Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's unacceptable so many women cry in the workplace?

542 replies

ttcpatronisers · 24/12/2021 07:57

I work in an office of approx 40 people. Half of them roughly are women.

Of the Half, the majority have cried in the workplace - many on multiple occasions and often when they are in the wrong about a situation.

I find this unprofessional and odd. Of the men, one has cried.

Why do women cry so often at work? Is it because there's some truth in us being unable to control our emotions? Is it because we fell it's accepted in society for women to cry? Or is it because we attention? Know we can get what we want when we cry as it softens a situation?

Honestly, I find it very odd and annoying. I feel it undermines us in the workplace.

I also find it incredibly unprofessional. Now obviously if something really bad has happened it's a different story but often these tears are because of minor events.

AIBU - crying at work isn't unprofessional
YANBU - people should hold their emotions together and perhaps go to the toilet and cry

OP posts:
ChequerBoard · 24/12/2021 10:20

Well this is a proper Xmas pile on.

I agree with you OP. I am 50 and have encountered women in senior roles who cry in the workplace when it's not going their way. I hate it.

And to be clear it the cases I am referring to no, it's not a culture thing, no it's not a personal issue causing the upset. It's a behaviour where there is an expectation that turning on the waterworks will garner sympathy and take the pressure off when a difficult issue arises.

It is highly unprofessional and very manipulative.

Copasetic · 24/12/2021 10:19

However, I don’t work in a caring environment and therefore my people are crying about deadlines not being met and not real life issues. I am not extending this to people dealing with real life and death situations as they are hugely pressured/stressful and I’m sure they are not bursting into tears in front of the public but simply occasionally amongst their team who would absolutely get it. Equally, anyone going through divorces, family illnesses and deaths - we all have these problems and men equally may cry in the work place about a family death for example but this is occasional too. What I think is unprofessional is crying over work issues in the work place.

ZorbaTheHoarder · 24/12/2021 10:18

[quote Copasetic]@Icenii people are all different and that is a positive. I can’t see a single positive that comes out of simply being weaker and then publicly displaying that weakness though.[/quote]
@Copasetic

Are you serious? Does crying mean that you are a "weaker" person?
Is it some terrible crime to display any weakness?

You sound as though you have about as much empathy as the OP, which is not saying a great deal!

Motnight · 24/12/2021 10:18

You are right Op. Those women who cry should be sacked immediately and replaced with more people just like you!

TerraNovaTwo · 24/12/2021 10:17

[quote Copasetic]@Icenii people are all different and that is a positive. I can’t see a single positive that comes out of simply being weaker and then publicly displaying that weakness though.[/quote]
Does crying mean a person is weak?

Icenii · 24/12/2021 10:16

If you think about it, men created and dominated the workforce and somehow emotions generally associated with femininity are not considered acceptable. Why is that?

I am not a cryer, I rarely see people cry in my male dominated profession, but I've seen aggression, anger, back stabbing. I know what emotion I'd rather be faced with.

TerraNovaTwo · 24/12/2021 10:16

Why do we have to act 'like men' to be treated equally? We are equal NOT the same. And we are both human so should be treated as such. You have no idea what those women are dealing with behind closed doors and what kind of arseholery they may be encountering 'professionally'.

Bore off with this stiff upper lip crap

CallMeNutribullet · 24/12/2021 10:15

I have cried at work a few times when I was going through enormous personal upheaval (bereavement) and then things went wrong at work to tip me over the edge.

I hated it and yes felt unprofessional but it was entirely outwith my control. I think if you're not someone who cries you think people who do can turn tears on and off like a tap. Trust me I can't control it. My brother also is sensitive so I don't NECESSARILY think men can't be like this too but I think men are raised to push down their feelings from a young age and express them in anger rather than through tears

AutumnWinterSpring · 24/12/2021 10:14

[quote Copasetic]@Icenii people are all different and that is a positive. I can’t see a single positive that comes out of simply being weaker and then publicly displaying that weakness though.[/quote]
Why is crying a weakness?

TerraNovaTwo · 24/12/2021 10:13

YABVU - Why do you think it is abnormal to cry when you are overwhelmed or shocked in a professional situation/job? To express emotion? To be human

And why are so many people in this workplace crying?

Copasetic · 24/12/2021 10:13

@Icenii people are all different and that is a positive. I can’t see a single positive that comes out of simply being weaker and then publicly displaying that weakness though.

AutumnWinterSpring · 24/12/2021 10:13

[quote ttcpatronisers]@GabriellaMontez no 'male' emotions are often unacceptable too but my post was about crying, not men [/quote]
Unacceptable to you.

