. But my partner and I have made careful plans together so please don't worry about us'. And then change the subject firmly.

wizzywig · 26/12/2021 15:20

Is your dad in the police? Fbi? Defence solicitor?

LittleRoundRobin · 26/12/2021 15:19

@AnnaMagnani

We experienced all of these from FIL who appeared to have formed images of all his children aged about 8 and despite them now being 40, he still had them down as 'the responsible one' 'the reckless one' and so on. Fine if you were the responsible one but poor BIL apparently couldn't be trusted with money based on his breaking a window with a football as a child. Hmm

Hmm, funny one that. I experienced this kind of shit too. I am the youngest of 7 cousins, (all born in the 1960s.) I am the youngest, but there's only 8 years between me and the oldest one. I was the quietest, and quite shy and studious as a child.

The second and third youngest are only just over a year older than me, yet I was the only one treated like a bit of a daft child by several extended family members. Even when I was in my 20s and 30s.

Much mockery and LOL-ing ensued when I got a passport and said I was going backpacking around Europe with a friend when I was 19. 'YOU! You will be dead within a day' roared an uncle. 'You won't even make it to the ferry across you won't, you couldn't tie your shoelaces til you were 8!' hooted an auntie.

Then there was the 'oooh she's got a BOYfriend!' type comments Grin And 'have you done it yet?' from my cousins, when I was 17/18 Hmm And the chuckling and mocking when I started taking driving lessons. 'Keep out of the fields everyone, and off the footpaths, Robin's attempting to drive' a couple of uncles said!

I had the last laugh though when I was the first of the 7 cousins to pass my test AND get my own car. They shut up then.

I also got some raised eyebrows when I announced I was getting married (at 27!) Like 'what you?' In their eyes and their minds, I was still the shy and bumbling little girl who couldn't tie her shoelaces til she was 8, and spent all her time reading, writing stories, and drawing.

And the same 'what YOU' comments came when I was pregnant with my first child too. Married, nearly 30, own home, and a successful career, and they were like 'YOU with a baby?!' Confused

I even had one incident when I was 33, and on my lunchbreak at work, and a van driver nearly hit me when I was walking across a zebra crossing. I shouted 'TWAT!' as he flew past. Unbeknownst to me, my cousin (2 years older than me,) was 100 or so feet behind me in a shop doorway. She went straight to my mother who lived 15 minutes walk from her, and told her! My mother left a nasty, condescending message on my answerphone at home saying I should be 'ashamed of myself for my behaviour.' Confused

No surprise then, that when my parents died (six months apart - 10 years ago,) I left the area, and never looked back. I've had nothing to do with anyone of them since.

Only my brother who moved to Canada in 2007. I still have him in my life, and his wife and 3 kids, though I don't see him often. (HE has nothing to do with the extended family either. He also stopped the contact when our parents died..) And I also have contact with 2 great aunts on my dad's side (and their 2 daughters, my second cousins, who have one child each,) who live 50 miles away and moved in the 1990s. CBA with any of the others... I ghosted them, as they brought NOTHING to my life.

As you say, some family members still see certain younger people in the family as that child who was clumsy/nerdy/a bit behind his or her peers/shy etc, as the child they were. They can't seem to get their head round the fact they are a totally different person now. A responsible, intelligent ADULT who is probably more capable of doing most things than them!

LittleRoundRobin · 26/12/2021 15:19

@JoshLymanIsHotterThanSam

I think after the first few times I'd answer with drug dealing and prostitution but I'm known to be a sarcastic twat who doesn't suffer fools.
Grin
JoshLymanIsHotterThanSam · 26/12/2021 15:07

I think after the first few times I'd answer with drug dealing and prostitution but I'm known to be a sarcastic twat who doesn't suffer fools.

Fairyliz · 26/12/2021 15:05

Are you a family who generally talks about money?
I’m in my 60’s with adult children and have always talked to them about how much I earn, how much things cost etc.
They know how much pension I receive and I know how much salary they earn. We don’t see it as something to be kept secret.
If your family never really discussed money and your mum didn’t work or only worked part time he might be worried that you can’t afford things.
As a matter of interest how much do you earn? Grin

StruggleStreet · 26/12/2021 15:04

What makes you think it’s jealousy? You say he has a comfortable life, what is it you think he’s jealous of? It’s really hard to say from the outside what is motivating his behaviour. My guess would be that he is concerned that you’re not being financially responsible and are living above your means.
Do you pay for lots of things with credit? Or could be be concerned that you are?
It’s much more common now for things like cars to be paid for on finance and I think this can seem concerning to those who have never used money like that. I know FIL has expressed concern when we’ve spoken about buying a car on finance or about student loan debt, saying that his generation saves up and buys things outright instead.

PermanentTemporary · 26/12/2021 14:50

Well... lion it is true that the money has to come from somewhere, however needed the works are.

ManicPixie · 26/12/2021 14:50

I assume he’s aware of what a job is and how an economy functions?

Some people are just weird about money I suppose. As long as that’s the only thing he’s weird about maybe it’s just best to laugh it off…