Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To be really really worried about energy prices

141 replies

Letshaveablackcelebration · 26/12/2021 05:01

Sorry, this isn’t very Christmassy but it’s been in the news a lot the last few days. I don’t think I had really grasped until the last week how serious the energy price hike is going to potentially be. At the moment we are on some super saver deal with Scottish power that I got through Martin Lewis so we pay around £100 all in for gas and electric. the cheapest I have found so far in comparison is £240 - it’s really horrific and partly because there are very few deals about.

Aibu to be really very concerned about the coming price rises- and the Inflationary pressures that will go with it. It’s a proper shitstorm and likely to bring 50% rises in bills.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JuliaMumsnet · 18/02/2022 11:41

Hello. Popping by to say that we're doing a Q&A with fuel poverty charity National Energy Action about these energy price hikes on Wednesday 23rd at 12 noon. The thread is now open for questions here.

georgarina · 05/01/2022 13:30

@Londonnight I am a landlord and have done this for my tenants, worth approaching them about this

Grantanow · 05/01/2022 13:25

Well said jetadore! Our government has failed miserably. We have the lowest gas storage in the EU, an inadequate nuclear capacity unlike France at 36%, an ageing distribution network and not enough solar panels. Privatisation has been a disaster waiting to happen - how many companies went bust? Underinvestment is rife (including in the water industry - think about raw sewage discharges into rivers) and lack of government action on house insulation, very limited help for retrofitting alternatives to gas CH, etc. Energy cost will feed into price rises across all markets. Boris has no grasp of the issues and allows a Minister to spend ridiculous amounts of money on lunch. Need I say more?

TreborBore · 29/12/2021 18:45

Draft proofing is a cheap and underrated way of keeping your home cosy. Feel with your fingers around all the places linked with the outside, such as windows, doors and fireplaces. Draft proofing strips and those sausage shaped cushions to go along doors are cheap. My home was well insulated but we discovered an icy blast of cold air down the chimney when we didn’t have a fire. We now block the aperture with an insulated board when the fireplace is not in use. Also watch for drafts through old double glazing or single glazed windows. Until the window leaking cold air in is replaced, we hung a thick velvet curtain with liner to tackle the worst of it.

Lasttraintolondon · 29/12/2021 18:28

This is going to be a disaster for loads of families. There's some good advice earlier in this thread for saving money and keeping the house warm.

The debate about Insulate Britain is a side show. They are obviously idiots but that doesn't mean their message is wrong. Insulating the homes of the worst off is a morally good thing to do, will reduce NHS demand, and is an easy green choice. It'll also create a load of jobs of people who actually pay tax and the money will come back round anyway. Who doesn't want more local jobs.

At a larger level, wind is intermittent and that's why we need nuclear. Also, here's an idea... Build three times the wind we need - sell it when the winds blowing to other countries, and when it's not, we'll have enough. Stop selling North Sea gas and oil abroad.

On a local level for those lucky enough to have the cash, solar and solar hot water are options. New builds should have these as a standard.

MumaD · 29/12/2021 17:23

@dementedpixie nope, I was only with them for a year. I had monthly emails asking for meter readings and in the emails it said the regular readings would help calculate if I'm paying the right amount, but that's it! And obviously they've gone bust now and I can't see any info on my account for previous readings (which I haven't kept anywhere else), but I did submit them regularly. So annoying!!

dementedpixie · 29/12/2021 17:17

@MumaD

So they don't amend things when they receive the regular meter readings that they ask for? My account has never said if I was in credit or not, sadly. But I've always paid a similar amount and have never been that much in debt before. The new company have said they have to use estimated readings to get the final bill and it can't be changed 🤷‍♀️
Did they never send you a bill when you were with them? That would have shown the balance of your account. They should really have changed the amount if you were getting into debt or you could have if you were keeping an eye on your bills
ivykaty44 · 29/12/2021 17:08

at EDF said

EDF when I looked was charging 27p per unit for electric plus 23p daily charge

octopus is 19p per unit

its an expensive company

I use 55kw between 22nd December and 28th December which cost £12.52

MumaD · 29/12/2021 17:06

So they don't amend things when they receive the regular meter readings that they ask for? My account has never said if I was in credit or not, sadly. But I've always paid a similar amount and have never been that much in debt before. The new company have said they have to use estimated readings to get the final bill and it can't be changed 🤷‍♀️

dementedpixie · 29/12/2021 16:45

When you have a fixed rate its the price per kWh that's fixed not the monthly direct debit. If you use more energy you pay more so if the direct debit isn't enough to cover your usage then you end up with a debit balance. I have changed my direct debit up and down depending on whether I'm in credit or debit

MumaD · 29/12/2021 16:24

I don't really understand how these fixed price deals work! I was with a company that went bust and we were on a fixed price deal and sent them regular meter readings, I've now been told by the new company that I owe over £400 because the price I was paying was not enoughConfused
I dread to think how much their new DD is going to be once it's all set up!!

