Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's unacceptable so many women cry in the workplace?

542 replies

ttcpatronisers · 24/12/2021 07:57

I work in an office of approx 40 people. Half of them roughly are women.

Of the Half, the majority have cried in the workplace - many on multiple occasions and often when they are in the wrong about a situation.

I find this unprofessional and odd. Of the men, one has cried.

Why do women cry so often at work? Is it because there's some truth in us being unable to control our emotions? Is it because we fell it's accepted in society for women to cry? Or is it because we attention? Know we can get what we want when we cry as it softens a situation?

Honestly, I find it very odd and annoying. I feel it undermines us in the workplace.

I also find it incredibly unprofessional. Now obviously if something really bad has happened it's a different story but often these tears are because of minor events.

AIBU - crying at work isn't unprofessional
YANBU - people should hold their emotions together and perhaps go to the toilet and cry

OP posts:
MagnoliaXYZ · 26/12/2021 09:06

I have cried twice at work. It was awful as I hate crying in front of anyone.

The first was after my first cardiac arrest where the patient died (I saw one as a student in A&E but the patient came in in cardiac arrest and it didn't really affect me as we were pre-warned and the paramedics had been on scene for a long time so expected it would be a poor outcome) and my second was after I'd qualified but we resuscitated that patient (the family came in and the patient died peacefully after I'd gone home). It was the middle of the night. I went to the staff room and cried on my own in the dark for about 5 minutes.

The second was after a disagreement with the clinical site manager. I was so angry with the decision she had made and I went and spoke to my lovely manager who agreed with my viewpoint. I cried after she said that. It was embarrassing as her office was right in the middle of the ward and I had to walk out of her office on to the ward to get to the staff room or the loo.

WhatWouldKalindaDo · 26/12/2021 03:57

I'm a veterinary nurse who has dealt with animals suffering awful trauma and witnessed many euthanasias. I've also spent hours in surgery with animals only to have them die in recovery.

I've absolutely cried at work before, I'm not ashamed of it and i don't think it's unprofessional. As a pp said, we're not robots.

Also, not everyone works in a corporate office environment. Some of us have jobs dealing with severe emotional situations on a daily basis.

OP I bet even you would cry if you had to witness someone putting their best friend of 15 years to sleep and hold their hand afterwards as they cried on your shoulder.

EarthSight · 25/12/2021 21:09

@temperancefugit

In my last job, a certain woman would burst into tears if someone disagreed with them when they were being unreasonable. Boss always came down on their side. I got so exasperated watching this happen again and again, when it was my turn to be overruled by their using this tactic, I went to boss's office immediately and 'broke down.' He overruled her and decided in my favour. Sometimes it's sheer manipulation, not always genuine distress. Only time I have ever done that. I'm usually a suffer in silence type of person.
@temperancefugit That's terrible.
EarthSight · 25/12/2021 21:08

Never heard anyone defend the criticism of men and call it mysoginist to point out a flaw in their gender

I have on a few threads on the relationships boards (which indecently, are full of women who've been emotionally abused, financially abused, physically threatened, physically beaten up, sexually assaulted and raped by men in past or current relationships).

One or two will show up to educate those women with NOT ALL MEN. Sometimes it's good to flip things around to see things from a different perspective, to question if we're being unfair. However, I do think it's unsurprising that all of the places of the internet those men could go, they choose to go on a website mainly for and dominated by women to tell women off for discussing inconvenient facts or experiences.

Stroopwaffle5000 · 25/12/2021 21:02

I have ADHD so have difficulty regulating my emotions sometimes and yes I have cried at work before. I'd be mortified if I knew someone like you was judging me, as I said, I can't help it!

BridStar · 25/12/2021 20:25

I've never seen anyone cry in the workplace, where the hell do you work? Maybe you need to ask why so many adults are forced to cry at your job rather than blaming them. It sounds a very weird place.

temperancefugit · 25/12/2021 18:17

In my last job, a certain woman would burst into tears if someone disagreed with them when they were being unreasonable. Boss always came down on their side. I got so exasperated watching this happen again and again, when it was my turn to be overruled by their using this tactic, I went to boss's office immediately and 'broke down.' He overruled her and decided in my favour. Sometimes it's sheer manipulation, not always genuine distress. Only time I have ever done that. I'm usually a suffer in silence type of person.

YenniferOfVengaBus · 25/12/2021 16:59

Agree it’s not necessarily a toxic workplace that is making people cry.

More likely to be working with you.

