Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Xmas gift from DH

64 replies

PineappleRisotto · 25/12/2021 03:40

It's totally rubbish. Exchanged gifts Xmas Eve over dinner with our two daughters as they are off to their in-laws tomorrow, as it's the in-laws turn for xmas day. No problem with that. In fact it's good because it lets me off the hook and we can be a bit quiet and peaceful Xmas day which suits us both nicely.

Everyone's present was well thought out, and well received.
Mine was {I hope} well received but fuck me it's hideous. Keerist knows what he was thinking!

He knows I like handbags. Not necessarily very expensive bags. Just bags I see, that I like. Mid-range priced bags that are either unusual or fit into my colour palette, if you like:}

He's bought me a black plastic monstrosity!! Very cheap but not even cheerful!! He is convinced now {because of my acting skills} that he's pulled it off in getting something totally impressive. I mean, how misguided can he be!!??

That's not the problem though. He's done this many times in our 30+ years of marriage. What is worrying me is a recent thread that somebody asked, and I paraphrase "Does your husband have to ask what you want for xmas?" Well, yes, because otherwise he won't have a fucking clue. I wish he 'would' ask because then I might get a present that I actually want. The premise of the post was that if your husband loves you enough he'll be on your case 24/7 round the shops to make sure he knows what you want and he won't have to ask. That he is so in tune with your needs and wants and persona that he'll do these lovely things for you and can anticipate your every whim. And you will always get the most perfect gift! This can only happen if he loves you very very much.

If that's what makes a marriage, then me and dh are entirely finished and fucked and our marriage is worthless. Sod all the times he looked after the kids while I went away for weekends with my mates. Bugger the nightime feeds we always shared, even though he was working the next day.

Nope. t's the really crap presents that will finish us off. This ugly black plastic handbag is the end of us.

OP posts:
pollywollydoodler · 25/12/2021 08:47

@DontBlameMe79

Am I the only one not to give a toss about presents? More junk usually. Unnecessary stress, I’m happy not to receive them and don’t have a lot of enthusiasm for buying them.
No you're not the only one. DH s not a shopper, it was painful to see how stressed he got about it, the year he presented me with a rug for my landing was a turning point 😄 my gift to him for years has been that he doesn't need to do it and his to me is that he does all the Xmas Day cooking.
lap90 · 25/12/2021 08:28

In future just send a link so he explicitly knows what you want.
I like handbags too.

DitheringBlidiot · 25/12/2021 08:21

If I didn't tell my dp what I wanted, along with a link I wouldn't get a good present either. Sometimes he might get me a "suprise" - usually bath stuff which is fine as I'll use pretty much anything.

I wouldn't act as though you like it too much though, otherwise how is he to know tang you would prefer something else. You don't have to be ungrateful just say you don't think you'll use it and it seems a waste so you're going to exchange it

DrSbaitso · 25/12/2021 08:13

We always ask each other for gift ideas for Christmas. He doesn't have to be a mind reader. And I rarely do the "men don't think that way" thing, but in terms of handbags, I do think it applies. He may know you like handbags but very few men will have an understanding of your preferred colour palette or equivalent. It doesn't mean they don't love you.

The problem, I think, is this:

He is convinced now {because of my acting skills} that he's pulled it off in getting something totally impressive. I mean, how misguided can he be!!??

You pretended you were delighted, so you can't be annoyed that he hasn't seen through you! This isn't fair. Like I said, he's not a mind reader and if you tell him you love it, he should be able to trust you on that.

You need to communicate more and not be afraid to tell him what you like. Maybe give him a few options so he can choose one and there's still an element of surprise.

FuckeryIsAfoot · 25/12/2021 08:03

The thread to which you are referring was goady AF. Don't let that get to you. Even turned out she was literally a newlywed. She ain't seen nothing yet.
Also, I would be on edge if my husbands little ears perked up every time I said I want something. I recently said I want a food processor. It wasn't a hint, I simply said I want one because I find chopping onions tedious and frankly, if I got that for Christmas I would be a little fucked off.

We do lists/choose our own in this house. He's impossible to buy for because he's into computers and stuff and I am absolutely clueless and so would your average curry's employee be. I never know what I want myself. I'm even more impossible. Maybe he should just start buying me food processors and meat cleavers.

mnp321 · 25/12/2021 07:58

Am I the only one not to give a toss about presents? More junk usually. Unnecessary stress, I’m happy not to receive them and don’t have a lot of enthusiasm for buying them

Me too. I'm very happy to receive nothing and often do for birthdays and Christmas. Without sounding like a fun sponge, it's more clutter to store and there's really nothing I need. Plus buying clothes is very difficult to get right in terms of taste and size.

I'd hate my husband to be thinking about my presents 24/7. Not least as our weekends involve a lot of ferrying the kids around rather than shopping or surfing the internet and I'd far rather have help with that. I find it a bit sad when buying presents is considered the litmus test in a relationship. The everyday stuff matters far more to me.

Rubyupbeat · 25/12/2021 07:52

We have been married not far off 40 years, we buy what we want, as and when nowadays, we both have charities we regularly donate to, but at Christmas we give a very large donation to them all, we like doing this rather than racking our brains for a want, which we could buy anytime. (We weren't always like this, Christmas was a time for a much wanted gift that couldn't be easily afforded normally)

HidingFromDD · 25/12/2021 07:50

tbh, I was with you until you said you'd got him a golf voucher (presumably for £30). If you're both at the stage where you buy what you need anyway, a voucher is pretty uninspiring and I do wonder whether he is currently thinking the same as you.

It does, however, sound like you've got a good marriage so maybe have a discussion about presents and present giving once festivities are well over?

Mintyt · 25/12/2021 07:36

Why are you pretending you like it, say have you the receipt please

Notimetolive · 25/12/2021 07:30

We’re passed the present stage too. Buy what we want for our hobbies when we need it. Much less stressful than having to pretend the gift is perfect and just what I want. DH always buys flowers and chocolates as a treat though. We’re both happy doing it this way and don’t care what other people think.

lisaandalan · 25/12/2021 07:29

What we do is send each other say ten or twenty pictures of things we like, then we obviously buy a couple of them, but it's still a surprise and something we want. X

onedayoranother · 25/12/2021 07:18

You've said it yourself - he thinks he's done great because you've told him he has! Stop acting! You can't say you love it to his face then come on here complaining. If this has happened year after year and you've been faking gratitude no wonder he has no idea what you like. Next time tell him, or get one of your kids to lead him in the right direction.

Sparkletastic · 25/12/2021 06:56

Time to drop your Oscar winning performance of fake delight. Tell him thank you but it isn't to your taste and ask if he can return it.

Mittenmob · 25/12/2021 06:43

I'm getting adverts on here for handbags, as if some ad agency monitors people talking about 'crap handbags' and thinks 'yep, this thread is a good space for this brand'

Mumdiva99 · 25/12/2021 06:26

My husband is crap at presents. This year he's wrapped me slippers I bought myself and liz earle I bought myself.

However if he benefits he's great. So yesterday he made us all pizza and cleaned up after. So I'll keep him a few more years.

Presents aren't everything.

Bellafrenum · 25/12/2021 06:20

That thread you refer to was batshit.

My dh gets a list, he gets a couple of bits off there and goes slightly off piste in a very safe way. He adores me.

Yuledo · 25/12/2021 06:16

That’s why dh has never been allowed to buy me presents since that first memorable Xmas.

Blossomsbloom · 25/12/2021 06:14

We gave up gifts years ago but no children so easier in that sense. It was always such a painful experience 😂 we started booking a weekend away or a day out and a nice meal and it's so much more relaxing. If we want something we just buy it for ourselves. I must admit though I would like something to open occasionally but it's not worth the stress!

EmmasMum12 · 25/12/2021 06:13

If he has form for buying duff presents why not let your daughters guide him next time? Why didn't they guide him this time?

If the limit is £30 and your daughters won't help, ask for him to do the Crisis giving - £29.06 (this year)

I'd say your marriage is over if his crap gift giving is the tip of the very big rubbish marriage ice berg

If he's just crap at gifts, then find a way round it (daughters, charity) and move on

Gretaburley · 25/12/2021 06:07

Why not tell him after Christmas?
Bring polite means this will carry on.
My dh got me a really crap watch one year (no financial reason).
I told him that I was disappointed.
He puts much more effort in since and it’s not because he knows my inner thoughts, it’s because he now asks what I would like.

itspartytime · 25/12/2021 06:03

Can you set up a new joint Amazon account and then save items in a list in there that you like -set him up a list too - that way you both might get what you actually like next time ?
Happy Christmas !

ShinyHappyPoster · 25/12/2021 05:59

I don't think present buying necessarily = love. Lots of abusive guys shower their wives and gfs with expensive 'perfect' gifts. If you can see some sort of attempt to get you something you'd like then I think your relationship is OK ie it kept to the budget you'd agreed; it wasn't picked up at the garage at the last minute; you can see there has been some thought ie you like bags.
My DH went through a spell of buying me very sparkly tacky-looking jewellery. It wasn't cheap and I'm a bit of a magpie in that I do tend to go 'ooh pretty!' at sparkly things. He hadn't realised that there was a difference between items that would catch my attention and items I'd wear. Once I realised why he was getting it so wrong, I just explained what I did like.

Rainydayss · 25/12/2021 05:53

Next year ask your daughters to help him pick a gift. Just exchange it, no big issue. It's annoying yes but some men are just not good at gifts.
It's really not worth ruining you day, they'll be posts on here later today of the DH who haven't bought one at all or done an Alan Richman Love Actually or drunk and abusive.

HollowTalk · 25/12/2021 05:44

Can't your daughters tell him what you'd like? What about an Amazon wish list?

OmgIThinkILikeYou · 25/12/2021 05:37

Lol if your fucked over a shit gift god only knows what me and dp are as we do no gifts 🤣

But like you, my dp is bloody fantastic in every other way so hopefully we can cling on for a few more years without giving each other perfect Xmas gifts