Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the Christmas Number One has gone tacky and downhill?

287 replies

SoniaFouler · 25/12/2021 10:53

I just saw that LadBaby has had its 4th Christmas number one single. Based on what? Tik tok and streaming views on YouTube? I haven’t heard the song and not going to bother but does anyone else think music these days is just low effort, cheap and bland? What about real Christmas number ones, like Spice Girls 2 Become 1 for example.

Also saw that they had a rivalry to get to number one with a band called “The Kunts”. Really? I have no problem with the word cunt but I also don’t think this fits in with the whole Christmas theme. Can you imagine a child saying “who reached number one, mummy?” And she replies “it was The Kunts darling”??

OP posts:
Cornettoninja · 26/12/2021 10:21

@DrSbaitso

Are peoples memories really that short?

Yes, because the Christmas Number 1 is irrelevant and nobody really cares except those who were hoping to get it. It's a bit of trashy, shameless Christmas fun, nothing more.

Maybe that’s why it grates to have the ‘it’s for charity’ line rolled out. It’s a happy byproduct of self promotion not an altruistic aim.

At least a variation of artists and songs rotates the cause a bit. Four years running and it just feels like people may as well donate directly to the TT 🤷‍♀️

DrSbaitso · 26/12/2021 09:52

Are peoples memories really that short?

Yes, because the Christmas Number 1 is irrelevant and nobody really cares except those who were hoping to get it. It's a bit of trashy, shameless Christmas fun, nothing more.

dudsville · 26/12/2021 08:26

@WheelieBinPrincess

No child is going to say ‘who reached number one mummy?’ Anymore then they’d say ‘let’s take our tea in the drawing room’

It’s no longer very relevant.

It was X factor winners for years and years anyway, I can’t imagine it means much of anything anymore.

Agreed
Wagsandclaws · 26/12/2021 08:24

Awful - same crap every year.

SoniaFouler · 26/12/2021 08:09

@PurBal

Tbh I’d rather Ladbaby got number one to an X factor winner because the profits go to charity.
Wy do people keep using this as an argument? All the X Factor Christmas releases were for CHARITY. They were literally known as the X FACTOR CHARITY SONGS. Confused One year was Help for Heroes, another was Great Ormond Street Hospital, the videos used to be black and white and showed footage of the charities they were released for. Are peoples memories really that short? Hmm
OP posts:
PurBal · 26/12/2021 07:58

Tbh I’d rather Ladbaby got number one to an X factor winner because the profits go to charity.

QueenofDestruction · 26/12/2021 07:55

UGH, Spice girls any song is better than that.

DrSbaitso · 26/12/2021 07:37

@EsmeraldaFudge

Saw some posts on another site last night of the irony of LadBaby declaring their intent to support food banks, but also making no secret of being Tory voters.
That seems logical to me...
Livebythecoast · 26/12/2021 07:34

I think the fact you have never heard the song, didn't realise 100% goes to the Trussell Trust and the song mentions Christmas in it lots of times means you haven't really got an argument for your post.
I can't say I'm a massive fan of their pranks but I think they genuinely want to help this charity which is so worthwhile.
Christmas no 1's are always a bit naff and this song is just a bit of fun for a good cause Xmas Smile

WhatScratch · 26/12/2021 07:19

Well, to be fair, without the Tories we wouldn’t have so many food banks for them to donate to.

EsmeraldaFudge · 26/12/2021 07:13

Saw some posts on another site last night of the irony of LadBaby declaring their intent to support food banks, but also making no secret of being Tory voters.

Herewearestar · 26/12/2021 06:54

Talking about charity, does anyone remember the 2 become 1 controversy?

It was released around about the same time as charity single “Knocking on heavens door” by Dunblane, and there were calls for the Spice Girls to delay the release until after Xmas, so more younger fans could buy the charity single. The SG’s management wanted the Xmas no. 1 and didn’t. I remember The Spice Girls having to defend the decision on TV, Geri insisting that it was just business, if I recall correctly.

It’s largely forgotten this, but really illustrated how ruthless the Spice Girls machine was.

SerenadeOfTheSchoolRun · 26/12/2021 06:45

I think it’s great that Elton John and Ed Sheeran have written a new Christmas song - I don’t think we get many anymore. I am a bit cynical that they hedged their bets for number one by teaming up with Ladbaby but then on the other hand they are up for a bit of silliness and both songs are for charity so why not.

Both songs mention bereavement at Christmas which I think is a good thing but I actually thing the sausage rolls songs lyrics handle it better. The sausage roll lyrics are fun and relatable for a family having Christmas together. I really like both versions having listened to them and danced to them in the kitchen before Christmas lunch yesterday.

Better than X factor for Christmas number one. I think we remember with rose coloured classes - Bohemian Rhapsody was good but not Christmassy and we had that three times. Loads of Christmas number ones were novelty or not very Christmassy.

