Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's unacceptable so many women cry in the workplace?

542 replies

ttcpatronisers · 24/12/2021 07:57

I work in an office of approx 40 people. Half of them roughly are women.

Of the Half, the majority have cried in the workplace - many on multiple occasions and often when they are in the wrong about a situation.

I find this unprofessional and odd. Of the men, one has cried.

Why do women cry so often at work? Is it because there's some truth in us being unable to control our emotions? Is it because we fell it's accepted in society for women to cry? Or is it because we attention? Know we can get what we want when we cry as it softens a situation?

Honestly, I find it very odd and annoying. I feel it undermines us in the workplace.

I also find it incredibly unprofessional. Now obviously if something really bad has happened it's a different story but often these tears are because of minor events.

AIBU - crying at work isn't unprofessional
YANBU - people should hold their emotions together and perhaps go to the toilet and cry

OP posts:
MilduraS · 24/12/2021 11:30

When I've made mistakes at work I've gone to my line manager and told them. I haven't ended up in tears. The fact that so many at your workplace do is concerning. You might not think it's not a workplace issue but over the years I've only see a handful of colleagues (out of hundreds) cry.

TractorAndHeadphones · 24/12/2021 11:22

Also adding if a colleague cried to me I would support and find out what was happening

I don’t think people are going around performance crying

TractorAndHeadphones · 24/12/2021 11:21

What? I’ve never seen this happen. What sort of workplace are you in where people are constantly crying?

Maybe something else is going on but come on most people are sensible and won’t cry about silly things in public let alone the workplace

Mypathtriedtokillme · 24/12/2021 11:17

I worked in a really stressful job in finance when a company was failing and losing contracts.
Lots of redundancies and international parent company pressure for reporting etc
It was awful.

Tears are often a stress relief which is better than anger.
We joked it was an inefficient use of time to cry in the loos.

It’s a bigger issue if that so many people cry. Wtf is wrong with the culture and environment of the company?

sleezeandwineparty · 24/12/2021 11:17

I can't except this is not a company thing, I have cried when I have been in the wrong or let's be polite... perceived to be wrong (scapegoat) when I have been in the wrong in companies where the culture is supportive and mistakes are dealt with in an adult manner, I am fine, but the calling into an office and told off in a company where The culture is toxic or just badly managed, I have cried out of frustration and upset about my treatment not because I have done something wrong. I rarely cry and my current employer is able to convey their needs and any errors without causing me to breakdown. Also when people are under stress they make more mistakes.
On the other note,
Men biologically find it difficult to cry, woman's hormones can increase frequency of crying, and judging women on a scale of men v women is not constructive and is sexist.

Lolalovesmarmite · 24/12/2021 11:15

I cried at work when I was being horribly bullied by a sexist misogynistic boss. Up until that day I had stood up to him every single time he had crossed the line. I was isolated, exhausted and trapped because of my contract and he pushed me so far I lost my temper and burst into tears through anger and frustration. I’m sure lots of women cry crocodile tears, but lots of women don’t and a workplace where people are routinely in tears would ring a lot of alarm bells for me.

TheCatShatInTheHat · 24/12/2021 11:11

I've cried at work, most of my colleagues have cried at work - mostly in situations where it is safe to cry, for example in supervision. It's usually for personal reasons and not about work - though managing work while handling outside stress can be a factor.

It's perfectly fine to cry at my work. We actually need to know if something is going on in people's private life because it will often mean they will need extra support to do the work (Social workers).

Grimchmas · 24/12/2021 11:08

I welled up at work last week over a tender moment. A colleague said something lovely to me. How unprofessional of me Xmas Wink

In a world where we are all corporate robots, nobody would cry, be unreasonable, everybody would leave home life at home and not bring work home and we might have emotions but we'd all wear our carefully curated face with only Corporate ApprovedTM emotions at appropriate levels and appropriate times.

Unfortunately for capitalism (and perhaps for the OP Xmas Hmm ) we aren't robots, we are humans, fallible, messy humans who sometimes can't hold tears in.