The men will find other, equally unprofessional, ways to channel their negative emotions around that.

Wineisrequired · 25/12/2021 16:21

YABVU- you sound like a very hard faced unsympathetic person .

ThesecondLEM · 25/12/2021 07:38

We had a "crying chair" at my old job.

I have cried loads at work and I'm as hard as nails. However, I am a veterinary nurse and it can be heart wrenching. I have never cried in front of a client its the men crying over their pets that breaks me.

Saoirse82 · 25/12/2021 04:53

@HairyFanjoBanjo

You come across contemptuous and sexist.

Women do this thing, men don’t, why can’t women be more like men. Hmm

I agree with this. And I say this as someone who rarely cries, my husband cries more than I do and I've always found it frustrating that tears don't come easy to me as I feel that tears help you heal, everyone feels better after a cry being able to realise that emotion. It's not that I don't feel the emotion I just don't cry, my mum is the same, I've seen my dad cry more than her so you're being sexist and you're wrong in your thinking.
StruggleStreet · 25/12/2021 04:45

People aren’t robots OP, it’s okay to show human emotion. I’d say if people at your workplace feel free to show some emotion in front of their colleagues and to talk about personal issues, that could also indicate a high trust environment rather than a toxic environment as people are suggesting.

Krabapple · 25/12/2021 04:33

After reading your posts I think you might be the problem here I think I’d cry if I worked with you.

peaceatlastnot · 25/12/2021 04:29

Try working in a school!

Gladioli23 · 25/12/2021 04:19

I don't think crying at work is ideal, but it's not a career limiting problem either. But then I would think that, as I have cried at work.

I work in an extremely high stress environment now, and am an extremely high performer - if you want something difficult to impossible doing, I'm the person you ask to get it done. I'm really highly regarded. But I also have limits, and I have cried when I am pushed to those limits over and over again.

Once (but not in the meeting) when someone external to the organisation was extremely rude, completely misunderstood what was going on and talked to me like I was 6.

Another time (not in front of anyone) after a hundred and something hour round of working. The most embarrassing that I remember was after 5-6 weeks of 70+ hour weeks, I'd had a call at 7pm from the chief exec needing stuff the next morning but 10, then at 9pm moving the deadline to 8am (because the parent Co were being twats and using that as a power move) I worked til 11 pm then got up at 4:30 and carried on (maybe not that insane but I only do brain work and my brain does not function without a full 8 hours) - met the deadline. But someone (new and a weird position of being sort of but not entirely my boss rang me: I'd never spoken to them before, they made the grave error of asking me how I was and I burst into floods of tears and sobbed down the phone at them.

It was awkward but both she and I got over it, and it absolutely hasn't impacted our work relationship - she is still trying to poach me to work for her full time. I always deliver and I deliver when no one else can, but I'm not an emotion free robot and people have to take the rough with the smooth - and in my workplace, given the promotions I've been given and the trust that is placed with me, that's a compromise they think is a good deal.

I've dealt with various other people crying at work: my previous job was a terrible workplace and people cried there all the time. It didn't make them bad people, it made it a dreadful place to work. Everyone I know who has left has been extremely successful in everything that they have done since, so it was definitely the workplace, not the people. Other times I've dealt with people crying due to e.g. a miscarriage and frankly that hasn't coloured my opinion of them at all. Most of them are people who can step out up when you need them and do deliver, whereas the non criers plod along and can't function at a high octane.

I've seen director level staff get to the point of cracked voices, teary eyes and had to do my fair share of calming down and telling them we'll get through this. I think it's an outcome of highly stressful environments tbh.

Furries · 25/12/2021 02:05

@ttcpatronisers - your style of posting/phrasing gives a bit of insight as to why your workplace might not be the utopia you think it is.

I completely get the “don’t bring personal stuff to work” thing in some ways. But sometimes situations break you in the moment - and your view seems very fixed.

This will probably sound very old fashioned and uneducated - because I am not meaning to lump women together and put them down. But if you take a good, honest look at your male workforce - there will be a woman supporting him somehow. Whether it’s a wife, fiancée, partner etc (even their mum). Their home lives, in a lot of cases, will somehow have someone else looking after them in some small way.

I’m reading back the small points I’ve made and, in a small way, it makes me cringe. But it’s the subtle truth. Men will never take on the mental or emotional load that women do - not in the greater scheme of things.