Ijustdontcare · 26/12/2021 06:21

@Teacupsandtoast

You do know that all the money from the downloads of the Ladbaby songs goes to the Trussell Trust foodbank charity? They've raised a HUGE amount and supported so many families - who cares if the songs are a bit rubbish?
No it doesn't. If you read the small print on their website, its 100% of the profit, not 100% of money donated. They spin it for marketing so that they're donating massive amounts to charity, but I imagine their "costs" see them net quite a bit of money from the venture
Chloemol · 26/12/2021 01:59

Donate

Chloemol · 26/12/2021 01:58

I suggest you do some google searching

That will tell you ladbaby do ate every single penny of profit to The Trussell Fund , you know food banks for those not as fortunate as the rest of us

Shame on you for moaning about them

WithANameLikeDaniCalifornia · 26/12/2021 00:17

What’s this now? The Spice Girls are real music? Hmm

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 26/12/2021 00:06

can understand people wanting to donate to a food bank - not sure why you have to buy a novelty song to do that though.

Disclaimer: I am not 'related' to Ladbaby, in spite of my username....!!

I agree with PPs that it's annoying that 'being in aid of charity' gets it a free pass - even if the charities don't actually see a very big percentage of the sale price.

Also the fact that these causes have to rely on charity at all. Every time I see the WaterAid appeals, it always makes me think that we and other wealthy countries were so desperate to spend millions, if not billions, funding Covid vaccines, which has the relatively small potential of seriously harming the people in these countries; but when it comes to ensuring they have clean water (much less a basic anti-starvation amount of food), we really don't seem to care at all about these 'boring' everyday deaths.

This is not to slate WaterAid or food banks in the least for the great work they do - but they shouldn't need to do it in the first place.

In theory, the Christmas Number One should be a completely 'free' choice, with people choosing their favourite, without feeling that they 'should' choose the charity one. Supposing millions of people did choose their actual favourites for musical reasons, split between 10 different options, but also all downloaded the charity one (maybe not even bothering to listen to it) as a 'little extra' - it's still a hijacking, however worthy.

Suppose 30 children give their teacher a token present at Christmas, but each child only gives their parent(s) one or two presents each - statistically, that would suggest that all of the 'sample selection' of children love their teacher far more than any of them do any of their individual parents.

Imagine if you regularly entered a serious painting competition with your finest, painstaking work - maybe you're an artist as your full-time job - where the exposure of winning would really help your continued livelihood, along with other skilled adults; but every time, a 4yo child with a sweet face entered with a blurry splodge, but was trying to draw attention to their pet good cause. Every year, they leapfrog all of the serious contenders with a wholesale pity vote. Why can't they feature/support the child's cause and efforts as a side effort, without taking away from the people who should seriously stand a chance of winning?

Yes, I know a lot of rubbish has historically got through - and I have no great love of Simon Cowell (although it did also begin the career of a hitherto unknown, as well as making him a packet) - but it just seems more honest that people should choose a rubbish song because they decide that they like it (or even just enjoy the kitsch value) rather than feeling that they should choose it - and if they don't, they're 'obviously' a nasty person who doesn't care about feeding the poor.

MichelleScarn · 25/12/2021 21:37

Oh @User135644 the 'ba da da da opening from Only You gets me every time. 'All I ever knew, only you' 🥰

thepeopleversuswork · 25/12/2021 20:39

@SoniaFouler

“I doubt you spat your tea out”

No darling it’s a a figure of speech.

Give me strength.

User135644 · 25/12/2021 20:26

@OldHip

Ok I have just looked up the list of Xmas number ones and the following are the only decent songs during the last 50 years:
  1. Rockabye
  2. Stay Another Day
  3. Don't You Want Me
  4. Another Brick In The Wall
  5. Merry Christmas Everybody
  6. Long Haired Lover From Liverpool*

*Hated/slated at the time, arguably due a rehabilitation

Just from the 70s and 80s:

Lonely This Chirstmas, Bohemian Rhapsody, Mull of Kintyre, Mary's Boy Child, Only You by the Flying Pickets, Do They Know it's Christmas, Merry Christmas Everyone, Always On My Mind

A lot of those are at least proper Christmas songs.

MorganKitten · 25/12/2021 20:11

The X Factor ruined xmas number ones

OvenBakedOwl · 25/12/2021 19:57

'100% of all profits going to the Trussell Trust.'

At a first glance, looks transparent. But what are their profits exactly? I mean, something could cost £1 to make and sell for £10. You'd be forgiven for thinking £9 is the profit which goes to charity.

But not if I factor in my time/ resources etc as a cost and I decide I charge £8 an hour for my efforts. Charity then get £1.

So it's not as clear cut as it may appear

HalfBrick · 25/12/2021 19:53

The charts are dead. They mean nothing these days. They were my everything growing up!
A kid streaming Drake on a tinny phone down the park 50 times does not constitute a best selling song in my book, but it does in chart world.

JackieWeaverHandforthCouncil · 25/12/2021 19:50

I prefer the old Christmas songs they put on rotation in the shops. My favourite is Driving Home for Christmas by Chris Rea.

I’m not a fan of charity singles. I’m dubious as to how much actually makes it to the charity after everyone has had their cut. I think the Ladbaby song is a pile of poo and I haven’t even heard it, have heard previous ones they’ve done so would be surprised if this was any better.

Think some people get stuck on the ‘charidee’ angle and get sucked in. I’m sure the charity would get a higher percentage if people just donated direct. Just because it’s for charity doesn’t make it worth buying or being number 1.

There’s a weird bit of British culture (I am British) that celebrates mediocre and this is an example.

Swipe left for the next trending thread