Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Told to return gift as unwanted

62 replies

Ihavenoideawhereitis · 25/12/2021 18:29

For the second year my dm has told me she doesn't like what I bought her and I should return it or keep it for myself.
It's just rude isn't it? Why not just say thanks and keep it or give it to charity without telling me. This has annoyed me a lot. Does anyone else do this?
AIBU to be annoyed that she feels the need to tell me my gift was shit?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WhistPie · 26/12/2021 11:06

The last Christmas that my DM was alive, she just wanted Hob Nobs. She got Hob Nobs. She was delighted.

QuizzlyBear · 26/12/2021 10:51

I often exchange gifts I'm given (I don't want people to waste money on stuff that'll sit in a cupboard unused) - and my DH and close family know this and always include the gift receipt! It's a good-natured running joke.

I would NEVER put the onus on the giver to return it and exchange it though, that's plain rude.

VanGoghsDog · 26/12/2021 10:46

@Ihavenoideawhereitis

I've told her to keep it or charity it as it can't be returned etc, but she will probably dump it on my doorstep like she did last years present and tell me to use it myself.

For those saying agree not to exchange gifts, this is what I have tried before. I told my dm and ds and dB that we wont do Christmas gifts anymore and that we will donate to charity or whatever and we don't want anything ourselves. I told them all well in advance and everyone agreed. Then two days before Christmas my dm turned up with presents from everyone. So that I looked like an arse. So I had to go out and buy last minute gifts for them all.

Sorry to all on this thread who also get told their gifts are crap and unwanted x

I told everyone this year that I wasn't doing gifts. I didn't tell them they they weren't, it's up to them what they do. You don't give to receive.

So if people give me gifts it's up to them, I told them I wasn't and no way would I rush out and buy some just because they chose to buy them.

Chamomileteaplease · 26/12/2021 10:41

Then two days before Christmas my dm turned up with presents from everyone. So that I looked like an arse. So I had to go out and buy last minute gifts for them all

That was your mistake - it was her who looked like an arse. You should have stuck to your guns. Try again next year.

I remember having an argument in the early days with my ex - he wanted to exchange the present I got him - I can't even remember what it was - and I gave him the receipt and expected him to do it. But he thought I should do it. That was a fun time Grin. I always think it is up to the recipient to go through the hassle if they decide to.

Nanny0gg · 26/12/2021 10:36

@RandomUsernameHere

I wouldn't mind this at all, my DMum told me (very nicely) that the present I got her for her birthday wasn't something she would really use, so I returned it. It was nearly £200 so I'm glad she didn't just give it away! We have a very open relationship, I would do the same if I was given something I didn't like. It's better than wasting it. It's a bit different with someone you don't know very well, but with people you're very close to it's better to be honest.
Out of interest, isn't £200 a lot to spend on someone if you're not sure they'll like it?
Nanny0gg · 26/12/2021 10:33

@TheOpenRoad

YABU. It's not a big deal to return or exchange a gift. She doesn't want you to waste your money.
There are ways of telling people though.

In future, OP, give her what she's asked for and if it's cheap look at it as a bonus for you!

Yuledo · 26/12/2021 10:22

Although saying that, there is one friend where I keep getting a similar style of product that is nice, but I never use. I made the mistake of not being honest the first time, and now years later, it’s far too late to say anything. What a waste

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 26/12/2021 10:21

We don't do adult presents any more, partly for this reason.

Yuledo · 26/12/2021 10:18

I think it’s rude if you are forcing your gift and taste on someone, rather than the other way round. You should want the recipient to be pleased with what you’ve chosen, even if it does mean you have to go to the effort of taking it back.
Can’t bear the waste and why should people lie. I want an honest relationship with people. Trust is of utmost importance to me. I don’t want lying involved, over big or little things.

MadameFantabulosa · 26/12/2021 10:17

One year I got my Mum a hamper from Fortnum’s, plus a plant that I knew she would like for her garden. She complained that she didn’t have anything to unwrap. Confused I think I am not going to win, regardless.

MargosKaftan · 26/12/2021 10:17

Next year ask her again what she would like. Buy that and only that. If it is cheap then so be it. Stop bothering with thinking.

The only time I have asked to return gifts have been when they have been very expensive and unusable - but then only if I thought they could be returned /exchanged. If not I've quietly charity shopped them.

TimeForTeaAndG · 26/12/2021 10:09

So if they turn up with presents you stand firm. That is a lovely gesture but as we agreed to not do presents this year I haven't got anything for you, pop your coats off and I'll put the kettle on.

If they moan at getting nothing just keep reminding them you had all agreed to not do presents.

Ihavenoideawhereitis · 26/12/2021 09:59

I've told her to keep it or charity it as it can't be returned etc, but she will probably dump it on my doorstep like she did last years present and tell me to use it myself.

