Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not have ealised until now that this was blatant neglect.

32 replies

Mooocows · 23/12/2021 14:05

Hello, name changed for this and just wanted to get it off my chest.

I have 3 cousins, the eldest (twins) are 18 and the youngest 15 (I am mid 20s). We were fairly close growing up and i saw them pretty regularly. My family always talked about their parents being lazy but it hasn't really clicked until recently that this wasn't just laziness it was neglect.

They were never taught basic hygiene. All 3 of them have lost several adult teeth due to decay. They barely shower. They don't eat normal meals but live of junk food and snacks. They have never been on holiday (not even in the UK and this is not a money issue) in fact I'm fairly sure they've never been taken to the beach or a farm etc by their parents (I have taken them since learning to drive). All of their school holidays were spent in front of the TV and parents just didn't want to know. They were never taught the importance of school...one of the twins was kicked out and one finished but with no qualifications (the youngest is hanging on by a thread)

As I've gotten older and learnt more about safeguarding etc I realise this wasn't just lazy parenting this was neglect and nobody did anything to help :( I feel so so guilty and so sorry for the poor things...they've really been screwed up for life. I dont know how to forgive myself for not standing up for them and now i don't know if there's anything that can be done.

I dont think there's really any point to this post but any advice would be welcomed.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Dontbeme · 24/12/2021 18:38

@Nowayoutonlydown your post made me cry, I recognised so much of myself in your post. For what it's worth this stranger on the internet is so proud of you and all you have achieved for yourself and your DC. I wish you every happiness in the future.

sweetbellyhigh · 23/12/2021 23:29

@2bazookas

I wouldn't say they've been screwed up for life.

They can get their teeth sorted out, change their diet, get an education, get a job, and explore all the experiences they missed in childhood.

Deprivation and lack of opportunity in childhood is not a life sentence.

That's the view from the outside, I dare say it is rather different for them. They have been taught that they do not matter enough to be cared for, they have not been taught how to care for themselves in the most basic ways so are unlikely to have strong hygiene practices. This will impact negatively on their ability to make friends, find work and so on. This in turns makes access to good dental care and so on much more challenging than it is for you or me.

And that's before we look at the psychological damage of growing up neglected.

Nowayoutonlydown · 23/12/2021 23:11

I would sadly say yes, they are screwed for life if over the next few years they do not see that what they faced was neglect, and take opportunities to ensure that this doesn't change the entire course of expectation throughout their lives.

I was very rarely at school, was considered to be educationally challenged. It was never the expectation of my teachers that I would achieve much at all. I completed 2 days of year 10. I had sporadic home tutorage (I was ill so LEA provided but parents would make excuses for teachers to not come in as the house wasn't clean) left school with 3 gcses (D,E and G)
We were allowed our school clothes washed once per week, one bath per week.
We stunk, I didnt have things I needed. Had no school shoes, but had trainers which I wore all the time everywhere which had numerous holes (no socks, didn't know to cut my toenails)

My understanding was just that we were poor and my parents were doing their best, but I didn't know anyone who had as little as me, or was bullied for smelling like I did.

It didn't become obvious to me until I had DD that these were active choices that my parents made, and that if I had any chance at making anything of myself I needed to literally do the opposite of what they did.

The first step was to access education, there are local youth training schemes- that's how I managed to resit my GCSEs- got really good grades, then I went into further training to give me a chance of achieving a job that would pay more than Nat min wage.

I then looked into counselling to improve my self worth, it was a short course of about 10 sessions.

I placed an importance on cleanliness- to smell nice, personally and in my surroundings brings me a sense of happiness.

And I set about making a life for myself that included fun experiences- not just surviving as I'd always expected for myself.

If I hadn't have had the access to the training I wouldn't have had any chance of breaking the cycle.

I've been left with a lot of MH issues, and I don't think I will ever feel I truly belong anywhere because in my mind I'll always be that smelly, thick kid thst didn't fit it because I didn't have the right support, things or life experiences to fit in.

