Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the Christmas Number One has gone tacky and downhill?

287 replies

SoniaFouler · 25/12/2021 10:53

I just saw that LadBaby has had its 4th Christmas number one single. Based on what? Tik tok and streaming views on YouTube? I haven’t heard the song and not going to bother but does anyone else think music these days is just low effort, cheap and bland? What about real Christmas number ones, like Spice Girls 2 Become 1 for example.

Also saw that they had a rivalry to get to number one with a band called “The Kunts”. Really? I have no problem with the word cunt but I also don’t think this fits in with the whole Christmas theme. Can you imagine a child saying “who reached number one, mummy?” And she replies “it was The Kunts darling”??

OP posts:
LittleRoundRobin · 27/12/2021 14:53

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll

If somebody stood on a street corner and asked you for £20, promising faithfully (maybe even providing proof) that £3-£5 of that money would go straight to a charity, with the rest going in 'costs', I highly doubt they would get a single punter.

However, do the same thing with a charity pop single, charity Christmas cards and the like - it looks like you the charity can really benefit.

Exactly this. And whilst I do buy from charity shops if I see something I like, I NEVER buy their Christmas cards. They're a rip off, like £3 for 10! You get a box of 30 or 40 for about £1.99 in Wilkos or Asda.

Also, I am shocked to hear that Lad Baby take a cut. So much for doing it for charity. Hmm And 136,000 were sold, and only £26,000 of the £136,000 they made has gone to the charity it was meant for? Shock That's disgusting. Where the F is the rest of the money? Where is the other 80% of the money?

Methinks people are being mugged off here. Hmm Someone needs to investigate where the rest of the money has gone. Something dodgy is afoot.

Cornettoninja · 27/12/2021 14:45

That’s the point though, it’s looking highly likely the level of support has been misrepresented or at best glossed over leaving people to make assumptions. That’s not okay, it’s grifting.

It’s a bit rich to throw around ‘pious’ when that’s precisely the angle this sausage roll bloke has been working.

DrSbaitso · 27/12/2021 14:42

[quote Cornettoninja]@DrSbaitso why are you focusing on TT? Of course they’ll be pleased with any donation. The question should be is whether the people who paid for the song are happy with the proportion that went to TT.[/quote]
Because that's who the song was supporting!

If people weren't happy with the percentage to charity, they could have done as everyone so piously says and given ALL the money to Whatever Charity.

Cornettoninja · 27/12/2021 14:23

@DrSbaitso why are you focusing on TT? Of course they’ll be pleased with any donation. The question should be is whether the people who paid for the song are happy with the proportion that went to TT.

DrSbaitso · 27/12/2021 14:19

@slashlover

Yes of course they're using it to promote themselves, nobody's stupid enough to think otherwise. I just don't see how it's any less self-serving and more altruistic to hop on it just to berate people for not Doing More. Especially right after a day of massive unnecessary gift giving and eating (which I have no problem with either).

The thing is that it's not about Doing More, it's about doing different. If everybody who spent 99p on the single donated it straight to the TT then they would have made a lot more money.

And if everyone who did Christmas had given all the gift and food money straight to the TT, then they would have made a mint. You can always Do More/Different.

Has anyone asked the TT if they're offended and critical?

Cornettoninja · 27/12/2021 14:11

It's for a charity and it's a bit of silliness and fun, who cares really

The silliness and fun bit doesn’t need the charity bit to justify its existence though does it? If the charity bit is tiny in comparison to rest of the profits it’s out of proportion in its promotion.

ScreamingMeMe · 27/12/2021 13:53

@the80sweregreat

Watch any Spice girls performances or videos and you will notice how good they were for a girl group ; they had a brand, Mel C could sing and they had a bit of charm and sass , the Americans loved them too. They were of a time. Stop ! Is a pop classic.
You see, I would consider the Spice Girls as dross too. Mel C a good singer? Come off it! What they had was good marketing.

With a few notable exceptions the Christmas Number 1 has always been naff. I didn't care about it when I was young, and I care less now.

If your musical tastes encompass more than the latest tacky pop songs, you've always been rather ill-served by the pop charts at any time of year shrug

Tabbacus · 27/12/2021 13:50

@slashlover

Yes of course they're using it to promote themselves, nobody's stupid enough to think otherwise. I just don't see how it's any less self-serving and more altruistic to hop on it just to berate people for not Doing More. Especially right after a day of massive unnecessary gift giving and eating (which I have no problem with either).

