Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU for wanting to double-barrel babies surname?

212 replies

ekkn · 23/12/2021 21:02

First baby, we aren't married but are engaged but realise that we won't be getting married for a long long time.

Things are also quite tense at the moment in the relationship, lots of arguments etc.

AIBU for suggesting we double barrel the babies name? I really don't want to have a completely different name to my child. But know that if we ever do get married it will not be for years and years to come, if we make it that far!

OP posts:
QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 24/12/2021 11:29

I gave the children my DPs surname, I was under the assumption that we would get married at some point. Although it used to bother me having different surnames it doesn't anymore but we are never getting married and likely split soon. My advice is give the baby your surname - hold the line.

LadyDanburysHat · 24/12/2021 11:19

He still can't understand my view but did later on apologise for saying he will never forgive me and rephrased to he will never agree to it.

He doesn't need to agree to it. He can't register the birth alone as you are not married. You can register the birth alone, or with him. He cans stamp his feet all he wants, but I'd be telling him that if he continued making a fuss about it then it won't be double barrelled, it will be your name only.

Fuuuuuckit · 24/12/2021 11:16

Oh love, please listen to a cautionary tale or two.

He may be a fab dad, so deserves to go on the BC.

But he sounds like a bit of a nightmare partner. Do you honestly, in your guts, feel like he will always put the dc first, and never, ever be a dick about parenting decisions? Always, even if/when the shit hits the fan?

My ex is on my dcs BC (for what it's worth, I believe a child has the right for it to be legally recorded who is their father) but he has been an absolute cunt about using his parental responsibility - insisting on being involved (and trying to frustrate) many many everyday decisions, despite only seeing them a couple of times a year. Refused consent for school vaccinations (pre covid, fortunately theyre old enough to decide re covid), school decisions, medical issues and famously refusing permission to let me take them on holiday to Spain.

This has cost me literally thousands of pounds in solicitors and court fees. Please make yourself aware of the frustrations that co-parenting can bring with anything less than 100% supportive partner.

Baby will be known as 'baby motherssurname' in hospital.

GoodnightGrandma · 24/12/2021 11:06

Just give baby your name, it gives you control in the future.

DorothyZbornakIsAQueen · 24/12/2021 11:04

I've probably been a nagging bitch over getting the house ready etc which contributes to most arguments

Also, get rid of your internalised misogyny before you have the baby.

DorothyZbornakIsAQueen · 24/12/2021 11:01

Give the baby YOUR surname.

Seen too many women, family included, where couples have split and child ends up with a lazy dad who doesn't deserve to share a surname.

BatshitCrazyWoman · 24/12/2021 10:51

@Dontbeme

Give the baby your last name. If you marry you can change it to all have the same name. Traditionally the baby always took mother's surname, so keep to tradition, just in case he tries that tactic.
Do this
megletthesecond · 24/12/2021 10:49

Give the baby your name.
It's horrible having a different name to my dc's. The dcs don't like it either. But out patriarchal law says I can't change it. (Zero contact with their dad for 13yrs).

MissNothing1991 · 24/12/2021 10:45

Completely agree. My daughter is stuck with the surname of an absolutely abusive dick who abandoned her at the age of two because I felt the need to go with tradition.

MissNothing1991 · 24/12/2021 10:44

I was adamant my daughter was having her dad's surname. He didn't care at the time really, but It was the stupidest decision I ever made. Cheated on me before she was even born, walked out at 15 months old, stopped visiting on her second birthday and stopped paying toward her upbringing at the same time. He refused to let me change her surname despite this, so now my 2.5 year old daughter will be stuck with that surname indefinitely of a man who treated her like absolute shit. And I now have the guilt of thinking I knew better.

I would at the very least double barrel, but truthfully, I'd consider just your surname for now if the relationship is souring, if you do then get married the surname can always be changed anyway.

BlueThursday · 24/12/2021 10:39

Be aware that should you split and the child has his surname then travelling can be an issue. Adult and child with different surnames on passports can be a total headache

Mooloolabababy · 24/12/2021 10:26

I'd give baby your surname and if you do get married then change baby's name then!

VikingOnTheFridge · 24/12/2021 10:22

He doesn't have to agree to it. When unmarried, legally the choice is 100% the mother's. His only recourse would be a legal challenge, and no court is going to agree that the baby should have his name rather than a double barrel. If he doesn't like this state of affairs, he should've considered that before conceiving.

FallonCarringtonWannabe · 24/12/2021 10:20

He still can't understand my view but did later on apologise for saying he will never forgive me and rephrased to he will never agree to it.
Well, thank fuck he does not have to agree to it. The arrogant fucker. It is entirely your decision. Baby would absolutely be having my surname only as he has shown clearly who he is with this.

I'm not financially dependent on him and never have been… and I earn double him
Well done for being so sensible! And do not marry him. There is nothing in marrying this man for you, and way too much to lose. And if you decided later down the line to marry him, keep your surname so you match your child and he can take the family name if he chooses.