From the outside though, I look to be pretty successful, I have a life far removed from what anyone would believe I should have.

Please just nurture them into a direction where they can love themselves and strive for better, if not for themselves, for their future children.

In breaking the cycle, my child's upbringing is a stark contrast to mine. She has a lot of things I never dreamed of being able to provide her (whilst it brings me some pride, it doesn't matter so much) but she has a bathroom full of toiletries, and support to do well educationally. She has dreams and aspirations and is achieving academically in a way I never expected. She has had lots of foreign holidays. Her outlook of life is amazing, because the cycle of generational neglect was broken.

timeisnotaline · 23/12/2021 22:49

[quote Jessie75]@timeisnotaline there are lies, damn lies and statistics[/quote]
Is that right? When it comes to neglect in early childhood there is evidence and more evidence.

Jessie75 · 23/12/2021 22:42

@timeisnotaline there are lies, damn lies and statistics

timeisnotaline · 23/12/2021 22:12

@2bazookas

I wouldn't say they've been screwed up for life.

They can get their teeth sorted out, change their diet, get an education, get a job, and explore all the experiences they missed in childhood.

Deprivation and lack of opportunity in childhood is not a life sentence.

Statistically they are much more likely to be screwed up for life.
Faretheewellmyfairyfay · 23/12/2021 22:07

Also agree with many other posts inc school, Social Services etc for the younger one and maybe even the older ones via vulnerable adults. But services areso stretched, they might not meet the criteria. Worth a go.

Faretheewellmyfairyfay · 23/12/2021 22:03

Someone I know has rather taken a younger relation under their wing over the past few years. To give a non-parental but slightly older and wiser perspective on life. Seems to be working quite well. It's just casual really but they're doing it mindfully, if you see what I mean. Not because of neglect but because the younger one (now late teens) is an only child, has had a few issues, and their parents have some strange ideas about some things. You could think about doing something like this for your cousins, if you want to.

Try not to feel guilty that you haven't realised this until now, it was normalised for you while you grew up that they were just looked after, or not, like that, and now you are seeing it through more adult eyes. We don't just magically become an adult at 18 and that's that, I have new perspectives on things quite regularly as I age.

You might want to speak to a counsellor about your feelings around this and around your feelings about why anyone else in the family, including your own parents, didn't do anything about this. Or maybe they tried. Would you want to ask your parents or other relatives about this (probably not during Christmas!)?

ESGdance · 23/12/2021 20:48

I suspect that there was/is emotional neglect that would have impacted the development of their social abilities that would need support even if the practical / hygiene issues were rectified.

AmyandPhilipfan · 23/12/2021 19:06

Perhaps not the lack of basic hygiene but the other things - no holidays, no days out, no importance placed on education, no decent meals etc are normal for a great number of families in my area and wouldn’t be considered anywhere near the level of neglect required for input from social services.

Dacquoise · 23/12/2021 18:34

I had this as a child. Parents who were barely teens themselves and woefully inadequate in so many ways. It seemed normal to me and my siblings. My DM had an absolute knack of shaming me for things that weren't my fault or responsibility so I suspect she was aware she was neglectful. As a consequence I wasn't given deodorant or sanitary towels when I needed them and ended with deformed feet from badly fitting shoes. I had surgery later on to correct them. Again my DM was in denial about why this was necessary.

I think the key here is that other family members were aware but didn't do anything about it. My parents were gossiped about by other family members. They didn't intervene probably because they had their own issues and probably felt better that they weren't as 'bad' as my parents

In your case Op the parents were labelled lazy and the situation accepted. Why aren't they eaten up with guilt? It absolutely wasn't your fault but your family system doesn't sound very engaged or aware. Denial is rife in dysfunctional families.

CruellaDeVilla · 23/12/2021 18:13

It’s not your fault, you were a child too 💐

coochyboochy · 23/12/2021 18:10

The 15 year old is still legally a child and could be helped - please report to social services.

sweetbellyhigh · 23/12/2021 17:55

@hamstersarse

Most people aren’t looking out for neglect, certainly children don’t notice, usually.

It’s an awful launch into life to have neglectful parents and I’m not sure I agree that lots make it into a healthy life, I think most don’t and they carry it around forever.

I think children notice but would not name it as neglect or abuse. They may think of the child as smelly or "poor" or dirty or weird, or they may just seemed they are different and therefore not a natural friend.

Neglect is so damaging 😢

MrsLargeEmbodied · 23/12/2021 17:37

who is at fault?
what about the extended family?

they cant be a one off?

Politics4me · 23/12/2021 17:14

What is their attitude now? Do they realise fully what they might have missed? Do they want to change in a constructive way?
If they do want to improve then there will be people willing to help from within your/their community.

You should not feel that you have to 'do' everything but I hope you can find others with more experience to engage with the cousins.

LostForIdeas · 23/12/2021 17:12

@HacerSonarSusPasos

Why are people voting YABU?
I voted YABU because seeing that the Op is only a couple of years older than the twins, it wasn’t her job to realise they were neglected. It wasn’t her responsibility to protect them.

Her responsibility was the grow up and make a life for herself, not too look out for younger cousins.

It was the responsibility of the adults round them including her own parents (who could for example, have them to places)…

PuppyMonkey · 23/12/2021 17:07

@2bazookas

I wouldn't say they've been screwed up for life.

They can get their teeth sorted out, change their diet, get an education, get a job, and explore all the experiences they missed in childhood.

Deprivation and lack of opportunity in childhood is not a life sentence.

True, but neglect on a scale like that can lead to attachment disorder/psychological problems that might prevent them ever doing those things properly.
Crabwoman · 23/12/2021 17:04

What do your parents or grandparents think OP? If there any reason why they didn't pick up on it and intervene?

Ozanj · 23/12/2021 17:03

That is how I grew up. I only don’t get tooth decay because I have incredibly close gapped teeth so nothing really gets inside them - so genetic quirk. I managed to pull myself together eventually - though I did have an extended adolescence to make up for it.

hamstersarse · 23/12/2021 16:59

Most people aren’t looking out for neglect, certainly children don’t notice, usually.

It’s an awful launch into life to have neglectful parents and I’m not sure I agree that lots make it into a healthy life, I think most don’t and they carry it around forever.

HacerSonarSusPasos · 23/12/2021 16:56

Why are people voting YABU?

Ponoka7 · 23/12/2021 16:53

The most important thing is to spell out their choices and make it clear that they can still achieve. If it's self esteem issues, then try to help with those. They'll need practical help to navigate life choices and opportunities, that is something that you can offer.

2bazookas · 23/12/2021 16:47

I wouldn't say they've been screwed up for life.

They can get their teeth sorted out, change their diet, get an education, get a job, and explore all the experiences they missed in childhood.

Deprivation and lack of opportunity in childhood is not a life sentence.

ComtesseDeSpair · 23/12/2021 16:05

It wasn’t your job to identify the problems or sort them out, it was that of the adults around them - including their teachers to whom the neglect should have been obvious. The 15-year-old though - if it’s still as bad as you say then does their school have a family support or welfare worker you could contact?

I think part of the problem is that people who are good parents and prioritise their children seem to find it very difficult to accept that some people are just crap parents and don’t put them first: any time there’s a thread on here about children routinely being sent to school without any lunch, having had no breakfast, in dirty or ill-fitting clothes, wearing no coat in a freezing winter and so on, the thread is always inundated by people justifying this as being the fault of the Tories / benefit cuts. There’s often all kinds of twisting and turning to insist this is so, even when it should be obvious that in most cases it’s just pure neglect, not a struggling parent with too little money to buy basic foodstuffs and wash clothes.