My goodness, what a crime it is to be a fallible human at an inconvenient time Xmas Hmm

humdingle · 24/12/2021 11:05

@ttcpatronisers well let's see, you say lots of women cry at your current workplace and you've observed the same thing happening at your previous work too. Yet most people here are saying they don't observe the same thing at their work. And you say it's definitely not a workplace thing... so... gosh, could it be a YOU thing? You do seem to be the common denominator in all this crying at work... 🤔

TerraNovaTwo · 24/12/2021 11:02

[quote Copasetic]@TerraNovaTwo again I'd say it's not even nice or not nice. It is literally just a fact. If everyone is allowed to be different and cry all over the place, why should I not really be able to empathise with it? I can empathise with real issues (eg someone's mum being ill, divorce etc) but I can't empathise with crying in the workplace because you've done something wrong, missed a deadline etc. To me they aren't real issues. I am very black and white as a person and if you're putting energy into crying, then you're not putting energy into solving the problem. Whilst with a real life issue it cannot always be solved, in my experience a not real issue always can be.[/quote]
A professional crying over something that they ought to be accountable for, such as going over a deadline or having majorly fucked up at work, is one thing. That's not the same as crying because you feel pressure all round (divorce, bereavement, etc) or because you are subject to blatantly unfair treatment in your workplace.

Copasetic · 24/12/2021 11:00

@anon12345678901 absolutely I would. Both show a total loss of control.

YerWanIsGettinNotions · 24/12/2021 10:59

@ChargingBuck

Yes I agree with posters men have anger issues, that's a separate thread - I wasn't posting about that.

Inadvertently, you were.

Because this isn't to do with workplaces.
It's to do with the fact that women cry more frequently than men.
That is down to social conditioning. "Boys don't cry" etc, so even when experiencing similar stressors & emotions, women & men express those feelings differently.

I have never worked anywhere where the majority of the female staff broke down in tears though. In fact I can only remember a couple of instances, in a 4 decade career, so it's certainly unusual.

This!

I remember a study in the last few years that found that people who cry more frequently have a different hormonal composition and higher levels of certain hormones, and are less able to control it when distressed (including emotions such as annoyed, frustrated or angry, not just "sad" or even manipulative). Women tend to have higher levels of those hormones as our baseline "normal". We get more emotional when we have hormone spikes, during pregnancy or certain points in the menstrual cycle. That isn't news to anyone here.

It's not defective or a weakness. It just is what it is. And I agree with everyone who has said that we need to stop viewing women as defective men - that really is the problem. Would it be more professional if women lost their temper and took it out on junior staff with the same regularity as we accept unthinkingly of senior men? I'd take a few quiet tears any time.

That said, I've cried at work once, thanks to a dickhead boss, but in the toilets because I'm sure he'd have enjoyed the victory if he'd seen it. I didn't cry when I had a miscarriage in the office toilets. I came close on a phonecall once when helping a customer through very difficult life circumstances which would melt a heart of stone but asked a colleague to tell me a joke instead (and I was pregnant at the time!) There's probably a trigger in the workplace too, is what I'm saying.

icedcoffees · 24/12/2021 10:59

I don't think people should hold their emotions in, though I do agree crying openly at work is unprofessional, because of the reaction it tends to provoke in others.

So we should change how we behave in tough or upsetting situations just in case it causes an issue with other people?

If someone feels awkward or uncomfortable because a grown man/woman is crying, that's on them, surely?

Elleherd · 24/12/2021 10:57

...the absence of men crying shows they are handling the situation better.

No it doesn't, it shows they are handling it or not, differently.

I wish my male friend had cried at work. Out of apparently nowhere he became convinced he'd made an error that was going to have repercussions for many. He didn't cry, he didn't get angry. He behaved professionally. He sucked in his emotions and tried to find what he believed he must have done, so he could try and fix it.

His colleagues had little idea what was going on with him. Unable to find anything wrong but convinced there was, he got up one morning and killed himself.
Deeply damaged so many around him, and a total waste of a life.

DownToTheSleighAgain · 24/12/2021 10:57

What kind of workplace makes people cry when they make a mistake?

