Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's unacceptable so many women cry in the workplace?

542 replies

ttcpatronisers · 24/12/2021 07:57

I work in an office of approx 40 people. Half of them roughly are women.

Of the Half, the majority have cried in the workplace - many on multiple occasions and often when they are in the wrong about a situation.

I find this unprofessional and odd. Of the men, one has cried.

Why do women cry so often at work? Is it because there's some truth in us being unable to control our emotions? Is it because we fell it's accepted in society for women to cry? Or is it because we attention? Know we can get what we want when we cry as it softens a situation?

Honestly, I find it very odd and annoying. I feel it undermines us in the workplace.

I also find it incredibly unprofessional. Now obviously if something really bad has happened it's a different story but often these tears are because of minor events.

AIBU - crying at work isn't unprofessional
YANBU - people should hold their emotions together and perhaps go to the toilet and cry

OP posts:
maddiemookins16mum · 24/12/2021 18:38

I’ve been in the workplace for 40 years. The only time I’ve seen Women (and a few men) cry was…
Death of family member
Car accident
Bullying in the workplace
and when the large travel firm/airline I worked for went bust 4 years ago and we were given 10 minutes to clear our desks and leave the building.

I’ve cried at work, my mum had died.

RoyalFamilyFan · 24/12/2021 18:35

I rarely cry anywhere. The only time I ever cried at work was a horrendous place where people were treated like shit by management. And yes others cried too.

SwishSwishBisch · 24/12/2021 18:31

@ttcpatronisers I’m curious, how do you release emotion when you're stressed/angry/humiliated/frustrated? What is your coping mechanism?

I work in a supportive, but stressful, industry. I’ve seen plenty of women get tearful in the office over the years - the vast majority of whom bite it down until they can escape to privacy, they’re not looking for sympathy or cuddles. I don’t find that unprofessional at all. Crying is a very natural response to heightened emotional states for some people, and our society’s insistence that crying is embarrassing/shameful/unprofessional does us no favours.

Can I suggest instead of offering your colleagues disdainful looks, you offer them a tissue and get on with your day?

GrimDamnFanjo · 24/12/2021 18:29

Ex civil servant here. I heard n the grapevine that a female minister was reduced to weeping silently in a meeting by her boss. This was in front of staff and special advisors, but could not be seen by the Minister who got her into this state.
If you think carefully you can work out who the boss was...

DrSbaitso · 24/12/2021 18:28

[quote Justheretoaskaquestion91]@DrSbaitso

I’m not surprised but I think it’s silly. I’m not embarrassed that as a woman I cry more than mine - I accept that that’s how it is/I’m proud of being a woman and that’s fine by me. I think it’s silly to try to deny it.[/quote]
I'm sure we all take your opinion with all due respect.

Copasetic · 24/12/2021 18:27

@DrSbaitso

Would you cry in a job interview?

Dunno. Would you be interviewing me?

Grin
tillytown · 24/12/2021 18:24

Where I work two of the men were fired for sexual harassment (should have been more but the others are friends with the ceo), two for fighting in the office, and one for stalking - I would prefer crying over this mess.

Why2why · 24/12/2021 18:23

OP read White Tears, Brown Scars and you’ll understand some people f the psychology behind the tears.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 24/12/2021 18:22

@DrSbaitso

I’m not surprised but I think it’s silly. I’m not embarrassed that as a woman I cry more than mine - I accept that that’s how it is/I’m proud of being a woman and that’s fine by me. I think it’s silly to try to deny it.

luckylavender · 24/12/2021 18:19

@ttcpatronisers - no we can't just 'accept that'. It's unusual. What's your recruitment process? Training? Support? Management? Coaching?

DrSbaitso · 24/12/2021 18:14

@Justheretoaskaquestion91

YANBU. Women cry more than men and yes it’s unprofessional. But this is MN where women are superheroes and men are villains so of course everyone is missing the point snd no one will agree with you.
Why are so many of these types surprised that a site for women centres women? And so threatened by it? Because that's all this weary old whinge is ever about.
Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 24/12/2021 18:10

YANBU. Women cry more than men and yes it’s unprofessional. But this is MN where women are superheroes and men are villains so of course everyone is missing the point snd no one will agree with you.

virtuallyanass · 24/12/2021 18:09

I've only cried once, a more senior member of staff who was not my boss, was telling me I was wrong and going on and on. However it was done like that. , I was the doer, I said that's how I'm doing it as that how I was trained. So she basically didn't know her stuff.

I have some staff in the past that cry very regularly, I don't think I've made them cry but other colleagues.

LakieLady · 24/12/2021 18:05

Side point: why are so many misogynists unable to spell the word? Does their autocorrect not work? Do their mums' basements emit a blocker on the technology?

Love this, @DrSbaitso.

LakieLady · 24/12/2021 18:03

I used to work with vulnerable people and families who were homeless, or at risk of becoming so.

Everyone on the team, including the men, has had a caseor two that has been so hopeless that they have been reduced to tears at least once, because of the sadness of clients' situations, but also throught rage and frustration at the lack of support and austerity cuts that make a bad situation worse.

The organisation has a caring and supportive ethos, and no-one, from the CEO down, would regard crying at work as unprofessional. Staff are always treated in a very supportive way when dealing with distressing cases, both my management and their peers. The approach is the same when the tears are caused by personal matters.

PigeonPants · 24/12/2021 18:01

Not RTFT so apologies if duplicate, but Anne Kreamer's It's Always Personal: Navigating Emotion in the New Workplace (2011) discusses a lot of related issues. In addition to crying, she dissects and attempts to categorise and critique expressions of anger, fear, anxiety, empathy, and joy in "professional" settings and understand some of the reasons why they may be or appear to be categorically different for men vs women.

