Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Don't Call An Ambulance

88 replies

NeverDropYourMooncup · 25/12/2021 23:20

After yet another thread where a poster has described symptoms that are red flags for cardiac events and YET ANOTHER poster has told them they're an expert and it'll be nothing - which it very well could be, but it might not - I'm beginning to think that it wouldn't be overreacting for MN to add 'Giving dangerous medical advice that could result in harm to a poster or family member' as a reason for banning posters.

I'm aware that this could be deemed a TAAT, but it's a serious matter that isn't confined to just one single occurrence. And I'll likely get mullered on here by the people who are so absolutely certain of their psychic abilities that they can't comprehend that their 'no, that symptom that is indicative of a heart attack/stroke/sepsis/cancer is just anxiety/menopause/a cold/need of moisturiser/a paracetamol' could lead to an unnecessary death or disability.

I think it's important enough to take any flak. MN can achieve great things, but can also be outright dangerous whilst it's seen as acceptable to do this.

If I'm coming on too strong here (obviously, I don't think I am), could MNHQ consider having a standard reply as they do for depression/self harm, don't offer money to sad stories or suchlike and have one for symptoms of chest pain, one for burns, etc?

OP posts:
Winniemarysarah · 26/12/2021 01:09

@Sideswiped

YANBU. The ever-righteous posters who proclaim you should never call an ambulance except in the case of your head being amputated should give their heads a shake. I often wonder if they've ever been in the awful situation of fearing for someone else's life as their responses suggest not - I suspect that if they were, they'd be the first on the phone to dial 999. According to them, even if a small child is seriously ill, you should bundle them into a car and take them, on your own, to A&E, regardless of your worry that something terrible might happen on the way. (And of course they possess a crystal ball to forecast the outcome, meanwhile having fuck all knowledge or expertise in the area concerned.)
I agree with this. This was on a different forum to mumsnet, but if I followed the advice given on there during an emergency then my daughter would 100% be dead. And the other forum is nowhere near as bad as mn when it comes to medical advice. Half of the comments were from people saying I shouldn’t be going to hospital at all. When I was there the rest of them were saying that I 100% should be listening to the multiple MEDICAL EXPERTS with their SCIENTIFIC PROOF of my daughters diagnosis, which I completely disagreed with. I refused to let them carry out the procedure that would have killed her, and she was less than 24 hours from death before she was correctly diagnosed by a nurse who helped me get her the treatment which saved her life. I feel like stabbing people in the throat when they comment ‘if you’re posting on here then it’s not an emergency and you don’t need a&e’ 😡😡
Throckmorton · 26/12/2021 01:07

Too right NeverDrop, I read the post you mean and was horrified at such dangerous advice

pluggee · 26/12/2021 01:05

Older people grew up with that, so to them calling an ambulance is a huge deal.

I've called an ambulance on a few occasions, they were all big deals.

NeverDropYourMoonCup · 26/12/2021 01:03

@RoyalFamilyFan

It used to be only a GP could call an ambulance. Older people grew up with that, so to them calling an ambulance is a huge deal.
Possibly 70+ years ago. But not for the lifetime of the vast majority of MN posters? I don't think MN is a site full of octogenarians eager to stop people from accessing urgent medical care.
OP posts:
Skiptheheartsandflowers · 26/12/2021 01:01

Thing is, there's a big problem with people who call ambulances for stupid reasons (e.g. needing a light bulb changed,according to someone I once knew who worked the phones) but they'll do that no matter what. Meanwhile lots of the genuinely Ill people are going 'I really shouldn't bother them' while gasping for breath or having a heart attack and they are easily guilt tripped into not calling. There should be a 'better safe than sorry' message, but I don't see it happening while ambulance services are as stretched as they currently are.

Thelnebriati · 26/12/2021 00:49

When to call 999 - the list includes chest pain.

www.nhs.uk/nhs-services/urgent-and-emergency-care-services/when-to-call-999/

RoyalFamilyFan · 26/12/2021 00:43

It used to be only a GP could call an ambulance. Older people grew up with that, so to them calling an ambulance is a huge deal.

SimpsonsXmasBoogie · 26/12/2021 00:41

Im not in the UK but I did used to live there and I found that a lot of people were very odd about ambulances. It was as if calling an ambulance was viewed as selfish and silly.

Seemed totally bizarre to me.

Lex345 · 26/12/2021 00:18

@OhLittleBoreOfWhabylon

if a member is verified as a profession and then gives terrible or dangerous advice, then what?

Then they risk their registration. Quite rightly.

You can always pick the genuine HCPs on such threads. They are the ones who do not confidently offer diagnoses.

I am not sure if I know of any NMC cases raised by non employment errors. I of course agree that poor practise should be held to account, but for precisely this reason, registered professionals will not offer a diagnosis on a forum. So we are kind of back where we started!
Almostwelsh · 26/12/2021 00:18

I know what you mean. I remember a pregnant woman posting that she felt unwell, couldn’t get out of bed, had nothing to drink and was alone. People told her she was unreasonable to call an ambulance. This was a potentially life threatening situation. Might not have been, but could have been and no one on the internet should be telling her not to make a fuss.

OhLittleBoreOfWhabylon · 26/12/2021 00:15

if a member is verified as a profession and then gives terrible or dangerous advice, then what?

Then they risk their registration. Quite rightly.

You can always pick the genuine HCPs on such threads. They are the ones who do not confidently offer diagnoses.