Chakraleaf · 29/12/2021 15:34

@MakeMineAdoubleChocolate

As it happens, I just put £20 on my top up key and into the meter on Friday and its now on 86p, I could throw up!!!! The guy at EDF said its our electric shower that's burning the electric. I doubt it. It's on a couple times a day, each time 10 minutes or less. I feel so angry that now it looks like we will be spending over 100 a month on electric. Looking to switch to Scottish Power, if anyone can recommend!!!!!
Many won't let you move atm
MrsSkylerWhite · 29/12/2021 12:35

No YANBU. This is going to be a serious problem for millions of people and there’s a good case for Govt. intervention.

MakeMineAdoubleChocolate · 29/12/2021 12:35

As it happens, I just put £20 on my top up key and into the meter on Friday and its now on 86p, I could throw up!!!! The guy at EDF said its our electric shower that's burning the electric. I doubt it. It's on a couple times a day, each time 10 minutes or less. I feel so angry that now it looks like we will be spending over 100 a month on electric. Looking to switch to Scottish Power, if anyone can recommend!!!!!

JassyRadlett · 29/12/2021 12:32

@ivykaty44

JassyRadlett im not sure that many actually know the IB goals and realise that they are protesting to achieve something that would really benefit themselves on a personal level and save them £££.

On the one hand the group has started in September 2021 and made headline news, so everyone is aware of them - but their PR is dreadful and pitted against a right wing media even worse

It’s a really interesting question about what achieves the most positive change in the long run - do we need the XR/IB/WSPU with their more extreme tactics to shift the ground of debate so that the centre ground shifts? Or are they in the ‘more harm than good’ camp?

When things shift it’s the extreme groups that tend to be remembered but on eg climate change, public opinion hasn’t shifted much since before XR, it was already a stated political priority for the majority.

There’s a huge debate on whether the NUWSS or WSPU was actually the more successful - and whether in fact some of the WSPU activity hardened positions and slowed change. I’m not saying one argument or the other is right - but it’s certainly open for debate (and historians are still actively debating the question - suspect the same debate will be happening in a century over climate campaigning!)

I tend to think that, apart from that broader question, IB’s tactics don’t make sense to people in a way they probably need to to cut through - in the same was as XR glueing themselves to the DLR/occupying the WWF HQ probably created a net negative for them; their other targets made more sense from their POV of their stated goals.

We want more energy efficient homes therefore let’s block a motorway is too much of a leap for most folk I think.

ivykaty44 · 29/12/2021 12:21

JassyRadlett im not sure that many actually know the IB goals and realise that they are protesting to achieve something that would really benefit themselves on a personal level and save them £££.

On the one hand the group has started in September 2021 and made headline news, so everyone is aware of them - but their PR is dreadful and pitted against a right wing media even worse

JassyRadlett · 29/12/2021 11:12

(I’m not sure IB’s methods are totally helpful - mostly because of childish ‘I don’t like them so I will discount their argument’ responses - but it is difficult to argue with their goals.)

JassyRadlett · 29/12/2021 11:06

So I don’t want them to waste it on insulation for houses if we’d get a better bang for the buck by doing something else…electrify the transport system, or build nuclear power or any one of a dozen other initiatives that reduce emissions and improve lives.

Demand reduction is almost always more cost efficient than increasing capacity, and especially with the shift to full electrification of energy, energy efficiency looks like particularly good value for money.

The problem is partly an accounting one - mass energy efficiency measures aren’t considered as infrastructure projects in the same way as new generation or storage would be - and partly an ideological/presentational one - paying for home improvements that would reduce demand can be portrayed as middle class welfare/adding value to their homes that people should (but largely don’t - storing up system wide costs) be willing/able to pay themselves.

So energy efficiency programmes tend to be underfunded, piecemeal and don’t get the scale needed to deliver the best financial efficiency - so they cost more than they need to and we don’t see the cost reductions and innovation that we’ve seen in renewables/storage.

In a nutshell, it’s more politically palatable to subsidise a nuclear power plant or O&G exploration and extraction than it is to subsidise energy efficiency to the same level, despite better return on investment. One could make less charitable comments about why that might be….

ivykaty44 · 28/12/2021 07:02

No choice before, I was a damn sight younger,didn't have health problems made worse by cold and damp.

Really, and you think what IB are protesting for is ridiculous.

Warmth in winter promotes healthy humans, healthcare and warms are basic human needs.

DontBlameMe79

In USA there is much the same arguments given about not having social healthcare given for everyone, you can go paying for everyone, whilst Europe looks on in amazement.
Heating actually prevents healthcare problems and thus why it’s conspired a basic need

I’m not convinced that you can give me a good reason why I should be against IB proposal to get homes insulated to prevent fuel poverty and help prevent people worrying so much about rising fuel cost, I see that as a good thing.

nannybeach · 27/12/2021 22:44

The draughty house was demolished to build a petrol station, the Caravan was a stopgap and rotted away. Pretty stupid questions. Why am I having solar, because fossil fuels are being banned,so we have to go some other path. No choice before, I was a damn sight younger,didn't have health problems made worse by cold and damp. You should try living in a caravan in the winter,with the mould, been there done that, worked damn hard for what I have now.