Is what is considered "professional" and "unprofessional" shaped by the fact that the workforce in white collar type settings has historically been primarily male, and the managerial levels who set the tone and decide the corporate culture even more so? Yes, of course there are some cases where crying becomes disruptive and self-indulgent and therefore inappropriate, but there's appropriate (and, she argues, even constructive) expressions of extreme emotions too - where are the lines drawn? Do they differ for men and woman, and in professional settings in different cultures (the book is primarily US-focused)? Perhaps some men should be crying more, or at least equally free to - and then we can decide what inappropriate crying is for everyone, not based on sex.

There's also a strong message being actively spread by misogynists at the moment (not covered in this book, as it's several years old) that women in general specifically weaponise tears and use them to manipulate and so any expression of emotion from women should be distrusted - and, especially, any expression that others do not share or understand. This is used to discredit women speaking about their own experience which, if you take a look around the world and even around the UK or US, is pretty shocking.

And yet, at the same time, there are still culturally pervasive attitudes - mainly but not exclusively outside of professional settings - that a stoic man is praiseworthy and a role model but a woman who doesn't show any emotion is a cold fish, unfeeling bitch, not empathetic, etc. So women get blamed for being too emotional - and not emotional enough. A lot of attitudes and perceptions about women crying and about men crying are still bound up tightly with regressive gender stereotypes, and with misogyny.

DrSbaitso · 24/12/2021 18:00

And so what? On MN there are always people starting threads about all the bad things men do - from rape to cheating. Never heard anyone defend the criticism of men and call it mysoginist to point out a flaw in their gender.

This makes no sense, yet somehow still reveals the true agenda. Gosh, it was so convincing behind that clever disguise. Rape, cheating, and crying at work. Damn, you got us.

Side point: why are so many misogynists unable to spell the word? Does their autocorrect not work? Do their mums' basements emit a blocker on the technology?

AlabamaSong · 24/12/2021 17:53

Working in a tech company a few years ago I saw a lot of tears, both joy and grief. People had given their heart and soul, some major contracts were both won, and some lost. We were bought by a larger competitor, a (financial) relief for some, and the end of the dream for others.

It doesn't sound like the OP has a lot of experience working in high pressure environments.

ttcpatronisers · 24/12/2021 17:50

@TheKeatingFive

For example, shouting, swearing, banging fists, even laughing really wildly. These are unprofessional things to do in the workplace.

But you didn't. You chose to start a thread about one thing women do more than men. 🤔

And so what? On MN there are always people starting threads about all the bad things men do - from rape to cheating. Never heard anyone defend the criticism of men and call it mysoginist to point out a flaw in their gender.

Funny that.

OP posts:
Chouetted · 24/12/2021 17:46

Why would crying be unprofessional?

I might cry in a job interview, yes. It's not like it's a choice. If I do, I probably just stubbed my toe or something. I might even shout "Ow!", because stubbing your toe hurts like hell. Or it's my hayfever, which i really can't control. I'd just apologise/explain quickly and move on, because that's the professional thing to do.

I never cry to manipulate people, I never expect any attention from anyone else because I'm crying. In fact, it irritates me when people try to draw attention to it, or extract meaning from it, and I find that unprofessional. Sometimes water comes out of my eyes and that's... because I'm human.

DrSbaitso · 24/12/2021 17:44

Would you cry in a job interview?

Dunno. Would you be interviewing me?

TheKeatingFive · 24/12/2021 17:39

For example, shouting, swearing, banging fists, even laughing really wildly. These are unprofessional things to do in the workplace.

But you didn't. You chose to start a thread about one thing women do more than men. 🤔

ttcpatronisers · 24/12/2021 17:29

I find it both interesting and odd how people perceive crying in the workplace. For a start, I never said it was so awful - but it is unprofessional.

Would you cry in a job interview? If not why as it's even to be such a positive thing for those who cannot see what I mean?

There are may behaviours unprofessional not just crying. I just decided to start a thread about crying.

For example, shouting, swearing, banging fists, even laughing really wildly. These are unprofessional things to do in the workplace.

At home, swearing is fine, all of those other behaviours are fine - just not in a professional environment. My personal opinion, prepared to get flamed which I have but 🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
SpookyScarySkeletons · 24/12/2021 17:24

@HunterGatherer

I was redeployed to a covid ward last year and saw every member of staff cry at some point. Including the men.
ThanksThanksThanks

Thank you so much to you and your colleagues.

FateHasRedesignedMost · 24/12/2021 17:13

I work in a team of about 10 women and have seen most of them cry over the years for various reasons.

My boss used to cry every time she had PMS (she’d start a row, cry then apologise and blame PMS!)

Our manager cried openly when we lost a patient. She also cried a lot when she was pregnant.

One female manager cried in a management meeting because she’d been up all night with teething toddler and nursery called her to say toddler had been sick.

Maybe men have less juggling to do? Eg they’re statistically less likely to be up in the night with kids, racing to and from school or nursery runs, on call to pick up sick kids, balancing work with the mental load of running a household etc?

I’ve cried at work once, when I felt attacked and undermined in a meeting I wasn’t prepared for or expecting. I desperately didn’t want to cry but it happened. It didn’t help I’d been woken at 3am that day by my DC and since getting to work there had been emergency after emergency, staff snapping, my friend crying on my shoulder about something. So I got angry and defensive and I guess that led to tears?

Maybe men express emotion differently eg shut down and withdraw, or become openly angry and raise their voice, or attack back when they feel threatened or hurt?

Swipe left for the next trending thread