Summerfun54321 · 26/12/2021 00:12

MN isn’t a medical advice forum. Anyone posting looking for medical advice is looking in the wrong place. Chat forums and factual medical advice websites shouldn’t mix. They’re totally different things and users need to be crystal clear about what is fact and what is opinion.

Lex345 · 26/12/2021 00:07

I do wonder what mumsnet could really do though. Say if they verified with NMC PIn-I guarantee I STILL would not be giving medical advice because it is beyond my sphere of competence and possibly a dangerous way to go-if a member is verified as a profession and then gives terrible or dangerous advice, then what?
What is more helpful-and is what has happened-is members reinforcing the need to get medical attention as the more people say it, the more likely the lone post falls into abeyance.

forcedfun · 26/12/2021 00:04

@needmoreshinys agreed. I see awful advice given on legal queries and (as a lawyer) can spot all the other actually knowledgeable posters, but that would often be far trickier for the op

forcedfun · 26/12/2021 00:02

@NeedAHoliday2021 in my experience ambulances can take a while for other things but whenever my son has had anaphylaxis/possible anaphylaxis they have arrived very quickly. Of course, use EpiPen then dial 999.

needmoreshinys · 26/12/2021 00:01

I often think that I should post something like

My medical knowledge comes from watching every episode of House, so its probably not lupas.

But most of the posts are people who are worried and not sure what they should do.

I think MNs needs to do a lot more, with regards to people saying they are a profession and giving advice, whether that is medical, legal or whatever,

forcedfun · 26/12/2021 00:00

In the moment it’s hard to make the call so dial 111 and they will get an ambulance if needed.

This is good advice. And the 111 online is good too. Also you can call 999 if you tvinj it is needed and they won't send an ambulance out unnecessarily - they will talk you through the situation and advise if they think an ambulance not needed

gogohm · 25/12/2021 23:57

I do agree op but in many cases the people posting are aware it's not that serious but are unsure if they should wait until the gp opens or seek out of hours gp service. In most cases I personally would suggest if you can get yourself/your child to hospital safely (ie not if a serious suspected fracture) it's usually quicker to drive. We have a walk in gp service 24/7 at the hospital site so you aren't interfering with the hospital work

forcedfun · 25/12/2021 23:57

@nonotquite I hope it all turns out ok, but you are doing the right thing - far better to get it checked.

Op I totally agree with you.

I think there is a weird culture among some parts of the population, where some people are really hesitant to ever call an ambulance/seek urgent help.

I will never forget looking after my newborn when she's grandfather (in his 90s) had a fall getting out of the car. I assumed DH family were calling an ambulance. I finished getting baby to sleep and came out to find DH grandfather sat on a chair in the hall looking an awful shade of grey. And everyone else busy sorting the Christmas dinner! I asked if ambulance was on its way and they looked at me like I was mad. I had to push hard to get them to call and when they did they just rang 111 and apologised profusely for troubling them... Thankfully 111 sent an ambulance ! He had broken both hips and was very unwell

NeedAHoliday2021 · 25/12/2021 23:52

When we thought dh was possibly having a stroke (was actually a weird migraine - he’d never had one before - that caused half his face to drop) I called an ambulance. Honestly, I wish I’d just put him in the car and driven him. They took so long to arrive it was scary. A few weeks later Dd had an anaphylactic reaction and I drove her because I didn’t trust them to arrive. In reality a dc struggling to breathe would be prioritised but after my previous scare, I couldn’t take that risk. Did get told off by ED doctors but Dd was fine.

I work in the nhs so know the pressure but it means the public are so desperate not to be a burden we try to avoid using the service when in reality they know we’re not medically trained so need a professional to advise. In the moment it’s hard to make the call so dial 111 and they will get an ambulance if needed.

Lex345 · 25/12/2021 23:51

I agree OP. I think what is scary is (I am trained as a nurse but quit earlier this year btw) most medical professionals will be very, very reluctant to hazard a guess a diagnosis online because it is working beyond your sphere of competence. I will happily advise people to seek medical advice, but there are a whole host of differential diagnoses in that thread and even doctors on 111 will not attempt a diagnosis over the phone for symptoms such as these-it would be negligent. I would be concerned about anyone claiming to be a medical professional who would say anything other than signposting to medical advice tbh.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 25/12/2021 23:50

@nonotquite

Oh I think this was my thread. Thank you I really appreciate your threat. Being an anxiety sufferer I often worry I'm overthinking or over dramatising things.. but I've never ever felt anything like what I'm experiencing now.

I am currently awaiting a call back from the clinical team.

Your safety is important and please don't feel guilty - NHS advice is absolutely clear that you are doing the right thing Flowers.
OP posts:
Sideswiped · 25/12/2021 23:50

YANBU. The ever-righteous posters who proclaim you should never call an ambulance except in the case of your head being amputated should give their heads a shake.
I often wonder if they've ever been in the awful situation of fearing for someone else's life as their responses suggest not - I suspect that if they were, they'd be the first on the phone to dial 999.
According to them, even if a small child is seriously ill, you should bundle them into a car and take them, on your own, to A&E, regardless of your worry that something terrible might happen on the way.
(And of course they possess a crystal ball to forecast the outcome, meanwhile having fuck all knowledge or expertise in the area concerned.)

nonotquite · 25/12/2021 23:47

Your thread ** sorry

nonotquite · 25/12/2021 23:47

Oh I think this was my thread. Thank you I really appreciate your threat. Being an anxiety sufferer I often worry I'm overthinking or over dramatising things.. but I've never ever felt anything like what I'm experiencing now.

I am currently awaiting a call back from the clinical team.

Swipe left for the next trending thread