Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Don't Call An Ambulance

88 replies

NeverDropYourMooncup · 25/12/2021 23:20

After yet another thread where a poster has described symptoms that are red flags for cardiac events and YET ANOTHER poster has told them they're an expert and it'll be nothing - which it very well could be, but it might not - I'm beginning to think that it wouldn't be overreacting for MN to add 'Giving dangerous medical advice that could result in harm to a poster or family member' as a reason for banning posters.

I'm aware that this could be deemed a TAAT, but it's a serious matter that isn't confined to just one single occurrence. And I'll likely get mullered on here by the people who are so absolutely certain of their psychic abilities that they can't comprehend that their 'no, that symptom that is indicative of a heart attack/stroke/sepsis/cancer is just anxiety/menopause/a cold/need of moisturiser/a paracetamol' could lead to an unnecessary death or disability.

I think it's important enough to take any flak. MN can achieve great things, but can also be outright dangerous whilst it's seen as acceptable to do this.

If I'm coming on too strong here (obviously, I don't think I am), could MNHQ consider having a standard reply as they do for depression/self harm, don't offer money to sad stories or suchlike and have one for symptoms of chest pain, one for burns, etc?

OP posts:
LSLLM · 26/12/2021 08:53

Why are people so funny about calling an ambulance? My recent first aid course I was horrrifed to see the whole room think there was no need to call an ambulance if they saw someone have an epileptic seizure. Wtf. It’s in my daughters care plan - ambulance immediately.

Just phone the bloody service, they can be the judge of the priority

Thisisworsethananticpated · 26/12/2021 08:41

If people are stupid enough to take advice from a website rather than call NHS 111…….

Tiramesu · 26/12/2021 08:31

In the same breath, people should.not be posting on Mumsnet to ask if they are a medical emergency...!

GoodPrincessWenceslas · 26/12/2021 07:56

I remember one thread where it turned out that the poster who had been told by a number of people not to call an ambulance turned out to be very seriously ill indeed; if she hadn't called the ambulance when she did it's pretty certain she would have died. Yet even after she had come back some time later and expressed her gratitude to the people who told her to call, there were still people who hadn't bothered to read the OP's posts telling her not to waste precious NHS resources.

Vanishun · 26/12/2021 07:52

Sort of wish you could change the thread title. It sort of stuck out at me as an imperative. The kind of thing that can unconsciously remind you not to do something when you mean the opposite!

PAFMO · 26/12/2021 07:50

@ViceLikeBlip

Anyone who has access to mumsnet also has access to the NHS website 🤷‍♀️ I think a simple disclaimer that nothing on this site is proper medical advice is sufficient.
I agree. Frankly, if someone is sitting next to you having what could be a heart attack and you're posting on MN asking what to do, then you're not going to sit and digest lengthy advice copied over from the NHS, but you might just read a terse one liner saying "nobody on here is a confirmed medical expert, why not try one of those instead".
GemmaRuby · 26/12/2021 07:43

YANBU - there should definitely be some kind of disclaimer, especially about urgent situations.

However I don’t agree with your suggestion that MNHQ should post specific advice from the NHS website (e.g. for burns or whatever). Because then they would be responsible for finding the correct advice, ensuring it was up to date etc. And could potentially cause harm and liability by accidentally giving the wrong advice.

In non-urgent situations, MN can be very useful for advice, reassurance and signposting.

ViceLikeBlip · 26/12/2021 07:33

Anyone who has access to mumsnet also has access to the NHS website 🤷‍♀️ I think a simple disclaimer that nothing on this site is proper medical advice is sufficient.

londonrach · 26/12/2021 07:32

Don't waste time re septics...I can be quick ..we should have called an ambulance looking back. The five hour wait was to be triaged. We were lucky that the removal of the mask and me saying suspect septics got the help he needed. He was vvv ill for two weeks and still not right.

londonrach · 26/12/2021 07:29

Husband had the start of septics a few weeks ago. 111 never called him back and we tried three times. Didn't want to waste an ambulance so went to a and e to be done five hours wait. He removed his mask and showed the problem...he was seen and treated in minutes

ThesecondLEM · 26/12/2021 05:24

The "nurse" on that thread has broken her code of conduct, if not the law.

As a veterinary nurse I am not allowed to offer diagnosis, I would be struck off the register. I can say, those symptoms need to be checked by a vet to rule out xyz but that's it. I can make an observation but diagnosis, absolutely not.

One would imagine these rules are more stringent for humans!