So, yes, women will often “break”. And it might be because of something that’s gone wrong at work. Personally, I’d kind of take it as a positive - because someone who doesn’t give a shit isn’t going to get upset. But I know that others would say that being unemotional is the best thing for business results.

I’d like to stress again, though, please be mindful that a lot of women in the workplace carry much more “load” than men do - it’s not obvious, it’s not right, but a lot of working women enable the working men to appear “better”.

If it helps - I’m single and no children. No “skin” in the game, but it’s what I’ve garnered from numerous years in fairly high pressured jobs.

Chouetted · 25/12/2021 00:40

I'd also suggest that minor difficulties with emotional regulation are probably not the sort of thing you want to be loudly railing against, unless you're 100% sure that this does not arise from a protected disability. There's laws against that sort of thing.

Happy Christmas, I hope I never have to work with you.

Luredbyapomegranate · 25/12/2021 00:19

Dunno. I’ve never encountered much if any crying and overall I’ve worked with c 50/50 men and women.

I guess some people have trouble controlling their emotions in the obvious, whether that’s anger, distress, anxiety, or whatever it is that causes bullying. You’re probably right crying is more common in women, but I expect the reverse is true for loosing your temper and shouting. I don’t think either is wrong as long as it’s very occasional - but some people just have trouble managing their emotions.

Emerald5hamrock · 25/12/2021 00:18

Boy's from previous generations were taught not to cry, called awful names if they were emotional.
I saw DP cry once in 16 years, he has seen me cry 100's of times over the years through sadness out of my control, not over an argument.
I've had a lot of loss he hasn't experienced yet.
My father never cried nor does my Dbro.

ldontWanna · 25/12/2021 00:16

@ttcpatronisers

The strange thing about this thread is that so many people put it down to a toxic workplace! Really? So every time someone cries it must be the workplace fault / it's like nowadays no one can take accountability for anything.

I've been in toxic workplaces but I don't cry! I stand up for myself if something isn't right - doesn't mean crying is still and acceptable regular way to behave.

What do you want? A cookie?

Here's the thing ... you're not special,stronger,more resilient. You're just another run of the mill emotional shut down.

aaaaaaaaaaaah · 25/12/2021 00:11

I've seen quite a few colleagues cry in various jobs I've had, mainly due to things going on outside of work. I have a couple of times myself (not proud of it). I think for me and the colleagues I've seen cry it's due to putting on a face when going through something difficult and just cracking in the moment. We are all human. Maybe shouldn't have gone to work that day but haven't wanted to let anyone down

Blanketpolicy · 25/12/2021 00:11

I am fairly good at compartmentalising my emotions, but once, when we found out my brother had cancer, work was stressful, I made a mistake, I broke down. Couldnt help it, excused myself and went to the loo and was mortified.

Thankfully I dont work with you op and everyone was very understanding.

Men generally dont cry, but it doesn't mean they dont sometimes need some understanding too. We are all human.

Puffin208 · 24/12/2021 23:57

Just to add, my comments relate to crying being an issue because it's a toxic workplace.

And after I'd done my weeping from fury in the broom cupboard, since plug-in AI decision making algorithms aren't yet available for most humans, I then usually turned into Jadis the witch and sorted out the issue as far as possible. The weeping in the broom cupboard was infinitely preferable to my doing what I've seen many male "superiors" (and a few women) do over the years, including ranting, raving, kicking walls, smashing desks, and using fat red face and bad breath and teeth proximity as an attempted method of intimidation.

Although I've direct experience of it not always being the case, as have many of my friends and family, I'd hope any employer would understand an employee crying out of sympathy for clients, patients, pupils, other humans, or animals; anger and frustration at deliberate political decisions and their damaging effects on much of society; or because they've had a bereavement or a near miss accident or have to live with an abusive or ill relative. Just to give a few examples.

littledrummergirl · 24/12/2021 23:55

I've been in toxic work situations where I stood up for myself and others. One resulted in an out of court settlement but it broke my mental health.
6 years down the line I still suffer, everytime I feel emotionally stronger something happens which gives me flashbacks and I end up crying. It's usually due to frustration at the unfairness of what is being said.
I fucking hate it but when I have cried it's because of a toxic manager.

ttcpatronisers · 24/12/2021 23:47

The strange thing about this thread is that so many people put it down to a toxic workplace! Really? So every time someone cries it must be the workplace fault / it's like nowadays no one can take accountability for anything.

I've been in toxic workplaces but I don't cry! I stand up for myself if something isn't right - doesn't mean crying is still and acceptable regular way to behave.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread