Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU for wanting to double-barrel babies surname?

212 replies

ekkn · 23/12/2021 21:02

First baby, we aren't married but are engaged but realise that we won't be getting married for a long long time.

Things are also quite tense at the moment in the relationship, lots of arguments etc.

AIBU for suggesting we double barrel the babies name? I really don't want to have a completely different name to my child. But know that if we ever do get married it will not be for years and years to come, if we make it that far!

OP posts:
Dixiechickonhols · 24/12/2021 15:05

An unmarried father who isn’t in bc can of course go to court for parental responsibility but it’s not often done.

Dixiechickonhols · 24/12/2021 15:03

Well if he’s being such a prat give baby your surname (babies traditionally have same name as mum if he’s going to pull tradition card) Is he going to parent with you? Letting him go on birth certificate gives him parental responsibility. PR means he can cause you hassle in long run if you split. It cost one of our Guide’s mums thousands in court fees and solicitor costs for court permission for girl to go on guides trip - dad had pr and was objecting. Needless to say judge agreed girl should go.
Op is unmarried and can’t put him on birth certificate - otherwise you could name anyone as father. On married women can add their husband as there is a presumption married woman’s husband is father of her baby. If he goes to registration appointment he can go on but up to op and if he cba going.

Mooloolabababy · 24/12/2021 14:54

I wouldn't as it sounds like this relationship is doomed anyway and if you meet someone in the future and get married, you and your Dc will still have different names. If you really can't give dc your surname then double barrel it, at least when your relationship does end (sorry to be blunt, but it's not looking good) at least ds will have your surname.

Aspergirl77 · 24/12/2021 14:48

@Merryoldgoat

If not on birth certificate, I believe the father has no parental responsibilities and rights, but may not be obliged to pay child support. Worth investigating

Entirely untrue.

I am a registrar of births and deaths. If parents are unmarried and the mother attends alone to register, only her details will be on the birth certificate and the father will have NO parental rights or responsibilities. The father can be added to the birth certificate later either by attending a reregistration appointment with the mother or obtaining a court order to have his name added).
appleturnovers · 24/12/2021 14:23

Double-barrel it, no question.

I'm married and our kids are double-barrelled.

You're not asking to not give the baby his name at all, your asking to give the child your name as well as his. That's a compromise. If he would "never forgive you for that" then he's being completely unreasonable.

Ibane · 24/12/2021 14:15

@ekkn

Another thought... which I know I'm going to get absolutely slaughtered by you all for suggesting it. But I will anyway to see your responses....

Changing my name to his by deed poll? I wouldnt be doing it for him. It would be for me so that I will have the same name as my child.

We wouldn't be married, because clearly we are not in an appropriate place to get married right now, but I would have his name and therefore my child's name. In the future if we separated, I would still have my child's name.

Despite everyone's advise I can't just give her my surname. The relationship would be sure to end and although I am financially okay, I have no family nearby other than his. Then there's selling the house whilst on maternity leave, renting whilst on maternity leave etc and thats a massive upheaval I dont need in the early months of my child's life. Not that I need shit from him over a surname, but here we are...

I dont want to separate from him, I'd like this to work if it can... naive and hormonal as I may be right now.

Do you actually want to feed the patriarchal egotistical fantasies of a man who would end a relationship with the mother of his child if she didn’t give their child his surname?

OP, this sounds like a worryingly coercive relationship.

user15364596354862 · 24/12/2021 14:08

which I know I'm going to get absolutely slaughtered by you all for suggesting it

That's not what is happening here btw - people are concerned, upset, and dismayed for you.

Just because he beats you down all the time, it doesn't mean that's what the rest of the world is about.

RedRobin100 · 24/12/2021 14:06

@Merryoldgoat

I’ve said YABU because I’d give the baby my surname in this situation.

You’re not happy and not likely to get married soon. In reality are you likely to ever get married?

I’d give them my name and that’s that.

This 👍🏼
user15364596354862 · 24/12/2021 14:04

I've probably been a nagging bitch

Please don't talk about yourself like that. It's a nasty, misogynistic way to describe yourself.

It would be for me so that I will have the same name as my child.

Despite everyone's advise I can't just give her my surname. The relationship would be sure to end

So you wouldn't be changing your name "for you" and you wouldn't be changing it out of choice.

You'd be changing it because he has coerced you. Which is entirely for him despite your attempts to claim otherwise, with you desperately trying to find a way to make the situation more bearable. That's not what choice means - what is happening here is the absence of choice.

And you'd be disregarding the convention of a baby taking her mum's name to use his because he has coerced you. What he is forcing you to do is not even "traditional", it's purely motivated by control.

That's coercive control which is abuse and illegal. Your relationship is already dead. I'm sad you are not yet able to accept that.

I hope you feel able to talk to Women's Aid and do the Freedom Programme at some point so you can see how toxic and unhealthy this all is. That your arguments are over "trivial" things is not a redeeming feature, and the fact that you blame yourself for his behaviour in such a misogynistic way is upsetting - even if it's normal to you and something you have talked yourself into tolerating.

mnp321 · 24/12/2021 14:02

Changing my name to his by deed poll? I wouldnt be doing it for him. It would be for me so that I will have the same name as my child.

My nephew's mum did that. She and my brother ended up not getting married and she called her next son my brother's surname too (he wasn't the father). He and I are always amused by how my father is going to reflect this in his massive A3 family tree drawing.

ChocolateDeficitDisorder · 24/12/2021 14:00

If your relationship can't survive some disappointment on his part, it's definitely not going to survive bringing up a child together.

PrincessNutella · 24/12/2021 13:56

With double barreled names, the child can take the mother's original name if a girl and father's if a boy, and have a matrilinial or patrilinial line of descent when getting married. It isn't complicated. Or they can do whatever the hell they want. But the point is, OP, it is not something you need to argue. It's your choice. He can get angry, but if this is an important issue to you, and it would be to me, don't back down. Do what you want.

FallonCarringtonWannabe · 24/12/2021 13:56

You can change your name to his at a later point, namely when your partner isnt threatening you.
You can change the baby’s name to his at a later point should you get over him threatening you actually marry him and take his name and both want the baby to have the same.
You can both add him to the birth certificate at a later point, should he turn into an equal parent.
He can add himself to the birth certificate at a later point by going to court.

YOU cannot change anything once it has been done. Those actions available to you are final. Give yourself the most options.

AnotherEmma · 24/12/2021 13:51

@ekkn

Another thought... which I know I'm going to get absolutely slaughtered by you all for suggesting it. But I will anyway to see your responses....

Changing my name to his by deed poll? I wouldnt be doing it for him. It would be for me so that I will have the same name as my child.

We wouldn't be married, because clearly we are not in an appropriate place to get married right now, but I would have his name and therefore my child's name. In the future if we separated, I would still have my child's name.

Despite everyone's advise I can't just give her my surname. The relationship would be sure to end and although I am financially okay, I have no family nearby other than his. Then there's selling the house whilst on maternity leave, renting whilst on maternity leave etc and thats a massive upheaval I dont need in the early months of my child's life. Not that I need shit from him over a surname, but here we are...

I dont want to separate from him, I'd like this to work if it can... naive and hormonal as I may be right now.

Absolutely terrible idea. If you really think that your relationship will end if you give baby your surname, it's not a relationship worth saving. It's going to end at some point anyway so you might as well give baby your surname.
SpiderFluff · 24/12/2021 13:51

Both names or your name. His choice which.

FallonCarringtonWannabe · 24/12/2021 13:49

Would he want you taking his name without being married?
Now he has you taking his name, a child, a child taking his name, why would he marry you?

And if he does, then leaves, are you ok with no longer being as sound financially as you are now?

When the relationship ends, will you be happier if you and your child have your surname of if you and your child have his?

When the relationship ends, will you still want his surname, or will you change it back and have a different surname to your child after all of it?

youvegottenminuteslynn · 24/12/2021 13:49

I don't think you should marry him because he sounds like a prick but if you're engaged, why is it that you say you know you won't get married for ages? If he's so set on the child having his name, why isn't it an option to have a registry office wedding and take his name then you'd all have the same name? I can't understand why you changing your name by deed poll is the option you're thinking of.

Politely OP, this relationship isn't viable long term as it's not a healthy or stable one.

He already isn't a good dad because he's being disrespectful to his child's mother, threatening her (I'll never forgive you) and putting his ego before both fairness and practicality.

It's so depressing to see the amount of men who push for their name because 'it's tradition' despite having kids before being married. I have no issue with kids before being married, obviously - just making the point that they pick and choose when they want to be 'traditional' to suit their preferences.

Puppyseahorse · 24/12/2021 13:45

It sounds like you know what the responses will be to that suggestion, so I won’t beat you over the head and tell you you’re wrong.

But I’m sorry you’re in this position, OP. This is becoming quite a sad thread.

You sound like you’ll be a lovely mum and I wish you all the best with baby.

ekkn · 24/12/2021 13:39

Another thought... which I know I'm going to get absolutely slaughtered by you all for suggesting it. But I will anyway to see your responses....

Changing my name to his by deed poll? I wouldnt be doing it for him. It would be for me so that I will have the same name as my child.

We wouldn't be married, because clearly we are not in an appropriate place to get married right now, but I would have his name and therefore my child's name. In the future if we separated, I would still have my child's name.

Despite everyone's advise I can't just give her my surname. The relationship would be sure to end and although I am financially okay, I have no family nearby other than his. Then there's selling the house whilst on maternity leave, renting whilst on maternity leave etc and thats a massive upheaval I dont need in the early months of my child's life. Not that I need shit from him over a surname, but here we are...

I dont want to separate from him, I'd like this to work if it can... naive and hormonal as I may be right now.

OP posts:
Viviennemary · 24/12/2021 13:30

Double barrelled is awful in most cases IMHO. Give the baby your name. I wouldn't be controlled like this by a man. It will only get worse.

Puppyseahorse · 24/12/2021 13:24

You want to give the baby a DB because you’ve been arguing. That’s more than reasonable.

But how about… wanting the baby to have your name simply because… you’re its mother? Your DP contributed a single cell to baby’s development… you contributed everything else.

I’ve never understood why so many women go in for this unnecessary patriarchal BS.

Stormbraver99 · 24/12/2021 13:20

We've been separated for 9 years now. Never been married.
Now the children are older they say they wish they had my surname.
They say it doesn't feel right them having his name (he's useless and has no time for them) and me having a different name.

Giving them his surname was one of the biggest cock ups I ever made!

GabriellaMontez · 24/12/2021 12:51

I'm divorced. The kids share his name. Wish I'd double barreled.

AnotherEmma · 24/12/2021 11:59

@DorothyZbornakIsAQueen

I've probably been a nagging bitch over getting the house ready etc which contributes to most arguments

Also, get rid of your internalised misogyny before you have the baby.

Yes, I was shocked by that too, oh so casually referring to oneself as a "nagging bitch" Shock

Does he ever call you that, OP? Or do you just use it to refer to yourself?!

Totalwasteofpaper · 24/12/2021 11:30

@JSL52

I'd give the baby your name and leave him off the birth certificate if he's being a dick.
I've said YABU

because you should 100% give the baby YOUR surname

Swipe left for the next trending thread