Furthermore, even a Dr would be on very dodgy grounds making a diagnosis based on a mn thread. That's pretty much why you don't see many Dr's comment. I bet there are a fair few sitting on their fingers mind.

Bagadverts · 26/12/2021 05:15

I agree about adding a reply from MN. There is some dangerous advice. As with a lot of threads the tone can be set by the first few posts. Can also be derailed .

This can be a link to NHS website. They may be reluctant to add text about specific symptoms or treatment such as burns in case it changes. Maybe they could say from NHS as at 26 Dec 2021, please check NHS website for updates.

I know some posters have got advice on the basis of threads that may have been life saving. I worry that if a poster follows advice to not call 999 and it is wrong they wouldn’t come back.

Tabbacus · 26/12/2021 04:40

It's not a medical forum, it would be a shame if all of the threads were deleted because some might not apply any common sense and listen to a bunch of strangers. Some threads are useful though. Most threads where people say about ambulances is when a) It'd be a million percent quicker to drive and its safe to do so b) its not an emergency response. Its not appropriate to say yes if unsure call an ambulance as if everyone did that they'd be waiting 10 hours for one to arrive when they could have gone in and be seen by then. How do you propose MN moderate these threads? And how many people said to the OP to seek help?

ENDOFMESSAGE · 26/12/2021 04:35

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

RantyAunty · 26/12/2021 04:27

@pluggee

Yes it's a weird phenomenon on MNs that you shouldn't call an ambulance unless you are already dead 🤷🏻‍♀️
They've probably been scolded and minimised in life to believe they don't matter, that anyone making a fuss about injury or an illness needs to walk it off or are seeking attention.
RoyalFamilyFan · 26/12/2021 03:39

Most who abuse services either have mental health issues, or social care issues or are simply dicks.
So changing a light bulb. For someone elderly with no one at all to help, having a dark room without a light is dangerous. I can see how someone in desperation would phone for help if they have no one else.

SimpsonsXmasBoogie · 26/12/2021 03:34

@Skiptheheartsandflowers

Thing is, there's a big problem with people who call ambulances for stupid reasons (e.g. needing a light bulb changed,according to someone I once knew who worked the phones) but they'll do that no matter what. Meanwhile lots of the genuinely Ill people are going 'I really shouldn't bother them' while gasping for breath or having a heart attack and they are easily guilt tripped into not calling. There should be a 'better safe than sorry' message, but I don't see it happening while ambulance services are as stretched as they currently are.
I think you've hit the nail on the head.

The idiots who abuse the ambulance service are going to continue doing that no matter what. Most normal people need to hear the message that it's ok to call an ambulance if they are genuinely concerned.

SD1978 · 26/12/2021 03:12

Vast majority of time. When the OP (in general) then takes the advice and calls 111 doesn't go to A&E anyway. There's usually a reason they can't/ don't want to. Maybe it's more people responding assuming low risk if you can hum and haw over the internet for several hours, and then never go anyway.

RoyalFamilyFan · 26/12/2021 02:30

@NeverDropYourMoonCup I just checked and it was in 1974 that everyone was able to phone for an ambulance themselves. But I had wrongly thought it was the same everywhere when it was not. Before 1974 local authorities managed ambulances and each had different policies.
I know in the area I am from that you had to phone the GP who if they agreed would phone an ambulance for you. You could not phone for one yourself. My parents won't phone for an ambulance themselves for anything really, but they have phoned me and I have phoned for one. I know as a child I was very ill and the GP refused to phone for an ambulance,. I stayed at home. The GP visited me at home finally three days later and was shocked at how ill I was, I was apparently way better than I had been. The GP admitted I should have been in hospital. I only mention all this because that history do influence elderly people and whether they will call ambulance.

Bunnycat101 · 26/12/2021 02:23

What I don’t understand is why people feel the need to comment on things they have no bloody idea about. I’ve been on a few threads where the only appropriate response was get to A&E. There was a recent one where a pregnancy lady had PROM and she was told off for contacting the hospital (who quite obviously wanted to see her for assessment).

RoyalFamilyFan · 26/12/2021 02:14

It can be difficult to know when to call an ambulance. There is real no public education about this.

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 26/12/2021 02:09

While I completely understand @SE13Mummy's stance, I do feel there is some merit in having the threads on a forum like MN - one poster has already pointed out that she took notice of info from a thread to go to A&E when she had the same symptoms, and turned out to have sepsis.