The thing is that it's not about Doing More, it's about doing different. If everybody who spent 99p on the single donated it straight to the TT then they would have made a lot more money.

That doesn't make sense, why would they have made a load more? People who want to and often do donate money will presumably still be doing so, but it's a whole load of others who perhaps wouldn't think to or wouldn't always have the means will have bought the single so what's the harm? Pretty sure the Trussell trust wouldn't have been charged for making the video or for it being uploaded onto streaming services etc.
slashlover · 27/12/2021 13:45

Yes of course they're using it to promote themselves, nobody's stupid enough to think otherwise. I just don't see how it's any less self-serving and more altruistic to hop on it just to berate people for not Doing More. Especially right after a day of massive unnecessary gift giving and eating (which I have no problem with either).

The thing is that it's not about Doing More, it's about doing different. If everybody who spent 99p on the single donated it straight to the TT then they would have made a lot more money.

DeepaBeesKit · 27/12/2021 13:41

It's for a charity and it's a bit of silliness and fun, who cares really?

I thought it was quite entertaining that Elton john & ed Sheeran got on board. If you can't pull off this sort of thing at Christmas when can you.

Cornettoninja · 27/12/2021 13:36

The entire mad debate is about the charity aspect!

No it isn’t, from the OP:

but does anyone else think music these days is just low effort, cheap and bland? What about real Christmas number ones, like Spice Girls 2 Become 1 for example

The whole charity thing got dragged into it because some people think that’s a good excuse for releasing dross and cashing in on the promotion benefits. Elton John and Sheeran are just as bad in this case imho - low effort self promotion for high publicity gains. I’m actually quite surprised that their teams weren’t more insistent about the percentage of profit going to charity being better advertised, it’s an vulnerable target leaving it open to debates like this. First rule of fundraising is to be transparent because ambiguity leaves you open to scrutiny and criticism.

It’s fine if people want to support a shit song, but trying to paint it as anything more than that i.e. altruistic when it’s a feeble nod in that vague direction is just irritating. 23k donated is great but none of the participants made this song with the goal of raising 23k alone, they’ve took their cut and expect to see more arising from the promotion benefits.

(And sorry OP, but 2 becomes 1 is also a pile of wank Wink)

Youdoyoutoday · 27/12/2021 13:18

Ladbaby is raising money for charity so it can be forgiven when it's a bit cheesy or naff! And its far more preferable to 'the kunts with Boris is a fucking cunt' however true the statement is, its not very festive!
However ladbaby now have 4 Xmas number ones which now rival the Beatles.... they must be doing something right!

DrSbaitso · 27/12/2021 13:13

@DrSbaitso, but that’s the point isn’t it? It’s not about the charity aspect is it? Why people are using that to defend a shit song by opportunistic people is beyond me.

The entire mad debate is about the charity aspect!

Yes of course they're using it to promote themselves, nobody's stupid enough to think otherwise. I just don't see how it's any less self-serving and more altruistic to hop on it just to berate people for not Doing More. Especially right after a day of massive unnecessary gift giving and eating (which I have no problem with either).

The TT got a shed load of money. They could have got much more if we had all spent our Christmas budget on them, but we didn't. Shitty novelty Christmas songs from people in showbiz are nothing new, and a good cause got a decent amount from it.

If the TT isn't offended about it, I don't think it matters who else is.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 27/12/2021 13:05

If somebody stood on a street corner and asked you for £20, promising faithfully (maybe even providing proof) that £3-£5 of that money would go straight to a charity, with the rest going in 'costs', I highly doubt they would get a single punter.

However, do the same thing with a charity pop single, charity Christmas cards and the like - it looks like you the charity can really benefit.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 27/12/2021 13:00

And some of the best Christmas No1s have absolutely nothing do,with Christmas (Bohemian Rhapsody

Don't be ridiculous: a song about a man being shot in the head NOT Christmassy?! Grin

They played Ernie (The Fastest Milkman In The West) on Radio 2 yesterday. I never realised that it had been the Christmas Number 1 in 1971 - not at all Christmassy, but as novelty songs go, much more cleverly-written than most.