Thirdly the arguments are always over stupid trivial things. Yes its very irritating and I'm sick to death of arguing over little things, but I'm also grateful they're not arguments over important issues.
For me this says he will not compromise, even on small trivial things.

Fourthly we haven't known each other 5 minutes
Pregnancy is a trigger for changing behaviour in relationships that are not good. What he was like before might be great. Go off how he behaves now.

Good luck, op.

CluelessAt50 · 24/12/2021 10:12

I was married but the kids still got double barrelled. So glad that I did. We're now divorced & he'd have loved nothing more than to have control over our movements which he would have had if the kids had just his name (permission to travel letters for passport control). No mother should risk inviting that level of control into her life. If you offer yourself & your children up as male possessions, the system will gladly assist the male to keep that control, even after you split up.

AlexaShutUp · 24/12/2021 10:11

@JSL52

I'd give the baby your name and leave him off the birth certificate if he's being a dick.
This.
ikeepseeingit · 24/12/2021 10:09

Yep I think double barrel is perfectly reasonable. I’m happy to see he’s apologised for saying he wouldn’t forgive you. That wasn’t a nice thing to say at all. I do find it very odd that men think they have all the rights over a child’s name when we’re the ones carrying them, giving birth and doing the majority of care after until they get to about 2/3. There seems to be a disproportionate expectation for men to get the rights over a child that we have put our bodies and life into. He’s put nothing into this baby yet, and he fully believes he has more right than you over it. It boggles the mind.

I can understand him wanting his own name with his own child, this does not trump your right to have the same.

Whammyyammy · 24/12/2021 10:00

@JSL52

I'd give the baby your name and leave him off the birth certificate if he's being a dick.
Nothing like using an innocent child as a pawn in a game is there.....
ekkn · 24/12/2021 09:56

Thank you for all your posts everyone!

I feel better knowing that I'm not being unreasonable and that the majority agree its a fair compromise/to just use my surname.

He still can't understand my view but did later on apologise for saying he will never forgive me and rephrased to he will never agree to it.

To clear up a few issues though:

  • Firstly finances dont come into it. I'm not financially dependent on him and never have been, I have worked my arse off before having a child so that I had a good job and would never have to rely on a man. This I have achieved and I earn double him. So I'm not holding on to something for the fear of not being able to support myself and my child. I made sure I was able to do that myself before even getting pregnant as this is something that's important to me.
  • Secondly I don't actually have low standards as someone suggested. I'm just currently very hormonal and not ready to throw the towel in when I'm pregnant. I've probably been a nagging bitch over getting the house ready etc which contributes to most arguments.
  • Thirdly the arguments are always over stupid trivial things. Yes its very irritating and I'm sick to death of arguing over little things, but I'm also grateful they're not arguments over important issues.
  • Fourthly we haven't known each other 5 minutes. I was on contraception for the years before we planned to have a child and only had it removed to try for a baby.
  • Finally I am not under some grand illusion that we will get married and live happily ever after.

Thanks to everyone who posted!

OP posts:
SamMil · 24/12/2021 07:53

If he doesn't want to double barrel, just give the baby your name. He is the one rejecting a compromise.

JeffThePilot · 24/12/2021 07:40

@Dozer

wishingitwasspring you’re making a false equivalence: fathers ‘shat on’ by women (?) vs fathers who who abandon their DC and pay little or no maintenance. The former group is dwarfed by the latter!

OP’s partner isn’t asking for a ‘say’: he wants the DC to have his name only.

Exactly.

He has a say - he wants his surname.
OP has a say - she could equally say she wants her surname.

Gee, if only there was an obvious compromise.

Dozer · 24/12/2021 07:22

wishingitwasspring you’re making a false equivalence: fathers ‘shat on’ by women (?) vs fathers who who abandon their DC and pay little or no maintenance. The former group is dwarfed by the latter!

OP’s partner isn’t asking for a ‘say’: he wants the DC to have his name only.

Merryoldgoat · 24/12/2021 00:14

@wishingitwasspring

We obviously have opposite experiences. I don’t know a single bloke militant about surnames who wasn’t a douche.

FortniteBoysMum · 23/12/2021 23:51

Tell your partner the baby is either having yours or you double it. Having his is not up for discussion. Point out that should you get married you change the name on the birth certificate to his then. He either meets you half way on doubling or he accepts baby is having your name. Why should the child have his when your doing all the work. My partner was not happy our sons is doubled but it was the only option I gave. He moaned for a long time but it was the correct call 13 years together our sons almost 12 and still no ring. Whenever the conversation of his name has been bought up by partners friends and how he should have dad's name I point out well dad should ask me to marry him then. Alternatively he can put up with it as why should I not share my child's name. My eldest from past relationship only has mine which made ds2 having mine in there more important to link the siblings.

wishingitwasspring · 23/12/2021 23:51

[quote Merryoldgoat]@wishingitwasspring

Telling OP he’ll never forgive her for double barrelling the surname? That sounds reasonable does it?

‘Tense’ always means some bloke is acting like a cunt and some woman us trying to placate him 🙄[/quote]
Not in my experience it doesn't.