Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unprofessional Surveyor (Deeply Worried) :(

107 replies

SurveyorProblems · 24/12/2021 15:01

Hi lovely Mumsnetters,
First-time poster, but long-term lurker :)

Sorry to bother you all just before Christmas, but I am desperate for some wisdom and advice and I thought AIBU might be the best place for support. :(

A few weeks ago, we asked a surveyor to do a Level 3 Building Survey for a property we would like to purchase. We have just received the completed report from him and the quality of the report is shocking.

As first-time buyers we didn't know what to expect really. So we spoke to friends and looked at examples of Level 3 surveys online.
Unfortunately, the quality of the report he has sent to us is shocking.

For example, he has misspelt our names (not a big issue in itself), but also there are numerous spelling errors across the whole report (including sections/descriptions which do not make any grammatical sense at all).

More concerningly, he boasted of taking lots of photographs.
However, the attached photos are of very low quality. The images are extremely blurry and sometimes it is impossible to determine what exact issue is being highlighted here. (Think taking a picture of the boiler from a weird angle and in bad lighting - so bad it is impossible to read the model).

He has requested that we pay him £700 for this report.
We are not sure if we are being unreasonable with our concerns. So any advice is really appreciated.

I would be happy to attach some sections which highlight the poor quality.

OP posts:
roseblosssom · 28/12/2021 13:43

Agree with everything @MojoMoon said. We've renovated a few properties and it's always surprised us how many of our buyers have paid £600 for someone to come into the property for 15 mins to look at all the things they could of looked at themselves during the viewing.

Ask for the boiler to be serviced if it hasn't in the past year.
Did you check out the fuse board? If you're worried about the electrics you can have a EICR carried out - should mote often things will be outdated but not dangerous.
Other things the survey will look at are the windows, presumably you checked them all out?
Did you notice any cracks?

On the other issue, don't pay the crook until you've had proper advice.

Frazzled2207 · 28/12/2021 13:38

Agree I would not get an expensive survey for a new house in excellent condition

(Not necessarily recommending this approach but we are buying a 2007 house and not getting a survey at all)

Clymene · 28/12/2021 13:35

I'm really confused why you got a level 3 survey for a new property. A home buyers report will be fine and I wouldn't bother getting an electrical check either. Gas appliances will have had to have annual checks if the property was rented out.

I've only ever paid for Level 2 surveys and have never bought a property less than 100 years old.

SurveyorProblems · 28/12/2021 13:26

@MojoMoon
Thanks a lot for your very comprehensive guidance.
The property is in excellent condition - it is less than 20 years old and the estate agent actually felt a Home Buyers Report would suffice - I believe it was previously rented out.
I have asked for a gas safety check certificate from the vendor (I think he has recently paid for one).
If he hasn't got one, should I get in touch with British Gas myself to arrange one? I am assuming I would be covering the costs.

Should I pay an electrician and plumber for any checks?
I am sorry about all of these questions.

OP posts:
MadeForThis · 28/12/2021 12:52

I would refuse to pay and tell him you will be happy to defend that position in small claims court.

MojoMoon · 28/12/2021 12:34

He sounds dodgy but assuming you then go ahead and get another survey done, are you fully aware of that a survey doesn't cover?

They aren't structural engineers so can say nothing about structural issues.
They aren't electrician/electrical engineers so can say little about the electrics. Equally the plumbing - they cannot judge whether it meets gas safety standards.
They don't climb on the roof or into loft spaces or anywhere not immediately accessible.

So if you have specific structural concerns or issues around the roof etc, even a proper survey will not tell you much about those.

That's not to say you should not get one but to make sure your expectations are correctly aligned to what you should get.

PersonaNonGarter · 28/12/2021 12:09

Aw OP, deep breath - it’s going to be ok, you are fine and no don’t pay him. I am really sorry this has messed up your Christmas. It didn’t need to because you are completely within your rights and he will need to resolve this - not you.