I can't speak for Ladbaby in particular, but it's a very old and successful marketing technique to associate your brand with charity. Some sort of a popular gimmick can prove very lucrative indeed and, sad to say, 'charity' can be just as much of a gimmick as anything else.

Cornettoninja · 27/12/2021 12:54

@DrSbaitso, but that’s the point isn’t it? It’s not about the charity aspect is it? Why people are using that to defend a shit song by opportunistic people is beyond me.

It is what it is, it’s just promotion of a wider ‘brand’ that people buy into (influencers in a nut shell). It’s mildly irritating that some want to make it something it’s not by making out dropping a few crumbs from their sausage roll in an envelope to a food bank is a charitable act. It’s not and it’s worth pointing it out because it’s a marketing schtick used by lots of quarters to get people to part with their money. Slapping ‘for charity’ on something doesn’t make it altruistic.

It’s still a good thing for the charity, of course it is, but people should understand that’s not where the majority of their money is going. There is at least one poster on this thread who stated they didn’t like the song but bought it because the money was going to charity. I would argue they were hoodwinked personally.

ReformedWaywardTeen · 27/12/2021 12:53

@DrSbaitso

26k went to the Trussle Trust

Is that not a good result?

Has the Trussel Trust refused the donation?

Mediocre for the potential sales of the download. I have seen the guy behind Ladbaby asked what percentage he took and what amount actually went to the TT. Rather tellingly, he and his wife seem to block people for asking, which may be for many reasons but whilst he stands accused of using the TT to profiteer and raise his own profile from mediocre and tedious youtuber to self styled saviour of people from poverty, he would be mindful to just say "X went to TT, Y and Z went here and why". And as someone else pointed out, if I was to download a charity single I think I would want to know if it's profit or full amount going to the charity. There have been other charity singles where fees and costs were waived. I can't see why at this point and 4 singles in, especially with Sheeran and Elton on it, they couldn't have negotiated the same?
DrSbaitso · 27/12/2021 12:38

Of course it COULD be a lot more. We could all have forgone all Christmas gifts and roast dinners and donated that money instead if we were truly motivated by raising as much as possible.

As it is, it's 26k more than the TT would have hot otherwise. Is the Trust offended?

Cornettoninja · 27/12/2021 12:36

@DrSbaitso

26k went to the Trussle Trust

Is that not a good result?

Has the Trussel Trust refused the donation?

26k from a Christmas no 1 seems on the low side on the face of it.

First result in Google says they made 136,000 sales. 99p a sale and 26k isn’t a fat lot is it?

I’m sure the TT did accept it gratefully, I’m not sure that everyone who bought the single for reasons of charity would be quite as pleased though.

PartyPrawnRingGames · 27/12/2021 12:35

It's a sign of the times that the top songs are a charity song supporting a food bank and a very strongly worded protest song against the government. Things will move on in a few years time.

CodenameEgg · 27/12/2021 12:34

@DrSbaitso

26k went to the Trussle Trust

Is that not a good result?

Has the Trussel Trust refused the donation?

That depends. How many of the people would have purchased the single if they knew it was 100% of the profit not 100% of the 99p they thought it was? How many of those people would have instead donated £1 directly to the Trussle Trust?

Obviously thats something that we can never know £26k is a good result, but there is always the possibility it could have been a lot more.

FangsForTheMemory · 27/12/2021 12:34

Bollocks. It was always crap and irrelevant.

Cornettoninja · 27/12/2021 12:33

@slashlover

I've googled everywhere but I can't seem to find what percentage of the 99p goes to the foodbanks.
I googled yesterday and couldn’t find anything either. Anyone who doesn’t particularly like the song handing over cash would be better off donating to the Trussell Trust directly. It isn’t like comic relief or children in need where a pot is shared out and smaller charities benefit when they wouldn’t have necessarily made similar gains independently.
DrSbaitso · 27/12/2021 12:30

26k went to the Trussle Trust

Is that not a good result?

Has the Trussel Trust refused the donation?

CodenameEgg · 27/12/2021 12:30

It bears repeating:

100% of the PROFIT goes to charity.

That could be a few pence. Since that isn't clear in any way how much profit from this single goes to charity I'd always refuse to buy it and donate directly.

Swipe left for the next trending thread