Cry, laugh, whatever… just get the job done. Although I would be very concerned if half my team (I manage 27) burst into tears regardless of reason.

Thecurtainsofdestiny · 24/12/2021 10:11

I have cried when a patient has died. Not in front of the public but in staff only spaces. I'm glad my colleagues have been understanding. As I am to them in a similar situation.

AutumnWinterSpring · 24/12/2021 10:08

@ttcpatronisers

Oh ffs people I've just explained - theu are crying because they've made a mistake in their job for example - or they are causing a problem or - they're having marital problems.

It is NOT a company thing - can we just accept that?

Are you making them cry? Wink
Teacupsandtrainers · 24/12/2021 10:07

[quote ttcpatronisers]@GabriellaMontez no 'male' emotions are often unacceptable too but my post was about crying, not men [/quote]
What are the professional and unprofessional emotions? Is there a list online somewhere? A training course I missed?

NinaDefoe · 24/12/2021 10:07

Just to add, I work with teenagers and the boys cry a lot more than the girls in school.
Girls often go very quiet.
Boys tend get angry and shout a lot too. They get embarrassed but I have helped dry lots of tears believe me.
Big generalisation but true on the whole.

Icenii · 24/12/2021 10:07

I don’t see how people can be expected to be taken seriously and be equal to men if they keep crying

Being equal does not mean being exactly the same. Do we have to act with masculinity, a label created by society, to be taken seriously?

Nowomenaroundeh · 24/12/2021 10:07

I absolutely hate this too OP, it plays right into the hands of the patriarchy.

It sounds like a culture has evolved where this is an acceptable line of defence.

Years ago I worked in sales and mentioned to two of my co-workers I wasn't looking forward to my quarterly review as for the first time, I had missed my target. They both urgently advised I cry as the boss didn't know how to deal with it. I was appalled.

MondeoFan · 24/12/2021 10:04

I've cried at work because they made a massive mistake in my wages and I was really counting on the money that day. Had nothing to do with me being unprofessional, it was out of sheer frustration. I had to pay the balance on a holiday that day otherwise I was going to lose the booking.

Some staff have cried at my work if they don't feel well, broken up with boyfriends or had an argument with a fellow colleague.

As we are all women working together except for 1 male I don't really give it much thought

NinaDefoe · 24/12/2021 10:03

@Copasetic

I totally agree. I don’t see how people can be expected to be taken seriously and be equal to men if they keep crying. I work in construction and know a female project manager who is not opposed to crying when things aren’t going her way but I couldn’t imagine her male counterparts ever doing this. They wouldn’t be ridiculed forever!
I bet plenty of them shout, swear, kick things and get angry.
Bwix · 24/12/2021 10:02

I have found the small number of occasions when I have cried at work totally mortifying. I would really rather not express emotions in the office like that. But it’s not as if you get to make a rational and considered choice on whether to cry or not. If I could choose, I would choose not to.

I think in over 20 years, there are four occasions when I have cried and one where I kept it together but was on the edge of tears. Two involved people shouting at me, one was after a bereavement, one was in a hugely pressured situation when I was heavily pregnant and the one where I was on the edge was following some unacceptable behaviour from a colleague.

This is how women typically express extremes of emotion. While men might shout. Shaming people for crying doesn’t make a great working environment: sometimes life deals you punches.

NerrSnerr · 24/12/2021 10:00

I bet quite a few men cry in the workplace, they just need to hide it due to sexism. They'll go off to the toilets or somewhere quiet to do it.

I work in mental health services and people do cry quite a lot. Sometimes the stuff you're having to deal with it at work is worthy of a little cry.

ldontWanna · 24/12/2021 09:58

@Copasetic

I totally agree. I don’t see how people can be expected to be taken seriously and be equal to men if they keep crying. I work in construction and know a female project manager who is not opposed to crying when things aren’t going her way but I couldn’t imagine her male counterparts ever doing this. They wouldn’t be ridiculed forever!
So the men you work with never show any emotion? They don't get angry, shout, swear, get physical, violent etc?
NandorTheRelentless · 24/12/2021 09:57

It's an observation that I have noticed majority of time it is female that do this and I can say the same on other places I've worked. These are observations I've made so how can other posters be telling me essential I'm wrong about what I've seen with my own eyes.

And what is the common denominator here?

Keke94LND · 24/12/2021 09:57

Is your implication that men can control their emotions more than women? Because I've seen a lot of out of control angry men..