He appears to have misrepresented his professional qualifications to you and undertaken work he was not suited to or qualified for. If so this was fraudulent. RIBA membership acts as a guarantee and provides safeguards in terms of professional negligence insurance. Right now you cannot rely on that report because it is not underwritten by professional standards. It is likely you would not get a mortgage based on that report and in any case you should not send it to the mortgage company as you now suspect it may be unsuitable.

So don’t pay him. Give him 7 days to provide you with details of his current professional regulators/professional bodies and insurance. If he fails to provide details within that time, start again (and note it with RIBA - who will be very unhappy).

User57327259 · 28/12/2021 12:08

It looks like this person who has done this L3 Report for you is a bit on the dodgy side. I hope you get to the bottom of this situation quickly.

I read that PP have mentioned RICS. I had a survey done on a property which I own. This surveyor who was part of a large company with offices in various locations asked for payment up front, I dont think that is very professional. He was sent by a well known local estate agent. He sent me the Report and it was awful. There were certain statements made that caused me alarm. What that surveyor did not know as the only person he saw in connection with that house was a woman alone in the premises. He was not aware that there were other members of the family who were experts on the subject he made false statements about. He was not aware that a workman who carried out certain jobs on the property was inspected by his professions governing body.

I took this up with his company and brought it to the attention of the senior complaints partner. All to no avail. I then referred it to the RICS who would not investigate. This surveyor had claimed there was a life threatening situation on the property but that was not important enough for RICS. (I had a group of experts come to check out his statements and they said there was no such danger and asked to see the Report which I showed them)

SurveyorProblems · 28/12/2021 11:46

@AnneElliott
How would I able to check this information?
I have PM-ed just to see if he is the same person....

OP posts:
SurveyorProblems · 28/12/2021 11:44

@Frazzled2207
The sad part is that he has no clue how serious this is. :(
He calls himself an architect and isn't one :(
Another problem is that he is stating that he has being doing the reports for almost 40 years and so this means that he is fully qualified to complete building surveys...

I actually had the audacity to ask me what exactly was missing from the report. His actual words were "what expectations have I not met?"

Erm...your report is not a L3 Building Survey...

OP posts:
Frazzled2207 · 28/12/2021 11:43

@Yuledo

What was asked for on the ad placed by your relative? What did he offer? What did he actually provide? Did he misrepresent his qualifications? If these don’t match, then he hadn’t got a leg to stand on.
Agree this is what is key here
Appleseesaw · 28/12/2021 11:41

I’m glad you’ve contacted the ARB. They take this sort of thing very seriously.

Yuledo · 28/12/2021 11:39

What was asked for on the ad placed by your relative? What did he offer? What did he actually provide? Did he misrepresent his qualifications?
If these don’t match, then he hadn’t got a leg to stand on.

AnneElliott · 28/12/2021 11:38

That is awful op - definitely report to RIBA if he's using their membership but is no longer a member!

Worth checking if he has any CCJs - the chancer we came across had several once we looked into it - and a swift email linking to them all and a 'see you in court' sent him swiftly packing. I'm trying to recall his name as he was also elderly, had had neighbour issues and was using RICS when he a was a no longer a member.

SurveyorProblems · 28/12/2021 11:38

@takenforgrantednana
I attached that picture as an example of the quality of the photographs.
I didn't want to include a picture of the boiler to respect the privacy of everyone involved. The boiler picture has some identifying objects included in the photo.

OP posts:
Frazzled2207 · 28/12/2021 11:36

I think he has blatantly misrepresented himself and you shouldn’t pay him a penny!

I’m fairly sure RIBA will want to know if someone is describing himself as an architect and is not.

SurveyorProblems · 28/12/2021 11:36

@notapizzaeater
Thanks for your message!
The job AD was posted on an online platform which asked submitters to fill in a multiple-choice type of form.

  • The online request was submitted for a surveyor to complete a "FULL BUILDING SURVEY". This is why all OTHER professionals who also replied to the AD were chartered surveyors with RICS registrations.
  • Now what is important is that the actual website (platform) states this definition of a "FULL BUILDING SURVEY" - "usually carried out by a Chartered Surveyor who is a member of RICS". It also states that the report needs to be a very detailed.