I have used it before, despite having some HCP background, when I got something stuck in my eye in the middle of the night - I was going to leave it but was advised to go to hospital (which I did, but I drove myself)

111 isn't always great in speed of response - I know myself, I used it for my grandfather years ago, when he was in great pain. It took them forever to call back, by which time he was almost crying with pain, and they were trying to insist that they had to talk to him directly - EVENTUALLY they sent an ambulance. He died a few days later in hospital from a perforated gallbladder and further complications.

So I can understand why people post on here - they may think that it's trivial, and there is a wealth of personal experience on here that can be tapped to show that it is/isn't; but I TOTALLY agree with the OP that there should be a standard MN caveat attached to ANY medical-type post.

Sometimes you just can't wait. I took my 3yo to hospital with strange symptoms, despite having called the GP, having seen him the day before as well - because I couldn't wait for him to call back. Good job I did - the child had appendicitis with a black and gangrenous appendix which was removed first thing the next morning.

I remember another poster who had a DVT - she posted quite casually to start with but enough people warned her what it could be, and how dangerous it could be, so she went to hospital and sure enough, it was a DVT.

Ectopic pregnancies - another example of people who have been helped on here.

But again, I totally agree that the "Do Not Call An Ambulance" crew should really keep quiet. There are far too many "I don't want to be a bother" people out there who would take that as the only comment worth paying attention to, despite 99 other comments telling them it was potentially very serious and they should go to hospital - and that could potentially be fatal for them.

Agreed that genuine medical professionals shouldn't/wouldn't be posting definitive advice either, and I'm sure they don't - so if someone claims to be one, and is doing precisely that, then chances are they aren't genuine. The only medical advice they would offer safely is "get seen by a medical professional" - which may involve an ambulance!

My own sister called me from the other side of the world to see whether she should call an ambulance for our father - the answer was "Yes". I expect if she'd called 111 they would have told her the same, but maybe not, and maybe there would have been hours of delay while they got a HCP to call back and check symptoms. (To be fair, I haven't used the system for years, so I don't know who answers now - it used to be screening call handlers who had a procedure to follow, including "I'll get a nurse to call you back" who then might say "I'll get a doctor to call you back" - hours)

SE13Mummy · 26/12/2021 01:27

I agree; there's a lot of worrying advice given in response to posts about medical situations and in an emergency scenario, something could go horribly wrong if the wrong advice was acted upon. @MNHQ posting a standard response on medical advice threads would require them to be made aware of any such thread which is all well and good during the day but less easy at night.

I'm involved with a different online forum and a few years ago, after yet another person posted photos of a rash and wanted randomers online to diagnose, we took the decision to stop publishing any posts seeking medical advice. Because of that decision we had to change the set-up of the entire forum but it's been worth it to know that no-one will be told to shove something soft in the mouth of an epileptic having a seizure, to rub oil into a burn or that it can't be meningitis because there's no non-blanching rash. We still get complaints about it, even though the person who posts will receive a message explaining that medical advice needs to be sought from qualified medics e.g. pharmacist, health visitor, GP, 111 or 999. People still complain that they only wanted to know if anyone else's cool child had had before bothering anyone medical and that they don't actually want medical advice. It often feels as though the advertising campaigns about only calling ambulances if necessary have been so successful that people worry their medical emergency isn't enough of an emergency. There's a confidence thing behind that, I'm sure. If I was worried about what felt like a medical emergency, I would call 999 or go to A&E and be completely prepared to be told that it needs to be managed in X way. I wouldn't berate myself if it turned out not to be a medical emergency but I know other people who would find that hard to cope with and so want to be right before seeking that advice. On more than occasion I've collected a parent and child from their home and driven them to hospital because the parent didn't have the confidence to make that call and even if agreeing to go only to humour me, didn't have transport/money for transport. Each time, the parent has been told by A&E that getting to hospital was the right thing to do because they were dangerously dehydrated or needed antibiotics for developing sepsis. It's concerning to think that if those parents had posted on an online forum and received advice telling them that a sudden lowering in temperature accompanied by no urine output was nothing to worry about, their child may not have received antibiotics in time to save their life.

Attached images show the signs and symptoms of sepsis.

Don't Call An Ambulance
Don't Call An Ambulance
RoyalFamilyFan · 26/12/2021 01:25

@NeverDropYourMoonCup no not that long ago at all.
It was only in the 70s that ambulances started to have paramedics. Before that they were a taxi service.

Gingernaut · 26/12/2021 01:24

@Angrymum22

Anyone who turns to mums et for health advice before consulting GP or seeking advise from 111 is a little misguided from the outset.
This.

111 is there if you're not sure.

Social media is for checking in once you get there

Swipe left for the next trending thread