DontBlameMe79 · 27/12/2021 22:21

@ivykaty44

So I don’t want them to waste it on insulation for houses

so on a thread of people worried about the rising costs of keeping warm you think that it'd be a waste of money to get the government to insulated houses, an electric travel system isn't going to keep people warm.

basic human needs are health, warmth and food and having insulated homes would go to achieving two for the 3 and leave money for the third

There was an “if…” after the part you quoted. So how do you know we could do 2 of the three things you mention with money to spare for the third? Are insulated homes going to solve the health crisis? Might help but the NHS could use up all the money we throw at it and still have its hand out as everyone has to die sometime and end of life treatments just get more and more expensive.

My point is everything we choose to do is a trade off and we have limited resources. We need to make sure we get the biggest impact from the resources we have and not just arm wave. Could be house insulation, could be something else…but needs a serious discussion, not superglue.

ivykaty44 · 27/12/2021 18:40

So I don’t want them to waste it on insulation for houses

so on a thread of people worried about the rising costs of keeping warm you think that it'd be a waste of money to get the government to insulated houses, an electric travel system isn't going to keep people warm.

basic human needs are health, warmth and food and having insulated homes would go to achieving two for the 3 and leave money for the third

DontBlameMe79 · 27/12/2021 16:06

@ivykaty44

DontBlameMe79 the government hasn't got any money, yet can waste billions on T&T, that money and much more is suddenly available. the government will spend far more on reaction than planning. insulation is a far better plan for 4 million homes in fuel poverty and that number will rise.

nanny - if its fine to live in a caravan with one heater, or a draft house ready for demolition - why are you bothering with solar for yourself?

people are worried about increasing utilities, they don't want to be living in the cold. just because 5% of houses can't be insulated doesn't mean you don't look at insulating the other 95%

My point on the Government not having any money is that it’s our money - And I agree they are world class at wasting it for us.

So I don’t want them to waste it on insulation for houses if we’d get a better bang for the buck by doing something else…electrify the transport system, or build nuclear power or any one of a dozen other initiatives that reduce emissions and improve lives.

People who say “do them all” usually accompanied with “by taxing the top 1%” are contributing about as much to the debate as the M25 face gluers.

ivykaty44 · 27/12/2021 15:50

DontBlameMe79 the government hasn't got any money, yet can waste billions on T&T, that money and much more is suddenly available. the government will spend far more on reaction than planning. insulation is a far better plan for 4 million homes in fuel poverty and that number will rise.

nanny - if its fine to live in a caravan with one heater, or a draft house ready for demolition - why are you bothering with solar for yourself?

people are worried about increasing utilities, they don't want to be living in the cold. just because 5% of houses can't be insulated doesn't mean you don't look at insulating the other 95%

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 27/12/2021 15:11

@amicissimma

We are reliant on gas imports from other countries.

The UK government, apparently supported by voters, is not encouraging more exploration and investment in potential UK gas fields.
We are not allowing fracking as our population is against it.

We are closing down our mines that produced relatively high-calorie and 'clean' coal and importing less useful and dirtier coal.

We continue to build subsidised windmills, paying the owners of the land they are on, and paying out when there is not enough wind to produce electricity. There is too much cloud cover in the UK for solar power to be reliable.

We don't build nuclear power stations, preferring to spend years fighting about them as people don't want one in their area, and importing nuclear from France, where we have no control either over the quality of the builds or over any radiation that should be released in the event of an accident. We are 'looking at' small scale nuclear installations, and looking at them, and looking at them ...

Gas and coal power stations can be brought on and taken off-line comparitively fast and can react to changes in wind and solar-generated power. Nuclear can give us

If we want the government to do something, price caps, insulation, etc, that will cost money that will be added to the bill. If we want commercial customers to pay more that cost will be added to what we buy.

Transportation costs are rising. Food costs are rising. Covid has left us with a big debt that will need to be paid. According to HMRC, only about 300,000 people pay more in income tax than they use. That's the population of a medium/large London borough. The oft-referenced multinationals that apparently escape paying their 'fair share' of tax, have tax demands made on them from every country they are involved with; why would the UK win out over other countries?

So much of this is wrong. We actually get most of our gas from the North Sea. We don't have a "big debt that will have to be paid" from covid - a nation's finances don't work like that - but politicians love to pretend it's like a credit card so they can pretend we all need to pay for rich people to get richer.

Multinationals pay far more corporation tax in the USA because the USA doesn't allow them to trade there otherwise - we could do the same, but choose not to.

HMRC are liars about most things things so I don't believe their claim that only 300K people are net contributors.

Swipe left for the next trending thread