For those saying agree not to exchange gifts, this is what I have tried before. I told my dm and ds and dB that we wont do Christmas gifts anymore and that we will donate to charity or whatever and we don't want anything ourselves. I told them all well in advance and everyone agreed. Then two days before Christmas my dm turned up with presents from everyone. So that I looked like an arse. So I had to go out and buy last minute gifts for them all.

Sorry to all on this thread who also get told their gifts are crap and unwanted x

OP posts:
mdh2020 · 26/12/2021 08:59

We buy my mother a lot of books and DVDs and we are just used to the fact that she will read (or part read) and watch once and then give them back. My DiL buys very expensive gifts that I never want but I regift them usually to my BF.

CaddieDawg · 26/12/2021 07:58

It's all about how it's done more than the exchanging/returning of gifts. My Mum would occasionally do this, but always bring it up carefully on boxing Day or the day after and say something like, it's lovely but I probably wouldn't use it, would you mind if we returned it and I got X or Y instead? She would never do it with non close relatives so often boxing day onwards I'd get a smelly set/pyjamas etc that she didn't like or we'd swap a box of chocs for anothers, with the giver having not a clue. Bringing it up on Christmas morning is just heartless imo.

Yummiliscious · 25/12/2021 22:44

My Nan used to do this. I think it was a generation thing, she was very practical, she wouldn’t understand todays attitude of buying lots of crap for the some of buying something. if she wasn’t going to use it she would rather you got your money back or used it yourself. She was home bound so couldn’t be going around dropping off to charity shops. She also felt the need to be brutally honest. I would have just bought her exactly what she had asked for.

Marvellousmadness · 25/12/2021 22:32

You obviously don't know her taste/interests and should have just stuck with that one present she asked for

StoneofDestiny · 25/12/2021 22:16

Yes it's unnecessarily hurtful.
I'd take it back and leave a gift out next year - or just get food treats.

Auntielateralflow · 25/12/2021 21:27

Just suggest that going forward you won’t be exchanging gifts
I don’t understand why more people don’t do it, saves all the angst

RandomUsernameHere · 25/12/2021 21:21

@CoastalWave

It's your mum.

Anyone else, I would say that's rude. If your own MUM can't tell you, there's a problem!

She's trying to save you money. You sound like if she had given it to charity, you'd be pissed off with that as well (looking for the present, not seen it, where is it etc)

Completely agree
RandomUsernameHere · 25/12/2021 21:20

I wouldn't mind this at all, my DMum told me (very nicely) that the present I got her for her birthday wasn't something she would really use, so I returned it. It was nearly £200 so I'm glad she didn't just give it away! We have a very open relationship, I would do the same if I was given something I didn't like. It's better than wasting it. It's a bit different with someone you don't know very well, but with people you're very close to it's better to be honest.

Fimofriend · 25/12/2021 21:14

My dad told me that if I was going to buy him cheap tat for £5 for Christmas he would prefer I didn't bother at all. I asked when I had done that. "For his birthday this year" was the reply. .....Hmmm yeah, that cost a bit more .... like closer to £40 but he never goes shopping so he has no clue what things cost. He doesn't give me a wish list and we do not live in the same country so it is not exactly easy to find gifts for him. He doesn't want clothes, tools, or decorative items. He is not interested in music or films. He no longer does gardening. He acts interested in the books I give him but then doesn't read them. I am very tempted to take him up on his offer of not exchanging gifts.

AliveAndSleeping · 25/12/2021 21:13

@Ihavenoideawhereitis

I understand those who say that it is a waste of money to give an unwanted gift and that is why its being returned, but it's the wasted time that annoys me far more. I don't want to take it back to the shop. I don't want to waste time doing that or thinking about what I should replace it with etc. Its not hugely expensive, and if its unwanted then it's unwanted. Say thanks, or say nothing. I am probably being unreasonable and childish, but it's Christmas day and I don't want to receive a message first thing which basically says your gift is shit, have it back.
Can't you tell them that? If they can be honest can't you as well?
AliveAndSleeping · 25/12/2021 21:11

If it was anyone else I'd be hurt it offended but not with my mum. I expect her to be (brutally) honest and I can be the same to her. If it was my mum shed worry about me spending money on something she doesn't want or can't use or maybe she just doesn't want me to spend money on her. It depends on your relationship otherwise bit it's not necessarily something nasty.

Aderyn21 · 25/12/2021 21:05

I think this is so rude. Even if the motivation is to save the giver from wasting their money, what's more important, the wasted money or the hurt feelings of someone who tried to do a thoughtful thing?
I can see why, if a present cost a lot of money, the recipient might want a gift not to be wasted but there are ways of going about things that are gentle and tactful. You don't just give something back and say you don't want it. When did people decide that manners aren't important any more?

Swipe left for the next trending thread