Are you saying that people who cry are big babies? Allowing yourself to cry is in many ways a sign of maturity.

anon12345678901 · 24/12/2021 10:57

@Copasetic

I totally agree. I don’t see how people can be expected to be taken seriously and be equal to men if they keep crying. I work in construction and know a female project manager who is not opposed to crying when things aren’t going her way but I couldn’t imagine her male counterparts ever doing this. They wouldn’t be ridiculed forever!
So the men who scream and shout, I take it you judge them just as harshly as women who cry?
Copasetic · 24/12/2021 10:55

@TerraNovaTwo again I'd say it's not even nice or not nice. It is literally just a fact. If everyone is allowed to be different and cry all over the place, why should I not really be able to empathise with it? I can empathise with real issues (eg someone's mum being ill, divorce etc) but I can't empathise with crying in the workplace because you've done something wrong, missed a deadline etc. To me they aren't real issues. I am very black and white as a person and if you're putting energy into crying, then you're not putting energy into solving the problem. Whilst with a real life issue it cannot always be solved, in my experience a not real issue always can be.

Circlesandtriangles · 24/12/2021 10:50

Well what's better? That people swear or shout or other behaviours? Or repress and then snap? Most of the time people cannot control when they cry in my experience. Why is it that people having normal human emotions feels uncomfortable and inconvenient for you? I agree it might not be professional in many contexts but sometimes it's necessary for people. People who work lose loved ones, have miscarriages, experience disappointment and fear and anxiety and all of this can lead to crying - usually when under other stresses too. For men, crying in public is a huge taboo as it's been drilled in since childhood to "man up", "big boys don't cry", "toughen up", "don't be a pansy" so they fear the social consequences of crying but I don't think that's a good thing at all, it means they have to repress normal human emotions. It doesn't mean men are tougher - it means they've been conditioned to feel shame for expressing their emotions, so they often don't, which to my mind is really sad and is why men consistently have higher rates of suicide or express emotion through displays of toxic masculinity.

YungWaffle · 24/12/2021 10:50

I think crying from women is just more publicly acceptable. I think more men than you know have likely cried at work, they just do it in a cubicle or something so that they don't have to deal with the social stigma (from men and women).

Uninterested · 24/12/2021 10:47

I’m not sure the fact that women cry more is social conditioning. As I said earlier I almost never cry but there have been times when I’ve felt generally more tearful and it’s been 100% because of hormones not because of changes in my circumstances. It’s an emotional reaction to a physical change. If we pumped men full of the same hormones then I bet they would cry too!

Starseeking · 24/12/2021 10:47

I don't think people should hold their emotions in, though I do agree crying openly at work is unprofessional, because of the reaction it tends to provoke in others.

It also really depends on why they are crying.

I have cried twice at work across a 20 year career. The first was when I worked in the City about 15 years ago, and after a client spent 10 minutes screaming abuse down the phone to me, it was disgusting. I was so shocked I burst into tears immediately after putting the phone down. My lovely boss at the time made the client apologise, which he did, but left within 6 months of that incident - yay!

The second was earlier this year, soon after I'd had a miscarriage, left my EXDP, sold my house and missed out on securing a new big job. I had a day packed full of meetings, and my DD's nursery called saying she had a high temperature. Everything I was feeling wobbly about came out in one big emotion in a side office, though my bosses PA noticed and had a word, and I was allowed to (gratefully) go home and collect my DD from nursery.

JohnSmithDrive · 24/12/2021 10:47

Why are "people" crying so much at your workplace?

In four years at mine, with a staff of 120, I know of three occasions when someone has cried. One was struggling with a marriage break up and probably shouldn't have been in work, one had a bereavement and the other was the subject of a malicious grievance.

IncompleteSenten · 24/12/2021 10:46

Some people are cryers, some aren't. I do think that tears are often manipulative but the sex difference is because boys and girls are socialised differently. Big boys don't cry and all that crap.

TerraNovaTwo · 24/12/2021 10:46

[quote Copasetic]@TerraNovaTwo it’s not a boast. It’s a fact.[/quote]
That's nice.

icedcoffees · 24/12/2021 10:46

@Mouseonmychair

You aren't going to get a sensible answer on here. But I agree where I see massively more women crying than men I think it is weaponisation of tears normally and an attempt to make people feel sorry for them. Even if the workplace is crap (which the op assures isn't) then the absence of men crying shows they are handling the situation better.
Or men show their frustration and anger in other ways, like shouting, ranting and raving instead.

I've never met a man who cried at work. I have, however, met my fair share of men who think shouting and belittling people is the right way to show how frustrated they are.

Swipe left for the next trending thread