I have asked for the platform to send us a copy of our JOB request. I believe it includes a comment section where we have specifically asked for a RICS Level 3 Survey.

OP posts:
takenforgrantednana · 28/12/2021 11:32

[quote SurveyorProblems]@DynamiteFilledRadish
@SummerWhisper

Thanks so much for your messages, guys.
He is an independent surveyor so not attached to any company (works as a sole trader), but he does have an RICS no.
I have arranged to speak to him on Monday regarding some of the issues I have had with his report.
I explained the issue with the photos and he has emailed back a sob story about how he needs the money as Christmas has been cancelled now at his house and he has recently spent a lot of money on electrical repairs...
Attached is an example of the quality of the photographs we have received.[/quote]
that isnt a boiler! its the room thermostat

SurveyorProblems · 28/12/2021 11:29

Because of the bank holiday weekend, I cannot get legal advice until tomorrow, but I was just wondering if anyone has any words of wisdom regarding this:

I have read online that under the Consumer Rights Act 2015, I can ask for either a price reduction or ask for the guy to fix the problem.

However, I am not sure how this would apply in our case because
(a) he misrepresented his qualifications in order to gain our business. E.g. He omitted the fact that he does not hold the professional registration that he claims to have.

(b) He is NOT qualified to RECTIFY the mistakes he has made.
He has promised a Building Survey (which according to the job AD, he answered should be at least the equivalent of a RICS Level 3). He CANNOT provide this service, so how can he FIX his existing work?

I am sorry for adding to everyone's stress during his festive period. :(

OP posts:
notapizzaeater · 28/12/2021 11:27

Did he actually put any of this in writing to your relative ? What was the exact wording of your relatives ad ?

SurveyorProblems · 28/12/2021 11:23

More concerningly, in his paperwork refers to himself as an "Architect". However, I cannot find any record of him on the Architects Registration Board.arb.org.uk/
The title 'architect' is protected by law in the UK, so I am not sure why he calls himself one if he is not on the register.
I have emailed ARB for clarification.
Most importantly, my relative employedthis guy because the paperwork and information provided referredto him as being registered with RIBA and specifically identifiedhim as an architect.I suppose this is what they call misrepresentation.

OP posts:
SurveyorProblems · 28/12/2021 11:22

For example, I asked for this guy's RIBA registration number as he includes the word RIBA in his email signature and paperwork.
He explained that his RIBA registration has run out.
However, apparently he holds the appropriate qualifications and he is therefore qualified to complete a survey. I am not sure how he can use the term RIBA in his correspondence when he no longer has an active registration. I certainly would not be able to do this in my field.

OP posts:
SurveyorProblems · 28/12/2021 11:14

@Elieza @SummerWhisper @Shedmistress
@SturminsterNewton
@CrappyXmasMarket

Hi lovely mumsnetters - I hope you all had a fantastic festive season. :)
Unfortunately, mine has been ruined by this ongoing saga. :(

I thought I send a brief update as this will sound like a nightmare to you all...
I emailed this gentleman asking for clarification regarding his professional expertise and I expressed dismay at the quality of work provided.

The response to my email has literally left me speechless.

I am yet to meet someone with such little self-awareness and
understanding of professional standards.
He doesn't even seem to know the actual law surrounding the profession he claims to be a part of...
He will have a hard time arguing that he has not misrepresented his expertise/survey and his qualifications.

OP posts:
SummerWhisper · 26/12/2021 21:30

The point is, no matter what the agreement between whom, he has provided something that is not worth the paper it has been printed on. It's not a survey. It's an observation, or even just a record of what the house looks like. This is utterly useless information and this con merchant should not be given a penny. He knows this, hence the sob story / emotional blackmail. Con man loud and clear. An architect of 35 years usually would not be short of a few hundred quid...

Elieza · 26/12/2021 13:52

Sale of goods act

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread